A Mandate

The Republicans oppose a government mandate to the individual requiring the purchase of health insurance. I oppose that as well, but this thread isn't about health care policy (which is a simple matter of opening Medicare to all and means testing the premiums to be paid (but I digress)).

BUT - today I heard Newt talking about letting We the People put part of our Social Security payments into a private account that we could manage ourselves.

NOW THEREFORE - wouldn't that be an individual mandate to purchase a retirement plan?


Post exceeding 100 words will be deleted.
Cut and Pastes will be deleted.

so?

Vote for teh black guy:cool:
 
They aren't taking anything away from SS. They are investing the trust fund in government securities - just like you would do with a portion of your private plan (if you were smart).


ETA - it's not YOUR money. There is no government account with your name on it. It's a pay as you go system where current workers support the current needs of the program.

Even if the options for making social secrity payments into a retirement account were (are) limited to government securities, I'd still rather do that then pay into social security. (And thanks, I do, and I diversify.)

I'm well aware of how the system works. I also have no confidence that the program will be in place when/if I'm in a position to benefit from it. I anticipate that by the time I'm nearing retirement age (or become disabled, etc) there will be no more social security. In short, it may not be "my money" but I've sure as hell made payments to the system since I was 16...and I believe I'll never benefit from it.
 
Even if the options for making social secrity payments into a retirement account were (are) limited to government securities, I'd still rather do that then pay into social security. (And thanks, I do, and I diversify.)

I'm well aware of how the system works. I also have no confidence that the program will be in place when/if I'm in a position to benefit from it. I anticipate that by the time I'm nearing retirement age (or become disabled, etc) there will be no more social security. In short, it may not be "my money" but I've sure as hell made payments to the system since I was 16...and I believe I'll never benefit from it.

If you become disabled (god forbid) tomorrow, you will be in a position to benefit from it. SS is a social insurance program, not a retirement plan.
 
BUT Social Security is not a retirement plan. In fact, half of those receiving it are under the minimum retirement age. They are the disabled and survivors.

So and therefore, Newt would mandate a retirement plan.

My understanding is that it would be optional and not a mandate, though I - admittedly - could be mistaken.

Good point about the percentage who still receive it under minimum retirement age; I would assume that's why he's suggested a "portion" and not a "one or the other" deal.

He's not going to get elected anyway.
 
If you become disabled (god forbid) tomorrow, you will be in a position to benefit from it. SS is a social insurance program, not a retirement plan.

I'm aware of this. I think that for many - the majority of Americans - SS is a necessary system that must be in place. I'm not suggesting that it should cease to exist (though I think it will eventually become bankrupt). I'm also not suggesting that workers (myself included) should stop funding the program; I do support moving a portion of the money I pay into a more secure (different) program.
 
Back
Top