Evolution vs God

I looked back at phrodeau's picture of the similarites between species and I think I need to imagine frogs as huge lions. That would be so cool.:cool:

I have a horrible feeling a crocoduck is just around the corner.

Woof!
 
'k, this is like a bit like a murder case...

we have a body (millions of species), we have fingerprints (a fossil record), dna evidence (the differences and similarities between the dna of each species and the reliability or predictions), we have the motive (the pressures of a changing environment) and the means (hereditary characteristics and random mutation).

the scientists on the jury are looking at this and saying, ''ok, this is a murder because all the small clues add up to proof beyond a reasonable doubt.''
and we have the creationists saying, ''look, unless you can show me the whole murder, in real time, with me standing close enough to get blood spattered, then it didn't happen. i've yet to see one piece of evidence that, on its own and in isolation, proves the entire case in a way that i understand. there was no murder and the body was put there by god.''
 
'k, this is like a bit like a murder case...

we have a body (millions of species), we have fingerprints (a fossil record), dna evidence (the differences and similarities between the dna of each species and the reliability or predictions), we have the motive (the pressures of a changing environment) and the means (hereditary characteristics and random mutation).

the scientists on the jury are looking at this and saying, ''ok, this is a murder because all the small clues add up to proof beyond a reasonable doubt.''
and we have the creationists saying, ''look, unless you can show me the whole murder, in real time, with me standing close enough to get blood spattered, then it didn't happen. i've yet to see one piece of evidence that, on its own and in isolation, proves the entire case in a way that i understand. there was no murder and the body was put there by god.''

My brain got a boner from that. Just sayin'.
 
******

I would find it a novel experience if any evidence of creation was presented at all, anywhere. Well creationists turn to the Bible. We look at archeological discoveries that authenticate it, history and other avenues.

But, that was not my point; my point was that you are asking others here to provide you with evidence of evolution that you personally could find in any one of the 10’s of thousands of museums worldwide.
No, I think I clarified that I was looking for a full evidence of a species change from one to another. I can concur with the evidence of adaption and natural selection and evidence presented in most museums.

By any and all accounts neither was Jesus, he came along much later in an attempt to re-brand the cruel, vile, vain vengeful god of the Old Testament.
My thought is that he came and changed the concept in the Old Testement that we had to do things in order to get closer to God. In the New Testement Jesus took on the burden and came closer to us. It's like Undercover Boss only a couple of thousands of years ago.

This is a personal emotional experience and isn’t evidence of anything except your state of mind; again worthless to all but you. I totally agree. That is why I said IN MY Mind.

Shompquack!

PS. I did not underline everything for any reason but to differentiate it from what you said. I am having trouble with my computer.
 
'k, this is like a bit like a murder case...

we have a body (millions of species), we have fingerprints (a fossil record), dna evidence (the differences and similarities between the dna of each species and the reliability or predictions), we have the motive (the pressures of a changing environment) and the means (hereditary characteristics and random mutation).

the scientists on the jury are looking at this and saying, ''ok, this is a murder because all the small clues add up to proof beyond a reasonable doubt.''
and we have the creationists saying, ''look, unless you can show me the whole murder, in real time, with me standing close enough to get blood spattered, then it didn't happen. i've yet to see one piece of evidence that, on its own and in isolation, proves the entire case in a way that i understand. there was no murder and the body was put there by god.''

I think I am standing here saying that I have a person that is still alive. We have evidence that shows that he may be killed. Does that mean he's dead?
 
That's called "moving the goalposts.

Or wandering from the metaphor.

Either way it's not an effective repudiation.
 
I honestly haven't looked at this much. Aren't they just subclasses of carnivores or meat eaters. I can always count on you to be thought provoking. I'll have to check it out. Also glad to see you back as girlsmiley!!:rose:

I've only ever been girlsmiley here. I don't have alts. Fuck that. Too much work.

Yeah, I reckon you should look into it, chick. It'll be good for you.

Also, I don't think lit's the place to find the answers you're looking for. You know?
 
I don't understand the initial question. Why is it "either/or" when it could be "both/and"?
 
I think the initial Issue arises when tested facts derived by the scientific method come into conflict with unquestioned beliefs proposed by old books.

But

Personally I think that anyone interested in the application of the scientific method, or the engagement of empirical evidence to understand the world quickly discovers that the explored universe does not contain evidence of god.

From there I go on to quote Douglas Adams.
 
That's called "moving the goalposts.

Or wandering from the metaphor.

Either way it's not an effective repudiation.

Personally, I think it is looking at it from a different perspective. She does an excellent, fantastic job of explaining her point of view. I was simply trying to explain mine.

Look. I tend to look at things from the point of view of a nurse since I have been one for over half my life. In a secular university I was taught to look at a person as the a sum of parts which are mind body and spirit. It is really through talking on lit that someone shared with me that atheists have a spirituality. It is just taken from things like love for family and friends,nature,etc. I hadn't thought of it like that before.

I am using Jesus as my spirtual mentor, even though he lived years ago. I respect what he stood for and his convictions. I already admitted that I am far from being a poster child for Christianity. I am finding that my life is enriched by this path. I am certainly not finding fault in the path someone else travels.

I certainly have no evidence for an afterlife. No one followed a dead person and wrote about it. LOL (There are only accounts of people who say they have experienced it but I don't see that as proof - just like some people say they have been on a UFO.)

I do have a hope that the essence of who I am will live on to meet my mentor. I figure if I'm wrong the worst thing that happens is that my end would be like everyone elses - nothing.
 
I've only ever been girlsmiley here. I don't have alts. Fuck that. Too much work.

Yeah, I reckon you should look into it, chick. It'll be good for you.

Also, I don't think lit's the place to find the answers you're looking for. You know?

