Is Obamacare imploding?

Thanks for making my point, assuming you are good enough to satisfy your customers demand, then that is exactly what should happen. Notice in your little premise that you charged less for your service....competition will always exert downward pressure on price.

(edited to add a period at the end of a sentence)

This is the sound of his post going right over your pointy head.
 
I never said all distortions were bad, merely that they effect supply and demand, and usually in a way that is not beneficial to the consumer. Now, I do think there is too much government regulation, but that's another topic entirely.

And I was pointing that in the real world you'd have to try damn hard to find something that doesn't have distortions. I'm sure you could find something if you tried hard enough but usually not.

I think in many cases we have too little government regulation and it directly leads to problems but as you said that's a separate topic. The topic at hand was distortion free markets which you started out selling as a positive and now much like regulations "well some are good, just if I'm talking I mean the bad one instead of the hundreds of good ones" where you're all wishy washy.
 
Hey guys....just pulled myself out of bed at the crack of who gives a shit PM. Earth is still spinning....Obamacare didn't end the universe. :cool:
 
You warn against questioning God, but have no problem telling others how He would feel about something that was never once mentioned. Presuming to speak for God puts you in a rather precarious position.

But you make an incorrect assumption. I believe I have said on numerous occasions that each is free to believe whatever one wants.

I believe that God speaks to all of the issues in the world, through Bible. That is my belief, that is my faith.

If in believing as I do and in that faith I have, believing that there is only one way to God and that those who do not accept Jesus Christ as their Savior will not be in heaven...that is my right to believe that.

We can debate as you wish, but my thoughts and opinions about this country come from my faith. Yours comes from yours.

I am completely opposed to obamacare and found an option that will work for my family. If you want to participate, that is your choice as well.

If we can agree that we have different points of view, perhaps discussions can behave here in a reasonable manner.
 
Exactly.

So where is the rationing coming in? If there is a product or service that someone wants, someone else will step in and fill the need.

So what if doctors have competition? They are, by far, the highest paid of any occupation and boo hoo if they are forced to accept less.

Obamacare will create MORE customers for the doctors, no less. That demand will force an increase in supply.

Unless the money one makes from being a Doctor goes down because of the inevitable price controls. Which I believe I've posted about before..

If government could create some rule or regulation to grow the economy, then why don't they do it? It should be easy, just demand that everybody buy everything. Just like that...we'd have full employment, everybody's need would be satisfied.

It's been tried before, many times, and always failed.

You know what they say "those that cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it"
 
I believe that God speaks to all of the issues in the world, through Bible. That is my belief, that is my faith.

And due to that faith you are more righteous than any other and thus are an authority on telling them how they should live, according to YOUR god, correct?

You love politicizing your religion, couldn't imagine you not voting it.
 
Unless the money one makes from being a Doctor goes down because of the inevitable price controls. Which I believe I've posted about before..

If government could create some rule or regulation to grow the economy, then why don't they do it? It should be easy, just demand that everybody buy everything. Just like that...we'd have full employment, everybody's need would be satisfied.

It's been tried before, many times, and always failed.

You know what they say "those that cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it"

Where are the price controls?????

The US government is the largest single purchaser of medical services, in the world. As the customer, can't they say, "No, I'm not paying $100 for that office visit, but I'll pay you $80?"

If a doctor doesn't want $80, nobody is forcing him to accept it, and he can stand firm on his $100 price. Some other doctor WILL accept $80. That's pretty much the definition of the free market.
 
What?

I was not assuming that the number of healthcare providers would stay the same. I have no idea about how many health care providers there will be.

What I did say, and will guarantee that the distortion in the healthcare marketplace is going to lead to price controls, followed by rationing.

Help me out here.

Either the number of medical professionals will increase in corresponding ratio to the new influx of patients (resulting in no rationing),
OR
the number of health care professionals will stay static and the new influx of patients will result in rationing, (in which case you are arguing the number of providers is static)

Which is it? I'm going with option A.

And whatever Walgreen's does, someone is going to pay for the additional staff they have to hire, which is going to lead to more cost shifting, followed by even more rationing.

Walgreen's is not doing this out a sense of obligation to society, they're for-profit organization and presumably have determined they can make a profit in this segment.
 
Where are the price controls?????

The US government is the largest single purchaser of medical services, in the world. As the customer, can't they say, "No, I'm not paying $100 for that office visit, but I'll pay you $80?"

If a doctor doesn't want $80, nobody is forcing him to accept it, and he can stand firm on his $100 price. Some other doctor WILL accept $80. That's pretty much the definition of the free market.

Which is exactly what is happening with medicare, which is exactly what will lead to rationing
 
Where are the price controls?????

