CEO compensation

Ishmael

Literotica Guru
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Posts
84,005
Bruce Bartlett

September 24, 2002

CEO compensation

In recent weeks, the press has made much of the bloated compensation paid to corporate executives such as Dennis Kozlowski of Tyco and Jack Welch of GE. Welch was even forced by public opinion to relinquish benefits promised him 6 years ago, in order to calm a firestorm of controversy.

The impression is that most corporate executives are just a bunch of greedy SOBs, who fleeced shareholders in order to line their own pockets. In Kozlowski's case, this may be true, but in the vast majority of other cases, including Welch's, the problem -- such as it is -- results mainly from tax-law changes enacted during the Clinton
administration.

It is now largely forgotten that one of Clinton's principal campaign goals in 1992 was to curb "excessive" compensation of corporate executives. In his campaign book, "Putting People First," he complained that corporate CEOs were making 100 times that of average workers. This resulted, he said, because wages were fully deductible
on corporate tax returns, no matter how large.

Clinton vowed to end this practice. In a rare case of being true to his word, he insisted that the 1993 tax increase include a provision limiting executive pay. As a result, the legislation denied a corporate tax deduction for pay in excess of $1 million. With the corporate tax rate being 35 percent, in effect it cost corporations 35 percent
more to pay their top executives more than $1 million per year.

But as is so often the case, the law of unintended consequences then took over. The legislation applied only to cash wages and exempted performance-based compensation. The goal was to avoid penalizing salesmen and those working on commission, for example. But the result was to fundamentally shift CEO compensation in
ways Clinton never imagined.

As financial writer John Cassidy explains in the Sept. 23 issue of the New Yorker, stock options as a form of compensation have been around since 1950. In that year, Congress decided that recipients of incentive stock options need not pay taxes on them until exercised. Shortly thereafter, the predecessor to the Financial Accounting
Standards Board (FASB) decided that such options need not be counted as an expense on corporate books.

Nevertheless, stock options were a very small portion of executive compensation for the next 42 years. It seems that executives shunned them as too risky. They preferred cash on the barrelhead. But this changed in 1993, when Clinton's populist pay constraint was enacted. Subsequently, corporate boards searched for ways to
compensate CEOs in ways that would not overly burden the business.

Stock options were the answer, because they did not count against the $1 million limit. The result was that options, as a form of compensation, exploded. Even the liberal Cassidy concedes that the reform "turned out to be counterproductive." The Clinton administration aided the trend toward stock options by helping torpedo a 1994 effort
by FASB to require that options be deducted from corporate profits. It did so under pressure from congressional Democrats such as Sens. Joseph Lieberman of Connecticut and Diane Feinstein of California.

Another tax problem also contributed to the abuse of stock options. Under current law, options that are indexed have less favorable tax treatment than those that are not. Many economists believe that non-indexed options are bad because, in effect, they reward executives for nothing when the market as a whole is rising.

A preferable approach, economists say, would be to raise the price at which options may be exercised according to a scale based on the Standard and Poor's 500 index of stocks or some other index. Only those executives whose stock prices rose by more than the index would benefit from stock options, rather than gaining largely from a
rising tide, as is now the case.

Unfortunately, current tax law effectively prohibits the use of indexed options, as Columbia University law professor David Schizer recently explained in the University of Pennsylvania Law Review. As a result, the most sensible way of using options for compensation is foreclosed, forcing companies to use a method almost guaranteed to foster abuse without benefiting shareholders at all.

Consequently, there are growing calls to abolish the $1 million limit on cash wages. On Sept. 17, a blue ribbon panel from the Conference Board made such a recommendation. Should such action be taken by Congress, it must also fix the problem that prevents using indexed options. This will go a long way toward eliminating truly excessive corporate compensation and ensure that CEOs are only given large rewards when shareholders benefit through above-average stock increases.
 
Another case of the "law of unintended consequences' biting us in the ass.

CEO's are hired to do a job. That is to run the company and increase the value of that company for the stock holders.

