Evolution vs God

so i need to change my ending to ''besides, you have evidence but i have feelings, which count for exactly the same as evidence because i feel they should, so you have to accept that evidence being overridden to feelings is equally as valid a basis to judge this case on.''

the problem being, if god didn't create you in his own image and as his favorite thing in all of creation, you're not special. you're just another critter trying to survive. you don't get chosen to be watched over and when you die you just rot back into the cycle, instead of living happily ever after in the happiest place in the world because you're so special and good that you deserve to. and, put like that, i can well understand why a person wouldn't be able to bring themselves to believe in anything that might not support the version of special they've been taught all their lives. rotting in the ground, if you judge a case on feelings, really can't complete.

so we'll always be the people tagged as trying to shake your faith and you can tag yourself as heroically refusing to let us. you get points for that in the happily ever after, and anyone who argues with that will burn forever. poor misguided fools that they are.

I said none of this. I don't think you need to change anything about the way you live your life. That is up to you to do with it what you want. You don't have to believe what I believe. I have many friends who don't believe the way I do, but I still cherish them.

I don't need to be special. My choice is not to believe that I alone am the center of the Universe. It is not all about me. I believe that there is a force greater than myself at work. There are things I cannot control.

I think I have said many times that I am not against Science. I also admitted that I believe in much of the Science out there. At this point I just cannot see some of the jumps made with the evidence.

I said that I don't have proof of the afterlife, heaven or hell, since the Bible is not the evidence Science wants. I would also never say that any of you are misguided fools.
 
As far as the creation story goes, god created the land and the sea. Bam! Done!
Clearly this was a simplified version, because we've seen islands born from underwater eruptions, and large areas destroyed by coastal erosion. So what was created was a process. An ongoing process, proven beyond doubt. It was explained as a story that the uneducated masses could understand.
...how is that different from the creation of and explanation of life?

Refusing to explore and learn is not proof of faith. Rather, it is proof of the frailty of the faith of those who take that attitude. The ability to see god in every detail shows a greater faith than refusing to entertain any detail that does not fit a narrow, restricted idea of what you think god should be.

you didn't respond to my point about the constant changes in land being proven and the creation of new land & sea being documented fact. why, when the story of the creation of land & sea was clearly a vastly simplified 'geology for dummies' version, can't the same be true of 'biology for dummies'?

if everything were explained in the bible, the book would take a million years to read. it would kill curiosity, stop people striving to learn and discover.

why is evolution in particular chosen as a battleground?
 
Because some primates are easily offended and don't like thinking that they evolved from monkeys, even though no one ever seriously asserted this.
 
'k, this is like a bit like a murder case...

we have a body (millions of species), we have fingerprints (a fossil record), dna evidence (the differences and similarities between the dna of each species and the reliability or predictions), we have the motive (the pressures of a changing environment) and the means (hereditary characteristics and random mutation).

the scientists on the jury are looking at this and saying, ''ok, this is a murder because all the small clues add up to proof beyond a reasonable doubt.''
and we have the creationists saying, ''look, unless you can show me the whole murder, in real time, with me standing close enough to get blood spattered, then it didn't happen. i've yet to see one piece of evidence that, on its own and in isolation, proves the entire case in a way that i understand. there was no murder and the body was put there by god.''

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lta67phR5A1r4ghkoo1_500.gif
 
(edited)

Well creationists turn to the Bible. We look at archeological discoveries that authenticate it, history and other avenues.
There may be archaeological discoveries to show that the Genesis stories have come to us accurately translated, but that has nothing to do with the accuracy of the stories themselves. There is no credible method of determining the accuracy of a story that tells about events for which there were no witnesses.

What you would like to hear from scientists is a report of the date and location that the first true chicken emerged from its egg. But all science can offer is a probability that it happened within a range of dates and on a particular landmass. Unlike the Genesis stories, that can be confirmed with credible methods.
 
I said none of this. I don't think you need to change anything about the way you live your life. That is up to you to do with it what you want. You don't have to believe what I believe. I have many friends who don't believe the way I do, but I still cherish them.

I don't need to be special. My choice is not to believe that I alone am the center of the Universe. It is not all about me. I believe that there is a force greater than myself at work. There are things I cannot control.

I think I have said many times that I am not against Science. I also admitted that I believe in much of the Science out there. At this point I just cannot see some of the jumps made with the evidence.

I said that I don't have proof of the afterlife, heaven or hell, since the Bible is not the evidence Science wants. I would also never say that any of you are misguided fools.

