BDSM for Nice Guys

rosco rathbone

1. f3e5 2. g4??
Joined
Aug 30, 2002
Posts
42,431
An interesting internet article:

So you're a nice guy. (This page is written to address BDSM for nice guys; there's an introduction to BDSM for good girls on the Web here.)
You think that people should be treated with respect and courtesy' you find violence, particularly violence against women, reprehensible; you would never, under any circumstances, raise your hand in anger against someone you love. And now your partner is asking you to tie her up, or call her names, or spank her, or even "rape" her. All this goes against everything you believe. What do you do?

For starters, it's not what you think.

The first thing to do is to understand, deep down inside, that it's possible to do these things and still be a good person. While some of these things may superficially resemble abuse, there's an important difference; unlike an abuser, you are doing these things because you both enjoy them, and you're doing them in a way that is safe, consensual, and respectful of her limits and desires.

One way to think about it is that you're playing a role. A person who plays a villain on TV is not actually a villain; and if you and your partner play out roles for your mutual enjoyment, it doesn't mean you're being abusive. You and your partner can play out roles in which you are harsh and demanding and she is your sex slave, and this does not mean that you actually believe women should be subordinate to men.

But I was always taught to treat women with respect!

There is nothing wrong or disrespectful about treating people the way they want to be treated.

Even if the way they want to be treated is not what you're accustomed to.

Not everyone has the same desires, wants, or needs. Treating your partner with respect means treating your partner the way she wants to be treated--even if that means she wants you to treat her like a dirty little minx sometimes. Seriously--if your partner is approaching you with the idea of exploring BDSM, then most likely, there is some part of her which responds very strongly to filling that role.

There is not one "right" way to behave that applies to all people all the time. If something adds pleasure to your life and to your partner's life, then it's not a bad thing, even if it is unconventional. And there's certainly no crime in taking pleasure from bringing your partner pleasure!

There is no rule which says that nice guys can't be adventurous. No law says that nice guys never fuck their girlfriends in the ass or tell their girlfriends to strip and masturbate in front of them. It's about learning what you like, learning what she likes, and creating a scene that brings you both pleasure; being a nice guy means being willing to explore avenues that bring joy to your partner's life!

What kind of guy enjoys doing these things?

The kind of guy who enjoys exploring with his partner and pleasing his partner, of course!

More than that, though; by exploring your fantasies and your partner's fantasies, you create a deep intimacy that's hard to beat. This kind of exploration, and sharing of fantasies and sexual feelings, helps form a bond of intimacy and trust that's at once more romantic and more passionate than you may believe.

And the pleasure to be gained simply from seeing your partner eager to service you and submit to your desires shouldn't be discounted, either...

To do this, though, you may need to unlearn some things about what "nice guys" do and feel. "Nice guy syndrome" can sometimes prevent you from being able to really focus on your partner, and see what she wants; you may see social proconceptions of who "women are" or what "women want" instead. Women are individuals; focus on what the woman you're with wants rather than what "women want."

In extreme cases, "nice guy syndrome" can make you feel uncomfortable seeing your partner as a sexual being at all. But human beings are sexual beings, and it's hard to imagine anyone who doesn't want to be seen as sexually attractive by her mate; seeing your partner in a sexual light is not only healthy, it's an important part of any sexual relationship!

I don't even know where to begin with this stuff...

As with most things, you begin simply. Sex in general and BDSM in particular are learned skills; like all learned skills, you learn by doing. Start slow, learn what you and your partner like and don't like, and elaborate on the things you learn as you go along.

The best way to get started exploring BDSM is by talking to your partner. Discuss your fantasies and her fantasies; don't worry about whether or not those fantasies are things you would really explore or not, or even if they're things that are plausible or feasible. You're just talking about the things that turn you on, no matter how outlandish or how kinky they may be. Don't be timid, embarrassed, or ashamed, even of fantasies that seem extreme or frightening; these are fantasies, after all, not reality. Even extreme fantasies that you would never consider doing in real life can provide ideas or suggestions about places to explore, or things that turn you on!

