off2bed
Disambiguator
- Joined
- Apr 11, 2008
- Posts
- 16,104
America is not an idea-state like the Soviet Union. America is an ordinary nation-state like France, which has been through at least ten regime changes since 1789 yet still remains the same country. An America under a different constitution or even a completely different system of government would still be America.
I completely disagree. France is France because they have, for the most part, been one people, one culture. The US is made out of other cultures (like Frankenstein's monster
). If one of those "other cultures" becomes dominant enough to drastically change the Constitution, then we are no longer America.