Evolution vs God

I can see that we are changing, adapting. What you are saying is that I am the missing link. :eek: Holy Scientific break through batman! LOL

Just show me one time when scientists can make the full link from one species to another and I would be happy to say I am wrong.

*sigh*

*sneeze*
Can you show that you are the same species as your great-great-grandfather? Can you prove that you and he could reproduce?
 
Belief in a god is no less valid if you believe that he guides an ongoing project, as opposed to '7 days, done, get on with it!'

...but the latter view would save a lot of effort in actually learning how incredible it really is.

If you enter into this with a them V us mindset, refusing to research or entertain any theory that wasn't given in metaphores that men could understand in biblical times, why bother asking the question?

To my mind, it would be an insult to god not to explore just how huge, complex, eon spanningly huge a deal it is. To be championed only by those who deny all your best work, who will never acknowledge the most incredible system imaginable, because they have their fingers in their ears, singing lalala, because nobody wrote it down when humanity was at a point where they wouldn't have understood... it's a morbidly depressing thought.

I suppose the difference, really, is whether you believe in god or in the writings about god by men.

You know I totally agree. The movie title suggest a verses mentality but I didn't make up the title. I don't think we have to fight.

I totally dig science. It fascinates me. If my sons want to be scientists I would say go for it. You would not believe the science I had to take at the University to get my BSN. But it only scratched the surface of what is available.

There is also no doubt that I cannot prove the existence of God at this point. I can look at anthropology examples of the authenticity of parts of the Bible. I can look at a number of things but I do not have the proof that there is a God. I can only tell you the difference this belief, that I am not the center of the universe that there is a power greater than myself, has made to me.

I think both sides want to put their fingers in thier ears and resist what could be some of the greatest discoveries of our times.
 
Can you show that you are the same species as your great-great-grandfather? Can you prove that you and he could reproduce?

This is just my thought on this. I think genetically I could prove with science that I am the same species as my great- great- grandfather. I don't have any desire to see if i could reproduce with my great-great-grandfather but even if we could we would not create a new species. That is why there is a concern when people who are for example first cousins want to marry and the genetics cause more abnormalities in the offspring. I think that with the generational lengthening it may take longer but eventually that the species would die out. It would become extinct but not become a new species.

Wow that is an interesting question, but no I can not prove that he and I could reproduce.
 
Ya know I have never once seen a discussion on this topic that didn't very quickly devolve into name calling and refusal to even consider other options from both sides.
Not here, not anywhere.
Everyone gets so stupid when it comes to this stuff. People on both sides stick their fingers in their ears and start screaming na na na na na na na!

Fucks sake.
 
I can see that we are changing, adapting. What you are saying is that I am the missing link. :eek: Holy Scientific break through batman! LOL

Just show me one time when scientists can make the full link from one species to another and I would be happy to say I am wrong.

*sigh*

*sneeze*

Are you wanting merely evidence of the tree of life, chronological sequencing in the genetic relatedness of species? Because I would be happy to point you in that direction.

Surely you are aware of the sophisticated techniques which allow geneticists to deduce at what point two related organisms diverged in their evolutionary descent. Such techniques would be nonsense without the context of a deep time evolutionary explanation for the origin of species.
 
This is just my thought on this. I think genetically I could prove with science that I am the same species as my great- great- grandfather. I don't have any desire to see if i could reproduce with my great-great-grandfather but even if we could we would not create a new species. That is why there is a concern when people who are for example first cousins want to marry and the genetics cause more abnormalities in the offspring. I think that with the generational lengthening it may take longer but eventually that the species would die out. It would become extinct but not become a new species.

Wow that is an interesting question, but no I can not prove that he and I could reproduce.
I see I chose a bad example. I should have done Julius Caesar.

My point is that "species" is only an attempt to classify living things. The term doesn't automatically make defined genetic boxes that everything fits into.
 
Are you wanting merely evidence of the tree of life, chronological sequencing in the genetic relatedness of species? Because I would be happy to point you in that direction.

