Sigh.

i honestly have a hard time deciding what's worse between voting v. appointing judges, but i really do not like giving them lifetime appointments.
 
2. What are your specific objections to those rulings and the Court's published rationales for them?



My objection is that the Court's majority has either never read Section 2 of the 15th Amendment, or (more likely) doesn't care what it says.
 
Two questions:

1. Have you read the opinion (or at least the summary of the specific legal principles that were ruled upon)?

2. What are your specific objections to those rulings and the Court's published rationales for them?

"Times have changed" is certainly a novel legal principle.
 
Two questions:

1. Have you read the opinion (or at least the summary of the specific legal principles that were ruled upon)?

2. What are your specific objections to those rulings and the Court's published rationales for them?

1. Yes, I've read both the majority opinion and the dissent.

2. Ginsberg's opinion nailed it, under the fifteenth amendment "

Section 1. The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.

Section 2. The Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation."

How can one possibly argue that the VRA is unconstitutional under section 2?
 
My objection is that the Court's majority has either never read Section 2 of the 15th Amendment, or (more likely) doesn't care what it says.

Your absurd statement is thoroughly rebutted by the very passage of the Voting Rights Act itself for the unmistakeable purpose of enforcing the provisions of Section 1 of the 15th Amendment. In the 48 years that the Voting Rights Act has been on the books, that purpose, and the VRA's effectiveness in achieving it, have remained unquestioned and unchanged.

As I hope my more detailed response to Sean will demonstrate, the Court's action today is primarily that of correcting an unconstitutional and thus "inappropriate" presumption in an act whose otherwise characterization as "appropriate legislation" is wholly affirmed and remains in force to continue to address the discriminatory evils it was designed to eradicate.

1. Yes, I've read both the majority opinion and the dissent.

2. Ginsberg's opinion nailed it, under the fifteenth amendment "

Section 1. The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.

Section 2. The Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation."

How can one possibly argue that the VRA is unconstitutional under section 2?

No one, least of all SCOTUS, is arguing that the VRA is unconstitutional in its entirety. If that is your interpretation after reading even the syllabus alone, I don't know how you could have missed the point so badly.

Only Section 4 of the Act, and only with regard to the "formula" it specifies therein AND only with respect to that formula initiating the remedy specified in Section 5, was held unconstitutional.

That Section 4 formula was as follows:

1, (a)....no citizen shall be denied the right to vote in any Federal, State, or local election because of his failure to comply with any test or device in any State" [used] "for the purpose or with the effect of denying or abridging the right to vote on account of race or color";

2. (b) The provisions of subsection (a) shall apply in any State or in any political subdivision of a state which (1) the Attorney General determines maintained on November 1, 1964, any test or device, and with respect to which (2) the Director of the Census determines that less than 50 percentum of the persons of voting age residing therein were registered on November 1, 1964, or that less than 50 percentum of such persons voted in the presidential election of November 1964.

The remedy for discriminatory conditions resulting from that formula were specified in Section 5:

SEC. 5. Whenever a State or political subdivision with respect to which the prohibitions set forth in section 4(a) are in effect shall enact or seek to administer any voting qualification or prerequisite to voting, or standard, practice, or procedure with respect to voting DIFFERENT from that in force or effect on November 1, 1964, such State or subdivision may institute an action in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia for a declaratory judgment that such qualification, prerequisite, standard, practice, or procedure does not have the purpose and will not have the effect of denying or abridging the right to vote on account of race or color

In other words, states and/or their individual voting districts who, prior to November, 1964, were found to discriminate the voting rights of its citizens by virtue of the formula described in Sec. 4 of the VRA were essentially judged to be guilty in perpetuity and any subsequent state or local statute changing or affecting voting standards or procedures whatsoever were required to be "preapproved" by the Department of Justice.

The only avenue other than DOJ pre-approval was a declaratory judgment by a federal District Court that the proposed statutory change was in compliance with Sec. 4 of the VRA.

