Freedom vs. Security

Which would you rather have? Explain

  • Freedom

    Votes: 31 83.8%
  • Security

    Votes: 3 8.1%
  • Other

    Votes: 3 8.1%

  • Total voters
    37
Freedom !!! Imagine that one day Ashcroft and his fundamentalist puppetteers would ban all sexual behaviour that is not related to marriage or reproduction. It's unlikely, but still scary as hell !!
 
John1980 said:
Freedom !!! Imagine that one day Ashcroft and his fundamentalist puppetteers would ban all sexual behaviour that is not related to marriage or reproduction. It's unlikely, but still scary as hell !!

I ahte to be the bearer of bad news but Ashcrost is anything but fundamentalist nor is Bush. They are both Right Wing religious extremeist, akin to Bin laden
 
Freedom

With Freedom I can enhance my own security.

If "Security" is the sole province of government, then I not only do not have freedom, I probably don't have the kind of security that I need.
 
Freedom of course.

Security is safe.Who wants to be safe?.

Actually are freedom and security mutually exclusive?.
 
Last edited:
For me, my own personal freedom has been my battle for the last 12 years. Until I achieve it I will never feel safe or be able to sleep soundly at night.

But that's just me.
 
freedom?

You are all idiots. With out security you cant have freedom.
 
With enough freedom, I can be responsible for my own security.
 
I want a blend of both. Without security, one cannot exercise freedom. Without freedom, one cannot ever feel secure.


There is no either - or choice here. You have to have both.
 
"If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, go from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May your chains sit lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that ye were our countrymen."

- Samuel Adams, August 1776
 
Re: Freedom

Weird Harold said:
With Freedom I can enhance my own security.

If "Security" is the sole province of government, then I not only do not have freedom, I probably don't have the kind of security that I need.

what he said.
 
Re: freedom?

Unregistered said:
You are all idiots. With out security you cant have freedom.

What bullshit. If security means more governmental controls, no thank you. Look at the countries which had extreme security, such as the USSR and Nazi Germany. Security in that sense does not equal safety. That kind of security is too uncertain, at the whim of whoever is in power.

Monitoring library usage, or Internet usage, is not going to save anyone from fanatics wanting to destroy.

It always seems as though those determined to wreak destruction on others will find a way around security.
 
We have our freedom because of our security. We go to war as an act of security to ensure our freedom.

American have the freedom to bear arms why for security well so the argument goes. I for one would welcome a law that probibits the carrying of hand guns. Is such a law for security reason ? It certainly inpinges on freedom. What if your freedom impinges on mine.

Not a simple question to answer really I think an acceptable level of security is a preresquite to our established freedoms.

babble babble babble.




Mike
 
Freedom. If I had a choice between total police state where you had to show ID before leaving your building and total anarchy where you had to bring your gun before leaving your building, I would choose anarchy.
 
FREEDOM BABY

It was too hard won. Too many lost lives over MY freedom. I am not willing to give it up for security. The only thing that is secure is that we'll all die one day. Security is a myth. There will always be something to be afraid of.

You need to study WWII if you don't agree, for that matter, take a walk through history... look at the personal aspects (WWII... women recycling nylons to make parachutes... children saving gum wrappers to help make ammo... our country as a whole turning off all light during the night in case of night attacks... people being thrilled to take rations so that our country could kick ass and take names) and then tell me you'd rather give the government MORE power. If you want more SECURITY by government control then you need to transplant yourself in Cuba or China. Besides this IS a free country. Your free to leave.

In this I'm secure... We should all take responsiblity for our own actions... No laying blame...

Some people in America forget that with rights also comes responsibility.

As far as handgun control... yes it should be... everyone should definitely control their handguns... rifles... assault weapons... etc. Not the government. I certainly would never break into someones home if I knew for a fact there was someone in the house who had a gun and knew how to use it. And use it well.

HOMELAND SECURITY? I got your answer...Give each airline passenger a weapon at the door. Would you hijack an aircraft knowing that the guy next to you had a weapon? I think not...

Todd, I didn't know you were a politically minded?
 
I actually don't know how to seperate both items. Is there freedom without any security ?
What kind of freedom is it, when you're suffering from all those fears, a terrorist act could harm your loved-ones ?
What kind of security is it, when you're freedom is limited by a police-state kind of security ?
 
I find that the answers all pointing to PHYSICAL security only are more interesting than the Freedom vs. security choices. What about economic security? The babbling mouthpieces that complain about Bush and Ashcroft are the same ones that back Social Security, Welfare programs, Unemployment Insurance, Government backed Health Care programs, etc...

If you're going to badmouth "security" than you have to badmouth them all which would put most of the posters here squarely in the "Extreme Libertarian" camp.

I'll vote with those who say we need both thanks.
 
ma_guy said:
I find that the answers all pointing to PHYSICAL security only are more interesting than the Freedom vs. security choices. What about economic security? The babbling mouthpieces that complain about Bush and Ashcroft are the same ones that back Social Security, Welfare programs, Unemployment Insurance, Government backed Health Care programs, etc...