Let's say, for example, that your partner has fantasies about being tied up and molested. You can start to explore by trying some light bondage or restraint; no need to go all-out, just start by holding her down or tying her arms with ordinary rope. If things go well, you may discover that you want to go farther next time, or you may come up with new ideas to try. And who knows? You may just find that it really turns you on...

At this point, it's probably worthwhile to discuss a few general guidelines as you start exploring this stuff. Some things to remember:

- Don't feel that you have to try everything all at once. Don't do too much, too fast. You have plenty of time! You're exploring what turns you on, what turns your partner on, and what you can create together; it's far better to end a scene thinking you could have gone farther than ending a scene thinking you've gone too far!

- Talk to your partner after you're done, espeically when you've tried something new. Spend some time talking about how you felt, how she felt, what turned you on, and what things you might want to explore later. Remember, whenever you try anything new, you will sometimes find things that you or your partner respond to in ways you didn't expect. You may even find that something you thought you'd like, or something she thought she'd like, triggers a negative reaction that you didn't anticipate. There's nothing wrong with that; you're exploring. By definition, when you explore, you don't always know what you'll find! If you discover something that you don't like, or that didn't go the way you expected, it's okay; you've learned from it, and now you have greater knowledge about how to please yourself and your partner.

- There's nothing wrong with taking pleasure from dominating your partner. If you find that you respond to taking charge in the bedroom, and your partner responds to being dominated, great! You're both happy; enjoy yourselves! Besides, it's much more fun to submit to a person who enjoys being dominant. It works both ways; you can take pleasure from pleasing your partner, and she can take pleasure from pleasing you.

- The greatest asset you have is a sense of self-confidence. It doesn't matter if you don't think you know what you're doing, or if things don't always go the way you wanted them to; it doesn't matter if you're uncertain about something you're trying. All this is normal. What does matter is that you project an air of confidence and control; just this alone can get you through a number of problems. You forget something? Something not working right? Smile and keep going anyway; chances are, she'll never even notice. Remember, you're playing a role; project confidence even if you don't feel it, and you'll do okay.

- Keep your eyes open and your common sense sharp. The best single safety tool you have is your common sense. Watch for problems; don't leave someone tied up unattended, don't try devices or gadgets on your partner if you don't have a sense of how they feel yourself.

But she wants me to spank her! I don't want to hurt her...

Ah, that's a bit tricky. Things are not always what they seem; there's a big difference between erotic pain and ordinary, garden-variety pain. The experience of pain in an erotic context, for someone who's wired that way, is nothing like what you may imagine; it's an incredible rush, that adds a powerful spice to sexual pleasure. Think of it like spice in chili; you might not like taking a bite out of a hot pepper, but in the right amount, it makes the chili a whole lot better...

Even things that look extreme, such as flogging or whipping, can be deceptive. These things don't feel like you imagine they do, and in the right environment with the right warmup, they're wonderful. And once your partner's endorphins, the natural painkilling chemicals produced in the brain, get going, it's the most intense, delightful high you can ever believe.

Of course, pain play is something you want to explore slowly. You don't jump right into it; ittakes time and practice to learn where your partner's limits are, and how your partner responds to things like spanking. But don't be so afraid of anything that looks painful--your partner is less fragile than you might think, and in the right setting, pain is both a powerful aphrodesiac and a tremendously pleasureable high. Pay attention, go slow, and you're not going to hurt her. As with many aspects of BDSM, pain is not always what it seems...

You can get a bit of my own perspective on pain play, if you'd like, here.

What if she wants me to call her names and humiliate her? That's not respectful!

Humiliation play, like pain play, is another of those things that's not what it looks like from the outside. In a sense, it's the emotional equivalent of pain play; and like pain play, it's all about context. In the right setting, under the right circumstance, with the right person, it can for some people be an intense, white-hot turn-on; and as with much of BDSM play, it's helpful to think about it as playing a role.

