Evolution vs God

I don't know everything about this topic, of course, but for me at this point it takes more faith to believe evolution than to believe that a higher power(whoever yours may or may not be) created the magnificent world we have.

Oh ffs, how many times do we have to go over this?

Science does NOT require faith; it demands that you prove your assertion, that you follow evidence, that your theory can provide falsifiable predictions and that you continually question and modify or abandon a theory ( and that's why they are called theories before we start on that line of stupid) when new evidence comes to light.

It is diametrically opposed to faith.

Faith is veridically worthless except to those who need it either as a comfort blanket or to explain things they don’t understand.

You know I really haven't had anyone give me solid proof yet.

So what you actually want is for someone to come along and place some “solid proof” directly in the palm of your hand and until they do you’re going to ignore the 100’s of thousands of pieces of evidence in 10’s of thousands of museums throughout the world, ignore all the evidence written in thousands of books, documentaries etc. Props!

I believe that if something was created it had to have a creator.

Oh Buda!

So I guess you’re saying that as the universe and everything in it is complex then it must have had a creator, right?

If that’s the case, using your logic, then the even more complex being that created the universe must have had a creator who is even more complex than the first and he must have had a creator who had a creator who had a creator ad infinitum. At this point all you’ve managed to do is get yourself in an illogical loop.

Incidentally, in a simplified form, can energy or mass (matter) be created or destroyed?

Woof!
 
Last edited:
^^^If I were smarter, I would have said what Phelia said.
 
Hey Try! You know I like you - I think you're sweet and genuine and fun. After the last creationism thread, though I certainly respect your right to your own beliefs, I thought it was best to avoid discussing religion with you. We're just never going to be on the same page, but I appreciate that you are always honest and respectful. I keep seeing this thread getting bumped, though, and I just have a few things that I'd really like to add.

Richard Dawkins is not "worried." Nobody who accepts the theory of evolution is worried. Not only because the logic and "evidence" in question hold about as much water as a pair of fishnet stockings, but because what is there to be worried about? That we'll find new evidence that will alter our idea of the development of terrestrial life? I'm not scared of that. That would be awesome. When I say that a belief in creationism is one of the wrongest things that an adult person can think (seriously, no offense intended! I promise! :D), I'm not trying to "prove" evolution; I'm just trying to find the truth. There are interesting theories about extinction and speciation that don't align perfectly with the Darwinian model. Cool. They don't have to. They just have to be supported by the evidence.

There are missing pieces. It doesn't mean they don't exist - it means we haven't found them yet. And we're looking! And it's exciting! The pieces of the puzzle that we DO have are pretty straightforward and quite convincing. When you say things like "show me X" and "I'm just asking questions," it's incredibly exasperating, because you're ignoring the MOUNTAIN of science that's already there, and why are you even asking questions in the first place? What do you have to prove? Why should you have to prove the word of God? Isn't the point that you don't have to? Isn't that what faith is? Why are people mangling and beating down pieces of brilliant science and solid evidence? This is one in a loooong series of contentions with evolution, not one of which has been held up so far. Here's a big old list of them from a pro-creation website ("no new species" makes the list).

It's like if I tell you that the planet Kepler-62f is 1200 lightyears away. Now, I'm fairly certain the Bible didn't cover that, because it is a document written by people who were constrained by the scientific knowledge of their time and culture, but let's say you ask me how I know that's how far away it is. I can point you in the direction of trigonometric parallax and Hubble's Law and absolute/apparent magnitude and a zillion other things that astronomers have dedicated their lives to understanding. Would you question them because we don't have a tape measurer that's over a quadrillion km long?

Anyway. There's science, and there's creationism. If faith doesn't require proof, why are these guys trying so hard?

http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/degrassi/images/9/99/43591-THIS-gif-ECaV.gif
 
That this bullshit will be taught to kids as science.

I'm not worried about that. I don't like it, of course, but I can't control what people teach their own children in their own homes. Save for a few rogue Texan syllabi with some ID thrown in to keep the crazies happy, it won't be taught in schools because it's a religious belief. The evidence for and theory of evolution will be taught, because it's science. Our best option is to bolster science education as a whole, including a renewed focus on critical reasoning.


That is so inaccurate. Recent data suggests that dinosaurs were more brightly pigmented and likely had some form of proto-feathers.
 
That is so inaccurate. Recent data suggests that dinosaurs were more brightly pigmented and likely had some form of proto-feathers.

The colors of the dinosaur and lizard are being muted by the flaming red hair of Jesus.
 
I'm not worried about that. I don't like it, of course, but I can't control what people teach their own children in their own homes. Save for a few rogue Texan syllabi with some ID thrown in to keep the crazies happy, it won't be taught in schools because it's a religious belief. The evidence for and theory of evolution will be taught, because it's science. Our best option is to bolster science education as a whole, including a renewed focus on critical reasoning.

Unfortunately, these lunatics are actually getting this stuff put into the science curriculum in public schools in the US. It's terrifying that the so called most advanced nation in the world can even countenance this bronze age bullshit in its education system.
 
