Should we attack Iraq?

Should the U.S. attack Iraq?

  • Yes

    Votes: 25 36.8%
  • No

    Votes: 31 45.6%
  • Not sure

    Votes: 6 8.8%
  • Where\'s a flirting thread?

    Votes: 6 8.8%

  • Total voters
    68
I'm not against fighting the war, I have a problem with people such as yourself comparing Afghanistan to Iraq. Afghanistan is one of the 5 poorest countries in the world, with a leader that lived in a hut. The Northern Alliance proved to be extremely helpful they were aligned before we appeared, jury is still out on the Kurds. Muslim militants were hesitant to help out Bin Laden in Afghanistan because it is virtually impossible to get to the place. We can't follow the same model because it took too long...When we start, groundtroops are needed to strike quickly to limit the opportunities that Israel can become involved and cause the war to broaden. Upon victory we'll have to stay there a long time because even if a proAmerican government is put in they are to be threatened by both terrorists and neighbors. I say you are a hawk and irrational on the topic because you let on that it will be a flippant affair. This war will be bigger than Gulf War 1 because everyone knows the stakes are sky high and there are big factors we'll have problems controlling.
 
70/30 said:
I'm not against fighting the war, I have a problem with people such as yourself comparing Afghanistan to Iraq. Afghanistan is one of the 5 poorest countries in the world, with a leader that lived in a hut. The Northern Alliance proved to be extremely helpful they were aligned before we appeared, jury is still out on the Kurds. Muslim militants were hesitant to help out Bin Laden in Afghanistan because it is virtually impossible to get to the place. We can't follow the same model because it took too long...When we start, groundtroops are needed to strike quickly to limit the opportunities that Israel can become involved and cause the war to broaden. Upon victory we'll have to stay there a long time because even if a proAmerican government is put in they are to be threatened by both terrorists and neighbors. I say you are a hawk and irrational on the topic because you let on that it will be a flippant affair. This war will be bigger than Gulf War 1 because everyone knows the stakes are sky high and there are big factors we'll have problems controlling.
OK, you're right, those are some big issues, and although I may have sounded overly cocky, I do think there are some serious issues. However, if there's one thing I have faith in, it's the U.S. military, if allowed to do their jobs and led by a clear policy.

That said, let me ask a serious question about all these potential problems, pitfalls, and possibilities: So what? What about these things is so overwhelming and so dangerous that they nullify the overriding imperative to rid the freedom-loving nations of the world of one of its biggest enemies?

I agree, we shouldn't walk into attacking Iraq with a willy-nilly, "oh let's give this a whirl," cavalier attitude. But it's been seven months since Bush identified Iraq as a standing member of the "axis of evil," and a year since September 11. That length of time at least indicates that there is thought being devoted to this. And you can almost sense (or at least Saddam does) that attacking Iraq is a certainty, and right now we're just waiting for the Pentagon or NORAD or the CIA or whoever to analyze all the info, run all the scenarios, and crunch all the numbers.

TB4p
 
Re: Re: TB4P

teddybear4play said:
Here, I'll throw a bone to Don K Dyck and the rest of you conspiracy theorists: whoever takes over in Iraq will have incentive to be friends with us — an end to the U.N. sanctions and renewed oil trade with the U.S.. They get money, we get lower prices at the gas pumps. I call that a win/win situation.
TB4p

Hi TB4p, Please . . . go and read your American history . . . there are some credible academics who tell it as it is . . . or read John Pilger's new book, "New Rulers of the World" which is based on US government documents.

Remember the 1973 "Oil Crisis" when the oil companies racked up huge profits by purchasing before the emergency??? Do you see any similarity with the present situation??
 
teddybear4play said:
But it's been seven months since Bush identified Iraq as a standing member of the "axis of evil," and a year since September 11. That length of time at least indicates that there is thought being devoted to this.

No it doesn't.

It means Bush is not getting the support he wants and needs from around the world, whilst at home his own Administration is quickly becoming split over the issue, some of his senior military men are voicing their doubts about the logistics of the job and now people from his daddy's administration, including Stormin' Norman, say it's a bad idea to invade Iraq.

And where was Colin Powell a few days ago when Bush was having his 'inner war cabinet' meeting prior to returning to Washington after the summer break?

Definitely conspicuous by his absence...

I doubt if the man is thinking anything through at all. Trying to hold together what little he's got is more likely...

ppman
 
Re: Of ships and sealing wax . . .

REDWAVE said:
Rex, I find all your points about Saddam singularly unconvincing. The Kurds in northern Iraq have a de facto independent state, under the protection of the U.S. "no fly" zone. Meanwhile, Kurds in Turkey (staunch U.S. "ally"-- i.e., client state) are viciously oppressed. I don't hear Bush calling for the liberation of the Turkish Kurds. The U.S. government is deathly afraid of Iraq becoming another Shiite theocracy like Iran. (BTW, I think the Shiites are the majority in Iraq, comprising 60% of the population). Kuwait? Iraq & Kuwait recently made nice and all kissy face with each other. War with Iran? The U.S. government supported Iraq during its war with Iran, with no criticisms then of Iraq's use of chemical weapons.

Re the embassy takeover, there's a link on www.cursor.org to a story on that.

Finally, the Sept. 11 atacks were a tragedy, but hardly constituted a serious threat of invasion. Also, there's no evidence linking Iraq to 9/11. Besides, something that big can only happen if the U.S. government lets it happen.

I agree with your point regarding the turkish kurds. Turkey is still violating human rights and not treated properly yet...

Fact is that the minority in the south still suffers from Saddams pressure.

