Is morality religion based?

if you know in your heart what is right and wrong, why are there debates on abortion?
 
Should morals be seperate from state?

Well can you legislate morals? At some point don't you have to? Legislate people's choices as right or wrong. Isn't it concievable that someone thinks that murder is morally acceptable? If so then isn't having a law against murder legislating morals?
 
christcat69 said:
If morality and religion are intertwined than why aren't more military men catholic? This way they can kill people as long as they ask for forgiveness.
Seriously though, I believe morals are independent not religious. You know in your heart what is right or wrong. You don't need to go to church so some priest can tell you what to do like he's so f***ing pious. Say you study the bible your whole life, you have no fun, only to find out on your death bed that your priest was unable to come pray for you because he was in jail for molesting a child. Now I say, as long as you know to draw the line at hurting others or yourself, then do it and have fun.

Yes this is true, but on the morals and religion point...how much is inherently known (as a human being without religious influences) and how much is taught or learned (which can and does include religious based teachings)
 
I said morals are seperate from religion, or are at least not dependant on it.

I never said there were "Absolute" morals.

Mind you I might think some are no-brainers, but then , that's me.
 
perky_baby said:
how do you know the difference? who told you? what taught you that one thing was right and the other wasn't?

I don't know about religious people but atheist have a little section of brain matter that tells us that if someone will be hurt in anyway by what we need, or want, or are about to do then we better weigh the possible pain we may cause against the personal satisfaction we'll gain. If the pain we could cause outweighs the satisfaction of fulfilling our need then we delay the process or alter it in a way that doesn't cause harm. I guess non-religious people just work that way.

Hummmm maybe we are genetic mutants that should be cast off from society since our little section of gray matter and life experiences tells us that hurting, manipulating, and seeking gain no matter what or who it damages can really make for crappy relationships and ultimately little or no gain. Ofcourse, casting us off from society would mean admiting that gawd made something less than perfect and does not really coinside with Jebus' teachings that we should love our neighbor. Owww there's another section of gray matter that is hurting. Damn I thought I got rid of that part with the acme home labotomy kit.
 
theGatsby said:
Should morals be seperate from state?

Well can you legislate morals? At some point don't you have to? Legislate people's choices as right or wrong. Isn't it concievable that someone thinks that murder is morally acceptable? If so then isn't having a law against murder legislating morals?

Morals can not be legislated well at all. If one has the morals of say...a Jeffery Dahlmer, or other luminary deranged person, laws will not change the outcome of their acts. Also, remember the prohibition, when alcohol was outlawed...mostly a relgious based push too I might add...It didn't take or stay long because everyone was still drinking and partying anyway.

Having a law against murder isn't legislating morals either. That is just making a way to punish a murderer for taking away the life of another without just cause.

How moral is captial punishment? How moral is child abuse by relgious 'father' figures? How moral is speeding?

Law are made to protect the innocent and give society a way to live together in groups. Morality is that which each individual has (or doesnt have), that little voice that says...no, don't do this or...yes this is right. That voice is a combination of inherent knowledge and then tempered with learned or taught rules on top of it all.
 
perky_baby said:
if you know in your heart what is right and wrong, why are there debates on abortion?

How about this question, if there are 1500 deer in a known area
and only enough food for 500 of them to make it through the winter, is it okay to give out more hunting permits to control the population? If 1000 are hunted, you save the population. In retrospect, if you kill 500 of them, the population still dies. How would you determine which deer to kill? Would you find the sick deer and kill them?
Should we instead force mothers to carry to term and give up their child for adoption? If so, how could be equal out the population? Perhaps, dispose of murderers or known rapists and molesters, or perhaps the old and sick?
 
didn't need an abortion lesson.

I'm prochoice, thanks.
 
Yeah, but do you see the seperations? Or at leat the ambiguities?
 
curious2c said:
Law are made to protect the innocent and give society a way to live together in groups. Morality is that which each individual has (or doesnt have), that little voice that says...no, don't do this or...yes this is right. That voice is a combination of inherent knowledge and then tempered with learned or taught rules on top of it all.

