astounding question

[Tashtim]

how does one judge a story to be good?? or,imagine if the author original or a fake copier,a stealer, of other work?? why i ask,read some of the stories in a said series and what u notice is a repition of a certain single idea.its like the author lakes depth to capture and create a new idea or theme that would help trancend the reader!!does the imaginative spell of a story end in the first chapter?mmmh? who is to blame,the author or the editor??? all i seek is an answer, for only then can we unlock the greatest inspirator of all,,DREAMS

 

[Auden James]

. . .

and astoundingly confused and unclearly posed.

 

[KarlMartinK]

Confused am I by questoin of much astoundingment, for little of which do I undersand in it. Is.

 

[mythtrav16]

Since when does "astounding" mean "dyslexic"?

 

[EveAnna]

how does one judge a story to be good?? or,imagine if the author original or a fake copier,a stealer, of other work?? why i ask,read some of the stories in a said series and what u notice is a repition of a certain single idea.its like the author lakes depth to capture and create a new idea or theme that would help trancend the reader!!does the imaginative spell of a story end in the first chapter?mmmh? who is to blame,the author or the editor??? all i seek is an answer, for only then can we unlock the greatest inspirator of all,,DREAMS

Sometimes I do read stories on here and think that I've read it before but that doesn't mean that someone has plagiarized another story, it just means I've read something similar. If a story fails, then I think its the writer not the editor. Also if you are reading a series then the same theme will run straight through it.

English may not be your first language? Your post is a little hard to read.