About wannabes and broken subs – Hecate spilling her poison

Hecate

Lady Hecate will do
Joined
Mar 18, 2000
Posts
1,657
WARNING: Hecate rambling, stay clear if you have an own opinion! ;)

Let me say how wonderful I find this new little corner of Lit – and let me say how utterly amazed I am about the number of posts and hits in such a short time. It does show me that there is a huge interest in BDSM and related topics – or at least a basic curiosity as to what it is all about. GREAT! Really really wonderful and encouraging to see we can talk and maybe even are listened to as we try to take the prejudices and dust off our likes.
But … (oh didn’t you just wait for that “but”? ;)) … there have been a few posts scattered all over the place that made me feel like lifting some issues to an own thread.

As stated in the title – one of them is

wannabes

I have read the term wannabes on some thread of the board and I read it used in the sense of “newbie” (not much better, I know). Let me clarify my understanding of wannabe in the BDSM context and I think it is clear we are talking two pairs of shoes here !

A wannabe – as the word indicates is someone who “wants to be” but isn’t what he/she pretends to be (yet).

There are different levels of being a “wannabe” - one is that you are new to something, so in the sense of the word you “want to be” a part of a group, sport, lifestyle .. whatever it is you are starting to wet your toes with. But strange enough this is not the kind of person/situation I link to being a “wannabe”. Because that kind of person will be part of whatever it is he/she wants to be part of in no time when a genuine interest is shown. And poof – before you know it you are becoming a new but integrated part of the new group. You may be a newbie *chuckles* but nobody will tell you you are a wannabe.

Now we have those who do NOT have a genuine interest in learning, understanding and integrating into the group they are sticking their feet in. They will remain on such a superficial level that they never will get over the “wanting to be” – stage. Those people – and let me now slide from general approach to the BDSM scene – are what I can not really tolerate very well, specially on the internet, where it is hard to distinguish at first between a nice front put up to deceive and the reality behind it. Specially in the BDSM environment I find that not only to be devious but dangerous. Specially when those however aquired semi-truths and notions are passed on as “knowledge” and experience, when there is no real interest in delving into the depth of all the different facets and sides of BDSM.

There is damage that can be done – there are people involved and feelings to be hurt – doing that under the cover of BDSM I take as a personal attack to something that I hold in high esteem and dear to my heart. There is no excuse whatsoever to show abusive (and I mean no “play-abusive” but the serious kind) behavioral patterns under the cover of being a Dom/me. People that use BDSM as a cover for a quick and careless lay, additionally to the mental damage to a trusting sub, maybe even causing physical pain (and in this case I mean pain and not sensation), those are the “wannabes” I am talking about. People who are simply craving pain but do not really feel like letting anyone else be in charge, people who do pretend to be submissive just to find a caring Dominant to dedicate time to them and their sexual pleasure but in reality just seek a little “extra kick” to get over some kind of boredom for a while or because they think it is “in” to be into BDSM, never exploring their real motivations, needs and desires but passing that on to someone else, those are wannabes in my book.

There is nothing wrong with needing sensation for pleasure – even without submitting – but then say so! There is nothing wrong with experimenting on the sub side – but let the other party know it is for the time being just that – an experiment! Do not (and here we have one of the downsides of the internet) pretend to be something you are not, be it Dominant or submissive!

There is no fault in being new to something and saying so openly to get assistance and guidance if wanted – or simply inspiration if needed. Everyone was new to most things at some stage and if we had let others drive us away from those interests by feeling intimidated by those with more experience we never would learn. So please, everyone out there being new to BDSM – you are NOT a “wannabe” in my book! Not as long as you crave to learn and grow and not only scratch the surface of things to then run off and pretend to be a “Master of your trade” after only the slightest glimpse of things!

So let me say again – someone honestly trying to learn or at least inform themselves may be NEW but is not a “wannabe” (read: pretender)! You are a novice Dom/me or a novice sub, but by taking the step to learn and inform yourself you are past wannabe-stage already and as valid a “member of the club” as are any of us and I invite you all in to learn, explore and share the discoveries of your journey.