Are you really saying anything at all? You have beliefs, which are apparently inviolable because their worth is totally subjective. However, should you suddenly decide to address these beliefs in discussions where more objective evaluation is pursued, we are supposed to respect your meaningless contributions, because they do not challenge anything? If you're not challenging anything, why bring them up at all? What do we care if you believe in Jesus, flying bananas, or werewolves? As long as you are not trying to compromise public policy, education, scientific endeavors, or the future of the country at large, knock yourself out!

Anyway, Stephen Jay Gould aptly tackled this subject years ago. You'd think we could move on already.

http://www.stephenjaygould.org/library/gould_fact-and-theory.html
 
Evolution is a fact. God is a theory, till there's enough evidence to prove it as a fact. In short, evolution is real, God, we don't know.
 
you didn't respond to my point about the constant changes in land being proven and the creation of new land & sea being documented fact. why, when the story of the creation of land & sea was clearly a vastly simplified 'geology for dummies' version, can't the same be true of 'biology for dummies'?

if everything were explained in the bible, the book would take a million years to read. it would kill curiosity, stop people striving to learn and discover.

why is evolution in particular chosen as a battleground?

Aren't you saying that we came to the same conclusion about changes in land?

Because of the origins of God's creation vs The Big Bang, and the conclusion that we evolved from apes and were not created like Adam and Eve.
 
I need to be special... In fact, I am special; watch this:

"Evidence?! What's evidence?" I said, jesting, and did not wait around to hear the reply!
 
Evolution is a fact. God is a theory, till there's enough evidence to prove it as a fact. In short, evolution is real, God, we don't know.

None of that is true.
Evolution is a theory and God is neither.
Stop being stupid.
 
If God is not only willing to lie to us but already has then why should we believe in His Word?
God told Abraham that he only had one son, when we all know perfectly well that he had two at the time.

We just have to smile and nod at God sometimes.
 
The root of anyone's belief in either God or no God, is faith the same faith it takes to believe in God is the same faith it takes to believe that matter is eternal. A person has to believe in one or the other. When I say faith I guess it would ring better in some peoples ears if I said metaphysical belief.

Darwin's general theory of evolution is still a theory. Darwin was the first to admit that fact.
There are other theories of evolution, case in point, the special theory of evolution.

Where did God come from? Where did matter come from? should we be disscussing the fallacies of the big bang theory as well?
 
Darwin's general theory of evolution is still a theory. Darwin was the first to admit that fact.
There are other theories of evolution, case in point, the special theory of evolution.
Of course it's a theory. It says so in the name. Nobody says otherwise.

Niether of those dispute evolution as a thing. They are different theories explaining the how and the whys of evolution. That evotution exists is not really disputed.

Also, they are more complementary than contradictory really.
The Special Theory is more concerned about the hows and whys of mutations and new transferrable traits on a sort time scale within a population, whereas the General Theory is concerned about speciation and big changes over longer time.
 
God exists only because wormshite is an unpalatable future. I for one, am happy that we have evolved to the level where this becomes a disputable matter.
 
Of course it's a theory. It says so in the name. Nobody says otherwise.

Niether of those dispute evolution as a thing. They are different theories explaining the how and the whys of evolution. That evotution exists is not really disputed.

Also, they are more complementary than contradictory really.
The Special Theory is more concerned about the hows and whys of mutations and new transferrable traits on a sort time scale within a population, whereas the General Theory is concerned about speciation and big changes over longer time.

The reason Darwin said his theory was a theory was the same reason it is still a theory and not a law.

Questions about existentialism bring up my thoughts of eternity. Where did anything originate? The answers are always metaphysical/faith based whether in the devine or in matter. But a choice is always made by the ponderer. The base of that belief in either case is the same type of belief ,in something that cannot be proven but still believed.

Kinda like a belief in the truth of evolution. Faith based. :D
 
I looked back at phrodeau's picture of the similarites between species and I think I need to imagine frogs as huge lions. That would be so cool.:cool:

To be honest, isn't speciation at the very heart of Darwin's Theory of evolution?? I can totally see the science behind natural selection and adaptation. Maybe I need to be specific and say I don't believe in speciation.

Wonderful thought provoking posts. Thanks.

