Evolution vs God

I am not taking one side or the other. What I am pointing out is that beliefs are based on our interpretation of the data.
The data is neutral, how we intrepret the data is how we come up with our opinions. Science collects the data we interpret it and of course put our own slant on things.

When I say matter is eternal I guess what I should say is what does a person belief has existed from the begining of time. Matter or a creator It is choice that most inquiring people wind up making based on our own belief system. But the basis for that choice is based on a metaphysical belief not on proven facts. Therefore the belief in God or no God is based on fath in either case. Not on identifiable facts.

I will sgn off on the subject , I have quit debating this fun subject many years ago. Enjoy the banter!

I particularly enjoy the really stupid ones that try and sound clever by using words like "metaphysical".
 
The special theory of evolution is proven by the factual observation of plants and animals evolving.
The general theory of evolution cannot be proven without factual evidence of a shift from one species to another. That evidence or lack thereof is what has been the crux of every intelligent debate on the subject.

Now back to the real reason I am on lit..... sex! :D
 
The special theory of evolution is proven by the factual observation of plants and animals evolving.
The general theory of evolution cannot be proven without factual evidence of a shift from one species to another. That evidence or lack thereof is what has been the crux of every intelligent debate on the subject.

Now back to the real reason I am on lit..... sex! :D

Oh, Toddster. I'd break my fingers trying to address and correct all of the problems with your posts. Science is really cool, and it's taken care of pretty much every single question that I think you're trying to ask. You should give it another chance.

Anyway, have fun and wear condoms!
 
Oh, Toddster. I'd break my fingers trying to address and correct all of the problems with your posts. Science is really cool, and it's taken care of pretty much every single question that I think you're trying to ask. You should give it another chance.

I have to continue to give major props to you for putting science in general, and evolution in particular in a wondrous and humble setting. Creationism, and especially young-Earth Creationism drive me up a wall and I'm thankful to those willing to put in the time to convey good information. It's a shame science illiteracy has been politicized in some senses.

One thing I would mention which hasn't really yet been touched upon is how Darwinian theory is itself dynamic and subject to refinement over its century and a half (and continuing) life. Most could point to the Modern Synthesis, when Darwinian theory successfully incorporated genetics and statistical methods into its repertoire. But actually Darwinism has been vulnerable to each next revolution in dynamics in physics. The original Darwinism owed much to equilibrium thermodynamics in much the same way as classical economics. The theory is still incorporating insights from complex system dynamics (and non-equilibrium thermodynamics), and the exact relationship between self-organization and natural selection is still debated. It's a very heady discipline, but for anyone willing to wade through the literature I highly recommend the epic tome Darwinism Evolving.
 
There may be archaeological discoveries to show that the Genesis stories have come to us accurately translated, but that has nothing to do with the accuracy of the stories themselves. There is no credible method of determining the accuracy of a story that tells about events for which there were no witnesses.

What you would like to hear from scientists is a report of the date and location that the first true chicken emerged from its egg. But all science can offer is a probability that it happened within a range of dates and on a particular landmass. Unlike the Genesis stories, that can be confirmed with credible methods.

Prodeau,

You don't know how much I value and respect you sharing your opinion and position with me. You have taught me a lot. I truly mean that.

I will share my thoughts with you about what I would like to see. I look at the errors in dating such things as the Shroud of Turin by respected Scientists and I wonder how far off they are on the origins of the earth. Now say they are a couple million years off, I understand that this could be a statistically acceptable variable for science but it creates reasonable doubt in me that does not make me change my views. I would like to Scientists to work further on this.

Then I look at verses like 2 Peter 3:8
"But do not forget this one thing, dear friends: With the Lord a day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years are like a day." Most Christians discount that this speaks of the days of creation but it makes me wonder. What are we maybe missing that would bring our positions closer together.

To be honest in this lifetime we are not going to have the answer to this. No one was there. No one knows for sure.

Thanks:rose:
 
I like to learn about creation and evolution, but the fact is I live right now. I choose to use Christ as my mentor. I heard a song today that pretty much sums up how I want to live my life.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0I2csO7_pOI


Do I think that atheists and people who believe in evolution can do something too. ABSOLUTELY! Wouldn't it be great if we stopped fighting and did something together.
 
The root of anyone's belief in either God or no God, is faith the same faith it takes to believe in God is the same faith it takes to believe that matter is eternal. A person has to believe in one or the other. When I say faith I guess it would ring better in some peoples ears if I said metaphysical belief.

Congrats! In a few short posts you’ve managed to hit nearly every single meme on this topic. So much so it leaves one wondering whether you’re a troll or a complete fucking idiot. Let’s look at the most fundamental ones, Mr metaphysical.

