Strict Constructionism

I guess you have a lot of people on ignore.

How many threads do you see in the front two pages that just refer to him as Obama?

He is President Obama. Not Obama. Not president. Not obummer.

To be honest I don't give a fuck how people refer to him. We know who and what we're talking about. And if you don't, then disconnect from the internet.

But since a point was stupidly made about the capitalization of constitution in a thread that was clearly about our constitution, then now I'll expect from here on out to see "President Obama" when speaking about him.
Oh, I see what you mean.

These are just matters of convention, capitalizing "Constitution" and "President" when referring to the US. Unfortunately for your druthers, I suppose, referring to the President by his last name only is also an established convention. I don't know when that started — might be interesting to find out.

But you can capitalize or never capitalize anything, put periods outside quotes, misspell half your words, if you like, and still be understood.

You can look at the posts in this thread and see that Constitution is normally capitalized, so pointing it out should be unnecessary. It's more the sort of thing one would do to annoy someone.
 
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

Any editor worth half a damn would send this line back with a giant red mark. It's like they intentionally made it gramatically ambigous.
It's grammatically correct, and there's nothing ambiguous about it.
 
You can look at the posts in this thread and see that Cognstitution is normally capitalized, so pointing it out should be unnecessary. It's more the sort of thing one would do to annoy someone.

Which is exactly my point.
 
You also thought that Bush should be impeached over the missing W's...



Define Militia in the terms of the Founders. I double-dawg dare you because it was a militia that stopped the British when they came for the arms of the citizens...

A militia is clearly not a military.
 
Oh, I see what you mean.

These are just matters of convention, capitalizing "Constitution" and "President" when referring to the US. Unfortunately for your druthers, I suppose, referring to the President by his last name only is also an established convention. I don't know when that started — might be interesting to find out.

But you can capitalize or never capitalize anything, put periods outside quotes, misspell half your words, if you like, and still be understood.

You can look at the posts in this thread and see that Constitution is normally capitalized, so pointing it out should be unnecessary. It's more the sort of thing one would do to annoy someone.

As we have talked about before, the Left truly believes it is a constitution, not THE Constitution, that hateful document composed only of negative liberties and not a bunch of good and gooder clauses...
 
Words must be defined or you get tyranny or anarchy, the boss or the mob. What we resist is common definition.
 
As we have talked about before, the Left truly believes it is a constitution, not THE Constitution, that hateful document composed only of negative liberties and not a bunch of good and gooder clauses...

Look who stops in to instruct us all in the ways of the Left. Your obsession is magnificent, sir!

:rolleyes:
 
How would it be possible to interpret the Constitution and apply it to today's issues unless you look at the "construction", tried to put it in its original context, and understood it has to be a living document to have meaning in today's world?

In other words, all of these factors need to be considered.
 
How would it be possible to interpret the Constitution and apply it to today's issues unless you look at the "construction", tried to put it in its original context, and understood it has to be a living document to have meaning in today's world?

In other words, all of these factors need to be considered.

Why do you hate the Constitution?
 
AJ is a boring old C&Ping dipshit.

He'll take any stance his party tells him to.

People that don't have it on iggy are wasting my time when you quote it.

Stop it, just let him and wat jerk each other off in peace.
 
Squibbs, you used to see the humor in things! You take things too seriously nowadays. :(

I find humour in humourous things.

I can open almost any thread and find rob and AJ having the same argument with both of them saying the same fucking things.

Clown shoes, it's all they are.

Or maybe you are right, maybe they are hilarious, witty and entertaining?

Na.
 
Read the Heller decision for as close to an originalist opinion as you're going to get today. the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed" is pretty clear to me. The part I bolded indicates the founders belief that the right predates the Constitution itself.

I am curious about this because I don't know American history very well.

How does an amendment predate the original document? Except in thought of course. But legally, does thought count?
 
I am curious about this because I don't know American history very well.

How does an amendment predate the original document? Except in thought of course. But legally, does thought count?

Vette didn't say AMENDMENT, he said RIGHT.
 
I am curious about this because I don't know American history very well.

How does an amendment predate the original document? Except in thought of course. But legally, does thought count?

The easiest way to understand the argument is to read Scalia's opinion in Heller. He lays it out cleanly.

The gist of it, though, is that it is an English common law right that accomanied settlement of the colonies.
 
How would it be possible to interpret the Constitution and apply it to today's issues unless you look at the "construction", tried to put it in its original context, and understood it has to be a living document to have meaning in today's world?

In other words, all of these factors need to be considered.

'LIVING' implies that the meaning or application or whatever changes from the original. Now that works if the new issue is in the same class of action as the original. If we're speaking of the 2nd Amendment and arms and militia, the issue the amendment acts upon must be a logical progeny of the original. OK? So if the militia are white males aged 18-45 (and they were the militia back then) their arms and accountrerments would have been muskets, rifles, knives, dirks, swords (think machetes), axes, hatchets, tomahawks, bows & arrows, gunpowder, lead, etc. A new appliance, like a breech loading rifle or a revolver or carbine are logical progeny of the originals. An AR15 is. A crew served weapon isn't. And as the first machine fired weapons were crew served, miniaturization prolly has not fit them within the protection of the 2nd Amendment. While a 40mm grenade launcher prolly is protected, as grenades are not crew served weapons.
 
Except Rights exist only so far as the government says they do. The right could not exist prior to the government.

And one could make the argument that the English common law ceased to exist when the new "documents" were ratified. In other words the constitution and amendments supersede the common law authority.
 
We should be hearing about natural rights any time now.
 
Back
Top