Evolution vs God

I feel sorry for those Catholics who have to accept that the story of Adam and Eve is an allegory, because it overturns the entire doctrine of Original Sin.

The moral lesson of Adam & Eve is that the Serpent told the truth and Gods threats were not truthful.
 
I am so glad I did look into it myself. :D I just listened to the maker of the video this morning. I think it will be interesting. Just out of curiosity what are the answers the questions? Can anybody tell me? That was only a trailer not the whole video.
What is the evidence that one species can evolve into a different species? Mules.
 
What is the evidence that one species can evolve into a different species? Mules.

A species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and create viable offspring. In other words, a species can have babies that can have babies too.

This is why a mule is not really a new species. When a donkey and a horse get together, they produce a mule. The mule, though, is sterile -- it cannot have or make new mules.
 
By the nature of it (as it takes thousands of years), it's not something you can simplify to the point of naming one species to a person with none of the background understanding.
I couldn't explain fusion without first explaining the atom, energy tranfer, etc. It would take more than one post. It would take me more time than I can be bothered, honestly, when you could just... study.

The peppered moth demonstrated natural selection enough for you to see how pressure encourages change,. natural selection. It's the kindergarten example.
Speciesation is, as I said, a lot harder to point a tiny finger at when the picture is a million years across. They may scoff at the mention of bacteria but there are parts of every living cell that, essentially, are bacteria. They make a good example because we can track them as they change, as they change so quickly... like when the flu mutates year to year to the point where the old shots don't work. Ignoring bacteria is like... ignoring bricks when trying to explain houses.

If you genuinely want to understand, don't expect to get that from a few words in conversation. Look into it properly.
 
Last edited:
In mainstream circles, creationists were on the verge of losing the debate nearly 200 years ago. It's amusing that modern intelligent design proponents often fail to recognize the ancient origins of their arguments. All that remains today of creationism is a politically motivated and scientifically illiterate vestige.

Honestly, evolution has become such a linchpin of modern biology, when speaking of its veracity it must be characterized by a confluence of evidence.
 
A species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and create viable offspring. In other words, a species can have babies that can have babies too.

This is why a mule is not really a new species. When a donkey and a horse get together, they produce a mule. The mule, though, is sterile -- it cannot have or make new mules.
Not all mules are sterile. There are a few dozen authenticated cases of mules reproducing. That is all it takes.
 
Why does it have to be "Evolution VS. God"? There is a not so subtle subtext here that it is the Faithful that is picking the fight.

How about "What can be explained through rational thought and applied physics is over here in this bucket, and then there is the other bucket, over there, where Faith is required to you to believe there is anything in the bucket at all. And they lived happily ever after."
 
By the nature of it (as it takes thousands of years), it's not something you can simplify to the point of naming one species to a person with none of the background understanding.
I couldn't explain fusion without first explaining the atom, energy tranfer, etc. It would take more than one post. It would take me more time than I can be bothered, honestly, when you could just... study.

The peppered moth demonstrated natural selection enough for you to see how pressure encourages change,. natural selection. It's the kindergarten example.
Speciesation is, as I said, a lot harder to point a tiny finger at when the picture is a million years across. They may scoff at the mention of bacteria but there are parts of every living cell that, essentially, are bacteria. They make a good example because we can track them as they change, as they change so quickly... like when the flu mutates year to year to the point where the old shots don't work. Ignoring bacteria is like... ignoring bricks when trying to explain houses.

If you genuinely want to understand, don't expect to get that from a few words in conversation. Look into it properly.

So you are saying that you can't name a species?

The peppered moth may adapt but it is still a peppered moth. Natural selection can select the variant best suited for an environment, but natural selection doesn't create anything new.

Antibiotic Resistant Bacteria - When antibiotics are first used on a population of bacteria, many die, but usually some survive and reproduce. This has produced seemingly stronger strains of bacteria (at least to that specific antibiotic). This does not prove evolution since there is no evidence of new genetic information. It merely underscores the fact that resistance was already present in the population. This can be shown from autopsies performed on explorers who tried to cross the Antarctic before the antibiotics were even being used. The explorers had antibiotic resistant bacteria in their stomachs. The bacteria was already there- it is nothing new.

I don't bring up this topic for any other reasons to but to continue to explore all sides of it. I have never been against Science. In fact I think it is fascinating. That is why I like to talk to people here. There are some here (Who keep their clothes on;)) that are very intelligent and more versed than I. Although - I did go to Kindergarten. LOL:D This topic is not something new for me.
 
Why does it have to be "Evolution VS. God"? There is a not so subtle subtext here that it is the Faithful that is picking the fight.

How about "What can be explained through rational thought and applied physics is over here in this bucket, and then there is the other bucket, over there, where Faith is required to you to believe there is anything in the bucket at all. And they lived happily ever after."

You know I agree with you. I don't know why they picked that title. I haven't watched the entire movie either. I am waiting for the You Tube video - money is tight - I don't think it has to be a fight but a mutual exploration.

I don't know everything about this topic, of course, but for me at this point it takes more faith to believe evolution than to believe that a higher power(whoever yours may or may not be) created the magnificent world we have.
 
Cherry picking peeps & editing cleverly. It's a dumb video and anyone with an ounce of scientific knowledge could answer the qusstions the 'experts' were stumped by. Anyone withan ounce of sense would look into it themselves instead of watching propaganda.

Meh. I dislike dawkins. He offends as much as the zealots he attacks. It's not like evolution proves a lack of god anyway.

Dumbarsery abounds.

well said.
 
So you are saying that you can't name a species?

The peppered moth may adapt but it is still a peppered moth. Natural selection can select the variant best suited for an environment, but natural selection doesn't create anything new.

Antibiotic Resistant Bacteria - When antibiotics are first used on a population of bacteria, many die, but usually some survive and reproduce. This has produced seemingly stronger strains of bacteria (at least to that specific antibiotic). This does not prove evolution since there is no evidence of new genetic information. It merely underscores the fact that resistance was already present in the population. This can be shown from autopsies performed on explorers who tried to cross the Antarctic before the antibiotics were even being used. The explorers had antibiotic resistant bacteria in their stomachs. The bacteria was already there- it is nothing new.

I don't bring up this topic for any other reasons to but to continue to explore all sides of it. I have never been against Science. In fact I think it is fascinating. That is why I like to talk to people here. There are some here (Who keep their clothes on;)) that are very intelligent and more versed than I. Although - I did go to Kindergarten. LOL:D This topic is not something new for me.
Are you suggesting coconuts migrate?
 
Are you suggesting coconuts migrate?

Q: What did the hurricane say to the coconut tree?
A: Hold on to your nuts, this is no ordinary blow job!

Terrible that this joke was what came to my mind. Today has been a stinker. I have no clue what you are talking about.:confused:
 
You know I agree with you. I don't know why they picked that title. I haven't watched the entire movie either. I am waiting for the You Tube video - money is tight - I don't think it has to be a fight but a mutual exploration.

I don't know everything about this topic, of course, but for me at this point it takes more faith to believe evolution than to believe that a higher power(whoever yours may or may not be) created the magnificent world we have.

So it is easier for you to believe what you can imagine that what you can prove?
 
So it is easier for you to believe what you can imagine that what you can prove?
It is easier for me to imagine you meant to say "than" rather than "that" in your sentence than it would be for me to prove it. However, if I could prove it, then I certainly could more easily believe it.
 
Back
Top