That said – and hey, you are still reading it seems … let me swap to the topic of


“breaking a sub”

In case you are reading this and don’t know me – I am a Domme (mostly anyway), and a bisexual one as well. (Talk about options here *winks*)

My submissive is more than my pet (oh yes, she is that too but ...) she is my lover and my friend. She is a most precious jewel that I wear in my “crown” - she sparkles and shines from deep within her, has that special glow that I adore about her. Why am I telling you all this?

Because the moment I would “break” her all that would be gone. There is no sparkle in a shattered and chipped diamond!

Breaking a sub – doesn’t it sound horrible (I can kinda hear the bones crack as I imagine a broken spine)?

Well, for some this is seemingly a challenge, one of the “greater aims” of domination. Sorry, but for me those people have just read a few too many fantasy novels about the subject it seems!

Let me take a detour and try to explain my understanding of breaking someone.

If you have managed to instill fear (physical or emotional) to such an extend into a person so that he/she will do whatever you tell them, without wondering if it is good for them, then someone is broken.

If you have managed to dissolve a feeling of “I am” in someone, so that this person can no longer define themselves and their position in the world without you telling them who they are and what they should do, then you have broken someone.

In my deep inner conviction we are always bound to the principle of safe, sane and consensual. Can breaking someone be consensual? We even might get into a discussion about that if you really stretch the limit of that word – but sane!? No fucking way!

BDSM is for me something to make each of the participants richer, stronger and more settled in who and what they are. If someone decides that they derive maximum pleasure from pleasing their Dom/me, fine – it is a gift gladly accepted. If they feel more secure in the knowledge there is someone they can lean on and someone they can orient their value system at – fine, as long as this is chosen by free will, just as I have seen it happen in non-BDSM relations too.

But if it results in a total loss of personal dignity (not during a limited scene, mind you – it can be thrilling in specific settings as a part of humiliation scening) and self-worth perspective even out of scene then I am having a serious case of breaking a spirit! Even more so if an experienced Dominant uses all the knowledge of physical and mental influence to push the submissive over that point.

If a Dom/me uses his/her powers to get a sub to exactly that point of self-neglect, making the sub a quivering wreck that only nurtures on the approval/disapproval of the Dominant then things are definitely being taken to far – way too far. Please All – realize that this is REAL, this is not some Gorean Fantasy book or the world of Sleeping Beauty! This is scarring/harming people for life in the worst of cases!

Again, if you don’t know me you may not jet have come across my rosebush-analogy. Never mind – it was written in my early days but still holds much of my conviction... in short: Consider a sub a rose bush and the Dom/me the gardener. A rose is a rose and will remain a rose. The gardener now tries to give it what it needs, water and warmth – and eventually something to hold on to, maybe he ties the rose into an intricate pattern so that it enhances the beauty of the blossoms and pleases him even more. But if the gardener tries too hard to make anything else from it but a rose or bends or cuts it down too much the rose will not bloom to the fullest, it even may die.
If you choose your sub why choose something you do not really want and try to forge it into something different?
If I want daisies instead of roses I can’t get anything but disappointed by the most splendid rose, and no matter what I do to it, it will never be what I seek. Will it be a daisy after I have broken the stem or ripped off the petals? NO!

We are not living in the dark barbaric times of ages past. Our “slaves” are so by free will – we need not force them into our service anymore. They are not seeking to get us killed for their own freedom, they do not refuse to serve us because they never had another choice and are rebelling.

We need not break spirits for our safety – and we should not break spirits for our “pleasure” – that is NOT BDSM, that is - to put it politely – disturbing!

We are in our times talking about a (mainly erotic based) relation of trust when we talk about dominance and submission. Our slaves/subs/lovers made a choice – a free, sane and consensual one, to be wearing our collar and chains in the first place. I for one intend to treasure that gift. I want my darling pet to grow, to develop – but not to change her personality, I love her for exactly that personality. I want her to fight me if she isn’t happy with what goes on – I do not want her to take all I dish out in a demure destructive way. BDSM is about fulfilling needs – of BOTH parties involved.

And even if we are not about love relations, don’t we choose our play partners for their personality, because they either complement us, or challenge us or whatever else we are seeking at the time? It is all about fun basically, about pleasure! And I simply enjoy it much more knowing there are the both of us having a good time (call me a Softie-Domme if you like). If my approach to BDSM is not for a particular sub then we shouldn’t be playing.


