Constructive Living

CL people love aphorisms, little pithy sayings.

"Let reality esteem replace self esteem."

We were asked to write a couple during my training. I'm struggling to remember the other one, but one of mine was "No words work." I punctuated it differently to make it into a sort of dialog:

"No words, work."

"No; words work."

"No words work."
 
Yes, I think Western philosophy has concerned itself more with the waves and less with the ocean. I'm not knocking Western contributions to the value of the individual (event or person) but I think it needs integration with Eastern value of the whole (patterns and groups).

You reminded me. David talks about the Steps Of Enlightenment:

A person is lying on a couch in a filthy room.
Ask him what he's doing. "Nothing."

He gets up and starts to clean. "I'm cleaning the room."

"I'm helping the vacuum cleaner clean the room."

"The room is getting clean."

"Reality is cleaning Reality's room."

Sounds bizarre, but the message is as you say, that we are a part of a whole.
 
This is a good insight. I never thought about it this way, but it certainly applies to, oh, I don't know, everything. School right now is a great example.

Seeing it this way very much helps me to realize that I can only learn when I've cleared my thoughts of all the opposing, destructive thoughts in the way. Weeding out laziness is a constant chore.

It also reminds me that people and entities who like drama - get dangerous when you threaten that drama. Your own mind for one. Anger, justifications, pain, drama.

How much you listen to it and count it as "real" instead of noise, really only depends on underlying conditions.

But fake pain and outrage have a very different tone than real pain and outrage. The same way a toddler in pain sounds different than one who is just whining because they didn't get their way.

Recognition of the differences between your internal toddler.

My main problem is that my internal Toddler is onto me and is very convincing and I'm often able to convince myself of anything - my answer has honestly often had to be to stop listening to myself because I'm selfish, determined, and too damned smart for my own good. I can talk myself into anything if I'm not absolutely pristine about my actions.
 
CL people love aphorisms, little pithy sayings.

"Let reality esteem replace self esteem."

We were asked to write a couple during my training. I'm struggling to remember the other one, but one of mine was "No words work." I punctuated it differently to make it into a sort of dialog:

"No words, work."

"No; words work."

"No words work."

Heh. Another Zen saying I like:

"Don't just do something, sit there."
 
You reminded me. David talks about the Steps Of Enlightenment:

A person is lying on a couch in a filthy room.
Ask him what he's doing. "Nothing."

He gets up and starts to clean. "I'm cleaning the room."

"I'm helping the vacuum cleaner clean the room."

"The room is getting clean."

"Reality is cleaning Reality's room."

Sounds bizarre, but the message is as you say, that we are a part of a whole.

I like the Oxen Pictures.

http://swamij.com/zen-ox.htm

Another guiding thought I use:

"An ordinary person who attains knowledge is a sage. But a sage who attains understanding is an ordinary person."
 
Behavior wags the tail of feelings.

This is a tough one for people to swallow. Feelings are a sort of sticking point for those learning about CL, because as I said before, we in the West are trained from an early age to be constantly aware of them. Yet we miss the very obvious truth that if you behave a certain way, you can influence your feelings a great deal.

As a martial arts student, I often felt like skipping class. Sometimes I did, and then I'd add guilt to the lazy depressed feelings. Sometimes I'd push through the low feelings and go to class, and by the end I felt wonderful. Hmmm.

Depressed? Clean something. Then even if you're still depressed, at least something is cleaner, and often, the act of cleaning is itself therapeutic, because you're at least somewhat distracted from the feelings of depression.

David sort of stumbled upon this idea when he was doing research into how depressed patients were treated. He decide he wanted to be one, be diagnosed and hospitalized, so he had to figure out how to become depressed. He did it, very simply, by acting as though he were. He sat and did nothing, stared at the floor, mumbled when he was talking to people, kept his room dark, etc, etc. Acted like a depressed person. Success. He was diagnosed and hospitalized. Then he had to figure out how to not be depressed any more.

Guess what?
 
Seeing it this way very much helps me to realize that I can only learn when I've cleared my thoughts of all the opposing, destructive thoughts in the way. Weeding out laziness is a constant chore.

It also reminds me that people and entities who like drama - get dangerous when you threaten that drama. Your own mind for one. Anger, justifications, pain, drama.

How much you listen to it and count it as "real" instead of noise, really only depends on underlying conditions.

