Dear Judge

http://jonathanturley.org/2013/08/25/alternative-sentences-and-punishment-creative-or-inhumane/

"Some judges have found themselves faced with the dilemma of sentencing a defendant to jail, but there is literally, “No room at the inn.” Some chief judges have been forced to order felony inmates released before their sentences were up, simply to make room for new inmates.
Some judges, especially at the municipal and county levels, have turned to creative sentencing. Some of the sentences seem to fit the crime and make one smile at the same time, such as sentencing young adults with ‘boom-box’ cars ticketed for loud music to spend anywhere from an hour to all day listening to classical music, jazz, bagpipes and oriental music. There was one judge who played saxophone in a jazz band, and he would throw in a few recordings of his own music. I don’t know how good the judge is on the sax, or whether that might come under the heading of cruel and unusual punishment."



http://www.telegram.com/article/20130125/NEWS/101259711/0

"Judges have five considerations when they sentence defendants, whether it is after a trial or a plea.

Punishment, rehabilitation, protection of the public, restitution and detriment (to society) are taken into account, Judge Paul L. McGill said during a recent day at Western Worcester District Court in East Brookfield.

“Jail time is one option, but we see people get released and re-offend time and time again, so obviously that doesn't work for them,” he explained. “Then we look at what else we can do.”



Judges and creative sentencing. I think in some cases it might work for what is considered minor criminal offences.

With overcrowding it might be a better alternative to home detention which I think is futile.

How is it punishment to sit at home with most of the nice things in life like your tv, computer, access to the net etc?

Bring back the stocks I say. ;)
 
In this state, when a judge is smart and creative, a woman generally steps forward to accuse him of inappropriately touching her kid 25 years ago. We gasp. The media goes apeshit. And the judge is yanked off his bench. Two years later the special prosecutor determines there's insufficient evidence to go to trial.
 
Back
Top