In today's ruling the Court said,

"States retain broad autonomy, however, in structuring their governments and pursuing legislative objectives. Indeed, the Tenth Amendment reserves to the States all powers not specifically granted to the Federal Government, including “the power to regulate elections.” (Gregory v. Ashcroft , 501 U. S. 452, 461–462). There is also a “fundamental principle of equal sovereignty” among the States, which is highly pertinent in assessing disparate treatment of States. (Northwest Austin supra, at 203.)

"The Voting Rights Act sharply departs from these basic principles. It requires States to beseech the Federal Government for permission to implement laws that they would otherwise have the right to enact and execute on their own. And despite the tradition of equal sovereignty, the Act applies to only nine States (and additional counties). That is why, in 1966, this Court described the Act as “stringent” and “potent,” (Katzenbach, 383 U. S., at 308, 315, 337). The Court nonetheless upheld the Act, concluding that such an “uncommon exercise of congressional power” could be justified by “exceptional conditions.” (Id., at 334. Pp. 9–12.)

The Court's description of the effects of Sec. 4 and 5 as an "uncommon exercise of power" justified only by "exceptional conditions" is appropriate for the same reason a presumption that someone is "guilty until proven innocent" would only be justified by "exceptional conditions."

The invocation of martial law, the suspension of habeas corpus, government orders to evacuate from the path of an oncoming storm are all uncommon exercises of power justified by exceptional conditions which we rightfully expect to be abandoned as soon as possible after the exceptional threat has passed.

The Court took note of that similar situation surrounding the VRA today:
"Nearly 50 years later, things have changed dramatically. Largely because of the Voting Rights Act, “[v]oter turnout and registration rates” in covered jurisdictions “now approach parity. Blatantly discriminatory evasions of federal decrees are rare. And minority candidates hold office at unprecedented levels.” (Northwest Austin, supra, at 202). The tests and devices that blocked ballot access have been forbidden nationwide for over 40 years. Yet the Act has not eased §5’s restrictions or narrowed the scope of §4’s coverage formula along the way."

So why did Attorney General Holder slam the ruling as "a serious setback for voting rights and has the potential to negatively affect millions of Americans across the country"?

Well, that's a lie, of course, but the fact that any redrawing of Congressional district lines has an "affect" on voting that would impact those NINE states and their voting districts already under the authority of VRA's Sec. 5 gives the Department of Justice and Attorney General Holder veto power over any "new" laws changing district boundaries. Or at least it did until today.

As Lois Beckett wrote two years ago in ProPublica, "While the Supreme Court ruled in 1986 that partisan gerrymandering was unconstitutional and could be challenged in court, it set such a high standard of proof that it made legal challenges of such districts extremely difficult. Since then, the Court has remained divided on whether there is any viable way to set a judicial standard for what makes a given district an illegal gerrymander."

Of course, the VRA has nothing to do with political gerrymandering, but neither was there anything in the law that would prevent an Attorney General from abusing it for his partisan political purposes. And the sudden loss of that portion of the law that inadvertently allowed him to do that could only be loudly grieved.

And that, my friends, is what today's wailing and gnashing of teeth is truly about.
 
Last edited:
Today's ruling has gutted the vra. And if you think it's just about gerrymandering, you haven't been paying attention.

Conservatives will be holding a celebration tonight at the Edmund Pettus bridge in Selma, Alabama. A single Negro will be thrown off the bridge to commemorate the Supreme Court ruling.

As Vetteman no doubt said today "It's a great day to be white!"
 
Actually, conservatives should be railing against activist judges legislating from the bench and amending a law passed by both houses and signed by a president, a law congress chose not to amend on its own.

They won't do that, of course. This thread's been around all day with nary a peep.

My comments have nothing to do with the quality of the decision. That's not my point at all. I just remember vette saying that he'll accept gay marriage when it's passed by an elected legislature and signed by an executive, and not when some judge tells him to.



By the way, Sean, I'm pissed. I thought this thread was about me.
 
Actually, conservatives should be railing against activist judges legislating from the bench and amending a law passed by both houses and signed by a president, a law congress chose not to amend on its own.

They won't do that, of course. This thread's been around all day with nary a peep.

My comments have nothing to do with the quality of the decision. That's not my point at all. I just remember vette saying that he'll accept gay marriage when it's passed by an elected legislature and signed by an executive, and not when some judge tells him to.