But fake pain and outrage have a very different tone than real pain and outrage. The same way a toddler in pain sounds different than one who is just whining because they didn't get their way.

Recognition of the differences between your internal toddler.

My main problem is that my internal Toddler is onto me and is very convincing and I'm often able to convince myself of anything - my answer has honestly often had to be to stop listening to myself because I'm selfish, determined, and too damned smart for my own good. I can talk myself into anything if I'm not absolutely pristine about my actions.
I love it. My internal toddler drinks scotch in the morning. Another thing that's sometimes suggested to CL folks is that they practice internal silence. I'm preaching to the choir, but that constant internal chatter most people keep up is counterproductive most of the time.
Heh. Another Zen saying I like:

"Don't just do something, sit there."
I believe taht one is on a plaque on the wall at ToDo.
I like the Oxen Pictures.

http://swamij.com/zen-ox.htm

Another guiding thought I use:

"An ordinary person who attains knowledge is a sage. But a sage who attains understanding is an ordinary person."

I love the oxen. I hadn't seen them before.
 
Feelings change like the Japanese sky.

~Morita

His point being that feelings are not logical entities. We can't predict them or use logic to manipulate them. They are not under our direct, willful control.

So why use them as a guide to our behavior? You wouldn't base your decisions on the patterns of the clouds, would you? I guess, unless you're a meteorologist. Or a climber. But you know what I mean, right?

The other great thing about the fact that we cannot control our feelings is that we are therefore not responsible for them, either. They're not "our fault." They just happen. So don't feel guilty because you're attracted to Recidiva; you can't help feeling attraction to someone. What can you help? Well, you don't have to send her PMs, do you?
 
Feelings change like the Japanese sky.

~Morita

His point being that feelings are not logical entities. We can't predict them or use logic to manipulate them. They are not under our direct, willful control.

So why use them as a guide to our behavior? You wouldn't base your decisions on the patterns of the clouds, would you? I guess, unless you're a meteorologist. Or a climber. But you know what I mean, right?

The other great thing about the fact that we cannot control our feelings is that we are therefore not responsible for them, either. They're not "our fault." They just happen. So don't feel guilty because you're attracted to Recidiva; you can't help feeling attraction to someone. What can you help? Well, you don't have to send her PMs, do you?

Yes, I think guilt is optional. It's a sign that you need to fix something. It's not an end in itself.

I really don't believe that "being wracked by guilt" means anything, unless you do something. I don't care. You don't get credit.

No credit for good intentions, either, if you persist in taking credit for the good intention, yet can't carry through.

Tangential to this is "the Four Agreements" by Don Miguel Ruiz from Olmec traditional teachings.

Agreement 1:

Be impeccable with your word - Speak with integrity. Say only what you mean. Avoid using the word to speak against yourself or to gossip about others. Use the power of your word in the direction of truth and love.

Agreement 2:

Don’t take anything personally - Nothing others do is because of you. What others say and do is a projection of their own reality, their own dream. When you are immune to the opinions and actions of others, you won’t be the victim of needless suffering.

Agreement 3:
Don’t make assumptions - Find the courage to ask questions and to express what you really want. Communicate with others as clearly as you can to avoid misunderstandings, sadness and drama. With just this one agreement, you can completely transform your life.

Agreement 4:

Always do your best - Your best is going to change from moment to moment; it will be different when you are healthy as opposed to sick. Under any circumstance, simply do your best, and you will avoid self-judgment, self-abuse and regret.

I think Western tradition believes too much in cause and effect as absolutes.

Doing good actions sometimes has horrible outcomes. And doing evil actions can be entirely rewarded on earth and I don't believe in heaven and hell, only here and now.

So the concept of Justice (which is a moral idea for me) is a human construct. Balance in nature takes place over time, and humans just are too small of a part of it to really have perspective.

Balance isn't in our inherent natures, balance is what's done to us.

Trying to achieve balance is bloody hard, because we've got that whole second law of thermodynamics working against us.

But trying to achieve balance I think it's the name of the game if I want to understand how and why things work, and the best way I can spend my time.
 
All very good stuff Perg and again to draw Buddhism into it a good comparision. Very similiar. It makes a great deal of sense.

We create our own world and engineer our own actions, and we control how we act. The question is what does one do with doubt and fear?
 