When most people think of stockholders, they think of the 'fat cats'. Speculative investors and such. But by far the largest investors in the market are the funds managers. The people that administer the monies that John and Mary Commonfolk have contributed to their retirement fund. Consequently most of the money in the market is in the form of investment pools created by, and for, the working people of the country.

When CEO compensation is tied to speculation as opposed to real performance, well, you get what you pay for. At least the salaries were visible and pressure could be brought to bear on the Board of Directors if required.

The results of political meddling in the affairs of business have always had consequences. Usually negative.

Ishmael
 
Clausewitz

War is the continuation of politics by other means.

N'est pas, Ishmael?
 
It is unfortunate that the people who write laws aren't as smart as those that find ways of circumventing these very same laws!
 
bknight2602 said:
It is unfortunate that the people who write laws aren't as smart as those that find ways of circumventing these very same laws!

The question is really, what business is it of Congress what anyone that is not a government employee makes?

If you were to offer me a job, I can ask for anything I want in terms of salary, and you can offer anything you want. We may, or may not, come to an agreement. But if we did, it would be just that. An agreement. As long as we were not trying to engage in some illegal activity, what role does the government have in our private treaties?

If some company wants to pay their CEO two hundred million a year, so what? First of all, it's not a penny out of my pocket. Or yours for that matter. You and I may not agree that the CEO is worth the money, but then again, it's none of our business either. If they aren't worth the bucks, their administration will be short lived indeed.

Personnaly I'd like to see the CEO's paid a straght salary for what ever they can negotiate. No stock option deals at all. Take the speculation out of the head office.

Ishmael
 
Defender of the Rich!

Charging to the rescue of those poor, downtrodden, unfairly maligned rich people, it's that knight on shining armor, Ishmule! He's valiently protecting them from the hordes of greedy poor people who are trying to take the CEO's hard earned stock options and other perks away from them! How unfair! Why, those greedy workers are actually so uppity as to think they have the right to a living wage! Do you know what that would do to corporate profits? Ole Ish might have to sell one of his Bentleys.

You were born in the wrong time, Ishmael. You would have made an excellent political leader of the Confederacy-- the greatest slavemasters' revolt in history!
 
Ishmael said:


The question is really, what business is it of Congress what anyone that is not a government employee makes?

If you were to offer me a job, I can ask for anything I want in terms of salary, and you can offer anything you want. We may, or may not, come to an agreement. But if we did, it would be just that. An agreement. As long as we were not trying to engage in some illegal activity, what role does the government have in our private treaties?

If some company wants to pay their CEO two hundred million a year, so what? First of all, it's not a penny out of my pocket. Or yours for that matter. You and I may not agree that the CEO is worth the money, but then again, it's none of our business either. If they aren't worth the bucks, their administration will be short lived indeed.

Personnaly I'd like to see the CEO's paid a straght salary for what ever they can negotiate. No stock option deals at all. Take the speculation out of the head office.

Ishmael

But with options, they can inflate the price through all sorts of accounting gimmickry, and then head out the door with the cash! That is what I meant, but I agree what business does the government have in looking at the compensation packages!
 
bknight2602 said:


But with options, they can inflate the price through all sorts of accounting gimmickry, and then head out the door with the cash!

And that's exactly what the bill passed with the '93 budget act led to. Actually, it inspired it to happen. It took a management tool out of the hands of the Board.

There also seem to be more than a few on the board that can't quite get a grasp on the creation of wealth. They see the economic world as a pie. If one person gets a bigger piece, then someone has to get a smaller piece. They can't understand that governments do not, and can not, create wealth. Governments are net consumers, not producers. The best you can possibly achieve in such a system is a static model. One in which indeed, the pie is of a fixed size.

There also seems to be little understanding of the dynamics that immigration and how that effects the mean income and the "poverty line". They also have little understanding of how communal families work within the 'poverty zone'.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:


And that's exactly what the bill passed with the '93 budget act led to. Actually, it inspired it to happen. It took a management tool out of the hands of the Board.

