Area 51

Okay, but I have problems with this in lots of fields. There are favorites that people have for certain reasons and rewriting them and losing all the original elements is disrespectful.

You can't do "Sweeney Todd" and hire people who are famous but can't sing to do the parts. It's disrespectful to those who love the original because of the acrobatics that good singers can pull off when performing Sondheim. Stuff Johnny Depp can't do.

I'm the first to say that Star Trek was goofy, campy fun, but it did make an attempt to be science fiction and not just fantasy.

Fantasy is "a wizard did it" which is what J. J. Abrams does. I'm also a fantasy fan and I don't expect to get explanations of magic. But that's why it's fantasy. There are those of us who know and love science the same way you could love Sondheim, and having someone who doesn't understand it make it "awesomer!" by evicting science from the equation...and strategy (which Kirk was awesome at, by the way) and philosophy (Spock) and romance (McCoy said what about his ex-wife, the Southern Gentleman?! What the fuck Karl Urban?!) is deserving of metaphorical disgust.

Yeah, I admit the alternate universe spin took some getting use to. I haven't seen "Into Darkness" yet and I seen every ST movie when they hit the theaters. Maybe only guys who've had a horrific divorce can relate to Karl Urban's McCoy role. Actually, I did see the new "Lone Ranger" instead when I went to see "Into Darkness". Tough choice, and Johnny Depp made it worth while....actually I'm not a Depp fan, but loved his Tonto.

Anyway, Area 51? Too heady for me today.
 
Yeah, I admit the alternate universe spin took some getting use to. I haven't seen "Into Darkness" yet and I seen every ST movie when they hit the theaters. Maybe only guys who've had a horrific divorce can relate to Karl Urban's McCoy role. Actually, I did see the new "Lone Ranger" instead when I went to see "Into Darkness". Tough choice, and Johnny Depp made it worth while....actually I'm not a Depp fan, but loved his Tonto.

Anyway, Area 51? Too heady for me today.

I saw the first and was livid, so I'm avoiding the second to make sure my head doesn't twist off my spine in offense. I heard enough of the criticism to feel good about that choice.

I love Karl Urban and Simon Pegg, solid guys both.
 
I like their 'UFO's were really just experimental planes', while almost half the released papers are blacked out!
The conspiracy-theory, tinfoil-hat brigade is going to go nuts!
:D

Why is it so out of the question that Earth was visited by UFO's? One crashed and we are studying it....its plausable, except for the fact, how in the world do you keep that a secret??
 
Just because no ones admitted to having the aliens does not mean they didn't crash.

They didn't want to admit that there was an Area 51 either.
 
Just because no ones admitted to having the aliens does not mean they didn't crash.

They didn't want to admit that there was an Area 51 either.

But with these blabber-mouths in the White House, writing books, leaking secrets to the press, how does that stay a secret?
 
I do think time travel would be more destructive than productive. The meddlesome humans would wish to stop tragic events such as the Holocaust, maybe even the crucifiction of Christ. But changing these events could have unforeseen backlash that could be catastrophic. While I hope we invent teleportation I hope time travel will stay impossible. I would be even happier if they first cured cancer. AIDS, war, famine, birth defects and men with small penises.

Go back in time to cure cancer? Like how far back?
 
Why is it so out of the question that Earth was visited by UFO's? One crashed and we are studying it....its plausable, except for the fact, how in the world do you keep that a secret??

It is possible, but not likely.
Any aliens smart enough to overcome distance and time would choose a place far more advanced than us to visit. If there are aliens at all, that is.

No - I don't believe that any crash-landed spaceship could have been kept secret.
Too many people with loose tongues.
And it's not like Area 51 was not known about.... it was. It just wasn't confirmed.
Now it is.
 
Biological life forms is just quantum entanglement on a much more massive scale.

Very delicate. As I'd stated earlier, we'd have to develop technology that could scan every particle we contain, it's trajectory, it's velocity, it's location, and store that data flawlessly and transfer that information somewhere else and put it together exactly as it was and where it was going.

Heisenberg's shakin' his head kinda.
 
Very delicate. As I'd stated earlier, we'd have to develop technology that could scan every particle we contain, it's trajectory, it's velocity, it's location, and store that data flawlessly and transfer that information somewhere else and put it together exactly as it was and where it was going.

Heisenberg's shakin' his head kinda.

They can't even transmit a phone signal or tv progaram without some kind of interuption.
I'm with you - transmitting life-forms is a long way off, if it's ever possible!
 
Very delicate. As I'd stated earlier, we'd have to develop technology that could scan every particle we contain, it's trajectory, it's velocity, it's location, and store that data flawlessly and transfer that information somewhere else and put it together exactly as it was and where it was going.

Heisenberg's shakin' his head kinda.

Given enough time and progress, it's an eventuality.
 
Given enough time and progress, it's an eventuality.

Given enough time and progress we'll come up with something different.

We'd probably much more likely isolate things like consciousness, record that and transmit that into a biological or mechanical "blank" on the other side.

I'm only talking about taking something with the complexity of your random human and copying it over long distances instantaneously being pretty much prohibitively complicated.

Other stuff's a better bet.
 
Given enough time and progress we'll come up with something different.

We'd probably much more likely isolate things like consciousness, record that and transmit that into a biological or mechanical "blank" on the other side.

I'm only talking about taking something with the complexity of your random human and copying it over long distances instantaneously being pretty much prohibitively complicated.

Other stuff's a better bet.


Knight Rider cars for everybody.
 
It is possible, but not likely.
Any aliens smart enough to overcome distance and time would choose a place far more advanced than us to visit. If there are aliens at all, that is.

No - I don't believe that any crash-landed spaceship could have been kept secret.
Too many people with loose tongues.
And it's not like Area 51 was not known about.... it was. It just wasn't confirmed.
Now it is.

Why would they choose more advanced civiliation? What if hey were just passing through? we have lots of natural resources, things they may need such as gold.
 
Why would they choose more advanced civiliation? What if hey were just passing through? we have lots of natural resources, things they may need such as gold.

And if they could come up with trans-galactic travel, they couldn't synthesize gold?
 
Why would they choose more advanced civiliation? What if hey were just passing through? we have lots of natural resources, things they may need such as gold.

That's speculation.
How do you know they need gold? They might not need anything from Earth.
Just because we use and need certain elements, doesn't mean they do.

I think it's incredibly narrow-minded to assume a) we actually know all the elements in the universe, and b) that any [possible] other life-form is in any way even remotely like us.
 
Back
Top