Well – if you made it till here I thank you for “listening” - you are now free to do with my opinion whatever you like (and be thankful I am running out of time right now since I could spill my poison on some topics for a long time). In case you wonder why I made a new thread of it - I simply couldn’t find one where to slip it in without it a) getting lost or b) disturbing the present dynamics of the thread.

And now to really piss you off all I said above in two sentences *weg* (you! – aren’t you a masochist subbie? Then stop complaining! ;))

a) “Welcome” to all who came to this corner to wet their toes on a subject they want to learn about – “watch your step” to all those who are seeking a “guide to abusive sexual behavior under the cover of BDSM”

b) BDSM is a delicate matter, physically and emotionally, and it has to be treated with respect and integrity if you want it to be a pleasant and fulfilling journey for all parties involved, following the rules of safe, sane and consensual
 
Thank you

I have read, and re-read, your post, Hecate. I've only relatively recently decided that being a Dom was right for me, so I still have some confidence and 'newbie' issues. Your words were expressed beautifully, so as to focus the scorn where it rightly belongs, on the pretenders and abusers, while encouraging those of us new to the lifestyle.

Between you and cymbidia, I have learned so very much, and I thank you both.
 
mmmm *soft rumbling purr*

i'm just here to bask...




This may seem like I am going off on my own tangent but.... did i mention i love holding hands? :D

Sk~
 
*running through the thread naked screaming* THIS NEW FORUM ROCKS!! THANX LAUREL & MANU!! :D

Halo :rose:
 
Hecate said:

wannabes

I have read the term wannabes on some thread of the board and I read it used in the sense of “newbie” (not much better, I know). Let me clarify my understanding of wannabe in the BDSM context and I think it is clear we are talking two pairs of shoes here !

A wannabe – as the word indicates is someone who “wants to be” but isn’t what he/she pretends to be (yet).

There are different levels of being a “wannabe” - one is that you are new to something, so in the sense of the word you “want to be” a part of a group, sport, lifestyle .. whatever it is you are starting to wet your toes with. But strange enough this is not the kind of person/situation I link to being a “wannabe”. Because that kind of person will be part of whatever it is he/she wants to be part of in no time when a genuine interest is shown. And poof – before you know it you are becoming a new but integrated part of the new group. You may be a newbie *chuckles* but nobody will tell you you are a wannabe.

Now we have those who do NOT have a genuine interest in learning, understanding and integrating into the group they are sticking their feet in. They will remain on such a superficial level that they never will get over the “wanting to be” – stage. Those people – and let me now slide from general approach to the BDSM scene – are what I can not really tolerate very well, specially on the internet, where it is hard to distinguish at first between a nice front put up to deceive and the reality behind it. Specially in the BDSM environment I find that not only to be devious but dangerous. Specially when those however aquired semi-truths and notions are passed on as “knowledge” and experience, when there is no real interest in delving into the depth of all the different facets and sides of BDSM.

There is damage that can be done – there are people involved and feelings to be hurt – doing that under the cover of BDSM I take as a personal attack to something that I hold in high esteem and dear to my heart. There is no excuse whatsoever to show abusive (and I mean no “play-abusive” but the serious kind) behavioral patterns under the cover of being a Dom/me. People that use BDSM as a cover for a quick and careless lay, additionally to the mental damage to a trusting sub, maybe even causing physical pain (and in this case I mean pain and not sensation), those are the “wannabes” I am talking about. People who are simply craving pain but do not really feel like letting anyone else be in charge, people who do pretend to be submissive just to find a caring Dominant to dedicate time to them and their sexual pleasure but in reality just seek a little “extra kick” to get over some kind of boredom for a while or because they think it is “in” to be into BDSM, never exploring their real motivations, needs and desires but passing that on to someone else, those are wannabes in my book.

There is nothing wrong with needing sensation for pleasure – even without submitting – but then say so! There is nothing wrong with experimenting on the sub side – but let the other party know it is for the time being just that – an experiment! Do not (and here we have one of the downsides of the internet) pretend to be something you are not, be it Dominant or submissive!