Remember, this is something you do because it's something your partner wants. You can, during a BDSM scene, call your partner a dirty, filthy whore, and it doesn't mean that's really how you see her; you're in a role, and you're doing it because it's a turn-on. Outside of that role, you may think your lover is the most exquisite woman ever to walk the face of the earth; the things you do during a scene are not the whole of how you see her in your ordinary, day-to-day life!

And there's nothing wrong with enjoying erotic humiliation, if your partner enjoys it. It doesn't make you a bad person; it doesn't mean you want to degrade women; it means you take pleasure in creating an environment that's arousing and exciting.

This kind of play may seem silly, or awkward, or both, when you first start experimenting with it. You may find it's difficult to say and do things which humiliate your partner, and it might feel forced or contrived. That's a normal part of playing any unfamiliar role. This sort of play, like any skill, becomes easier and more natural with practice.

Don't worry about it becoming something that changes the way you think about women in the real world; like pain play, humiliation play is contextual both for your partner and for you. It's not going to suddenly make you into an insensitive clod. The difference in mindset between exploring humiliation play with a lover and actually believing that women deserve to be degraded is as great as the difference between playing a hit man in a movie and actually being a hit man.

But I still don't know what to do!

Here are some ideas to start with:

- If you want to explore bondage, the easiest way to do this is with plain old cotton or nylon rope. Nylon stockings and silk scarves can cause problems, because they tend to bunch and be difficult to untie. You can tie your partner to the bed, to a chair, or simply bind her hands behind her back. Once you have her bound, you can go in a number of different directions. For example, you can kneel over her and tell her to service you with her mouth, or you can penetrate her and have sex with her. Or, you might try sensation play, running your hands or ice cubes or soft cloth or things like that over her body. Blindfolding her can make these sensations more intense. You can add a little bit of light pain play to the mix by pinching, pulling, or twisting her nipples, running your fingernails over her skin, and thinngs like that. Biting her, teasing her with tongue or fingers, and that sort of thing can be a lot of fun too.

- For introductory pain play, spanking, pinching, and biting can be good ways to begin. You might bend her over your lap, or--for a bit more fun--tie her down bent over the bed. You can combine this with roleplaying if you like; perhaps she's a naughty student and you're the disciplining teacher, for example. You can spank her with your hands, a paddle, or even a wooden spoon. Start with light, rapid strokes, and gradually increase the force until you find her limit. Remember, if you start light and build up gradually, you can get those endorphins going, which is exciting and intoxicating!

- Humiliation play can be verbal, or can involve things you do to her, or things you order her to do, or some combination of all three. For example, you can order her to kneel in front of you and give you oral sex while you tell her she's a filthy slut, or you can order her to call herself a slut or beg for sex while you tease her with your fingers and tongue, or you can kneel over her as she lies on her back and tell her to stroke you in her hands until you ejaculate over her body.

- Give her instructions to do things that excite or arouse you. For example, if you enjoy watching her masturbate (and who doesn't?), tell her to touch herself while you watch. You can be as detailed as you want, instructing her how and where to touch herself, and how hard, and how fast, and in what way; you may even enjoy instructing her to moan and sigh as she does. Or, take a different approach. Take her out to dinner, but give her detailed instructions about what she is to wear. Have her wear something that makes her easily accessible--a skirt with no panties, for example. Throughout dinner, keep her aroused by dropping hints about how you can't wait to get her home, and how she's so sexy that you're planning to have your way with her; then, when you get home, bend her over, hoist up her skirt, and take her!

- Surprise her. Mix things up. If you're exploring dominance and submission, try calling her at work one day and telling her to remove her panties, or go into the restroom and touch herself. Or, send her a text message on her phone telling her that you have plans for her and you're going to tie her up when she gets home. If she's at home when you're at work, send her an email with a list of things to do to arouse herself so that she's in the proper state of mind when you get home. If you've been talking about trying something new, create a scene where you're doing something you've done before, then add it in! Or, buy a new toy without telling her, and introduce it into your scene.