But what is the method of teaching? Religion?
 
perky_baby said:
didn't need an abortion lesson.

I'm prochoice, thanks.

I'm not trying to preach but I was just trying to say that their is a downside to everything if you look at it from a different angle. I think you are incredibly intelligent and didn't mean to insult you in any way. Sorry.
 
Laws are based on defending peoples stuff from one another.

Go check out King Alfred's Doomsday Book. (British History)

Religion comes into law when law says what religion is entitled to, or exempted from.
 
Oscuridad said:
Oh I give up.

Sort it out for yourselves.

<grin> it's just a great debate, sugah. And I for one, think you're doing famously.


christcat, no harm done, was just trying to go back to topic.

so many people scream seperation of church and state. I believe that means we dont' have a national religion and no one dies for their beliefs.

When it gets to the do's and dont's I believe our laws are morality based, and lots of them because of religious views.

The line between right and wrong is drawn by someone when it comes to law. And that person, or persons learn of right and wrong from different places, mainly religious dogma.
 
Indeed, and that the root of most religions is the same sense of right or wrong. It is the legislation of a specific religion that is wrong.
 
Oscuridad said:
I gotta get outta this thread before I go nuclear.

Oh you mean you're gonna blow. Can I watch? :D
Sorry I just had too.

Really you guys just need to go here to hash this out.

Hugs
Belle
 
Law is an outgrwoth of property, sad but nonetheless true.
It might be more complex now with hate crimes and all, but let's not delude ourselves that religion defines law. If that were true, Roe v. Wade could never have happened.

No religion ever had a monopoly on morals anyway. If most of us were Buddhists than going to McDonalds would be far less morally neutral than it currently is.

Tx Belle was on the right track when speaking about that little piece of brain. You don't get denied it for lack of a religion.

Further, I think that religion tends to lull it to sleep, as somebody else is takin' care of all that. (unabashed opinion)

Can I do my primal scream therapy now?
 
Oscuridad said:
Law is an outgrwoth of property, sad but nonetheless true.
It might be more complex now with hate crimes and all, but let's not delude ourselves that religion defines law. If that were true, Roe v. Wade could never have happened.

No religion ever had a monopoly on morals anyway. If most of us were Buddhists than going to McDonalds would be far less morally neutral than it currently is.

Tx Belle was on the right track when speaking about that little piece of brain. You don't get denied it for lack of a religion.

Further, I think that religion tends to lull it to sleep, as somebody else is takin' care of all that. (unabashed opinion)

Can I do my primal scream therapy now?

excellent, and yes. Thank you very much. That's what I was looking for. I just couldn't figure it out in my head. That works for me.

I'm trying to figure out what I believe and why I believe. I was stuck on morality vs. religion. You helped me mucho.

Thanks, oscuridad.
 
perky_baby said:
I'll try to be a bit more coherent.

I'm saying that morality has a huge base in religion. People decide what is morale and what isn't according to what they're taught according to lots of Judeo-Christian dogma.

I'm wondering how people differentiate between a religious morality issue and just a morality issue.

If there is no difference, then religion is morality and there should be a seperation of morality and state.

I believe, that the immorality of politics proves just that.

I think they are seperate things, but interrelated.

A person doesn't need a religion to have morals.

You & I have both met people acting immorally in organized religions. The biblical Pharasies , for example, were rather religious, but very immoral.

Personally, I think people are better with both a religion & morallity.

Power is problamatic. It requires compromise, & that isn't good for a sense of morallity. It isn't good for a religious leader , either.
 
perky_baby said:
excellent, and yes. Thank you very much. That's what I was looking for. I just couldn't figure it out in my head. That works for me.

I'm trying to figure out what I believe and why I believe. I was stuck on morality vs. religion. You helped me mucho.

Thanks, oscuridad.

Pleased to be of service.

... I'm feeling better now BTW.
 
Back
Top