Incest/Taboo Story Idea

[bobb_sledd]

I am by no means a writer but this story idea struck me.

A gay couple are approached by a lesbian couple, one of whom is the sister of one of the guys, to father a baby the natural way with the non-sister. They agree. In return the gay couple asks that the non-sister carry the baby of the gay brother. Along the way the lines blur. Incest, and more, ensues.

 

[TheLobster]

They agree. In return

Am I reading this wrong or are those two “different” scenarios actually the same? The non-sister gets impregnated in both cases, and we’re presumably not getting to the incest yet.

I’m not sure how we would get there in any case, though. How do the lines blur? MMF threesomes that become MMFF?

 

[bobsch703]

Am I reading this wrong or are those two “different” scenarios actually the same? The non-sister gets impregnated in both cases, and we’re presumably not getting to the incest yet.

I’m not sure how we would get there in any case, though. How do the lines blur? MMF threesomes that become MMFF?

I assume gay non-brother fucks & impregnates his husband's lesbian sister, then gay brother fucks & impregnates lesbian non-sister. Turns out they're all somewhat bi and all kinds of shenanigans ensue - lotta different combinations possible.

 

[Carnevil9]

I always thought it would be great for a lesbian couple, each of whom has a straight brother, to ask the brothers to fuck each non-sister. That way, if either or both of them get pregnant, the baby would have DNA from both families. But I guess that is more of a scenario than a story at the moment; still needs some sort of plot, such as a will-they-or-won't-they fall into incest.

 

[Rob_Royale]

See, where I'm torn on this idea, is the lesbians. I've known several and they're usually of the 'no dudes' mindset.

So if for the sake of argument, we found two who would at least entertain the idea of penetrative sex with a man for the sake of procreation - it would be a very mechanical thing. A guy fucking them from behind while their partner strokes their hair. In my mind - not very sexy, because no one is really having a good time.

I have also known bi-women who were in committed relationships with women who would be much more agreeable to adding a dude to the bedroom. So my question is this - what is the draw of using lesbians in this story? Is it the big dick fixes lesbian fallacy? Or some sort of power thing?

 

[bobb_sledd]

Am I reading this wrong or are those two “different” scenarios actually the same? The non-sister gets impregnated in both cases, and we’re presumably not getting to the incest yet.

I’m not sure how we would get there in any case, though. How do the lines blur? MMF threesomes that become MMFF?

Now you all know why I'm not a writer.

I assume gay non-brother fucks & impregnates his husband's lesbian sister, then gay brother fucks & impregnates lesbian non-sister. Turns out they're all somewhat bi and all kinds of shenanigans ensue - lotta different combinations possible.

This is true.

I always thought it would be great for a lesbian couple, each of whom has a straight brother, to ask the brothers to fuck each non-sister. That way, if either or both of them get pregnant, the baby would have DNA from both families. But I guess that is more of a scenario than a story at the moment; still needs some sort of plot, such as a will-they-or-won't-they fall into incest.

And this is true.

See, where I'm torn on this idea, is the lesbians. I've known several and they're usually of the 'no dudes' mindset.

So if for the sake of argument, we found two who would at least entertain the idea of penetrative sex with a man for the sake of procreation - it would be a very mechanical thing. A guy fucking them from behind while their partner strokes their hair. In my mind - not very sexy, because no one is really having a good time.

I have also known bi-women who were in committed relationships with women who would be much more agreeable to adding a dude to the bedroom. So my question is this - what is the draw of using lesbians in this story? Is it the big dick fixes lesbian fallacy? Or some sort of power thing?

I wouldn't read so much into it. I see it as a sex story not an exploration into bi/gay relationships. But again, I'm not a writer. I'm just planting the seed. It would be up to the author to take the story wherever they wish.

I appreciate you all taking the time to chime in. Thank you!

 

[Statius]

Yeah I can't get on board with a lesbian having sex with a guy. I know lesbians. I know what they go through. It's repulsive and disgusting. I was approached for a 'donation' once, artificially. In no way would she or her partner have sex with a guy to have a kid. I get the taboo aspect, the edginess of it for a story, but no.

 

[CharlotteKurai]

What if the the four people can explore more than having sex with a guy or a woman. I mean like knowing them eachother.