Surely you are aware of the sophisticated techniques which allow geneticists to deduce at what point two related organisms diverged in their evolutionary descent. Such techniques would be nonsense without the context of a deep time evolutionary explanation for the origin of species.

You're both idiots.
 
I see I chose a bad example. I should have done Julius Caesar.

My point is that "species" is only an attempt to classify living things. The term doesn't automatically make defined genetic boxes that everything fits into.

Now you want me to Screw Julius Ceasar. LOL I see what you are saying.
 
Are you wanting merely evidence of the tree of life, chronological sequencing in the genetic relatedness of species? Because I would be happy to point you in that direction.

Surely you are aware of the sophisticated techniques which allow geneticists to deduce at what point two related organisms diverged in their evolutionary descent. Such techniques would be nonsense without the context of a deep time evolutionary explanation for the origin of species.

I simply wanted to know of an example of one species that turned into another. I also enjoy some different conversation. If you a have some references you wanted to share I would like that.
 
Last edited:
oh my. so it does.
fancy that :cool:


:cool:



tryharder, one question: which came first, the chicken or the egg?

I don't know - but I like them both fried.

My opinion is that the chicken came first. What do you think?
 
Last edited:
I don't know - but I like them both fried.

My opinion is that the chicken came first. What do you think?

i think the chicken had to emerge from an egg

if it was the first 'true' chicken, what laid the egg?
 
i think the chicken had to emerge from an egg

if it was the first 'true' chicken, what laid the egg?

Tim Howard, the tourettes afflicted american goal keeper who plays for everton in the EPL and who features in my rival thread - Everton vs god.
 
People confuse the fact that believing in god doesn't necessarily mean that you are a Christian or a Muslim. You can also believe in both God and evolution. I believe in God, but I think the bible is a pile of shit.
 
Hey Try! You know I like you - I think you're sweet and genuine and fun. After the last creationism thread, though I certainly respect your right to your own beliefs, I thought it was best to avoid discussing religion with you. We're just never going to be on the same page, but I appreciate that you are always honest and respectful. I keep seeing this thread getting bumped, though, and I just have a few things that I'd really like to add.

Richard Dawkins is not "worried." Nobody who accepts the theory of evolution is worried. Not only because the logic and "evidence" in question hold about as much water as a pair of fishnet stockings, but because what is there to be worried about? That we'll find new evidence that will alter our idea of the development of terrestrial life? I'm not scared of that. That would be awesome. When I say that a belief in creationism is one of the wrongest things that an adult person can think (seriously, no offense intended! I promise! :D), I'm not trying to "prove" evolution; I'm just trying to find the truth. There are interesting theories about extinction and speciation that don't align perfectly with the Darwinian model. Cool. They don't have to. They just have to be supported by the evidence.

There are missing pieces. It doesn't mean they don't exist - it means we haven't found them yet. And we're looking! And it's exciting! The pieces of the puzzle that we DO have are pretty straightforward and quite convincing. When you say things like "show me X" and "I'm just asking questions," it's incredibly exasperating, because you're ignoring the MOUNTAIN of science that's already there, and why are you even asking questions in the first place? What do you have to prove? Why should you have to prove the word of God? Isn't the point that you don't have to? Isn't that what faith is? Why are people mangling and beating down pieces of brilliant science and solid evidence? This is one in a loooong series of contentions with evolution, not one of which has been held up so far. Here's a big old list of them from a pro-creation website ("no new species" makes the list).

It's like if I tell you that the planet Kepler-62f is 1200 lightyears away. Now, I'm fairly certain the Bible didn't cover that, because it is a document written by people who were constrained by the scientific knowledge of their time and culture, but let's say you ask me how I know that's how far away it is. I can point you in the direction of trigonometric parallax and Hubble's Law and absolute/apparent magnitude and a zillion other things that astronomers have dedicated their lives to understanding. Would you question them because we don't have a tape measurer that's over a quadrillion km long?

Anyway. There's science, and there's creationism. If faith doesn't require proof, why are these guys trying so hard?
 
Back
Top