The US government is the largest single purchaser of medical services, in the world. As the customer, can't they say, "No, I'm not paying $100 for that office visit, but I'll pay you $80?"

If a doctor doesn't want $80, nobody is forcing him to accept it, and he can stand firm on his $100 price. Some other doctor WILL accept $80. That's pretty much the definition of the free market.

and look at how well the obama fucktard government rolled out obama care! yeah, we should put more eggs in that basket:eek:
 
Hey guys....just pulled myself out of bed at the crack of who gives a shit PM. Earth is still spinning....Obamacare didn't end the universe. :cool:

That's what you think. The reality is that the world ended Hitler came to power and since then we've been living in Hell.

And due to that faith you are more righteous than any other and thus are an authority on telling them how they should live, according to YOUR god, correct?

You love politicizing your religion, couldn't imagine you not voting it.

How do you think she ended up down here with us. Bearing false witness is a fairly major crime.
 
And due to that faith you are more righteous than any other and thus are an authority on telling them how they should live, according to YOUR god, correct?

You love politicizing your religion, couldn't imagine you not voting it.

I do not claim to be the authority. I do however, think that if someone has beliefs in something or someone, that person should know about it.

Faith and politics go hand in hand. If people do not believe in God, they vote for things that support that.....

Same with believers.....vote what they believe.
 
Not disdain....actually, .....well, it doesn't matter.

Anyway, you are correct in that God said to obey the government put in place until it conflicts with God's authority. God wins out!

As far as the healthcare that is being forced upon people....it provides money for abortions. Nope, don't think God would approve of that one!

I don't know why it matters what my opinions are. Obamacare is limping along to be the law of the land. You are welcome to use it. I have chosen a different route! Everyone is happy!

That you don't care how you come across as a Christian pretty much says it all.

Actually, God did not say, "obey the government put in place until it conflicts with God's authority." That is wishful thinking. "God wins out!" Christianity and being a Christian isn't a game. That you think so again shows how little you know about the Bible.

I don't know the specifics on abortion under the ACA, mainly because it doesn't affect me personally. I would think that given the restrictive abortion legislation that has been enacted in the states, and the fact that there are women who actually need abortions for health reasons, that this would not be something to be too concerned about. Considering that God has a history of having the Hebrews murder and make war on anyone that doesn't play by his rules, I have a hard time thinking he's too concerned about abortion. It's one less sinner to be concerned with.

You see Obama limping along. I see it differently. I don't really care about your opinions. You're just one more conservative nut who thinks they know it all. What I find annoying is that you come to a liberal porn site (you know, the liberals you express so much contempt for) to convert others by spouting your ignorance of Christianity and showing your disdain for anyone who disagrees with you.

It's strange that you say I'm welcome to use the ACA, especially since I can't afford it. Very Christian and tea party of you.

You don't seem too happy.
 
Help me out here.

Either the number of medical professionals will increase in corresponding ratio to the new influx of patients (resulting in no rationing),
OR
the number of health care professionals will stay static and the new influx of patients will result in rationing, (in which case you are arguing the number of providers is static)

Which is it? I'm going with option A.



Walgreen's is not doing this out a sense of obligation to society, they're for-profit organization and presumably have determined they can make a profit in this segment.

At this point I don't have any clue what you are talking about, no Doctor is going to give his good or service away for free. Can we agree on that?

If the ACA increases the number of consumers of health care, which I believe we have agreed upon previously, the price of healthcare will go up, as demand will outstrip supply. This will drive the price up Since some segment of this large increase of consumers will not be able to meet that price, the government will regulate the price At some price point persons who would have done whatever was required of them be become a healthcare provider will decide it's not worth it to do so. This will lead to scarcity and rationing. It's already freaking happening!
 
At this point I don't have any clue what you are talking about, no Doctor is going to give his good or service away for free. Can we agree on that?

No. Because even that is funadmentally untrue.

If the ACA increases the number of consumers of health care, which I believe we have agreed upon previously, the price of healthcare will go up, as demand will outstrip supply. This will drive the price up Since some segment of this large increase of consumers will not be able to meet that price, the government will regulate the price At some price point persons who would have done whatever was required of them be become a healthcare provider will decide it's not worth it to do so. This will lead to scarcity and rationing. It's already freaking happening!

There is no reason to think the number of doctors won't increase or a lot of other things that should happen to prevent what you're seeing in the future.
 
That you don't care how you come across as a Christian pretty much says it all.

Actually, God did not say, "obey the government put in place until it conflicts with God's authority." That is wishful thinking. "God wins out!" Christianity and being a Christian isn't a game. That you think so again shows how little you know about the Bible.