The root of anyone's belief in either God or no God, is faith the same faith it takes to believe in God is the same faith it takes to believe that matter is eternal.

Theist: Belief in the existence of a god or gods, especially belief in a personal God. In most cases belief of God as creator and ruler of the Universe and everything in it. They have faith because they have this belief in the absence of evidence.

Atheist: In general don’t have this belief. So Atheism is normal expressed so; a LACK of belief in God. There is a subtle, but, important difference between saying “I have a LACK of belief in god” and saying “I do not believe in god.” In essence what is being said is “I’m not making a statement on the existence of god base on faith alone, show me the evidence and I’ll make a decision.”

I hope you see the difference, but, somehow I doubt it.

The reason Darwin said his theory was a theory was the same reason it is still a theory and not a law.

This is such a fundamental misunderstanding of Science that it’s over for you.

You have to be careful with scientific definitions of words as they are a little different than those in common usage.

Theory: is basically an accepted hypothesis.

A scientific theory is a hypothesis supported with repeated testing, critical review and eventually becoming accepted as true in the scientific community. However, a theory is valid only as long as there is no evidence to dispute it. Therefore, a theory can be dis-proven if new evidence comes to light. This is basically the scientific community’s way of being cautious.

That said the Theory of Evolution is probably one of the most tested of all theories; all of which it has passed so it is probably about as close to a fact as the scientific community will ever admit.

Laws: Are different than theories, they are not an step higher than theories on a scientific scale of Truth. NO theory can ever graduate to becoming a law.

A law is a generalization of observations which are undeniable, obvious and don't require further explanation, they just are.

For example Newton's Law of Gravitational attraction, which states that every massive particle in the universe attracts every other massive particle with a force which is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.

This is immediately obvious as if this wasn't true then we all would be floating around in space, but it doesn't explain why we aren't floating around, it just is, and therefore it's a Law and not a Theory.

The rest of your posts are peppered with other errors and window dressed with long words; which after these fundamental errors it’s pretty safe to assume you equally don’t understand.

Woof!
 
The special theory of evolution is proven by the factual observation of plants and animals evolving.
The general theory of evolution cannot be proven without factual evidence of a shift from one species to another. That evidence or lack thereof is what has been the crux of every intelligent debate on the subject.

Now back to the real reason I am on lit..... sex! :D

Wow, you're a total fucking moron.
 
Atheist: In general don’t have this belief. So Atheism is normal expressed so; a LACK of belief in God. There is a subtle, but, important difference between saying “I have a LACK of belief in god” and saying “I do not believe in god.” In essence what is being said is “I’m not making a statement on the existence of god base on faith alone, show me the evidence and I’ll make a decision.”

That's an agnostic not an atheist. An atheist doesn't believe in God.
There are different types of atheists but what you described is an agnostic.
 
Prodeau,

You don't know how much I value and respect you sharing your opinion and position with me. You have taught me a lot. I truly mean that.

I will share my thoughts with you about what I would like to see. I look at the errors in dating such things as the Shroud of Turin by respected Scientists and I wonder how far off they are on the origins of the earth. Now say they are a couple million years off, I understand that this could be a statistically acceptable variable for science but it creates reasonable doubt in me that does not make me change my views. I would like to Scientists to work further on this.

Then I look at verses like 2 Peter 3:8
"But do not forget this one thing, dear friends: With the Lord a day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years are like a day." Most Christians discount that this speaks of the days of creation but it makes me wonder. What are we maybe missing that would bring our positions closer together.

To be honest in this lifetime we are not going to have the answer to this. No one was there. No one knows for sure.

Thanks:rose:
I highly doubt that we will ever find evidence of trees that are older than the sun and moon.
 
To elaborate somewhat, an epistemic agnostic is one who holds knowledge of the divine or transcendental cannot be had through scientific or rational means. They involve articles of faith. A soft atheist is one who does not have faith God exists. A hard atheist is one who holds positively that God does not exist.
 
I choose to use Christ as my mentor.
Well, Jesus told me that matter came into existence as a result of particle pair production. I posted a link for you. Anyway, I said, "How the hell would you know?" and he said, "'Cause my dad's God!" Then he pushed me down and stalked off.
 
That's an agnostic not an atheist. An atheist doesn't believe in God.
There are different types of atheists but what you described is an agnostic.

Ummm no.

An agnostic person is one who believes that nothing is known or can be known of the existence or nature of God or of anything beyond material phenomena;...