There still is an "Iraq vs Iran" conflict no matter how anybody handled their last war.

Your link leads to a question. In my very personal POV the conclusion in that article - quote:
"posted by The CounterRevolutionary 10:08 PM [+]"
is wrong...

9/11 was no invasion in any military sense but I for one consider it an attack. We might argue whether it was only the US or the entire western world who was attacked by terrorists.
But those people - no matter if they had saudi, afghan, palestinian or iraqi passports - acted as members of the Al Qaida network under support of the "Axis of Evil" and here we find our targets. Saddam Hussein is just one single member of that axis.

Rex :rose:
 
Axis of Evil-- Bush, Rumsfeld, & Ashcroft?

You're really grasping at straws now, Rex. "Axis of Evil" was a really stupid, simplistic phrase by Bush to begin with. And there's no evidence Hussein was in any way involved with 9/11, despite the fervent efforts of the U.S. government to connect him with it.

I can't blame you for keeping mum about the embassy takeover. After all, if you told us what you know, you'd have to kill us, right?
;)
 
Re: Axis of Evil-- Bush, Rumsfeld, & Ashcroft?

REDWAVE said:
You're really grasping at straws now, Rex. "Axis of Evil" was a really stupid, simplistic phrase by Bush to begin with.

Indeed, the "Axis of Evil" was a weak attempt by Bush, and whatever poorly build machine spits out his speeches, to make Bin-Laden and Saddam appear to be as bad as "The Axis Powers" alliance from World War II, which consisted of Germany, Japan, and someone else. Sorry, my history is fuzzy. But if I'm correct, I believe that "The Axis Powers" was a title that was chosen by the formentioned allies. The "Axis of Evil" was nothing more than a lable Bush attempted to put on the terrorists and their leaders, one that he had hoped would develop strength and make the people hate the enemy even more, no matter what enemy that might be. If Bush classified them to be in the "Axis of Evil" then he could make the American public hate whoever he wanted.

"It has been confirmed...Alanis Morset has joined the Axis of Evil."

:D And now, I must run and hide in a bunker deep unground for the assault of the Alanis fans.
 
I saw a CNN poll today that claimed 53% of Americans were currently in favor of invading Iraq. Down from 71% at the end of 2001. There is a big undecided contingent like myself that wants to see some allies involved and a bare bones plan on what would be done after we win.
 
Re: Axis of Evil-- Bush, Rumsfeld, & Ashcroft?

REDWAVE said:
You're really grasping at straws now, Rex. "Axis of Evil" was a really stupid, simplistic phrase by Bush to begin with. And there's no evidence Hussein was in any way involved with 9/11, despite the fervent efforts of the U.S. government to connect him with it.

I can't blame you for keeping mum about the embassy takeover. After all, if you told us what you know, you'd have to kill us, right?
;)

Hi Redwave, pp man, Merlin et al,

Have you noticed how difficult it is to educate the Americans about their own history??

In Oz we have just seen the economic card played by the Iraqs. In resonse to our Cowboy Prime Minister "Honest" John Howard, backing the US Dubyah Administration sabre rattling, Iraq cancelled $200 million wheat import contract and are threatening to cancel the remaining $200 million. Needless to say, this is a good strategy for bringing reality to our myoptic Prime Minister. Every grain farmer in eastern Oz has rung the PM to tell him to shut up and stay out of any war that will muck up our primary products markets, all ready battling the US Farm Bill subsidies and similar EU subsidies.

However, Howard's ego is probably large enough that just before he retires, probably in the next 12 months, he is likely to legislate conscription to provide cannon fodder for the US military campaign. The local consequences are mind boggling - it will be back to Vietnam resistance for many voters, with a likely change to a Labor/socialist government.

I notice that Dubyah excluded from the list of terrorist organisations MI5 (responsible for the Princess Diana assassination), the Mossad, and of course his own CIA (responsible for the overthrow on numerous democratically elected governments throughout the world, especially in the western hemisphere).
 
Last edited:
Don

Thanks for your remarks. I agree Australia is facing serious turmoil-- as is the U.S., the world's foremost imperialist power. You may find my new thread "The Eagle Has Crash Landed" interesting. I invite you to comment on it.
 
History



Indeed, the "Axis of Evil" was a weak attempt by Bush, and whatever poorly build machine spits out his speeches, to make Bin-Laden and Saddam appear to be as bad as "The Axis Powers" alliance from World War II, which consisted of Germany, Japan, and someone else. Sorry, my history is fuzzy. But if I'm correct, I believe that "The Axis Powers" was a title that was chosen by the formentioned allies.

The other people would be Italy. There was a guy there named Mussolini. Not as successful as Hitler, but Hitler got some ideas from him. Try watching Charlie Chaplin's "The Great Dictator."

I still like to laugh at these arguments that Iraq is somehow involved in 9/11. Why can't even pro-military strife people admit that if we went after EVERY evil, we should start with those most embarrassing ones we never vanquished. We could start in Cuba and finally oust Castro. Hey, we already have Marines in Guantanamo! Good cigars for all Americans! After we finish with Cuba, we can go to Iran and take vengeance for them kicking Carter out of office back in 1980. After we've leveled Iran I'm not sure what we'll use it for. Hopefully it's flat enough to use for several large runways so we can fly sorties through the Middle East without depending on Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia is the next target. First we helicopter drop a few tons of raw sewage on Mecca, then we cut it into several pieces and send them into geosynchronous orbit so religious zealots don't know in which direction to pray. Finally we will have made the world safe for democracy and we can all pray in public schools followed by chanting the "under God" pledge of allegiance.
 
Back
Top