I don't know the specifics on abortion under the ACA, mainly because it doesn't affect me personally. I would think that given the restrictive abortion legislation that has been enacted in the states, and the fact that there are women who actually need abortions for health reasons, that this would not be something to be too concerned about. Considering that God has a history of having the Hebrews murder and make war on anyone that doesn't play by his rules, I have a hard time thinking he's too concerned about abortion. It's one less sinner to be concerned with.

You see Obama limping along. I see it differently. I don't really care about your opinions. You're just one more conservative nut who thinks they know it all. What I find annoying is that you come to a liberal porn site (you know, the liberals you express so much contempt for) to convert others by spouting your ignorance of Christianity and showing your disdain for anyone who disagrees with you.

It's strange that you say I'm welcome to use the ACA, especially since I can't afford it. Very Christian and tea party of you.

You don't seem too happy.

You think following God is a game? Great for you!
I could not be more serious about it! If you see being a Christian as something to "hold you back", then that is your own issue.

As you don't care about my opinions, your's are not my concern either. I do hope to find you in Heaven one day, but that is between you and God.

Obamacare? I am sorry you can't afford it. I can't either. I found an alternative that will work for my family. We won't pay a fine and we won't be subjected to trying to find a way to pay a monthly premium that is close to the same amount as our mortgage.

Whether you believe me or not, I do care. That is why I think obamcare is such a horrible plan. When all is said and done, people who truly need help still will not have it.....but the obama and his kind will been seen as heros.
 
No. Because even that is funadmentally untrue.



There is no reason to think the number of doctors won't increase or a lot of other things that should happen to prevent what you're seeing in the future.

It's unicorns and rainbows all the way down.

Seriously, one simple premise if governments could create full unemployment, then why don't they?

If healthcare is a right, then why doesn't everyone already have it?
 
That's what you think. The reality is that the world ended Hitler came to power and since then we've been living in Hell.

LMAO...maybe I should check the city before opening my yap...wonder how long before the Nazi Zombies make it to my place.

How do you think she ended up down here with us. Bearing false witness is a fairly major crime.

Capital crime if only those damn liberals would GTFO and let us legislate the BIBLE like the constitution says we should.

Faith and politics go hand in hand.

Only in your warped bat shit sense of reality.

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"

There is a reason that was numero uno on the bill of rights......it's because faith and politics end in tragedy every trucking time.

If people do not believe in God, they vote for things that support that.

No, they vote for things of real world importance like building roads and taking care of the community. They simply don't want to waste their time with imaginary boss's who have never shown up or done shit for anyone beyond their own skulls.

Same with believers.....vote what they believe.

Because they think their Christian righteousness entitles them to not only just ignore the constitution but common courtesy/respect of others and try and ram their religion down everyone's throat through force of legislation at every chance they get.

It's strange that you say I'm welcome to use the ACA, especially since I can't afford it. Very Christian and tea party of you.
 
Last edited:
This is the sound of his post going right over your pointy head.

No it didn't, he's trying to point out that there are times when governments willful distortions of a market is a good thing.

That's begging the question, and something I wasn't arguing in the first place.

I've noticed that through all of this discussion, no one has been able to refute the fact that the willful distortion in the market will effect price. And almost always in ways the negatively affect the consumer.
 
No it didn't, he's trying to point out that there are times when governments willful distortions of a market is a good thing.

That's begging the question, and something I wasn't arguing in the first place.

I've noticed that through all of this discussion, no one has been able to refute the fact that the willful distortion in the market will effect price. And almost always in ways the negatively affect the consumer.

It's not that no one has been able to refute your point (not a fact), it's that you are all over the place with your position(s).
 
It's unicorns and rainbows all the way down.

Seriously, one simple premise if governments could create full unemployment, then why don't they?

If healthcare is a right, then why doesn't everyone already have it?

Governments can create full employment. They don't for a number of reasons mostly because it's stupid.

Ah if healthcare is a right why doesn't everybody already have it? The real answer to this is simply that rights are an artificial construct invented by humans.

If you want something a little less deep your rights are precisely what your government says they are, nothing more and nothing less. So you would be correct in that case Health Care is not a right because the US government does not offer it as a right, that is something I intend to change.

No it didn't, he's trying to point out that there are times when governments willful distortions of a market is a good thing.

That's begging the question, and something I wasn't arguing in the first place.

I've noticed that through all of this discussion, no one has been able to refute the fact that the willful distortion in the market will effect price. And almost always in ways the negatively affect the consumer.

Because that's like refuting the point that not killing Godzilla means King Ghidorah will destroy the city. The reality is that since neither of them are real it's kinda moot to discuss your point. The reality is that your point works however you want it to because it's based in a fantasy that doesn't exist.
 
Back
Top