Sigh.

You think they vote on strict party lines because of legal differences?

i don't think they're idiots who only vote along party lines without rigorous legal research and justification of their opinions
 
You think they vote on strict party lines because of legal differences?

It's all opinion so of course they'll tend to vote along party lines and consider it legal differences. If it was all fact there would never be dissent.
You find a legal system that's perfect be sure and let us know.
 
It's all opinion so of course they'll tend to vote along party lines and consider it legal differences. If it was all fact there would never be dissent.
You find a legal system that's perfect be sure and let us know.

One where the judges aren't political appointees would be a fucking good start.
 
It's a mixed bag of a decision.

The conservative wing of the Supreme Court delivered a political masterstroke: it said the USA can no longer rely upon 1965 voter registration percentages to determine discriminatory areas. That, in truth, should have been updated long ago. Their remedy, to have Congress redraw the map, is a huge gift to the Republicans, because there is no way in hell that racist Tea Party Rapepublicans are ever going to vote for any map that doesn't ensure white superiority.

I was very surprised and pleased to learn the Supreme Court left the statute about citizens being able to sue for damages under the Voting Rights act intact. Alito, Scalia and his boy have all previously opined that part was unconstitutional. Guess they didn't have the votes.
 
One where the judges aren't political appointees would be a fucking good start.

It's worked out pretty well for us so far. They make mistakes and sometimes it can take time for those mistakes to be corrected but for the most part it's fine. Not liking a decision doesn't make it wrong. Sometimes it's the constitutionally correct one but not a popular one.
 
And just by the way, what evidence do you have that proves the judicial system is superior in the UK?
 
Not to burst your bubble, but everyone has political motivations. You, me, judges, everyone!

And yet, no matter how unpopular the decisions they make, British judges don't get accused of political bias. Funny, that.
 
And yet, no matter how unpopular the decisions they make, British judges don't get accused of political bias. Funny, that.

Okay, we bow to your moral superiority and overall betterness. Now shut up.
 
I lost my illusions about the Court a long time ago. Once you know who the identity of the petitioner and the respondent, you can predict the outcome of virtually every case. Scalia's dissent in the police DNA decision is pretty much the only surprising thing that's happened the whole term.
 
Back
Top