There also seem to be more than a few on the board that can't quite get a grasp on the creation of wealth. They see the economic world as a pie. If one person gets a bigger piece, then someone has to get a smaller piece. They can't understand that governments do not, and can not, create wealth. Governments are net consumers, not producers. The best you can possibly achieve in such a system is a static model. One in which indeed, the pie is of a fixed size.

There also seems to be little understanding of the dynamics that immigration and how that effects the mean income and the "poverty line". They also have little understanding of how communal families work within the 'poverty zone'.

Ishmael

Unfortunately you have stated the obvious, that government has a place in our society, but not to the degree that some populists/liberals want!
 
I do think that CEOs are overpaid, but I agree that hey, if your willing to pay it, Ill take it. kind of reasoning on the CEOs part.
as to everyone being entitled to a working wage. it would be amazing what one could afford withouth the need to pay taxes induced by wellfare programs, and social outreach programs. that are funded primarily out of the poor-middle classes pocket. personally I think a nice flat 6% federal income tax with no tax breaks is the way to go.. no loopholes, no deductions.

of course some say that punishes the poor.. but how so? it punishes the rich actually, which the poor should be ALL in favor of. whens the last time you met a rich man that actually paid the kind of taxes he should? tax shelters are wonderful things. which means they don't pay their part, which means you the working class stiff has to make it up.
 
I like stock options; they defer taxes.

I like big fat salaries; they buy nice things anytime.

And bonuses.

And meetings in sunny warm places.

And nice company cars.

I dislike paying a lot of income tax.

No matter what they do, my accountant will compensate so I can be better compensated.

War is hell.

Business is fun.

Pick one.
 
Lancecastor said:
I like stock options; they defer taxes.

I like big fat salaries; they buy nice things anytime.

And bonuses.

And meetings in sunny warm places.

And nice company cars.

I dislike paying a lot of income tax.

No matter what they do, my accountant will compensate so I can be better compensated.

War is hell.

Business is fun.

Pick one.

Meetings suck no matter where you are.. sunny warm or not.... cause your stuck in a room with some poor bastard that has nothing else better to do than give a four hour presentation ginned up by marketing to make the brass feel better about the color they decided to make the new button on the widget. I pitty that poor bastard. unless of course he's from marketing.. then well, I hate taht bastard.
 
A secondary (and admittedly unrelated) issue is the fact that under the Securities Laws any additional perks to the CEO over 80K a year must be reported...so, the SEC will probably be getting in on the Welch action, if they haven't already.

As far as the tax law is concerned, three years ago while we were riding a crazy bull market, few would have complained about the speculative element of stock options to evade the tax system.

For as long as we are taxed, corporations and businesspeople will always find accountants and attorneys smart enough to find their ways through loopholes in the system. A speculative risk to avoid tax is better than nothing, I think.

But that's just my law 101 talking.
 
I dont much care for complex tax schemes

I studied math and engineering in college so the whole "Simple Is GOOD" was drilled into me early (yeah like it wasnt obvious I was a hard sciences guy instead of a lib arts guy from the get go)

but still any system as inefficient as our tax system needs to be seriously looked at.

Flat taxes baby.. thats the way to go... or no income tax and a federal sales tax that stacks on state sales tax. and capitol gains and death benefit taxes can both kiss my ass.
 
what's wrong with capitol gains? Why should money you've earned from a job, found on the street, won in the lottery, or been gifted with be treated any differently than money you've earned by selling appreciated assets.

A federal sales tax large enough to sustain a low flat tax or no income tax whatsoever would stifle consumer spending to a large degree.

Finally, the general consensus is that a low, flat (or dual-tiered) tax system is most efficient...the problem is, from a policy standpoint, why should someone making 20K be taxed at the same rate as someone making 1 million? Can't that person making 1 million afford a greater tax on some of that excess part? At some point the tax system is seeking to put some of the burden for the low-wage earners on the wealthy because they can afford it.

