D.C. sniper

I'm back

Ok, DCL-- if that's your real name-- I'll play along and respond to your points, since you were nice enough to deny you're Hanns.

(1) That's an interesting fairy tale you've concocted there, but it's not what happened in D.C. on Sept. 27, as I documented, from both mainstream and alternative sources, in my "D.C. repression" thread. I know you're familiar with that thread, since you posted to it several times. You're a damned liar.

(2) The only difference between the two, as I see it, is one is carried on by a government, and the other is carried on by an individual or a group of individuals. I'm sure someone as educated as you obviously are has heard the old saying, "One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter." There's a lot of truth to that saying.

(3) No good. Cite to me from the United States Code. You referred me to a secondary source, from the U.S. military-- hardly a neutral, objective source on the subject.
 
The erosion of Posse Comitatus..

One of the most controversial uses of the military during the past 20 years has been to involve the Navy and Air Force in the “war on drugs.” Recognizing the inability of civilian law enforcement agencies to interdict the smuggling of drugs into the United States by air and sea, the Reagan Administration directed the Department of Defense to use naval and air assets to reach out beyond the borders of the United States to preempt drug smuggling. This use of the military in antidrug law enforcement was approved by Congress in 10 U.S.C., sections 371–381. This same legislation permitted the use of military forces in other traditionally civilian areas—immigration control and tariff enforcement.

The use of the military in opposing drug smuggling and illegal immigration was a significant step away from the act’s central tenet that there was no proper role for the military in the direct enforcement of the laws. The legislative history explains that this new policy is consistent with the Posse Comitatus Act, as the military involvement still amounted to an indirect and logistical support of civilian law enforcement and not direct enforcement.

The weakness of the analysis of passive versus direct involvement in law enforcement was most graphically demonstrated in the tragic 1999 shooting of a shepherd by marines who had been assigned a mission to interdict smuggling and illegal immigration in the remote Southwest. An investigation revealed that for some inexplicable reason the 16-year-old shepherd fired his weapon in the direction of the marines. Return fire killed the boy. This tragedy demonstrates that when armed troops are placed in a position where they are being asked to counter potential criminal activity, it is a mere semantic exercise to argue that the military is being used in a passive support role. The fact that armed military troops were placed in a position with the mere possibility that they would have to use force to subdue civilian criminal activity reflects a significant policy shift by the executive branch away from the posse comitatus doctrine.

Congress has also approved the use of the military in civilian law enforcement through the Civil Disturbance Statutes: 10 U.S.C., sections 331–334. These provisions permit the president to use military personnel to enforce civilian laws where the state has requested assistance or is unable to protect civil rights and property. In case of civil disturbance, the president must first give an order for the offenders to disperse. If the order is not obeyed, the president may then authorize military forces to make arrests and restore order. The scope of the Civil Disturbance Statutes is sufficiently broad to encompass civil disturbance resulting from terrorist or other criminal activity. It was these provisions that were relied upon to restore order using active-duty Army personnel following the Los Angeles “race riots” of the early 1990s.

Federal military personnel may also be used pursuant to the Stafford Act, 42 U.S.C., section 5121, in times of natural disaster upon request from a state governor. In such an instance, the Stafford Act permits the president to declare a major disaster and send in military forces on an emergency basis for up to ten days to preserve life and property. While the Stafford Act authority is still subject to the criteria of active versus passive, it represents a significant exception to the Posse Comitatus Act’s underlying principle that the military is not a domestic police force auxiliary.

An infrequently cited constitutional power of the president provides an even broader basis for the president to use military forces in the context of homeland defense. This is the president’s inherent right and duty to preserve federal functions. In the past this has been recognized to authorize the president to preserve the freedom of navigable waterways and to put down armed insurrection. However, with the expansion of federal authority during this century into many areas formerly reserved to the states (transportation, commerce, education, civil rights) there is likewise an argument that the president’s power to preserve these “federal” functions has expanded as well. The use of federal troops in the South during the 1960s to preserve access to educational institutions for blacks was an exercise of this constitutional presidential authority.

In the past five years, the erosion of the Posse Comitatus Act has continued with the increasingly common use of military forces as security for essentially civilian events. During the 1996 Olympics in Atlanta, over ten thousand U.S. troops were deployed under the partial rationale that they were present to deter terrorism. The use of active-duty military forces in a traditional police security role did not raise any serious questions under the act, even though these troops would clearly have been in the middle of a massive law enforcement emergency had a large-scale terrorist incident occurred. The only questions of propriety arose when many of these troops were then employed as bus drivers or to maintain playing fields. This led to a momentary but passing expression of displeasure from Congress.


:D
 
LC

That was actually a good contribution from you, Lost Cause, although I have the feeling you C&P'd it from somewhere. I will take a look at the statutes you mentioned. I don't think any of them cover the situation I'm talking about here.
 
Re: The erosion of Posse Comitatus..

Lost Cause said:
One ..... from Congress.


:D

Hey LC this is exactly how Redpimple is gonna read your post, he won't accept it because DCL didn't post it.

Redpimple will not acknowlegde this post because it contains facts.

I applaud you on your effort.
 
Cut & paste.....

If I'm looking for a subject and the text describes what I want to say, of course I'll c&p for times sake. Most of the time, by the time I research and type an opinion, the direction of the thread has changed, and my post is almost irrelevant to the dialogue. C&P is good for keeping hard data/facts intact, making it nonpartisan.

