Don't know how else to put it. When we started our relationship it wasn't really D/s it was more vanilla than anything else. We met off and on and agreed that there would be no emotional attachments. He is married and wants to remain so though if she hasn't as he said had sex with him in over 2 years I'm not sure why. But at the same time I am married and will not desert my invalid husband. He can not function alone. His dementia, brain damage, total loss of bodily functions and make it impossible for him to be on his own. I am just waiting till something happens, either he goes into a nursing home or ???? At any rate our relationship was to be just to take care of our immediate sexual needs. FWB Friend with benefits. Any way to get back to what I am wondering about. He finally decided to get a motel room for us instead of his car. Ok first time in a bed. Should be nice. He says to me can we maybe try anal now. I say yes I do want to. So he tells me to start using a finger or two and maybe a dildo on my ass to loosen it up, the goal being to make it so we don't need to use lube. I go back and ask why he doesn't want to use lube. That since the anus doesn't produce natural lube like the pussy does it is wise even if I was experienced at anal that we use lube. This goes on for a while and I am quoting him things I have read here and at fetlife. That without lube it is possible to tear the inside and could lead to bigger problems. Oh by the way all of a sudden he is referring to me as his sub. He owns me and I will do as he wishes. Ok so if that is the case sir, why don't we get to discuss safe, sane, and sober procedures. I don't think you want to hurt your baby girl. Anyway finally he agrees that we will use lube after all what kind of man do I think he is that I would fuck a virgin ass without lube. I said because that is what you said and I quoted him. I said since we are now officially playing D/s then we need to talk about safety issues. Then he starts on maybe I'm not submissive after all. I say I never said I was, if you go back to the beginning of our talking I said I was interested in D/s but not sub yet. Not sure I'm ready. Then he says if you don't trust me by now . I say I do trust you and don't see why it is such a problem to discuss the safety issues of what we do. I tell him I want to make him happy and if that means I have to suffer pain in anal sex so be it. I will, I want to make him happy. In fact due to something that happened to me when I was 7 I feel that I need to face my fear of anal sex and then maybe I can get over it and in fact that could be the reason why I can't orgasm. So now he comes back with lets forget even trying it, I am just happy to be with you. You are not ready for anal and you are not ready for D/s, I will wait. So am I wrong to insist on lube with anal sex? Am I wrong as a sub to insist up front? Why is it so important for him to want no lube?