❌Monthly Song Challenge: Archived🎵

Day 25

There are no points to be had. I know that. But I still want to support your lovely ideas @morelikeasong , because you're awesome, and this thread is awesome ❤️

I’m pretty sure she cancelled the point game because my amazing post just broke the point system and no one but Moses would be able to catch up.

Or it could’ve been because that one guy was a big ol’ dickhead. But it’s probably the point thing.
 
Operator by Jim Croce


This song was the first time I ever understood that songs could use words that weren’t literal. I remember being like 7 years old listening to this song on my father’s tape deck and I heard the line “there’s something in my eye”. I thought, “Hey… there’s not really something in his eye. He’s crying!” And my mind was blown.

Jim Croce definitely had some of the most amazing songwriting ever. It’s sad he was taken too soon and really didn’t get to enjoy his success.
 
Oh damn, what a fantastic song!
Great... now I've got to go get 'Station to Station' and listen to the whole thing...
I'll never get to bed at this rate (lol). Thank you for the excellent song choice!
One of my all time favorite albums... sorry to keep you up!
 
Operator by Jim Croce


This song was the first time I ever understood that songs could use words that weren’t literal. I remember being like 7 years old listening to this song on my father’s tape deck and I heard the line “there’s something in my eye”. I thought, “Hey… there’s not really something in his eye. He’s crying!” And my mind was blown.

Jim Croce definitely had some of the most amazing songwriting ever. It’s sad he was taken too soon and really didn’t get to enjoy his success.
I grew up, almost literally, listening to Jim Croce. My mother's favorite album was his Greatest Hits (and it tells you a lot about him as an artist that after two albums you end up with a Greatest Hits that is full of amazing music). And I loved this, but like you said, didn't really get it until later. But after you "take the blow," oh, fuck, does this song hit hard.

"But that's not the way it feels." This song is pure life. Just that. And there isn't a higher compliment I can give than that.
 
Day 25: A song from the 70s

No points, but I want to keep the loving spirit of this week by choosing another Jewish duo -- the duo. I am not Jewish, but I had a friend while living in NYC who told me if I wanted to understand what it felt like to be Jewish in New York to listen to this song. It is quiet, and understated, but talks about alienation and belonging all at once. Of longing, but a celebration of hope. Love for identity, and a city that embraced that in its own way. It is a love song. I don't know if I ever understood it as well as she wanted me too, but I love it (and her) all the same.

"The Only Living Boy in New York," Simon and Garfunkel.

 
Please, no further responses to this

I just want to make it clear that I have spoken to and forgiven @The_spirit_of_oz . He’s a good person and I do believe his heart was in the right place (although his words were not). The following is not directed at him and I’d like the conversation about what happened last night to end here.

It’s tricky to navigate being Jewish on the internet right now. There are a lot of misunderstandings and false equivalencies being perpetuated in social media spaces.
I don’t want to get too far into the details. This isn’t the space for that.
Just know that Israel’s actions don’t speak for Jewish values or the opinions/beliefs of the Jewish people as a whole. I imagine many of you are familiar with the government of your own country not representing your beliefs and often doing things in direct contrast to that. Now imagine people assuming that a country across the globe that you aren’t a citizen of somehow accurately represents your views and holding you responsible for them.

Going to leave it at that and I’ll ask that you do, too. Let’s keep this thread about the love of music. 💛 thanks everyone
 
Day 25 - Song from the 70’s


This was Billy Joel’s first single…

It has since become Billy's signature song, and is based on his time playing piano at the Executive Room bar in Los Angeles, and all the familiar faces he saw there, except he was calling himself Bill Martin at the time.
 
Back
Top