Look no one says "I don't collect stamps" unless someone else starts talking about stamp-collecting. That there is no god is fact until those claiming there is one can prove it. If I told you I have a invisible pink dragon hiding in my garage you probably wouldn’t believe me without proof. You are then by definition an Adragonist.

Atheism is not a belief any more than "not collecting stamps" is a hobby. Atheism is a lack of belief.

There isn`t an atheist out there who wouldn't change his tune on a dime with decent proof, Doesn't mean we'd all start worshiping the truly evil Abrahamic deity, but with proof we'd accept his existence.

Woof!
 
I will share my thoughts with you about what I would like to see. I look at the errors in dating such things as the Shroud of Turin by respected Scientists and I wonder how far off they are on the origins of the earth. Now say they are a couple million years off, I understand that this could be a statistically acceptable variable for science but it creates reasonable doubt in me that does not make me change my views. I would like to Scientists to work further on this.

What fucking difference would it make and why would it convince you?

The Earth is approx. 4.5 billion years old. That’s 4 500 000 000 years

If they are off by ± 1 million years. That’s 1 000 000 years it is still and error of less than 1% and a 1% error is more than acceptable.

To be honest in this lifetime we are not going to have the answer to this. No one was there. No one knows for sure.
Thanks:rose:

You never will if you don’t look.

You asked for evidence of transitional states between species and you have been given them, even though you could have easily found them yourself. If you wish I’ll give you more.

As per usual you are ignoring them and just carrying on in the same old way.

Do I think that atheists and people who believe in evolution can do something too. ABSOLUTELY! Wouldn't it be great if we stopped fighting and did something together.

Sure, no problem.

So long as you stop inflicting your religion on us. But, most importantly of all stop abusing children and inflicting your mumbo jumbo on them.

Woof!
 
Lets just cut to the chase.

One of the hallmarks of being an adult is confronting your own mortality. At the time of that confrontation you make a choice. You either choose to see life as finite and accept it, or you choose to not accept it and find faith.

IMHO - all the empirical evidence says you should accept it. If you somehow cannot accept the evidence of this reality your only other choice is to believe in an alternate reality. All the arguing ( AKA "religion") is just a justification why people who are not like me cannot accept the evidence of this reality.

It does not mean I am right. But I am choosing to believe in the facts presented by this existence, and I am not resorting to magic to try and make sense of reality.
 
And my answer to your question is that historical scholars generally agree that Jesus was a person.
Not exactly.
You said
I think it is generally accepted, through documetation more abundant than those that say that Julius Ceasar existed, that Jesus existed.
A huge difference from just saying Jesus was a real person.
 
you didn't respond to my point about the constant changes in land being proven and the creation of new land & sea being documented fact. why, when the story of the creation of land & sea was clearly a vastly simplified 'geology for dummies' version, can't the same be true of 'biology for dummies'?

if everything were explained in the bible, the book would take a million years to read. it would kill curiosity, stop people striving to learn and discover.

why is evolution in particular chosen as a battleground?
It's not the only one. There are those who argue the earth was created some few thousand years ago as it is today, with evidence that it's much older merely to test man's faith in god. Which, of course, makes as much sense as saying it was created 10 hours ago, complete with all our memories in order to test our faith.
 
What fucking difference would it make and why would it convince you?

The Earth is approx. 4.5 billion years old. That’s 4 500 000 000 years

If they are off by ± 1 million years. That’s 1 000 000 years it is still and error of less than 1% and a 1% error is more than acceptable.



You never will if you don’t look.

You asked for evidence of transitional states between species and you have been given them, even though you could have easily found them yourself. If you wish I’ll give you more.

As per usual you are ignoring them and just carrying on in the same old way.



Sure, no problem.

So long as you stop inflicting your religion on us. But, most importantly of all stop abusing children and inflicting your mumbo jumbo on them.

Woof!


What you have shown me was similarities between different species. They are still different species. It is frustrating to have people who don't know me say I have made no effort to find out about evolution. I didn't always believe in Christ and even when I did I haven't stuck my head in the sand about Evolution. I am not ignoring them.

I brought up the subject so I guess I am inflicting it on you. I always felt you had a choice to participate in the thread or not. Just like you can tell someone no thanks if they ask to talk to you about it. I know there are religious fanatics out there. I'm not one.

You know you couldn't cut me to the core more than telling me I am abusing my kids. As a survivor of sexual abuse by two family members and constant fear of even breathing when I was young you may have no idea, or unfortuantly maybe you do. My kids are in public school. They learn about evolution. We have talked to them and they understand what is presented at school. We do go to church. When they become men it is up to them to decide just like it is up to us. I would give my life for my kids.
 
Back
Top