- If you run out of ideas, try doing things you've done before, but in a new way or with a new element, or combined with other things you've done. If you enjoy watching her masturbate, try adding a blindfold and telling her to touch herself. Or, make her touch herself as she watches herself in a mirror. Or make her describe how she feels out loud as she masturbates. If you enjoy having her give you oral sex, try tying her hands behind her back and then having her kneel in front of you. The possibilities for combining even simple, basic ideas in novel ways are endless; by doing this, you can keep things new and exciting all the time.

Remember: You're doing this to have fun, to share yourself and your fantasies with your partner, to make your sexual lives more exciting and dynamic, and to increase your pleasure and your partner's pleasure. There's no right or wrong way to do it. Have fun! Experiment! Be creative! And above all, enjoy yourselves!
 
THe title of this article is "Why? Why Would You Hurt Someone You Love?"

He never answers the question; except to say that it is "all about context". I suppose that that description following is supposed to be so erotic that all questions and ideas about context are rendered moot. I still consider the question unanswered, however.


"It's all about context. In the right context, with the right person, inflicting pain is deliciously erotic.
I generally start by laying the crop gently across her ass, just below the curve where her ass meets her legs, so that she knows where the first blow will land. I leave the crop there for a moment, pressing it against her skin, letting her imagine what it's going to feel like.

Sometimes, I'll start tap-tap-tapping her ass with it, in a gentle stacatto, to let the anticipation build and to start the blood rushing to her skin, sensitizing it. Other times, I'll just wait, without moving, until she relaxes.

Eventually, without warning, I'll lift the crop and bring it down very quickly, so fast that it whistles as it moves through the air. She will usually scream when the crop lands, arching her back and thrusting her hips upward against the crop as it lands. Her body tenses and quivers, and the first welt appears almost instantly. Sometimes, I'll pause for a minute, waiting for the stinging to pass and her body to relax before I bring the crop down again.

Other times, I'll place my hand on the small of her back, holding her against the bench as I keep the crop moving, nonstop, WHACK WHACK WHACK, each stroke leaving a bright red mark behind. When I do this, she will continue to scream, each stroke drawing a louder cry until they all blend together. At that point, I'll stop suddenly, and wait for the endorphins to hit.

It only takes a second. She will relax against the bench with a dreamy smile on her face, and then the laughter comes. She'll laugh uncontrollably, her face flush, totally unaware of everything around her.

After the first rush subsides, I'll start with the crop again, tapping her on the ass or the back of her legs, building the intensity very slowly. When she starts to moan under the crop, I'll bring it down hard again, leaving another welt. At this point, she'll usually start laughing instantly. I will keep the crop moving, striking her hard three or four times in quick succession, until she's screaming and laughing at the same time. I can keep her there for quite a while, floating in a place where the world is more or less a peripheral blur.

When I finally finish with the crop, I'll stroke her gently with a soft piece of fur, watching her quiver and moan and sigh. It takes a long time for her to come down; it's usually several minutes bfore she can even stand. She floats there dreamily for the longest time, grinning and totally high. And it's very, very exciting to take her to that place."



I dunno. Perhaps it is "erotic" because she seems to like it, in the end. "She might scream and cry; but you are giving her what she wants!".

And that's all well and good. It leaves out all mention of the selfish pleasures of sadism, however.
 
rosco rathbone said:
An interesting internet article:

So you're a nice guy. (This page is written to address BDSM for nice guys; there's an introduction to BDSM for good girls on the Web here.)

RR... You have NO idea just how timely your post is! http://freespace.virgin.net/xxx.99/s/naughty.gif

I was wondering how I was going to talk him into doing this. http://freespace.virgin.net/xxx.99/s/spank.gif

(there really should be a wicked evil grin on his face... not a mean look!)
 
Uncle Rosco you say it so much better than the article.

