"Loving Wives" and knee-jerk reactions. A theory.

thebullet

Rebel without applause
Joined
Feb 25, 2003
Posts
1,247
Many people who read Literotica have absolutely no sense of humor when it comes to the “Loving Wives” category. In this genre, quality of the writing and reasonableness of the plot don’t really count for much.

There is a theory I’m working on. The next thing you are about to hear is my theory. Uh-hum. My theory: there is a posse of vigilantes consisting of the usual gang of idiots who don’t even read the stories. Instead they fast-forward to the end. If the husband divorces the wife they give the story a high mark. If he doesn’t they give it a ‘1’ and call him a cuckold/wimp often implying that the writer is dickless.

Ever since the public comments section came on line, I’ve been amused to read what people have had to say about “Loving Wives” stories. The negative posters who identify themselves are almost invariably knee-jerk responders. They have two ‘Loving Wives” response templates; one they use for when the husband throws the wife out, the other when the husband tries to save the marriage, or worse – infinitely worse – finds the infidelity arousing.

There is no margin of error for these automatic responses. Even if the husband walks out instead of throwing out the wife, the marks are lower. Humor and good writing in these stories go right over these peoples’ heads.

I decided to test my theory by writing my own “Loving Wives” story. I put some humor into the story. I acknowledge that my sense of humor is a bit warped so I can’t criticize those who don’t understand it. I made the husband a cold, calculating mean-spirited son of a bitch with practically no redeeming qualities.

There is one writer, (If you follow the “Loving Wives” section you all know who I mean), whose stories invariably involve explaining how the protagonist goes about getting the evidence on the wife, always culminating in the successful denouement of his plans, the wife begging for mercy while he laughs at her. I mean, for just one story, okay. But for every story you write? No offense intended but aren’t there, like, other plots available in the universe of plots?

Just for shits and giggles, I borrowed this strategy for my story, too.

But, dear readers, don’t you want to see something completely different occasionally? I gave my loving wife a brain. My loving wife was just as manipulative as the husband, and she was better at achieving her agenda. Her plan wasn’t to screw around on her husband; it was to screw around with his head. It was to get her husband’s attention.

She fucked the fattest, ugliest guy she could find, knowing that her husband was watching on spy cameras he had planted in the bedroom.

Here is where I threw out a little hook for the readers to bite on or refuse the bait. I was betting the usual gang of idiots would bite. Boy was I right!

My story’s husband rushed home and beat the living crap out of the fat ugly boyfriend and then threw him out of the house. His intention was to throw the wife out too. He had already hidden all of the marital assets.

But then the story made a u-turn. For the first time in the marriage, the wife captured the husband’s interest by showing she was an independent and sexy person, not just a trophy. In the end, he decides to give the marriage a chance.

I got an email, anonymous of course, that said:
I HATE wimp husband stories. YOU get a 1. Be honest, just tell us he is a happy cuckold and we won't waste our time.

The husband in my story almost knocked the boyfriend's balls off and this makes the husband a ‘happy cuckold’ and a ‘wimp’? Did I miss something here?

My theory is, of course, confirmed. Since the marriage wasn’t immediately terminated the husband is a wimp, according to the usual gang of idiots.

I have another theory. If I change the title of my story and re-post it, but slightly alter the ending so that the husband throws the wife out in the end, my average score would rise by a full point in the ratings. BUT IT WOULD RUIN THE POINT OF THE STORY!

HEY, USUAL GANG OF IDIOTS! READ THE F*KING STORIES. AND GET A SENSE OF HUMOR TRANSPLANT. YOU OBVIOUSLY DON’T HAVE ONE.


The story that proves the theory

No, don't ask for a link to my other stories. The usual gang of idiots might slam them too!
 
:D

Ya gotta love readers!

I received some feed back recently castigating me for adding a rider at the end of the story reminding readers to vote or comment IF they enjoyed the story.!
 
LOL - Well, this was enlightening. I had never read anything from this section, and completely assumed that it was about, well, literally loving wives. LOL I didn't know it was meant as sarcasm. Well, something embarrassingly new to me :D lol

There is a theory that entertainment should appeal to the lowest common denominator. Not that I necessarily agree with this theory, but it is a thought?
 
CharleyH said:
There is a theory that entertainment should appeal to the lowest common denominator. Not that I necessarily agree with this theory, but it is a thought?

One which TV production companies are all too ready to follow: Jackass, Survivor, Big Brother and on and on.

Gauche
 
Readers -

There is a certain element of "feedback givers" whose sole purpose, it seems, is to read stories in specific categories of which they somehow disapprove just to low vote and send anonymous comments.


They don't like Loving Wives, or Anal, or Incest, yet they'll read stories there just so they can bitch about them.


Truly stinks. I told someone recently to delete 'em and forget 'em.


:)




Now, as to the Nude Story Contest? Fuck! How many '1' votes can one story get? Geez, don't get me started! :mad:




Um, but I digress.
 
I shouldn't really complain -

the story isn't doing all that badly.

BUT - this has never happened to me before. You'll have the occasional '1' bomb, some people don't like it, some do, whatever. But it is at least fairly accurate.

But this? Every morning I don't even want to check votes because I know it will be knocked down again. And I have 60-some votes now so in order for it to drop from a 4.34 to a 4.25 overnight is with a couple of really low scores.

I don't give a damn about the contest, now, I'm just tired of one of my stories being attacked just 'cause it is IN a stupid contest.