If you're going to badmouth "security" than you have to badmouth them all which would put most of the posters here squarely in the "Extreme Libertarian" camp.

I'll vote with those who say we need both thanks.

Sadly...I think we are going to lose alot of both.
 
Apples and Oranges.

Freedom is not to do as I please, but a responsibility towards society. If you are Free, you are secure, in a free society.

Security is ensuring others do not do as they please and threaten your freedom.
 
Freedom

Freedom, but it isn't as simple as just thinking about the two. We have a relatively free society, but there are rules and regulations that make the society work.. Maybe security may have to be one of them.
 
lilpriss said:
FREEDOM BABY

It was too hard won. Too many lost lives over MY freedom. I am not willing to give it up for security. The only thing that is secure is that we'll all die one day. Security is a myth. There will always be something to be afraid of.

You need to study WWII if you don't agree, for that matter, take a walk through history... look at the personal aspects (WWII... women recycling nylons to make parachutes... children saving gum wrappers to help make ammo... our country as a whole turning off all light during the night in case of night attacks... people being thrilled to take rations so that our country could kick ass and take names) and then tell me you'd rather give the government MORE power. If you want more SECURITY by government control then you need to transplant yourself in Cuba or China. Besides this IS a free country. Your free to leave.

In this I'm secure... We should all take responsiblity for our own actions... No laying blame...

Some people in America forget that with rights also comes responsibility.

As far as handgun control... yes it should be... everyone should definitely control their handguns... rifles... assault weapons... etc. Not the government. I certainly would never break into someones home if I knew for a fact there was someone in the house who had a gun and knew how to use it. And use it well.

HOMELAND SECURITY? I got your answer...Give each airline passenger a weapon at the door. Would you hijack an aircraft knowing that the guy next to you had a weapon? I think not...

Todd, I didn't know you were a politically minded?

awesome post

I am a bit of everything minded, politcally because of current world situation
 
lilpriss said:
FREEDOM BABY

It was too hard won. Too many lost lives over MY freedom. I am not willing to give it up for security. The only thing that is secure is that we'll all die one day. Security is a myth. There will always be something to be afraid of.

You need to study WWII if you don't agree, for that matter, take a walk through history... look at the personal aspects (WWII... women recycling nylons to make parachutes... children saving gum wrappers to help make ammo... our country as a whole turning off all light during the night in case of night attacks... people being thrilled to take rations so that our country could kick ass and take names) and then tell me you'd rather give the government MORE power. If you want more SECURITY by government control then you need to transplant yourself in Cuba or China. Besides this IS a free country. Your free to leave.

In this I'm secure... We should all take responsiblity for our own actions... No laying blame...

Some people in America forget that with rights also comes responsibility.

As far as handgun control... yes it should be... everyone should definitely control their handguns... rifles... assault weapons... etc. Not the government. I certainly would never break into someones home if I knew for a fact there was someone in the house who had a gun and knew how to use it. And use it well.

HOMELAND SECURITY? I got your answer...Give each airline passenger a weapon at the door. Would you hijack an aircraft knowing that the guy next to you had a weapon? I think not...

Todd, I didn't know you were a politically minded?

Absolutly right on!

Hell yeah! I agree with giving every airline passanger a weapon. That way when the kid in front of me is being a whining little shit I can just blow his brains out. Or cosh him other the head. Or slit his little throat. And his folks too if they complain.

And that crazy person is going to feel a whole lot more secure with a weapon and the voices in his head will tell him exactly how to use it.

And just wait for the drunk to shout "Who the fuck are you looking at?" Not only is he drunk. He's armed too.

Yep hand out those weapons, makes the flight a whole lot safer.

Freedom, way to go! Freedom to drink and drive, get so smashed I can't find the road anymore and fuck it why not drive through through the mall. No need to worry about other people - the smart ones will get out of the way, the ones who don't derserve to get run down. Just gives evolution a helping hand.

Freedom to buy guns. Automatics, semi-automatics, armour piercing ammunition. Sure I can be responsible, just make sure that everyone else is responsible enough to not to fucking piss me off or else I'll blow their fucking heads off.

Freedom to walk into a high school and gun everyone down. I'm responsible person, I'll take responsibility for my actions. Hell, I'll even put a bullet through my brain, save the tax-payers the cost of a trial and execution.

We're all responsible for our actions, we don't need the laws to tell us to where saftey helmets, seat belts, not to drink and drive.

And it's nice to know that people like lillpriss "would never break into someones home if I knew for a fact there was someone in the house who had a gun and knew how to use it. And use it well." So she'll only break into those homes she knows there isn't a gun. Or the owner is out and so not able to shoot her, no matter how well s/he can use a gun.

Screw security.

GIVE ME FREEDOM
 
a country that actually has to have this discussion has neither of the two things.

and that is a scary thought.
 
Back
Top