A practical example from my life:

I first met Greg when he did a brief presentation on CL for staff at the psychobrat place. He asked if any of us wanted exercises to do for specific purposes. I said that I was trying to quit smoking. He had me carry a piece of paper with my cigarettes and for a week write down each time I smoked and for how long, and the exact time. I could smoke all I wanted, but I had to write it down.

I think he was a little surprised when I showed it to him a week later. I got the impression he didn't think I'd follow through.

The next week, I was to write each evening a schedule for when I would smoke the next day. I could schedule as many as I wanted, but I had to stick to the schedule.

I made it about four days, and said, the hell with it, and stopped smoking altogether.

Why does it work?

Because it gives you a very simple lesson on a deep level of understanding. You are totally in control of whether or not you smoke. Big surprise there, I know, but there's two kinds of learning, right? There's reading a recipe and there's baking a cake. The Japanese call it tai-ken, roughly "body knowledge." That's the goal of many Morita exercises, to create that deep undestanding.

ah, this can be used with any mindless actions that one may do
 
David sort of stumbled upon this idea when he was doing research into how depressed patients were treated. He decide he wanted to be one, be diagnosed and hospitalized, so he had to figure out how to become depressed. He did it, very simply, by acting as though he were. He sat and did nothing, stared at the floor, mumbled when he was talking to people, kept his room dark, etc, etc. Acted like a depressed person. Success. He was diagnosed and hospitalized. Then he had to figure out how to not be depressed any more.

Guess what?


Interesting idea, but what about biochemical issues?
 
All very good stuff Perg and again to draw Buddhism into it a good comparision. Very similiar. It makes a great deal of sense.

We create our own world and engineer our own actions, and we control how we act. The question is what does one do with doubt and fear?

I think doubt and fear are tools.

When only your ego is involved, it's easy to doubt and fear, because you're focusing only on yourself. Life is painful, everything's an insult. There's no greater context, no greater framework.

You have to decide whether or not your doubt and fear are there to protect you from something that will do you harm, or whether they're the easy way out and you rely on them too much to keep you from taking chances.

Again you have to put right action into perspective.

Doubt that someone from Nigeria has your best financial interests in mind is a good thing.

Doubting a friend or a loved one when there's no cause, just because you feel insecure, not a good thing.

Change your perspective.

"ABC" is another concept from Charlotte Joko Beck - "A Bigger Container"

Put your situation in a bigger container, a larger perspective, discount your own ego, look at the entire thing as if it were not you, without your emotions.

"Most of us are susceptible to tendencies of either suppressing aspects of the moment we
find unpleasant on the one hand, or being overwhelmed by them on the other. With mindfulness, we can learn to ‘hold’ experiences within our awareness without getting thrown about by them – remaining open to both pain and pleasure within a broad and rich perspective. In this way we can develop a broad and stable awareness that is like a bigger container. An image that describes this is comparing a teaspoon of salt dissolved in a small or large ‘container’ of water. If you put a teaspoon of salt in a small glass of water it will have a very strong taste. But, if you put the same teaspoon of salt in a big lake of clear water the taste will be negligible and the body of water will be largely unaffected. With mindfulness we can become like this deep and clear lake, where individual experiences do not overwhelm us and we can remain stable and steady within the ups and downs of life, whilst being honest about what is happening moment-to-moment."
 
Interesting idea, but what about biochemical issues?

Addressing medical issues and getting the correct treatment/diet/exercise program, or admitting that something's just...busted and you're clueless...

All part of the path.

A lot of it is the courage to continue honest trial and error and not finding the answer, not finding it, not finding it...until you try a combination of whatever therapy or lifestyle that works for you.

At least that's how I did it. I have a decent medication regimen right now - after years of being scared of medicine because of how often it done me wrong...and going...for me...back into the lion's den for me - sit vulnerable in a doctor's office when I didn't think it would work, but I had to do something.

(can you tell I tried a lot of different philosophies? In the end what works - Imitrex - but the rest of the philosophies kept me alive long enough to get there )
 
The only problem that I have with some of this is that I feel that it's all more complicated than that.

Sometimes you doubt or fear because there are pieces missing to the puzzle and life doesn't make sense without those pieces. It's hard to apply these principles then when it seems to need something concrete


I think doubt and fear are tools.

