Is morality religion based?

patient1 said:
I think they are seperate things, but interrelated.

A person doesn't need a religion to have morals.

You & I have both met people acting immorally in organized religions. The biblical Pharasies , for example, were rather religious, but very immoral.

Personally, I think people are better with both a religion & morallity.

Power is problamatic. It requires compromise, & that isn't good for a sense of morallity. It isn't good for a religious leader , either.

Damn it, you beat me to it.

What he said.

I also think it is hard to differentiate between morals I'd have anyway and those I have based on my religious beliefs. I'm not sure it is possible to separate the two even if I want to.

Nice thread, Perky. Interesting comments, you made me think!
 
I think Morality is needed in religion, but religion is not needed in morality.

Religions have base morals... something that all people who are truly faithful to their religion follow. Being Atheist myself, I follow a different set of morals then most people, but everyone has their own moral, or honor code
 
I think of religion as a social construct. It can be moral or corrupt. Between Islamic Fundamentalism and the Catholic Cult of Pedophilism, I think we've all seen that.

Morality is something that is both innate and developed from our experiences and environment. It's our inner code that establishes right and wrong. It can be expressed religiously but the two are not mutually inclusive.

I think spirituality needs to be brought into this. Spirituality can be separate from any religion or expressed through religion. Spirituality is closely tied with our morality. I think the higher we hold our spirituality the more sure of our morals we are.

Religion should be separate from politics and government. Ethics which are often governed by morals, should not be separate. For this reason I think politicians with spirituality are desirable, and sometimes you see some who show those subtle signs of knowledge and wisdom spiritual folks often have.
 
perky_baby said:
lavender, please post this thread, so someone will answer it.

Obviously, I'm only allowed to post about ducks and fucking.

LIAR!!

You are perfectly capable of posting about fucking ducks or ducks fucking.

Do not give us that sad sob story.
 
Originally posted by perky_baby
If so, is that the reason the blowjob pres got off with a slap on the wrist?

seperation of church and state? seperation of morality and state?

discuss.
Pretty much exclusively, religions have been the purveyors and enforcers of morality throughout mankind's history.

Their source of authority is mysticism, the special source of knowledge that transceds reason and intellect commonly called faith or belief in the unknown, the unseen, the unknowable.

Those who have deviated from the religious based morality have been the statists, the collectivists. They have essentially taken the same tenets and substituted the state of society or the collective for god.

All such efforts have been implementation of variants of altruism.

Morality has typically been excluded from the realm of man's intellect, from the province of reason. The exception to this monopoly was Ayn Rand who constructed a philosophical system (which entails morality and ethics) based entirely on reason and reality. It ignores mysticism and denies the use of faith, i. e., acceptance of the unknowable and incomprehensible as a basis for moral decisions and choices.

Clinton got off with a slap on the wrist because his political party had sufficient votes to keep him in office despite evidence that supported his removal.

The Democrats were not going to relinquish their political power for any reason whatsoever, certainly not on the basis of ethics or principle.

Their supporters and defenders keep up the lies that the impeachment was about sex (read lavender's post) when there was nothing in the impeachment charges regarding sex. The charges were specifically perjury, suborning perjury and obstruction of justice.

Why lavender has a vested interest in perpetuating these lies I cannot comprehend. She doesn't impress me as being so stupid as to have no means of knowing the facts, thus I have no reasonable choice but to presume she is lying.

The disingenuous tack regarding the way he treated Lewinski or his wife likewise have no bearing whatsoever on the impeachment. While these are morally reprehensible behaviors, they are not crimes (unless possibly the involve slander in the case of Lewinski).

But these should not have been part of the impeachment proceeding as she intimates. Nor could there be an legal culpability for his lying to the American people. But, based on the man's demonstrated historical behavior, what else would one expect of him? That he lied in that case was of absolutey no surprise to me whatsoever.
Originally posted by perky_baby
I'll try to be a bit more coherent.

I'm saying that morality has a huge base in religion. People decide what is morale and what isn't according to what they're taught according to lots of Judeo-Christian dogma.

I'm wondering how people differentiate between a religious morality issue and just a morality issue.

If there is no difference, then religion is morality and there should be a seperation of morality and state.

I believe, that the immorality of politics proves just that.
There are a couple of points at play here.

First, separation of church and state was created to preclude a state religion being declared and adopted, thus given preference over other religions.

Second, morality, for the most part, deals with non-criminal actions, choices and decisions. There is no legitimacy for government delving into such choices which do not involve criminal behaviors.

As most people understand, it is not possible to legislate morality. Alcohol prohibition was a perfect example. The utter failure of drug prohibition today is an equally good illustration of that principle.

It is not the place or purpose of government to dictate choices to the citizenry. The only legitimate purpose of government is to protect the rights of its citizens.
 
Re: Re: Is morality religion based?

Unclebill said:
Pretty much exclusively, religions have been the purveyors and enforcers of morality throughout mankind's history.

True and when those purveryors and enforcers meet other purveyors and enforcers of a different religion we get WAR. The whole my gawd is better than your gawd thing kicks in and all hell breaks loose.

First, separation of church and state was created to preclude a state religion being declared and adopted, thus given preference over other religions.

Second, morality, for the most part, deals with non-criminal actions, choices and decisions. There is no legitimacy for government delving into such choices which do not involve criminal behaviors.

It is not the place or purpose of government to dictate choices to the citizenry. The only legitimate purpose of government is to protect the rights of its citizens. However, more and more American laws as well as laws in other fundementalist countries are being dictated by religion. Sodomy, marriage, divorce....every aspect of our lives is dictated by a religious moral code that has been allowed to become a law. It would do the country good to remember what you've written. Do you want to run for office? I'd give you my vote.
 