There is no fault in being new to something and saying so openly to get assistance and guidance if wanted – or simply inspiration if needed. Everyone was new to most things at some stage and if we had let others drive us away from those interests by feeling intimidated by those with more experience we never would learn. So please, everyone out there being new to BDSM – you are NOT a “wannabe” in my book! Not as long as you crave to learn and grow and not only scratch the surface of things to then run off and pretend to be a “Master of your trade” after only the slightest glimpse of things!

So let me say again – someone honestly trying to learn or at least inform themselves may be NEW but is not a “wannabe” (read: pretender)! You are a novice Dom/me or a novice sub, but by taking the step to learn and inform yourself you are past wannabe-stage already and as valid a “member of the club” as are any of us and I invite you all in to learn, explore and share the discoveries of your journey.


b) BDSM is a delicate matter, physically and emotionally, and it has to be treated with respect and integrity if you want it to be a pleasant and fulfilling journey for all parties involved, following the rules of safe, sane and consensual
Hecate, I would like to thank you for your well-written and thoughtful thread. I consider myself somewhat of a "newbie" in the BDSM lifestyle, but the problem is that I am so new an inexperenced in it that I'm not sure how much into it I am. Does that make sense?
While I understand what you're saying about the difference between a newbie and a wannabe, I can also see how someone might start out being curious about the lifestyle, learning about it, trying it, and then deciding that it really isn't for them. Does taht make them a wannabe? Is that harmful to others in the lifestyle? I don't think so.

Now, my question is: how much do you have to be into the idea of BDSM in order to be considered a true "BDSMer"? I'm so confused right now in this matter, because while I know that I could never be in a relationship where it's just "conventional" sex all of the time, I don't think that I would be able to be someone else's 24/7 slave (I consider myself submissive- well, most of the time...). I'm not into the more extreme forms of D/s, but I do get extremely turned on by other forms- almost craving them. Does the fact that I may not be as into certain aspects of BDSM as others make a "wannabe" more than a "newbie"? (Also keep in mind that since I haven't ever had my limits tested, I don't even know if I'm into the more extreme froms of BDSM play).

I know that there is a lot of information on this in the monster BDSM thread, but it's way too long for me to sift through.
 
Wonderful thread. Very thoughtful and informative. Thank you for taking the time to help educate and enlighten us.:D
 
Re: Re: About wannabes and broken subs – Hecate spilling her poison

lilminx said:

Hecate, I would like to thank you for your well-written and thoughtful thread. I consider myself somewhat of a "newbie" in the BDSM lifestyle, but the problem is that I am so new an inexperenced in it that I'm not sure how much into it I am. Does that make sense?
While I understand what you're saying about the difference between a newbie and a wannabe, I can also see how someone might start out being curious about the lifestyle, learning about it, trying it, and then deciding that it really isn't for them. Does taht make them a wannabe? Is that harmful to others in the lifestyle? I don't think so.

Now, my question is: how much do you have to be into the idea of BDSM in order to be considered a true "BDSMer"? I'm so confused right now in this matter, because while I know that I could never be in a relationship where it's just "conventional" sex all of the time, I don't think that I would be able to be someone else's 24/7 slave (I consider myself submissive- well, most of the time...). I'm not into the more extreme forms of D/s, but I do get extremely turned on by other forms- almost craving them. Does the fact that I may not be as into certain aspects of BDSM as others make a "wannabe" more than a "newbie"? (Also keep in mind that since I haven't ever had my limits tested, I don't even know if I'm into the more extreme froms of BDSM play).

I know that there is a lot of information on this in the monster BDSM thread, but it's way too long for me to sift through.

lilminx...

I would encourage to read the links posted here... and try not to concern yourself overly much with labels... I know that as a relative "newbie" it can be overwhelming...

I spent 20 years in relationships that encompassed parts of BDSM, without a Dom... and the last 6 months in a relationship with a Dom... so you see my experiences are limited...

My relationship today is constantly evolving, changing, as we grow to know each other more, as our needs become more defined, as the trust between us develops and grows... and as I personally discover what my needs are... and they are not the same today, as they were a year ago or even 6 months ago...

And I tend to think that there are no hard rules here about the form a relationship is to take... If you look at the people here who are in relationships, every one of those relationships is different...

My relationship with Himself, would never suit cymbidia and what she needs from a Dom/me...

By the same token, Ebonyfire, would never do for me....

And while I can see myself in the role of a switch, I cannot see Himself in the role of a sub...