When only your ego is involved, it's easy to doubt and fear, because you're focusing only on yourself. Life is painful, everything's an insult. There's no greater context, no greater framework.

You have to decide whether or not your doubt and fear are there to protect you from something that will do you harm, or whether they're the easy way out and you rely on them too much to keep you from taking chances.

Again you have to put right action into perspective.

Doubt that someone from Nigeria has your best financial interests in mind is a good thing.

Doubting a friend or a loved one when there's no cause, just because you feel insecure, not a good thing.

Change your perspective.

"ABC" is another concept from Charlotte Joko Beck - "A Bigger Container"

Put your situation in a bigger container, a larger perspective, discount your own ego, look at the entire thing as if it were not you, without your emotions.

"Most of us are susceptible to tendencies of either suppressing aspects of the moment we
find unpleasant on the one hand, or being overwhelmed by them on the other. With mindfulness, we can learn to ‘hold’ experiences within our awareness without getting thrown about by them – remaining open to both pain and pleasure within a broad and rich perspective. In this way we can develop a broad and stable awareness that is like a bigger container. An image that describes this is comparing a teaspoon of salt dissolved in a small or large ‘container’ of water. If you put a teaspoon of salt in a small glass of water it will have a very strong taste. But, if you put the same teaspoon of salt in a big lake of clear water the taste will be negligible and the body of water will be largely unaffected. With mindfulness we can become like this deep and clear lake, where individual experiences do not overwhelm us and we can remain stable and steady within the ups and downs of life, whilst being honest about what is happening moment-to-moment."
 
The only problem that I have with some of this is that I feel that it's all more complicated than that.

Sometimes you doubt or fear because there are pieces missing to the puzzle and life doesn't make sense without those pieces. It's hard to apply these principles then when it seems to need something concrete

Well. Yeah. It's hard.

I don't expect life to make sense. It's often senseless. Grasping that is terrifying.

Being entirely in the dark and not being sure, yet still acting, that's the gist.
 
Feelings change like the Japanese sky.

~Morita

His point being that feelings are not logical entities. We can't predict them or use logic to manipulate them. They are not under our direct, willful control.

So why use them as a guide to our behavior? You wouldn't base your decisions on the patterns of the clouds, would you? I guess, unless you're a meteorologist. Or a climber. But you know what I mean, right?

The other great thing about the fact that we cannot control our feelings is that we are therefore not responsible for them, either. They're not "our fault." They just happen. So don't feel guilty because you're attracted to Recidiva; you can't help feeling attraction to someone. What can you help? Well, you don't have to send her PMs, do you?


This is a truth that I have tried to impart to my children at home and my kiddos at school. It is okay to feel what you feel, it is your behavior that you have to edit.
 
Morita's primary insight can be summed up as follows: No matter how you feel, you can still act. This is one of those controversial ideas. We are trained almost from birth in the West to believe that feelings drive behavior. Morita disagreed, and he had ample personal evidence of this. We all do; we've all had times when we felt one way an acted another. Been really pissed but spoke calmly and politely. Really didn't want to get out of bed and did anyway. There's a series of three statements from Morita which are the complement to the Naikan ones, below:

Accept your feelings.

Know your purpose.

Do what needs to be done.

This is my life.

Naikan was developed by a businessman who wanted to share with everyone an experience he had while pursuing a seriously rigorous form of Zen, an ordeal of meditating for a long time in a cave or something like that. He also wanted to apply accounting technique, as it was his background. He based his school on three questions, which form the core of modern Naikan and half of CL:

What have I given?
What have I received?
What troubles or difficulties have I caused?

oooh! I like this. Great way to look at things. And also painful. Very painful, indeed.
 
Well. Yeah. It's hard.

I don't expect life to make sense. It's often senseless. Grasping that is terrifying.

Being entirely in the dark and not being sure, yet still acting, that's the gist.

But what if the acting you have to do as nothing to do with the problem that your facing?

What if the acting is still functioning in your day to day life while bigger questions are making no sense, but your general feeling state is effected by the reaction the need for answers to these questions?
 
But what if the acting you have to do as nothing to do with the problem that your facing?

What if the acting is still functioning in your day to day life while bigger questions are making no sense, but your general feeling state is effected by the reaction the need for answers to these questions?

I think that's called life.

I think your problem is expecting it to have a concrete, absolute sense, and to always know the answer.

