Small Penis Question

[SoCalAshley]

I knew that would get your attention. Seriously, I just finished a story where I date a man who has a penis less than four inches. I treat the situation with respect, and the story has a happy ending. Would this story still be placed in the Fetish Category? It has explicit sex, so the other logical category would be Erotic Couplings.

 

[madelinemasoch]

Depends on the dialogue used.

 

[SoCalAshley]

Depends on the dialogue used.

There is no dialog that states that a small penis is freakish. The story is more about how to deal with a small penis in a positive manner.

 

[Kelliezgirl]

There is no dialog that states that a small penis is freakish. The story is more about how to deal with a small penis in a positive manner.

Probably not fetish then.

 

[madelinemasoch]

There is no dialog that states that a small penis is freakish. The story is more about how to deal with a small penis in a positive manner.

Yeah, probably not Fetish material. Coming from an expert on such things...

 

[Djmac1031]

Doesn't sound like Fetish. Fetish would imply thr female character has a THING for small dicks.

Or that he has a thing for being humiliated because of his size.

 

[NoTalentHack]

Depending on the buildup and resolution , either Romance or Erotic Couplings sound good.

 

[StillStunned]

Anal?

 

[AwkwardlySet]

Unless the size of the cock is somehow relevant or even central to the story, then no, it doesn't belong in fetish.

 

[KeithD]

There is no dialog that states that a small penis is freakish. The story is more about how to deal with a small penis in a positive manner.

Deal with it incidentally. Maybe a sentence of surprise that it could get the other character off--if not by itself than by the techniques employed to make up for it.

 

[SimonDoom]

It would be appropriate for Fetish if either:

1. The female character has a particular fetishy interest in small penises, or

2. You write it in a way to appeal to readers' fetishy interest in small penises.

Otherwise, it doesn't sound like Fetish.

 

[MyBareTorso]

I knew that would get your attention. Seriously, I just finished a story where I date a man who has a penis less than four inches. I treat the situation with respect, and the story has a happy ending. Would this story still be placed in the Fetish Category? It has explicit sex, so the other logical category would be Erotic Couplings.

If there's no SPH or similar, it definitely doesn't sound like Fetish... Erotic Couplings is always a safe bet...

 

[Britva415]

Would this story still be placed in the Fetish Category?

As the author, did you fetishize it in the story?

 

[Britva415]

Unless the size of the cock is somehow relevant or even central to the story, then no, it doesn't belong in fetish.

Exactly my thoughts. I wouldn't even describe/name/state the size of it at all if there isn't any Chekovs-gun type of reason to do so.

 

[SoCalAshley]

As the author, did you fetishize it in the story?

I did not, and I thank you all for your thoughtful responses. I will post my story in the Erotic Couplings category.

 

[FiveInch033]

I knew that would get your attention. Seriously, I just finished a story where I date a man who has a penis less than four inches. I treat the situation with respect, and the story has a happy ending. Would this story still be placed in the Fetish Category? It has explicit sex, so the other logical category would be Erotic Couplings.

I've wrote a bunch of stories with guys who are smaller. I didn't put it in fetish, but I did put it as a tag.

 

[VerbalAbuse]

I've wrote a bunch of stories with guys who are smaller. I didn't put it in fetish, but I did put it as a tag.

Nobody is small. Everybody is perfect size.

 

[bobsyouruncle55]

There is no dialog that states that a small penis is freakish. The story is more about how to deal with a small penis in a positive manner.

it's not the size that counts it's how you use it.the wife told me before we met she had a few boyfriends
some had a small penis but knew just how to use it

 

[SimonDoom]

Nobody is small. Everybody is perfect size.

This is like the erotic equivalent of Lake Wobegon, where all children are above average.

 

[Escierto]

it's not the size that counts it's how you use it.the wife told me before we met she had a few boyfriends
some had a small penis but knew just how to use it

That was definitely true in my experience.

 

[SoCalAshley]

It was also true for me. That is why I wrote a story about it. Unfortunately, it is still in the pending category. As soon as the story is published, I will post a link to it in this thread. I would love to get feedback, especially from other women who also have positive experiences with men who have a less-than-average penis.

 

[FiveInch033]

It was also true for me. That is why I wrote a story about it. Unfortunately, it is still in the pending category. As soon as the story is published, I will post a link to it in this thread. I would love to get feedback, especially from other women who also have positive experiences with men who have a less-than-average penis.

I'm looking forward to reading it. It'd be rewarding for me to read a story about a guy who is smaller from a woman's perspective and it be positive.

 

[MrHereWriting]

It was also true for me. That is why I wrote a story about it. Unfortunately, it is still in the pending category. As soon as the story is published, I will post a link to it in this thread. I would love to get feedback, especially from other women who also have positive experiences with men who have a less-than-average penis.

Without reading the story, I can't really say, but if the focus of the story isn't on the guy's little dick, whether it be uplifting and celebrated, or degraded, it doesn't sound like a fetish story.

But, is his penis really small? Let's let Randy Marsh answer that question.

 

[SoCalAshley]

I can’t believe it’s been nine months since my original question: "I just finished a story where I date a man who has a penis less than four inches. I treat the situation with respect, and the story has a happy ending. Would this story still be placed in the Fetish category?"

I originally wrote my small penis story for the 750-word challenge. For various reasons, it was never published. In retrospect, I am glad it never made it to publication. It gave me a chance to make changes to the story, so it evolved into something more than just a small penis story. If the story resonated with you, I would love to get your feedback.

Small Piece of Meat

 

[Kumquatqueen]

I can’t believe it’s been nine months since my original question: "I just finished a story where I date a man who has a penis less than four inches. I treat the situation with respect, and the story has a happy ending. Would this story still be placed in the Fetish category?"

I originally wrote my small penis story for the 750-word challenge. For various reasons, it was never published. In retrospect, I am glad it never made it to publication. It gave me a chance to make changes to the story, so it evolved into something more than just a small penis story. If the story resonated with you, I would love to get your feedback.

Small Piece of Meat

Sweet.

Same moral as my story Making Lemonade - if a man enthusiastically goes down on a woman, she won't care much about his cock size, if the guy isn't defensive and is willing to work round it. Or at least, some women will be happy.