Disaster capitalism in areas affected by calamities

hashtag45

badass 2nd rate Litizen
Joined
May 9, 2015
Posts
9,307
‘Disaster capitalism’: Why Haitians prefer local NGOs over American Red Cross
https://www.rt.com/news/362561-red-cross-haiti-money/

In a report, ProPublica revealed that the American Red Cross basically raised half a billion dollars to aid Haiti after it was devastated by a monster 7.0 earthquake in 2010. It had only built six houses out of the promised 700 by 2013.

Meanwhile, the US Red Cross said in a statement on its website that it deployed its teams to the affected areas in Haiti and is now “distributing a first round of life-saving relief supplies, including hygiene (cooking) kits, and cholera-prevention kits.”
It also claimed that it “is playing a key coordination role with local authorities and international humanitarian organizations to ensure life-saving support and supplies reach all those in need as soon as possible.”

"I think the American Red Cross is a good example of disaster capitalism,”X said, using the expression that was coined in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks.

“American Red Cross specifically does not have the capacity to do large-scale disaster relief and reconstruction correctly, but continues to collect resources and money to do so.”
The money "balloons” into huge packages full of benefits and privileges for the underprepared NGO staff – people who often don’t even have the language skills to connect with the locals.
Indeed, the 2015 report points to a trend of not hiring enough locals. More money went into paying high international salaries for arriving staff.

“Even before this disaster hit, what we Haitians wanted to do was take back the disaster-capitalist narrative, which always paints Haiti as waiting for a handout, waiting for the West to save us, and that’s not at all the case,” X told RT, adding that there are powers – the government among them – just waiting to “mobilize before the disaster hit, and will be there long after the cameras leave.”
 
Read the thread title which pretty much synthesises my opinion, Rob.
 
1.It is amazing what people will capitalize on, amazingly disgusting.
2.I like your av, hashtag. :)

1. I know...
This sort of scenario isn't exactly news, but American Red Cross! I was shocked to see that name.

2.You're kind, thanks. :)
Initially, I started uploading selfies in order to set limits on certain comments (people might fear appearing foolish in front of their friends if seen to throw "third world stinky paki rapist" slurs or inuendoes re anal sex at someone who's obviously female).
But tbh, I'm starting to enjoy this sort of exhibitionism. I guess the GB is starting to rub on me too. ;)
 
The US Red Cross is corrupt to the core.

Fraud is America's business model. The NGOs are no different.

Billy and Hilly Clinton made a lot of money from Haiti's disasters.

That's capitalism. The many suffer for the profit motives of the few.
 
Around Hooterville donations pay huge salaries and benefits to charity executives. Charities are rackets.
 
That's capitalism. The many suffer for the profit motives of the few.

Bullshit.

The many suffer because natural disaster, the suffering hasn't got a fucking thing to do with capitalism and will happen with or without it.

Capitalism is making a profit off of it.

Which may or may not be scummy depending on the capitalist involved.

Did the price gouge them and hose them when the check clears? That's scummy.

Did they give them the best price they could and deliver top notch service? Nothing wrong with that.

Capitalism, just like Socialism, religion and the liberal pant soaking AK-47 are not inherently evil.

The PEOPLE in control of those things determine if they are good or bad.
 
Last edited:
As I learned it, capitalism is the economic system where producers and buyers decide whats made and sold.

With socialism the government makes ObamaCare and you gotta buy it or else.
 
‘Disaster capitalism’: Why Haitians prefer local NGOs over American Red Cross
https://www.rt.com/news/362561-red-cross-haiti-money/

In a report, ProPublica revealed that the American Red Cross basically raised half a billion dollars to aid Haiti after it was devastated by a monster 7.0 earthquake in 2010. It had only built six houses out of the promised 700 by 2013.

Meanwhile, the US Red Cross said in a statement on its website that it deployed its teams to the affected areas in Haiti and is now “distributing a first round of life-saving relief supplies, including hygiene (cooking) kits, and cholera-prevention kits.”
It also claimed that it “is playing a key coordination role with local authorities and international humanitarian organizations to ensure life-saving support and supplies reach all those in need as soon as possible.”

"I think the American Red Cross is a good example of disaster capitalism,”X said, using the expression that was coined in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks.

“American Red Cross specifically does not have the capacity to do large-scale disaster relief and reconstruction correctly, but continues to collect resources and money to do so.”
The money "balloons” into huge packages full of benefits and privileges for the underprepared NGO staff – people who often don’t even have the language skills to connect with the locals.
Indeed, the 2015 report points to a trend of not hiring enough locals. More money went into paying high international salaries for arriving staff.

“Even before this disaster hit, what we Haitians wanted to do was take back the disaster-capitalist narrative, which always paints Haiti as waiting for a handout, waiting for the West to save us, and that’s not at all the case,” X told RT, adding that there are powers – the government among them – just waiting to “mobilize before the disaster hit, and will be there long after the cameras leave.”

Think Clinton Foundation, gold mines, hotels and Hillary's family...

;) ;)
 
PS - Disaster Capitalism is a political phrase having nothing to do with the study of economics or charitable organizations.
 
PS - Disaster Capitalism is a political phrase having nothing to do with the study of economics or charitable organizations.

You know me. I'm a dilettante in such matters and I like a good conspiracy theory too.

I thought that the term "disaster capitalism" had similar connotations to Naomi Klein's 'The shock doctrine'. Meaning that corporations or certain govts. take advantage of naturally occurring disasters in order to advance their neoliberal agendas. (Ie the New Orleans flood/hurricand Katrina). Or they even manufacture such disasters (the wars in the Middle East).

But this seems to be different than that. I'm not reading some nefarious conspiratorial agenda or racketeering with these organizations. Just incompetence or corruption at a lower level, within their ranks.
 
...

But this seems to be different than that. I'm not reading some nefarious conspiratorial agenda or racketeering with these organizations. Just incompetence or corruption at a lower level, within their ranks.

Do you think that government follows a similar arc as it grows?

;) ;)

Read the link in my Medieval America thread.
 
The UN's charitable relief agencies are even more incompetent and inefficient than the US Red Cross.

Medicins Sans Frontieres (Doctors without Borders) are much more effective at providing help on the ground.
 
Back
Top