Who's fucking whom?

[blin18]

I had a story idea; it's kind of fun, but I don't think it will ever bubble to the top of my queue.

A girl - let's call her Ava - has a boyfriend Ben. Ava has a bit of a light-bondage fetish where she likes to be gently restrained and fucked, all the while pretending poorly to dislike it, though she enjoys struggling. Playing out her fantasy with Ben is fun, but what Ava really hungers for is not knowing who is fucking her. It could be Ben for all she cares, it's just the not knowing that she wants to try, but she's too shy to enlist a stranger, even though it would take about 5 minutes and a personal ad.

They enlist the help of close friends Cam and Dee. Cam and Ben have similar builds, and coincidentally similar sized cocks. Ava explains what she wants to Dee, and Dee is excited, she wants in on the action. The girls decide to get themselves tied up and blindfolded, with earplugs / noise-cancelling headphones. This would happen in adjoining hotel rooms.

Cam and Ben wouldn't know which girl is in which room, but they would flip for keys in the bar downstairs and then come into their chosen room with blindfolds, ear-plugs, oven mitts, ribbed condoms and latex cock rings (to shorten their stroke a little and make it foreign); find a naked girl, fuck her, and then meet back in the bar. After a short interval of recuperation, they swap keys and do it all again.

So they KNOW they fucked their GFs best friend, but they don't know which fuck she was. Similarly, the girls know they were fucked by their best-friend's BF, but not which fuck.

Twist: Ava gets into the not knowing and REALLY enjoys the first fuck. It wasn't that much like Ben, so she thinks it was Cam. Then within 2 minutes of him leaving, the next guy arrives. He's got a long, thick cock that she KNOWS isn't Ben, so now she knows she being fucked by Cam and she goes completely fucking ape-shit and almost cums herself into a coma. Ava is lying spent -still restrained - when a few minutes later, the door opens and another guys comes in. WTF? Ava thinks it's a real assailant and in a panic she uses the safe word. Ben unties her, and she realises that the second guy was the REAL stranger when she looks down and sees cum still leaking out of her pussy

 

[sirhugs]

interesting... but why recruit a chum if she craves stranger?

 

[lovecraft68]

interesting... but why recruit a chum if she craves stranger?

Safety, and I think because of that it makes the story believable

 

[CeasarBoobage]

I like this idea!

All four people clearly know what's going on, but it's the thrill of the unknown that that helps the drive the excitement.

Also, no earplugs, but an MP3 player hooked up to the noise-canceling headphones. And oven mitts? I know why, but it made me LOL. Since the women are also of matching sizes, maybe bare hands or gloves would work since touch can be a huge factor in the experience.


Alternate 1:
Cam tells Ben that Dee has previously expressed interest in a spit-roast. During one of the swaps, both guys go into a room, entering her from both sides. The woman finishes quickly, so the guys go to the next room and repeat performance (don't want them too tired out!). Now all four know there was a 3-way, but not which person was in which position.

Alternate 2:
Ben tells Cam that Ava has expressed interest in wearing a strap-on to do another woman. The guys go buy one that matches their size and puts it in a backpack, handing to Ava with instructions to not peek, and they have altered the playlist on her MP3 player. The new track is audio of Ben telling her to open the bag and use the toy on Dee, then to leave the bag in her room when she's done. The last track that plays for Dee is to tell her what happened and she has to do the same to Ava. Again, they all know what's happened, but not who and when.

Alternate 3:
Combine elements of 1 and 2.

Alternate 4:
Although it kills the original story line with the 'anon' factor, they are all so turned on with the addition of girl play and/or spit-roast, all four go to the room for a full 4-way.