By the way, Sean, I'm pissed. I thought this thread was about me.

Ha! I did actually think of that after I posted it.
 
Actually, conservatives should be railing against activist judges legislating from the bench and amending a law passed by both houses and signed by a president, a law congress chose not to amend on its own.

They won't do that, of course. This thread's been around all day with nary a peep.

I was surprised to learn today that there was actually an amendment to update the map criteria in 2006. It was defeated by Rapepublicans, largely because it would have subjected America's midwestern racist mecca (Indiana) to federal oversight.

My comments have nothing to do with the quality of the decision. That's not my point at all. I just remember vette saying that he'll accept gay marriage when it's passed by an elected legislature and signed by an executive, and not when some judge tells him to.

The Vettebigot has also made the same acceptance claim about mixed-race marriages. At least his bigotry is consistent.


By the way, Sean, I'm pissed. I thought this thread was about me.

I did too. I thought this thread was just Sean pitchin' woo to you, I was about to start my own thread but thought I'd search "Shelby" first to make sure someone else didn't already. I was more than a bit surprised.
 
Today's ruling has gutted the vra. And if you think it's just about gerrymandering, you haven't been paying attention.

It most emphatically did no such thing. It merely took the nine states previously subjected to "preclearance" (Sec. 5) and put them on an equal legal footing with the other 41 states.

Is it your position that the other 41 states are not prohibited under VRA from discriminating against people of color with respect to voting rights? Give me a fucking break. You're pissing down your leg like half the other idiots here who don't know the law and care even less about critically examining it.

You are flat ass wrong, and I am surprised and sorely disappointed in your apparent inability to admit it.
 
"Times have changed" is certainly a novel legal principle.

Well, it's not. At least I hope not, despite Scalia's insistence otherwise. If law and times did not change, Rosa Parks would still be at the back of the bus, and we'd still be executing the mentally retarded.

Affirmative action is dying an awkward death. The timing may be wrong right now. But in the long run, though, it may be a good thing. At some point Vetteman's claim of being a downtrodden white man may take traction.

Supreme Court judges have always been political in the states. Below that, it used to not necessarily be the case. Iowa, for example, once had a great system.

Everything is political now.
 
Your absurd statement is thoroughly rebutted by the very passage of the Voting Rights Act itself for the unmistakeable purpose of enforcing the provisions of Section 1 of the 15th Amendment. In the 48 years that the Voting Rights Act has been on the books, that purpose, and the VRA's effectiveness in achieving it, have remained unquestioned and unchanged.

As I hope my more detailed response to Sean will demonstrate, the Court's action today is primarily that of correcting an unconstitutional and thus "inappropriate" presumption in an act whose otherwise characterization as "appropriate legislation" is wholly affirmed and remains in force to continue to address the discriminatory evils it was designed to eradicate.


With all due respect--and you're usually above calling people "absurd" unless they're overtly absurd--Justice Ginsburg agrees with me and not you, and I'm certainly comfortable with that company.



Well, it's not. At least I hope not, despite Scalia's insistence otherwise. If law and times did not change, Rosa Parks would still be at the back of the bus, and we'd still be executing the mentally retarded.

Affirmative action is dying an awkward death. The timing may be wrong right now. But in the long run, though, it may be a good thing. At some point Vetteman's claim of being a downtrodden white man may take traction.

Supreme Court judges have always been political in the states. Below that, it used to not necessarily be the case. Iowa, for example, once had a great system.

Everything is political now.


You'd think the Democrats wouldn't forget that after the repeated screwings they've gotten from the Court the last 13 years.

And yet, both Thomas and Alito sit on the Court having gotten less than 60 votes to confirm, an option that would obviously not be available to the nominee of any Democratic president. And John Roberts sits as the fourth straight Republican-nominated Chief Justice, a man who told the Senate "Well golly, I just want to be an impartial umpire and have no one notice me," only to turn around and issue activist decision after activist decision.

The only recourse for the Democrats is winning so many presidential elections in a row that there's no way for Scalia and Kennedy to avoid having their successors go blue (the reverse of Bush I getting to replace Brennan and Marshall). But that's hard to do.
 
Back
Top