No, no I don't think you should say that. Sorry - I was making a silly joke there, more than anything :) I think that you should say "I believe in creationism," and when people ask why, you can tell them that you have faith in the gospel of your religion. I don't think you can say you do or don't "believe" in evolution, because I still don't think you understand it. I don't think you can say that you still have questions about the fossil record, because I think you are plainly denying the evidence that contradicts your beliefs. Even the creationists in that video don't seem to get too hung up on speciation - they are focused on biblical "kinds."

When I say there are still missing pieces, I don't mean to imply that there are any serious holes in the chain of evidence that proves evolution. There's no smoking gun in the way that a perfectly preserved fossil record of every species ever to exist would be, but evolution has been all but verified through consilience - a convergence of evidence including genetics, palaeontology, biology, comparative anatomy, etc. If you're looking for transitional fossils to show you the common ancestors between species or kids or whatever you want to call them, they exist! We've got dozens of feathered dinosaurs, which is why I chose my particular example of species in flux :D

I would recommend that you read Richard Dawkins' The Selfish Gene. I don't know if you've ever looked at Darwin's actual On the Origin of Species, but I find his writing style (the style of the times, really) tedious and hard to read. Dawkins is much clearer, and it's really an incredible book. It's about biology, not religion. I am open to any book recommendation that you may have for me, of course! Fair's fair :)

Anyway, I think it's actually a bit wonderful that when I look at the inconceivable vastness of the universe and the relative tininess of me, I think "there's no way anything could have made me," but someone else can look at the same thing and think "there's no way I could exist if something hadn't made me."
 
Last edited:
The root of anyone's belief in either God or no God, is faith the same faith it takes to believe in God is the same faith it takes to believe that matter is eternal. A person has to believe in one or the other. When I say faith I guess it would ring better in some peoples ears if I said metaphysical belief.

Darwin's general theory of evolution is still a theory. Darwin was the first to admit that fact.
There are other theories of evolution, case in point, the special theory of evolution.

Where did God come from? Where did matter come from? should we be disscussing the fallacies of the big bang theory as well?

Oh dear. This is all so, so wrong. "Matter is eternal"? Is a "metaphysical belief," no less? I'm not even sure what you're saying but I'm very sure that it's wrong. Let's start here, though. I'm an atheist. It's not that I don't believe in God, it's that I only believe in things that are supported by reason or evidence. God is not a thing, for me. Has nothing to do with it. He's not any part of my concept of the world except that lots of other humans believe in him. Faith does not exist for me.

But sure, Todd. I would love to "disscuss" the fallacies of the big bang theory. Can you get the ball rolling on that one for us?
 
Last edited:
But sure, Todd. I would love to "disscuss" the fallacies of the big bang theory. Can you get the ball rolling on that one for us?

This should be fun. For your next trick are you going to get a Cocker Spaniel to discuss existentialism?
 
I am not taking one side or the other. What I am pointing out is that beliefs are based on our interpretation of the data.
The data is neutral, how we intrepret the data is how we come up with our opinions. Science collects the data we interpret it and of course put our own slant on things.

When I say matter is eternal I guess what I should say is what does a person belief has existed from the begining of time. Matter or a creator It is choice that most inquiring people wind up making based on our own belief system. But the basis for that choice is based on a metaphysical belief not on proven facts. Therefore the belief in God or no God is based on fath in either case. Not on identifiable facts.

I will sgn off on the subject , I have quit debating this fun subject many years ago. Enjoy the banter!
 
Kinda like a belief in the truth of evolution. Faith based. :D
No.

We know that evolution exists due to factual obervation of animals and plants evolving. This is beyond question. Just like we know there's gravity - things fall down.

Anyone who have a purebred dog can tell you all about it. It's a product of human guided evolution. Intelligent design, if you wish. ;)

Speciation is a theory of one effect of evolution - divergence of separated populations into unique spieces. According to this theory, said purebred dog race might actually evolve into a separate animal eventually if it's gene pool is kept uncontaminated by mongrel splooge.

Natural selection is a theory of the macro mechanics of evolution.

The special theory of evolution is a theory on the micro mechanics of evolution.

"God makes it happen" could be a theory too. But since it's based in presupposition instead of derived from postitivistic observations, it's still just a hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
This should be fun. For your next trick are you going to get a Cocker Spaniel to discuss existentialism?

I would, but then FOX news would snap him up as a panel expert on healthcare and climate change. Or maybe he could work as a columnist for the Daily Mail.

This thread is going to be extra funny once we confirm that it's all just a computer simulation, anyway.

Ohh, that reminds me! Try, read this too. It's cool. The Last Question.
 
Back
Top