Weren't you just roobarb? I must have confused you with someone else.

I just like seeing the world from other points of view. It's interesting.
 
Well that's fair enough.

But it would also be fair to say that believing the moon was held in the sky by the hand of an invisible giant is also "another point of view".
 
Weren't you just roobarb? I must have confused you with someone else.

I just like seeing the world from other points of view. It's interesting.

I guess it can be. :D

No, I wasn't just roobarb. It's all good.

I know you do, and it can be interesting to see things from a dif perspec, but I reckon you'd be better off going back to school. A course or something.
 
I think it is generally accepted, through documetation more abundant than those that say that Julius Ceasar existed, that Jesus existed.
Huh? "Generally accepted" by whom?

...the missing pieces of creationism are filled by evidence I can't substantiate to others of the change in my heart and life.
As has happened to many people, if someone was in your life and said they loved you, demonstrated through acts that they loved you, etc., and so you came to believe they loved you so you married them, then one day you woke up and found they had emptied your bank accounts and taken all the valuables from your home, would you still insist that they loved you? Or would you accept that you only imagined that they loved you?
In other words, your evidence is just a state of mind (as mentioned) and isn't really evidence at all. It's like drunks saying they see pink elephants.
Comparing "evidence" for god to the evidence for evolution is just ludicrous.
 
Well creationists turn to the Bible. We look at archeological discoveries that authenticate it, history and other avenues.

And all that does is provide evidence that some individuals (we don’t know who) wrote papers that were at some time later in history assembled into a book by yet other individuals we know little or nothing about; it does NOT substantiate any of the claims made there-in.

So it is worthless in providing evidence of how life got here.


o, I think I clarified that I was looking for a full evidence of a species change from one to another. I can concur with the evidence of adaption and natural selection and evidence presented in most museums.

A well-documented example…….. from Dinosaur to Archaeopteryx to Hoatzin

http://universe-review.ca/I10-72-Archaeopteryx2.jpg

The Hoatzin (among others) retains artefacts of its evolution.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00bm2c7

Well worth a look.^^

My thought is that he came and changed the concept in the Old Testement that we had to do things in order to get closer to God. In the New Testement Jesus took on the burden and came closer to us. It's like Undercover Boss only a couple of thousands of years ago.

So god is a long way short of a perfect being then; capable of vanity, vengeance, cruelty, intolerance.

Sounds kinda like a man? Perhaps a man whose hand wrote the original good book! The concept was originally wrong? So the maker of life and universes is a fallible being?


PS. I did not underline everything for any reason but to differentiate it from what you said. I am having trouble with my computer.

No problem

Woof!
 
'k, this is like a bit like a murder case...

we have a body (millions of species), we have fingerprints (a fossil record), dna evidence (the differences and similarities between the dna of each species and the reliability or predictions), we have the motive (the pressures of a changing environment) and the means (hereditary characteristics and random mutation).

the scientists on the jury are looking at this and saying, ''ok, this is a murder because all the small clues add up to proof beyond a reasonable doubt.''
and we have the creationists saying, ''look, unless you can show me the whole murder, in real time, with me standing close enough to get blood spattered, then it didn't happen. i've yet to see one piece of evidence that, on its own and in isolation, proves the entire case in a way that i understand. there was no murder and the body was put there by god.''

I think FIGITS pushed the egg in the warp hole with the big banger.
 
Huh? "Generally accepted" by whom?

As has happened to many people, if someone was in your life and said they loved you, demonstrated through acts that they loved you, etc., and so you came to believe they loved you so you married them, then one day you woke up and found they had emptied your bank accounts and taken all the valuables from your home, would you still insist that they loved you? Or would you accept that you only imagined that they loved you?
In other words, your evidence is just a state of mind (as mentioned) and isn't really evidence at all. It's like drunks saying they see pink elephants.
Comparing "evidence" for god to the evidence for evolution is just ludicrous.

I think I already said a couple of times that my experience would not be evidence to anyone else. And my answer to your question is that historical scholars generally agree that Jesus was a person. I am not saying they agree he was God.
 
so i need to change my ending to ''besides, you have evidence but i have feelings, which count for exactly the same as evidence because i feel they should, so you have to accept that evidence being overridden to feelings is equally as valid a basis to judge this case on.''

the problem being, if god didn't create you in his own image and as his favorite thing in all of creation, you're not special. you're just another critter trying to survive. you don't get chosen to be watched over and when you die you just rot back into the cycle, instead of living happily ever after in the happiest place in the world because you're so special and good that you deserve to. and, put like that, i can well understand why a person wouldn't be able to bring themselves to believe in anything that might not support the version of special they've been taught all their lives. rotting in the ground, if you judge a case on feelings, really can't complete.

so we'll always be the people tagged as trying to shake your faith and you can tag yourself as heroically refusing to let us. you get points for that in the happily ever after, and anyone who argues with that will burn forever. poor misguided fools that they are.
 
so i need to change my ending to ''besides, you have evidence but i have feelings, which count for exactly the same as evidence because i feel they should, so you have to accept that evidence being overridden to feelings is equally as valid a basis to judge this case on.''

the problem being, if god didn't create you in his own image and as his favorite thing in all of creation, you're not special. you're just another critter trying to survive. you don't get chosen to be watched over and when you die you just rot back into the cycle, instead of living happily ever after in the happiest place in the world because you're so special and good that you deserve to. and, put like that, i can well understand why a person wouldn't be able to bring themselves to believe in anything that might not support the version of special they've been taught all their lives. rotting in the ground, if you judge a case on feelings, really can't complete.

so we'll always be the people tagged as trying to shake your faith and you can tag yourself as heroically refusing to let us. you get points for that in the happily ever after, and anyone who argues with that will burn forever. poor misguided fools that they are.

Jesus!
 
Back
Top