That to me is a subtle form of your ego feeling like God somehow. Like you should know. How the hell should you know?

If the bigger questions fail to provide answers, stick to the small questions - what's the next right action - eat a good meal, get some decent sleep, create some art, help someone do something they need to get done with love in your heart, cook a good meal for someone?

It has to be okay for the bigger questions to not make any sense. Then the small things are done with love instead of wasting your time just thinking about questions you'll never know the answers.

This is embodied by one of my favorite Woody Allen lines - and I'm not a fan of Woody Allen but I love him for this:

"How the hell do I know why there were Nazis? I don't know how the can opener works!"
 
IT still sounds to me like avoidance some how. At some point they can't be avoided anymore.


I think that's called life.

I think your problem is expecting it to have a concrete, absolute sense, and to always know the answer.

That to me is a subtle form of your ego feeling like God somehow. Like you should know. How the hell should you know?

If the bigger questions fail to provide answers, stick to the small questions - what's the next right action - eat a good meal, get some decent sleep, create some art, help someone do something they need to get done with love in your heart, cook a good meal for someone?

It has to be okay for the bigger questions to not make any sense. Then the small things are done with love instead of wasting your time just thinking about questions you'll never know the answers.

This is embodied by one of my favorite Woody Allen lines - and I'm not a fan of Woody Allen but I love him for this:

"How the hell do I know why there were Nazis? I don't know how the can opener works!"
 
IT still sounds to me like avoidance some how. At some point they can't be avoided anymore.

Let me put it to you this way. When you don't have enough information, then feel free to not make a choice. Or make a choice and acknowledge you're not sure, you just feel you need to do something, and take your best shot, and be responsible for it.

However, some "deep" questions are often wastes of time.

Sometimes me trying to consider the mind of God is like the ants in my back yard wanting to drive my car. Even if they organized enough to steal my keys, do you think they could drive it?

IF there's a huge pattern (as there is to driving law, right of way, etc...) I believe that the inner workings of the universe are out of my ultimate reach, but doing relative good deeds isn't.

Accepting my limitations isn't avoidance, it just isn't wasting my time on things I chased long enough to feel I was wasting my time on them while there were things to be done.

If there's a great plan, it can be great enough to let me in on it, otherwise I'll go on appreciating puppies, kittens, mountains and washing the dishes.
 
Accepting my limitations isn't avoidance, it just isn't wasting my time on things I chased long enough to feel I was wasting my time on them while there were things to be done.

What your saying here is important, but the there are times when the heart leads you back, and in the end you have to deal with it.
 
What your saying here is important, but the there are times when the heart leads you back, and in the end you have to deal with it.

Yes, and without any specifics I can't address the heart.

Sometimes the heart is right, sometimes it's selfish.

For one of my real life examples of spiritual choices, I've had to take huge questions and make them smaller, to fit me.

"Are people basically good or evil?"

That's too big. I had to rephrase it to "There are good people on this Earth because I'm one of them."

"Is Karma real? What's Fate? Is there free will?"

I had to redefine:

"Fate can only be determined in the past tense. I will behave as if fate did not exist, as if my choice matters, and the only things that I am sure are fated, have already happened."

When my heart is eternally puzzled, I rephrase. Usually from something entirely general and huge to something absolutely specific to myself, that I can work with.

These thoughts are mine. They fit me because I tailored them to myself. I developed these thoughts by educating myself about karma, fate, free will, the heart and good and evil....

But in the end I had to do it myself.
 
Yes, and without any specifics I can't address the heart.

Sometimes the heart is right, sometimes it's selfish.

For one of my real life examples of spiritual choices, I've had to take huge questions and make them smaller, to fit me.

"Are people basically good or evil?"

That's too big. I had to rephrase it to "There are good people on this Earth because I'm one of them."

"Is Karma real? What's Fate? Is there free will?"

I had to redefine:

"Fate can only be determined in the past tense. I will behave as if fate did not exist, as if my choice matters, and the only things that I am sure are fated, have already happened."

When my heart is eternally puzzled, I rephrase. Usually from something entirely general and huge to something absolutely specific to myself, that I can work with.

These thoughts are mine. They fit me because I tailored them to myself. I developed these thoughts by educating myself about karma, fate, free will, the heart and good and evil....

But in the end I had to do it myself.

A human being sitting alone in the dark is neither good or evil.
 
Back
Top