I'm all for simplicity, but I reiterate, so long as there are taxes, the wealthy will hire attorneys and accountants to avoid/defer them.
 
thats the point exactly, the rich arent handling more of a payment because of lawyers and accountants. so the tiered tax system we have now is flawed.

and why should someone who worked for their money from poor to rich, or hell even someone that inhereted it pay more than the poor?

I mean I make a dollar I pay 6 cents on it.. no matter how many dollars I make
 
I'd like to imagine that not all wealthy people get out of paying all their taxes. Still, there is some economic reasoning for taxing the wealthy at a higher tax rate...its really less skin off their backs. A mother trying to make it at 20K/yr with two kids to feed shouldn't have to pay taxes at the rate that a businessman with two lovers and a wife should pay. The maintenance on the lovers and the wife is clearly higher, but our tax system needs to ensure that the mother's two kids get fed (let's ignore welfare for this hypothetical). Throw into the mix a federal government with a lot of programs it wants to run, and the simple fact is, someone will have to bear the burden of paying for this war. Do we increase the taxes on the mother and keep a flat rate when she's scraping by and the businessman is deciding whether he needs to buy a Grey porsche to go with his favorite suit? Increase the taxes on the clothes/food/etc. that she needs to raise those kids by increasing the sales tax? Policy indicates that we should shift that burden to the rich businessman and his two lovers and a wife and to tax the excess he makes at a higher rate.
 
Diablogrl said:
what's wrong with capitol gains? Why should money you've earned from a job, found on the street, won in the lottery, or been gifted with be treated any differently than money you've earned by selling appreciated assets.

A federal sales tax large enough to sustain a low flat tax or no income tax whatsoever would stifle consumer spending to a large degree.

Finally, the general consensus is that a low, flat (or dual-tiered) tax system is most efficient...the problem is, from a policy standpoint, why should someone making 20K be taxed at the same rate as someone making 1 million? Can't that person making 1 million afford a greater tax on some of that excess part? At some point the tax system is seeking to put some of the burden for the low-wage earners on the wealthy because they can afford it.

I'm all for simplicity, but I reiterate, so long as there are taxes, the wealthy will hire attorneys and accountants to avoid/defer them.

I happen to favor a national sales tax.

I would expect that all of the necessities would be untaxed. Food, shelter, medicine, and reading material (there should me no tax on education).

The fact is that the wealthier you are, the more 'non-essentials' you will indulge in. Consequently it would be 'progressive' in that respect. Further, the working poor would not be taxed to any great degree. (I don't consider cable TV a non-essential.)

17% would be revenue neutral right now.

Yes, there would be a dip in spending at first. Although that is not altogether bad either. The people would have to put their money somewhere. A bank, or such. That means that more money would be avialable for loans etc. Further, this could be 'phased' in, or a three year lead period allowed for business and individuals to prepare.

The only people that would be against it are the tax preparers and the tax atty's.

To bad. We shouldn't need them anyway.

Ishmael
 
Fewer taxes.

Smaller government.

And just the missiles that Ishmael needs in order to have something to talk about.

:)
 
Lancecastor said:
Fewer taxes.

Smaller government.

And just the missiles that Ishmael needs in order to have something to talk about.

:)

OK, sounds good to me. :D

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:


OK, sounds good to me. :D

Ishmael

My perfect government
few taxes, few laws, death penalty used. 1 appeal, big military.

rape, child molestation and wife beating capitol crimes.

those are my issues
 
Aquila said:


rape, child molestation and wife beating capitol crimes.

Are you serious? I will give you that Rape and Pedophila are grave offense, but capitol offenses?

And Wife Beating? I think that wife beaters are despicable, but the death penalty?

C'mon....get serious.

The death penalty is out-dated. Just lock 'em up, throw away the key. Same ending, less headache.
 
Last edited:
Since most of Congress seems to have plenty of it's own businees concerns, I actually have to wonder if the results of this legislation were as unintended as they are being made out to be.
 
Back
Top