Here's a good example, it's a wonder they can't find the sniper:

The National Security Agency intelligence agency monitors phone calls, radio and TV broadcasts and other ''signals'' around the world. Those communications make up the bulk of all the raw information U.S. intelligence experts sift through every day.


Headquarters: Fort Meade, Md.

Employees: 16,000

Annual budget: $4 billion; $3.5 billion more allotted for eavesdropping satellites.

Surveillance equipment:

Ground based listening posts: 15-20

Listening satellites

in orbit: 7

Intercept posts on

embassy rooftops: 40-50

Communications monitored every hour at average listening post: 2 million

Amount actually processed by decrypters, translators and analysts: 1%

Little known fact: In February 2000, the NSA's computer system crashed, a sign of overload. It was down for four days.


Sources: U.S. intelligence officials; James Bamford, author of Body of Secrets, a book about the NSA; and Jeffrey Richelson, author of The U.S. Intelligence Community
:D
 
Still quiet

Well, the sniper still hasn't struck again. Hopefully, he never will. If he's smart, he'll lay low for a while now, until the manhunt subsides a little.

It may be more than one person, and I have no way of knowing for sure it's not a woman, but I would bet almost any amount it's a male. Specifically, a white male, ex-military, probably an extreme right-winger.
 
Originally posted by REDWAVE

(2) The whole manner of these killings strongly indicate it is being done by someone with a military background. Also, remember the recent Fort Bragg killings, in which several career NCO's shot their wives. After all, the U.S. military is the largest and most powerful terrorist organization in the world. Its whole purpose is to produce trained, ruthless murderers. Why should it be surprising that some of them should freelance on the side?

The one thing about you that really stands out, red ripple, is that you continually sink lower and lower. You have no concept of anything, you just flap your jaws without having a clue about life or anything.

But on the bright side, even though you probably think you having something valuable to add, the rest of us see just how pathetic of a human being you really are.

Dude, your every minute of existence must be excrutiatingly miserable.......:rolleyes:
 
Well . . . actually, Rodney, I've been tokin' on some good stuff this evening, and I'm feeling pretty good. How are you?
:p
 
Hey there, Hanns-- er, I mean DCL

Hey there, DCL. Good to see you're back.

You're a statistician.
 
Red, as usual, you've managed to screw this analysis up, too.

1) Those arrested in DC committed illegal acts right in front of police officers. The "ruthless efficiency" you mentioned involved, in most cases, leaning over and picking up a limp protestor (most of whom barely had a clue what they were protesting, might I add). The sniper(s) on the other hand is committing an act that, unless they make an incredible mistake or is unlucky, is nearly impossible to track. That's why sniping is such a widely-used tool for both militaries and terrorists. It's high reward for low risk.

2) That these attacks involve a sniper does not even remotely suggest anyone with any ties to the military. It does, however, suggest that there is a person (or are people) who have time to find a nice hidey hole with a good view of a public place, have a rifle with even a half-assed scope, and will wait until they can take a shot at someone who is either standing still or is moving very slowly. Note that the sniper has yet to shoot a jogger but has only shot those people walking at not a very quick pace or standing still. As at least two national news networks have proven, it's painfully easy for someone who has never even shot a gun before to hit a non-moving target at 100-200 yards with an average rifle and scope.

3) The Posse Comitatus ACt has not been violated. In fact, whatever military involvement has happened in this case has been very carefully curtailed so as not to violate the Act. Not only would the military be loathe to violate the Act, the local police would scream bloody murder. Cops are very territorial creatures, you see.
 
Redwave, you are outclassed here. Go away.

I won't go into countering all of your knee-jerk vomitus du jour. That has been done very well by other thinking members here. But the link you posted to indymedia or whatever did upset me. You see, to psuedo-intellectuals like yourself, if the gov't doesn't want everything published, you people are looking for a conspiracy against yourselves. In reality, it is a safety matter for people involved. For those of us who are on the front lines, America's first responders, (fire, police, EMS, etc) we don't need the general public knowing everything about our SOPs, Comms, etc. It is for our safety. Let's see you put your ass on the front lines, then give your spiel. Oh, that's right, you couldn't even try to digest this yourself, just post a link to some other article written by a psychotic on a psychotic web page. The black helicopters are coming for you, man!! Run!!! Those of us who do face responding to a WMD incident, or sniper incident, or other terrorist incident, don't want, or need your kind of help, redtard. You, on the other hand, could do with a little Xanax, Versed, and possibly a few other meds. Get counseling and give us all a break.
 
Breaking news - Todd's got a thread going, maybe an arrest. I'm off to listen to the radio.
 
We ought to be polite with Red. Although I disagree with his points, we should argue based on the points and not add personal insults to it.

I know that there are some that only offer personal insults, but those few are easy to ignore.
 
Re: Still quiet

REDWAVE said:
Well, the sniper still hasn't struck again. Hopefully, he never will. If he's smart, he'll lay low for a while now, until the manhunt subsides a little.

It may be more than one person, and I have no way of knowing for sure it's not a woman, but I would bet almost any amount it's a male. Specifically, a white male, ex-military, probably an extreme right-winger.

I just had to bump and quote. The suspected sniper(s) don't appear to be white or right-winger.

Possibly Muslim or recently converted.

But hey you nailed the male thing
 
Back
Top