However refering to your final comment on sadism..

Are you saying that nice guys can be sadists?

If so Myst is missing out, and that makes you....nice??:confused:

I find it both slightly amusing and slightly disconserting that BDSM articles can ask the question and then ramble indefinatly without answering the question at all.

In fact it happens so often that the people who write these articles could be politicians (they rarely answer the exact question asked/stated either). Hmmm politicians who are into BDSM? Surely not lol

:rolleyes:
 
I didn't read the whole article, but...

I don't want to think of Sir as a "nice guy." Of course, I know that he's not an ax murderer and he cares about me. But even the idea of s&m with a "nice guy" who is only doing it to give me pleasure....shazam, any magic is gone just thinking about it that way.

-justina
 
Rosco, you did indeed write that out very well, a really good guide for baby Doms. I must, however, agree with Justina, if the WANT is missing & they are just doing it to please you it just doesn't work properly within a sub's head.
 
Dammit

I just found out I am a good girl. (Though, the wants and needs are mutual but the reasoning is very close, indeed). And all of this time I had been thinkin I was a baby thug in the making.
 
Myst said:
I don't play with nice guys or good girls.


But good girls are ALWAYS so much more fun to corrupt and degrade and reduce to whimpering begging subbish sluts (or sluttish subs)...
 
Re: Dammit

Luna_Wolf72 said:
I just found out I am a good girl. (Though, the wants and needs are mutual but the reasoning is very close, indeed). And all of this time I had been thinkin I was a baby thug in the making.

No baby, you're a good girl

(now go read my previous post ;) )
 
shy slave said:
Are you saying that nice guys can be sadists?

He might not be, but I certainly am!

I enjoy inflicting a certain amount of pain where I know the woman I am inflicting it upon is enjoying it. I'm a "nice guy" - I deliberately cause pain for just anyone, and when I do, it's under very controlled circumstances. But yes... I enjoy inflicting pain, and that makes me a sadist. Sort of.

...within limitations.
 
I like to think of myself as a generally humane and well socialized person.

That said, I really don't think I had this many conflicts about hauling off and spanking someone's booty. Once I'd decided to do it, whether I could look myself in the mirror again, didn't really enter into it. I knew I would only be spanking those I respected because, frankly those I don't are not worth that kind of attention.
 
Netzach said:
I knew I would only be spanking those I respected because, frankly those I don't are not worth that kind of attention.

Precisely. No way would I want to play with someone I had no respect for. Sheesh. Where's the thrill in having the submission of someone for whom I have no respect?
 
respect is over-rated. (likewise in the article*).

and how about bottoms who prefer where it's absent

---
*nice article, rr; the gentleman dom to a T.
 
Last edited:
Pure said:
respect is over-rated. (likewise in the article*).

and how about bottoms who prefer where it's absent

Run into one of those -- not surprisingly, I didn't work too well for her. It happens. It's all about compatibility.
 
Justina123 said:
I didn't read the whole article, but...

I don't want to think of Sir as a "nice guy." Of course, I know that he's not an ax murderer and he cares about me. But even the idea of s&m with a "nice guy" who is only doing it to give me pleasure....shazam, any magic is gone just thinking about it that way.

-justina

LOL, have to agree..had one like that many moons ago. Sort of took the thrill out of it to be asked to give step by step instructions throughout, then to have to justify why I saw some things as acceptable that he felt were far from healthy. Give me a sadist who knows what he wants, how to get it, and has no issues with whether it is right or proper. Contrary to some people's belief, though he is often called a gentleman or gentleman Dom, it does not impede Francisco's ability to inflict pain and take control in the most direct, brutal, and 'no nonsense' way. :)
This fallacy continues to thrive whereby a Dom equates someone who goes around abusing indiscriminately and irresponsibly, and has no social skills or manners....yuk, that is just a loser.

