That just makes you hot
It didn't start off as penis size, I think the OP expanded to include that when we all decided we liked tall weighty men.
but we should get together some time 
thats funny, I have a thing for Amazons....
lets get together and make some giant babies....
Yes, certainly do.
Sadly, there is alot of truth in this.
Well just something as food for thought... I've read that for something like every 35-40 lbs lost, you can "recover" about an inch of penis length. In overweight men, there is often fat at the base of the penis that "hides" length. When the weight is lost, you actually end up regaining some of that length, making the penis look bigger (or more appropriately, look its true, normal size). You don't actually grow, obviously; you're just sort of rediscovering length you already had! My ex found that to be the case when he lost a lot of weight (about 160 lbs). Of course, there is a limit to what you'll uncover -- you're not going to lose your way to an 8-inch cock if you don't have one already.
All that said, though... from a woman's point of view, it's mostly about how you use it, and more importantly, how you use other parts of your anatomy! I think a man with a smaller cock can certainly still be a good lover. But yeah, you'll run into size queens. All women are different. Variety makes the world go 'round!
I know you were looking for feedback from women, but let me offer a little advice:
The guy that I do know who would be easily comparable is married to this lil chick. She looks like she could be my sister in the plump, short form. Why do some "real" men end up with these teeny things???