All of us are different... I don't think that can be said enough... Yet even in our differences, we share commons needs as well...

Take what you need... don't worry about being new... you too will find your place...
 
A respectful bow to Hecate

Madam to use an old expression...........You are both a scholar and a lady.

Your post was truthful and well thought out. I hope all (both old and new to the practice) read your post and heed it.
 
Right F'ing On, hecate! :D


Oh..and welcome to the Forum here SK...you're definitely welcome here. ;)
 
Hecate, this was extreemly well thought out and an interesting perspective. I am glad you premised it as being your opinion. If this is poison I will die at your feet feeding upon it. Thanks for sharing.

Abuse troubles me in any relationship and for someone to hide behind the mask of a BDSM relationship to cause mental or physical harm is indeed disturbing.

Lilminx, I wish to reinforce what cellis shared. You will find a buffet of info here that you can use to help shape and define yourself. The main thing being self identification. If you don't need a lable, don't worry with it. Enjoy the delightful journey of self and of your relationship.

We are all in this together learning and growing. Such is life.
 
i think i would like to say a little about the idea of being "broken" as a sub.

i do not sub because i feel i am inferior to my partner. it's not a comment on my low self esteem that i'm willing to give up control. like cym, i see my submission as a gift and i need it to be taken as that.

i have been broken. it's difficult to think about taking someone so maliable and willing to bend and breaking them. think about it this way: if you are patient and careful you can get a piece of wood to contort in ways you never thought possible without damaging it. if you snap it in two, it will never be whole again.

i want a Dom/me who will push my limits, but i would rather be celebant for the rest of my life than be broken like that again. when you give your whole self to a person and they treat it badly, it is a very long and difficult task to get it all back.
 
seXieleXie said:
i want a Dom/me who will push my limits, but i would rather be celebant for the rest of my life than be broken like that again. when you give your whole self to a person and they treat it badly, it is a very long and difficult task to get it all back.
I've never been broken, used like an unwanted, valueless toy and then discarded as the other moved on with their life.

Not like that, no.

But we've all been badly used somewhere along the way, haven't we? Many of you know that things went bad for me, very bad, at the end of my time with my last Dominant. He violated my trust and faith in his honesty and goodness. He displayed a callousness toward me that shocked and hurt me, that cut to the core of who i was as a submissive of worth and value.

Many years ago, before i knew how to say, "Stop! This is bad! I don't want you to do that to me!" i was terribly hurt, broken in many ways, by someone who caned me viciously and without any care at all for my well-being.

My point here is that submissives give of that which makes human. We give our bodies, yes, but we give our souls, too, the deepest and best parts of who we are as humans and as people. We give our love and trust and compassion and fantasies and need. We give all we can give, and then we give more, and end up totally open and naked to our Dominants.

If a Dominant abuses that utter openness, even just a little, it rebverberates through our lives like the tolling of a great bell for a long long time afterwards.

Breaking a sub is a bad thing.
Hurting us through callous disregard is almost as bad.

If we owe you our loyalty and honesty, so do you owe us the same. We break easily because we are so open. Be careful with us, please.
 
Last edited:
thank you hecate for some very wise words -
it is difficult sometime to judge our own levels of knowledge - I would hate to think that any advice I had given had been the cause of anyone ever suffering pain and distress and I am sure most of us feel the same way. Also if I am wrong I admit it and I don't pretend to be always right.

I was once given advice from someone on the topic of anal play (not here i am thankful to say) - i was very new to this and was asking if it was normal for it to hurt - they answered that yes it was and I should just let my partner slam it in and whatever pain i felt would go as soon as he was all the way in!!! needless to say i though there was something a bit odd in this advice and so i posted back saying - yes but it really worries me and i don't see how an erect penis or large dildo is gonna fit up my ass. I was told to stop worrying and go for it!!
I didn't and checked elsewhere - but that kind of advice from someone masquerading as a fully experienced all knowing dom is dangerous.

