Sister tries to "save" bi-brother and his boyfriend

[Strangebuddy]

Note: before reading further do know that the idea below is meant to be a light hearted, if not comedic, story. No kidnapping, no conversion camps, no nonconsent or torture.

Guy came out as bi in high school. While his dad was pretty accepting and his mom, while clearly uncomfortable with the revelation tolerated it at first and has come to accept his identity as he reaches adulthood. While he didn't have it easy in high school after coming out, he did manage to do okay and has a boyfriend (who is also bi). While he and his boyfriend hang out during the summer, getting ready to go to college, his sister comes home from college.

Sis and our lead used to be inseparable and got along even into their early teens. After brother came out though, sister has distanced herself from him and even said some rather horrible things about him to his face and behind his back. See, sis has always been a big church goer while her family stepped away after the new pastor started devoting more time to bigoted sermons.

...naturally, brother is not happy about seeing her again.

To his surprise though, his sister is actually
Very loving when she comes home and actively seeks his forgiveness. She claims that the campus church taught her a lot and that she still doesn't like him being bisexual, she loves him and wants get back their old bond.

Brother's overjoyed, though weird things do start to happen. Sometimes he comes back to his computer to find it on after he thought he had shut it down. His sister also seems to be interested in his sex life and seems to find it very interesting when he admits he's still technically a virgin (he leaves out the oral sex).

It all comes to a head when his boyfriend calls him and claims that his sister tried to seduce him when he was dropping some stuff off. Brother comes home to find sister nervously sitting on his bed, dressed up like one of his favorite fetish models. She tells him that she does honestly feel bad about how she treated him in the past and she doesn't mind him going out with his boyfriend but it's a sin for him and his boyfriend to have sex with each other so she figures she'll seduce them so they "get back" their taste for women and don't sin.

Brother is disturbed by this but then he thinks about it, talks to his boyfriend and then...

 

[LairOfTheCougar]

Interesting.

Are brother and boyfriend exclusive with each other, or do they bring girls into the mix? How much experience with women do they have?

Does sister intend to nail her brother, and if so how is that less of a "sin" than fucking his boyfriend? Or is the saving ploy simply a ruse for sister to get into brother's pants and her earlier behavior had more to do with jealousy than anything else?

 

[LairOfTheCougar]

Not to derail the thread or anything, but this has given me an idea for a perhaps more perverse variation on this.

The Cougar Crusaders
A group of older, horny ladies take it upon themselves to cure strapping young gay guys of their unfortunate tendencies with loads of hot sex.
It could be as lighthearted or as dark as one pleases.

At one end, it could simply be the ladies groping the guys with the lads finally just giving in and putting out simply because it's easier. Basically an interesting inversion of the usual guy pressures girl into sex scenario.

At the other end, the guys are actually kidnapped, subjected to various tortures and taken against their wills.

Plenty of fun possibilities in between as well.

 

[Strangebuddy]

Interesting.

Are brother and boyfriend exclusive with each other, or do they bring girls into the mix? How much experience with women do they have?

Does sister intend to nail her brother, and if so how is that less of a "sin" than fucking his boyfriend? Or is the saving ploy simply a ruse for sister to get into brother's pants and her earlier behavior had more to do with jealousy than anything else?

I figured the lead would have little experience with women since he came out at 15 and Lits rules prevent him from having sex till he turns 18. His boyfriend might though.

I figured the sister either sees it as the lesser of two evils or an okay act since its to "save" someone. I also figured she sees it as an excuse to lose her virginity and experience sex with another person...or possibly she wants to "save" herself (wink wink)

 

[ColetteJulie]

Or sister has a big secret that she needs to keep a secret. If she has sex with her brother she'll have leverage over him. That's what she was doing with his computer, setting it up to record at a certain time with the webcam. Or if you want to take the blackmailing even further, someone is blackmailing sister and orders her to do both her brother and his boyfriend while they watch on skype or she is a load of shit.

The campus church is where sister got her education. It would be a really small world if the minister's son and the sister did it and he's a kink. Who of course recorded their scenes.

Poor sis checks porno sites everyday in angst because the blackmailer said he would put a 'taste' on the internet for them.

It could also blow up in her face and brother could find out about the blackmailing. Then he could be a help or another threat.

I hope you have great fun with this one...
It's really such a good idea.
Collette

 

[Raziel83]

I like that the guys are bi rather than gay so they can turn this seduction scheme around on her. Perhaps she thinks that her brother is gay instead of bi and when they figure out what she is doing decide to tease her back (whether because they are kinky and think that mmf threesome just gets better with some incest) or because they don't think she would really do it.

I think the latter idea in particular has potential... She just wanted to seduce brother's boy friend but when they both act interested in her she tries to keep up her act of being a seductress and think that the best way to get her to leave them alone is to pretend to seduce her so that she would get scared but at some point all three really have gotten so horny that they can't back down.

 

[Asbel]

If he's bisexual, though, why would being with a girl convert him? He likes both.

Just saying.

 

[Hypoxia]

I like that the guys are bi rather than gay so they can turn this seduction scheme around on her. Perhaps she thinks that her brother is gay instead of bi and when they figure out what she is doing decide to tease her back...

If he's bisexual, though, why would being with a girl convert him? He likes both.

Right, Asbel. That's why Raziel's idea works. Bro is bi and lives with guy; sis thinks they're gay and she can redeem her bro at least. But neither minds sliding a hot cock into her as her 'conversion' payoff.

 

[Strangebuddy]

I like Raziel's take. The original idea was that she was buying into the "you're not bi, you're just a confused straight guy going through a phase" stereotype.

Them flipping it on her was one conclusion I was thinking of. They think that she'll back down if they come on strong to her, only to find out that she will go all the way and they have a three-way. They then have sex with each other afterwards while she's there to show that they aren't going to change, sister either accepting it or being distraught over it, with a possible addendum being her admitting to a same sex relationship she's been wanting to have with a friend as she's been a closeted bi for years and figured sex with two guys would "fix" her but now she sees that being attracted to the same sex is something she can't change, so she's going to call her friend up.

...which leads to bro and his boyfriend wondering if they did a good deed untintentionaly, or were just really bad in bed.

 

[Raziel83]

...I would end that with the sister starting to date her brother's boyfriend and brother hooking up with the girl his sister liked. ...Except that actually they would live in a polyamorous foursome but keep the charade for the sake of their homophobic families. Happy ending for everyone!