Hey Try! You know I like you - I think you're sweet and genuine and fun. After the last creationism thread, though I certainly respect your right to your own beliefs, I thought it was best to avoid discussing religion with you. We're just never going to be on the same page, but I appreciate that you are always honest and respectful. I keep seeing this thread getting bumped, though, and I just have a few things that I'd really like to add.

Richard Dawkins is not "worried." Nobody who accepts the theory of evolution is worried. Not only because the logic and "evidence" in question hold about as much water as a pair of fishnet stockings, but because what is there to be worried about? That we'll find new evidence that will alter our idea of the development of terrestrial life? I'm not scared of that. That would be awesome. When I say that a belief in creationism is one of the wrongest things that an adult person can think (seriously, no offense intended! I promise! :D), I'm not trying to "prove" evolution; I'm just trying to find the truth. There are interesting theories about extinction and speciation that don't align perfectly with the Darwinian model. Cool. They don't have to. They just have to be supported by the evidence.

There are missing pieces. It doesn't mean they don't exist - it means we haven't found them yet. And we're looking! And it's exciting! The pieces of the puzzle that we DO have are pretty straightforward and quite convincing. When you say things like "show me X" and "I'm just asking questions," it's incredibly exasperating, because you're ignoring the MOUNTAIN of science that's already there, and why are you even asking questions in the first place? What do you have to prove? Why should you have to prove the word of God? Isn't the point that you don't have to? Isn't that what faith is? Why are people mangling and beating down pieces of brilliant science and solid evidence? This is one in a loooong series of contentions with evolution, not one of which has been held up so far. Here's a big old list of them from a pro-creation website ("no new species" makes the list).

It's like if I tell you that the planet Kepler-62f is 1200 lightyears away. Now, I'm fairly certain the Bible didn't cover that, because it is a document written by people who were constrained by the scientific knowledge of their time and culture, but let's say you ask me how I know that's how far away it is. I can point you in the direction of trigonometric parallax and Hubble's Law and absolute/apparent magnitude and a zillion other things that astronomers have dedicated their lives to understanding. Would you question them because we don't have a tape measurer that's over a quadrillion km long?

Anyway. There's science, and there's creationism. If faith doesn't require proof, why are these guys trying so hard?

Quoted for awesomeness. Thank you for conveying the humility before nature any good scientist should express. For the scientist, joy is not found in the certainty of faith in any one article, but in the revelation of discovery.
 
Quoted for awesomeness. Thank you for conveying the humility before nature any good scientist should express. For the scientist, joy is not found in the certainty of faith in any one article, but in the revelation of discovery.

Do fuck off.
 
Unfortunately, these lunatics are actually getting this stuff put into the science curriculum in public schools in the US. It's terrifying that the so called most advanced nation in the world can even countenance this bronze age bullshit in its education system.

You're right, and even though I was being glib about TX, they tend to influence textbook content nationally. I do think we're moving in the right direction. I like to believe that knowledge is also naturally selecting, in a way, and that lateral progression and regression are hard to gauge. We're not out of the woods, but I believe that one day the idea of teaching creation in schools will be as outrageous as the idea of Galileo being tried for heresy. I do think it's important to stay vigilant and consistent: creationism is not science.

Is there a CFI branch anywhere near you? I'm a member here, and I like some of their events, but there seem to be a lot of bureaucratic issues for a relatively small number of people. Some of the members really are quite arrogant, too.
 
I simply wanted to know of an example of one species that turned into another. I also enjoy some different conversation. If you a have some references you wanted to share I would like that.

It's important to appreciate the evidence for deep time evolutionary processes is by it's nature largely forensic. However, fortune smiles upon you for having access to the fruits of modern science, and reports of speciation. For your perusal:

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-speciation.html
 
Yep. Under my one and only (modified by Oz) name. How 'bout you, knob scratch?

It's obvious what my prior account was, an account I no longer have any need of. You're quite welcome to put me on iggy.
 
It's obvious what my prior account was, an account I no longer have any need of. You're quite welcome to put me on iggy.

It's not obvious to me, and I humble before nature and revel in discovery (thanks, btw). Are you jeninnnnnnnnnflorida reborn?
 
It's obvious what my prior account was, an account I no longer have any need of. You're quite welcome to put me on iggy.

Oh, I probably will when I get bored of you. Right now I'm drinking.
 
It's not obvious to me, and I humble before nature and revel in discovery (thanks, btw). Are you jeninnnnnnnnnflorida reborn?

Yes I am. I hadn't intended on participating around the board except for a brief lark, but something pulled me in and I decided a name change was in order.
 
Of course they are. 1.

Believe whatever you like. My familiarity with the board comes from how long I've been lurking, off and on, since years before your account was registered. When I first encountered the General Board REDWAVE, Problem Child, and mellon collie were several of the active users.
 
Believe whatever you like. My familiarity with the board comes from how long I've been lurking, off and on, since years before your account was registered. When I first encountered the General Board REDWAVE, Problem Child, and mellon collie were several of the active users.

Of course. So you activated your one and only two year old alt this week.
 
Of course. So you activated your one and only two year old alt this week.

Since you asked, yes. I had forgotten the account even existed, and asked Laurel for a name change before posting under it.
 
Back
Top