In less dangerous terms it can be very disappointing to chat to someone online who states they are a dom and then realise that really means they only want a quick cyber fuck and don't want to have to be concerned with their partners feelings or thoughts - and they think 'playing' at being a dom is the way to do it.

re breaking subs, anytime i hear this all i can think of is that scene in The Crow when the evil brother and sister are lying on the bed with another girl and he says - i think we broke her (she is dead)
 
WOW! I didn't really expect any replies at all to my rant - talk about nice surprises :)
 
A rant that is well worth reading, pondering, reading again and digesting, one word at a time.


Thank you, Hecate.



lilminx: It is a confusing time and should you wish to share with me or just throw ideas around, you know where I am.

A "true BDSMer?" ....should not be your concern. Being true to yourself is the only truth you seek.

*hugs* minx.
 
Thank you Cellis, Unregistered, and MT for your replies. MT, I might take you up on your offer and PM you soon. I have a lot of considering to do about what I want and need.


Sorry, Hecate, for semi-hijacking your thread. I probably should have posted this my questions in a separate thread, but your words brought many questions to tghe front of my mind that have been simmering for a while. I hope you're not upset with me.
 
lilminx

we are here for each other... feel free to pm me any time...
 
Hecate's rambling is wisdom

I am a Dom that has been in the lifestyle a day or two <smile>

I have never read these issues handle so well and with so much wisdom before

Thank you

Richard
ask@gtii.com
 
A Vanilla question

Ok, so I'm not vanilla, more like butter pecan but I'm not a Dom nor a sub and I don't play one on the internet.

But I AM very facinated by the lifestyle. I read about it as much as I can. I write about it (poorly) sometimes. I think about it a lot. And I am learning a lot about it here at Lit and other places.

Does this make me a wannabe? Keep in mind, I have never billed myself as a Dom or a sub to try to take advantage of someone. I wouldn't do that. I did experiment being a sub once, but just really didn't get into it. I was honest with the wonderful Domme before, during and after the experiance and we parted ways as friends.

BTW: If it is a major faux pas (edited to remove an obvious proof of my own redneckedness) for me to post here, let me know and it won't happen again.

Ray
 
Last edited:
No, Ray.

You have committed no faux pas by posting.

An no, one could not say anything negative about relationships and interaction that are based upon honesty, as you described with the Domme.

The lifestyle is interesting and many more research and read than actually participate, of course.

You were right on the money when you said

I have never billed myself as a Dom or a sub to try to take advantage of someone

You are just fine! :)

Welcome to the forum. :)
 
Hi Ray.
:rose:


Hey guys? Ray isn't as unfamiliar with all this as he seems, nor is he a stranger to our way of viewing things. Ray and i are old friends, as a matter of fact, and have talked about BDSM type stuff quite a bit in the past.

What Ray is, however, is unassuming and naturally uninclined to push himself to the forefront for any limelight hogging. He's also one of Lit's pre-eminent authors, with a story list here that's longer than your arm.

Do you remember me talking about the story Hecate wrote as a response to that essay i read last spring, the one called Dominant Space? (http://members.aol.com/MasterNik/DomSpace.html)

Well, there were two stories written and posted to Lit as a result of the essay, and Ray wrote the other one. It's a marvelous story but never got anywhere near the votes Ray is used to because, well, because it's disturbing to people who come here to find something to which they can whack off.

Anyway, here's a link to Ray's story on that same subject. I think you'll agree with me that he's got a pretty good handle on how we think and why we do the things we do when you read this story.
http://www.literotica.com/stories/showstory.php?id=13628



So hi, my friend, and welcome here.
Post away.
We don't discriminate on the basis of whether or not you like a little cuff action with your loving.
:cool:
b.
 
cym,

Aw, now ya made me blush! Thanks for the kind words and the link to my story :)

Ray
 
Thank you for this informative thread. I am so grateful to find the BDSM forum!

I am so newbie, my toes aren't even wet, yet. Except in fantasy.

I don't know if this is appropriate here or not (if not please let me know), but I used to work for a rape crisis center. The work we did there dealt with sexual abuse of all forms. I think that many people wouldn't consider turning to this resource that are in the BDSM lifestyle, but the group I worked with was amazing and we offered anonymous support to any situation, including helping those that asked to sort out what may and may not have been consentual in a role playing or scenario (I don't know if I'm using the right words, here). Anyway, just thought I'd throw that out there, I'd be happy to give anyone the referral.

Again, thank you, I'm reading a little each day and learning so much!
 
Back
Top