Re: Re: Is morality religion based?

Unclebill said:
The only legitimate purpose of government is to protect the rights of its citizens.


Um sorry for the snip, but this line says it all for me.
 
Re: Re: Is morality religion based?

Unclebill said:
Pretty much exclusively, religions have been the purveyors and enforcers of morality throughout mankind's history.

...
Those who have deviated from the religious based morality have been the statists, the collectivists. They have essentially taken the same tenets and substituted the state of society or the collective for god.

All such efforts have been implementation of variants of altruism.

...

I think I'd agree with you if you had said that religions have been the recorders or "codifiers" of moral codes throughout history.

For the most part, religions have only been the final arbitors of morality when they were the dominant force in a particular society. That makes it very difficult to separate the source of the moral codes from the religion that recorded them and the society that formulated them.

For example, Agricultural societies generally have a different set of moral codes from hunter/gatherer societies. Warrior societies have yet another set of moral imperatives.

"Morality" is derived from and tailored to fit the needs of a particular society. The religion(s) that arise along with the moral codes serve only as a means to codify and explain the morality that develops to fit the society. As society evolves, what is considered "moral" evolves along with it -- independent of religious strictures. If the religion also evolves it survives. If the religion doesn't (or can't) evolve to fit the new morality, then it either must seize secular control, to force it's outdated morality on the society, or die.

Unfortunately, religions have successfully gained control of secular society often enough throughout history that the concept of morality has become inextricably entertwined with "religion". Religions have moved beyond the society they evolved in and forced unsuitable moral codes on the societies they "conquered."

Contary to popular belief, religion is based on morality, NOT morality on religion. Morality came first.
 
Originally posted by curious2c...There are some very moral politicians, but I think they all compromise themselves at one point or another while in office making them, for the most part, immoral...
I'll contest the morality of virtually every one of them on a very simple basis; the lack of personal integrity.

Every one of them takes an oath to uphold the Constitution. With rare exception, they all violate or ignore that oath.

If a man does not honor his freely taken promise, his oath, his pledge, how can he claim morality or integrity? Honestly, he can't.
Originally posted by perky_baby
if you know in your heart what is right and wrong, why are there debates on abortion?
The public debate regarding abortion is less about the actual morality of abortion than it is about some people having the power to dictate to others what choices they make in their private lives. The morality of abortion is a personal and private decision rightly between the woman and her doctor and hopefully her husband.
Originally posted by Oscuridad
I said morals are seperate from religion, or are at least not dependant on it.

I never said there were "Absolute" morals.

Mind you I might think some are no-brainers, but then , that's me.
If there are no absolutes, then you are essentially saying that morals are unknowable, and thus effectively non-existent.

The alternative to absolute morality is a morality with standards that are flexible. But such standards are then without meaning because the degree of flexibility permits even further abrogation.

As I noted earlier, one of the tenets of collectivism is the circular logic in defining that which is good.
That definition is, "The good is whatever benefits the collective and the collective declares what is to its benefit".

This is the collectivist premise that good is whatever serves the collective. Another is the end justifies the means. Another is truth is whatever serves the collective.

The Democrats in particular over the past few weeks have demonstrated this ever so clearly by the feeding frenzy they created and perpetuated over Lott's stupid statements at a birthday party.
Originally posted by TxBelle
...Ofcourse, casting us off from society would mean admiting that gawd made something less than perfect and does not really coinside with Jebus' teachings that we should love our neighbor. Owww there's another section of gray matter that is hurting. Damn I thought I got rid of that part with the acme home labotomy kit.
Or perhaps that creation was something a bit closer to the perfect.
Originally posted by TxBelle
However, more and more American laws as well as laws in other fundementalist countries are being dictated by religion. Sodomy, marriage, divorce....every aspect of our lives is dictated by a religious moral code that has been allowed to become a law. It would do the country good to remember what you've written. Do you want to run for office? I'd give you my vote.
If you review the history of America around the time the United States of America was founded, the Federal government was a second try at a national government.

There was also a pronounced distrust of government, particularly a centrailized government, by the colonists.

They would never have adopted the Constitution had the founders undertaken to correct all the problems and potential problems they perceived in government and its attendant abuses.

For example, they could never have abolished slavery. But they did provide the means to do so.

They also could not have overturned local and state laws with the sweep of a hand because the Constitution would never have been adopted.

But again, they provided the means to protect the citizen against tyranny in government.

Most of the laws you cite are state statutes. They are not subject to Constitutional limitations of authority because each state has its own constitution and legislature.

It then becomes necessary to challenge the bad laws and have them overturned.

One of the more revolutionary ideas of the founders was their perception of intellect and integrity of the common man and their trust of it. They created the jury system for multiple reasons. One, of course, was to assure as good a chance at a fair trial as possible by having the evidence of charges judged by a group of one's peers.

Part of the idea behind this system which is virtually unknown today is that their intent was also that the jury would judge bad law and deny enforcement of such law. By denying enforcement, they could virtually force a legislature into repealing such law.

But today, there is no judge who will ever in jury instructions inform them that they have a responsibility to judge the law as well as the facts of evidence.

And the rise of the kinds of laws you cite are the result of people in legislative and judicial offices who hold some degree of tyrannical motivations, i. e., the burning need they seem to possess to rule the lives of other men.

These people are not satisfied with the idea of government simply protecting the rights of the citizen, they are interested in and motivated to have government dictate moral choices as well. Thus we have laws prohibiting smoking, gambling, prostitution, alcohol consumption, and a myriad of others. This is why we have consumer protection laws and business regulation and ADA.

And the political thugs who create these asinine laws have absolutely no culpability nor remorse for the disastrous consequences resulting from the inevitable Law of Unintended Consequences.
 
Back
Top