Catalina :rose:
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: Dammit

James G 5 said:
No baby, you're a good girl

(now go read my previous post ;) )

I read it (the previous post) and since I know your sado-skills run pretty deep I might be able to get into the whimpering thing (from pain...). However sluttish sub behaviour? Nope (though we could try for a weekend or 4)

:rose:
 
Respect is *all there is.* It's what makes me different from Elizabeth Bathory.

It is not overrated.

It is often misplaced.

When I meet someone like that, and there are not as many as online would have you think...when I meet someone like that I relish the latitude to do as I please and in NOT "respecting" them, but respecthing their kink, which others don't respect enough to fulfill....

how does that negate respect?



Pure said:
respect is over-rated. (likewise in the article*).

and how about bottoms who prefer where it's absent

---
*nice article, rr; the gentleman dom to a T.
 
Netz on respect: It's what makes me different from Elizabeth Bathory.

You mean there IS a difference????
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

OK,OK, by day,.... maybe....
 
rosco rathbone said:
It's about learning what you like, learning what she likes, and creating a scene that brings you both pleasure; being a nice guy means being willing to explore avenues that bring joy to your partner's life!

Remember: You're doing this to have fun, to share yourself and your fantasies with your partner, to make your sexual lives more exciting and dynamic, and to increase your pleasure and your partner's pleasure. There's no right or wrong way to do it. Have fun! Experiment! Be creative! And above all, enjoy yourselves!

I got a kick out of this.

In my world, at least, I don't want this crap. I don't want Mr. Nice Guy, as Justina and Cat said. Fuck that. I submit, and I am there to serve. That means that I am there for his pleasure, not for mine. It's all great and fine, if I get my groove on when he's beating my ass, or whatever he's doing to me, and believe me, I do *grin*; but the bottom line is, he is no service top.

If I ever even act like I might be thinking like I'm topping from the bottom, I'm snatched right back into reality. No Mr. Nice Guy--and I like it that way.

~anelize
 
I have been

told by subs that they were surprised that a "nice guy" could be so dominant when the door was shut to the room.

I suspect that other dominants hear the same thing.

When I take control of the sub the last thing she (or I) are thinking about is what a nice guy I am.:D
 
Lately I have been reading some very good postings from you RR, what has happened I have not been away that long have I?... and I also would like to know what SCUW stands for.;)

I happen to think that nice guys can be very good Dom/me’s, wanting to take care of the needs of your partner, having good manners and treating others with the respect they earn is just what should be part of any person in this world, and especially that of a Dominant. I know it is not a popular opinion that Dominants should be role models to their property and lead by example.

Being a nice guy in my book does not mean not having an assertive nature (yes I know a double negation) and it has nothing to do with being able to be or not to be a Dominant.

To answer the question asked in the article "Why? Why Would You Hurt Someone You Love?"

My answer to that question would be because I love her I hurt her, because I enjoy seeing her fling under my whip, because I enjoy the blood running down her back after I have cut her with my razor, and because I enjoy how she reacts when I push another ice cube up her butt.

Being a sadist does not mean you can not have manners, being a nice guy does not make you automatically a pushover, fulfilling the needs of your sub does not mean you are not a good Dominant, negating your own needs and not enjoying what you are doing makes you a bad Dominant. For both partners to fully enjoy each other there needs to be a feedback in the scenes played. A submissive finds much more pleasure when scening with a Dominant, Top, PYL, because there is feedback, because the sub can sense the pleasure of the Dominant and the same applies for the Dominant.

I am sure that most will agree with me that the best scenes they ever have had were those where all involved afterwards had their needs fulfilled and all parties involved had a good night.

Francisco.
 
Last edited:
Francisco, that's funny. I was thinking the same thing, but about Catalina's posts since you returned. Maybe we've all just learned a bit about life recently & also learned how to play nicely with friends.

You hit the nail on the head. A submissive finds pleasure in the feedback from a real Dom. That's what's missing when nice guy vanilla partners do the B & D physical stuff just to please their submissive partners.
 
Back
Top