Okay - done digressing again. Thank you, Lime -

:)

(I haven't voted on any of the stories in the contest. I've read quite a few, but I'm going to wait to vote until the final contest list is posted. I don't think I'll be giving any '1' votes, however.)
 
Now, as to the Nude Story Contest? Fuck! How many '1' votes can one story get? Geez, don't get me started!

Sarah:

I bet I have you beat! My story that started this thread is indeed a National Nude Day story. And it has been slammed a multitude of times by the reactionary assholes that lie in wait, waiting to pounce on unsuspecting "Loving Wives" stories.

I have to admit, though, that my story wasn't unsuspecting. It was, in fact, suspecting.

BTW - geez I love your avatar! Submit it for your National Nude Day story and you've got a winner.


The story that started all this ranting, and BTW, it's a National Nude Day story

_____________________________________
Ninety Percent of Everything is Crap - Sturgeon's Law

Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity - Hanlon's (Heinlein's?) Law
 
thebullet said:
Sarah:

I bet I have you beat! My story that started this thread is indeed a National Nude Day story. And it has been slammed a multitude of times by the reactionary assholes that lie in wait, waiting to pounce on unsuspecting "Loving Wives" stories.

I have to admit, though, that my story wasn't unsuspecting. It was, in fact, suspecting.

BTW - geez I love your avatar! Submit it for your National Nude Day story and you've got a winner.


The story that started all this ranting, and BTW, it's a National Nude Day story[/i]

Well, you probably have me beat. I mean, a Contest Entry, and in the Loving Wives category? Double slams for you, baby!

:rose:
 
I f****d up.

I wrote a 'Loving Wives' story about a loving wife.

I should have read some high rated stories in that category before I submitted it.

The feedback was abusive. 'How could they live happily ever after?' 'What the f**k was I doing?'

I have the impression that writing about a happily married couple is a crime - if it is posted in the 'Loving Wives' category.

However some feedback came from AH friends. They made up for all the abuse from Anonymous.

I might put another Loving Wife story in that category. It might cause some readers to blow a fuze.

Og
 
*grin*

Sweet Og, you are such a rebel!

(would personally love to see a few readers blow fuses - permanently)



Lime -

I haven't written in the Loving Wives category yet. Hmmmm. Most of my stories wind up being married couples having great sex, but just with each other. (Is that too boring?) :D
 
Re: Readers -

sweetsubsarahh said:
There is a certain element of "feedback givers" whose sole purpose, it seems, is to read stories in specific categories of which they somehow disapprove just to low vote and send anonymous comments.


They don't like Loving Wives, or Anal, or Incest, yet they'll read stories there just so they can bitch about them.

yeah, what's the deal with that? I haven't had much negative feedback, but the Loving Wives theory seems persuasive. If Reader doesn't like said category of stories, why take the effort to send a snarky email/comment?
 
Re: Re: Readers -

kinky shy girl said:
yeah, what's the deal with that? I haven't had much negative feedback, but the Loving Wives theory seems persuasive. If Reader doesn't like said category of stories, why take the effort to send a snarky email/comment?

Exactly. Why even read a story you know you aren't going to like?

(some people just like to complain)
 
Re: Re: *grin*

Lime said:
I've only written stories about couples as well. Putting another body in there taxes my brain so.

Can't imagine you being boring. Take the plunge. At the very least they'll be good fodder for a rant.

Lime

:D

Mmmmm - perhaps I'm going about this story writing all wrong. I should be thinking of rant fodder ideas . . .

*grin*
 
I've only been here a while, but I've already notices a lit of the knee jerk reactions you've mentioned.
And not always in the story feedback either.
It seems that there are more than a few who have no sense of humor and prefer to attack everything in sight. Sort of like a rabid hyena.

Sometimes I wish there was a site where those rabid individuals could download a sense of humor.
(Or an IQ in the tripke digits...)
 
I would say you got it half right Bullet. they aren't knee jerk reactions, they are just jerk reactions.

-Colly
 
Okay, I've given you the negative side of writing a "Loving Wives" story. Here is the positive side:

I posted a story to the Romance section 37 days ago. It's a pretty good story and currently has a rating of 4.91 (take that you neo-con Loving Wives motherfuckers!)
But it only has 3200 downloads,71 votes, and 4 public comments in 37 days.

My "Loving Wives" story has a rating of only 3.93 (over half a point lower than my next lowest rated story).
BUT: in ONE day it has had 6400 downloads, 70 votes and 11 public comments (some of which are actually complimentarly).

So you take the bitter with the batter.
 
thebullet said:
Okay, I've given you the negative side of writing a "Loving Wives" story. Here is the positive side:

I posted a story to the Romance section 37 days ago. It's a pretty good story and currently has a rating of 4.91 (take that you neo-con Loving Wives motherfuckers!)
But it only has 3200 downloads,71 votes, and 4 public comments in 37 days.

My "Loving Wives" story has a rating of only 3.93 (over half a point lower than my next lowest rated story).
BUT: in ONE day it has had 6400 downloads, 70 votes and 11 public comments (some of which are actually complimentarly).

So you take the bitter with the batter.

Your 3 chapters of Romance are rated 1,2 and 3 in the Top List for Romance. ONLY 71 votes? Most of my stories struggle to reach 10 votes after a year or two. I have dozens of stories with no public comments or any feedback at all.

You are doing very well with both stories. The rating of 3.93 may change once the voting is audited.

Congratulations,

Og
 
Back
Top