WTH Why not shake things up with a HotWife story that has a sloppy seconds theme

SebastianHolt

Really Experienced
Joined
Apr 3, 2025
Posts
100
Clearly, this will attract lots of attention from all the happy haters of the Hotwife/LW category, but would this also turn off women? My gut says yes; however, I think the raw, flagrant heading might attract some women. Of course, fiction has the advantage of being free from aids and STDs. My thought is we have a wife who isn't into sex, and she goes on this journey. She wants to find hot sex and is seeking lovers. Thinking she got married right after college and only had 2 to 3 lovers, who were not very skilled, nor could they last long. Anyway, so she finds two guys who are willing to try out a menage and other things. They are not gay nor bi, just horn dogs. They meet up, have some drinks, and get at it. The first dude comes pretty quickly due to being overly excited for his first hook up (and using something like Grinder [oh wait, is Grinder a bi sexual website?])

Anyway, my point is this ... the first guy doesn't last long, and as soon as he moves off the bed, dude #2 jumps on her.

Would love to hear from a woman who has had two men ... and when the second guy penetrates, what things go through her mind? What is she feeling? Is she comparing #1 dude's cock to #2? Does her body feel different after the first guy cums?

From the guys, has anyone been dude #2? How does it feel to penetrate a woman after a guy has come in her?
 
Clearly, this will attract lots of attention from all the happy haters of the Hotwife/LW category, but would this also turn off women? My gut says yes; however, I think the raw, flagrant heading might attract some women. Of course, fiction has the advantage of being free from aids and STDs. My thought is we have a wife who isn't into sex, and she goes on this journey. She wants to find hot sex and is seeking lovers. Thinking she got married right after college and only had 2 to 3 lovers, who were not very skilled, nor could they last long. Anyway, so she finds two guys who are willing to try out a menage and other things. They are not gay nor bi, just horn dogs. They meet up, have some drinks, and get at it. The first dude comes pretty quickly due to being overly excited for his first hook up (and using something like Grinder [oh wait, is Grinder a bi sexual website?])

Anyway, my point is this ... the first guy doesn't last long, and as soon as he moves off the bed, dude #2 jumps on her.

Would love to hear from a woman who has had two men ... and when the second guy penetrates, what things go through her mind? What is she feeling? Is she comparing #1 dude's cock to #2? Does her body feel different after the first guy cums?

From the guys, has anyone been dude #2? How does it feel to penetrate a woman after a guy has come in her?
The great thing about being a writer is that you can write whatever you can imagine. The great thing about being a writer on Lit is that you can publish what you write.

If this is a story you want to write, dust off the old keyboard and start typing. Never experienced these things in real life? No problem. I've never been a love-sick troll, or ridden an eight-legged lizard, or betrayed humanity to a shapeshifting space vampire, or shagged my twin sister, or given a sexual massage to my school bully, or been shot by a vampire-hunting priest, or any of dozens of things I've described in my stories.

Use your imagination. Try to picture for yourself what it would be like, and then relate that to something that you have actually experienced. Identify a few elements or moments, and use those to hang your description on.

Even if you can't do that, you clearly want to write the scene. So write it, read it back, try to imagine it happening, and add all the details that would make it feel more real. Rinse and repeat. That's the essence of writing.

Good luck!
 
My thought is we have a wife who isn't into sex, and she goes on this journey. She wants to find hot sex and is seeking lovers

The most interesting part of this story is how you get from



to



Figure that out and the rest will fall into place.

Yeah I'm with Simon in that you really need to figure out what story you want to tell, because your description sounds like two opposing ideas: a wife who "isn't into sex," and a who "wants to find hot sex" sounds like two different people to me.
 
Well, I can see it, with a wife who isn't into sex because it's boring. She decides she hasn't had much experience, and her girlfriends are telling her that the husband is apparently underendowed.

So, she's off to find out what she missed by not dating more.

As for the two guys, ... been there, both as the first and the second. The second guy finds it's VERY well lubricated and not as stimulating with less friction! As for the woman, they were just into it. One time, she was just so into what she was feeling, she barely noticed the tag-team change. and barely noticed the change.
 
Would love to hear from a woman who has had two men ... and when the second guy penetrates, what things go through her mind? What is she feeling? Is she comparing #1 dude's cock to #2? Does her body feel different after the first guy cums?

From the guys, has anyone been dude #2? How does it feel to penetrate a woman after a guy has come in her?

Yes, I compare. If one guy cums in me (we don't do this alot) its the same as whenever my husband creampies me. Sometimes it feels 'wetter' sometimes it feels warmer. Sometimes I only feel him pulse and twitch etc.

For your second question; This is hard for me to explain but my husband said after our first threesome (he went second but I wasn't creampied) that it was similar to when we have sex for a bit then switch to something else (e.g oral) then go back to sex. For example when we first have sex he has to go a little slower etc until I can accommodate him but since our friend got that part out of the way he could "jump straight in at full power". He also said i felt a lot warmer inside after his friend had been inside me first.

Hope this helps!
 
As for the two guys, ... been there, both as the first and the second. The second guy finds it's VERY well lubricated and not as stimulating with less friction! As for the woman, they were just into it. One time, she was just so into what she was feeling, she barely noticed the tag-team change. and barely noticed the change.

Seems like it would make sense for the bigger man to go second.

I'm not speaking from experience.
 
WTH Why not shake things up with a HotWife story that has a sloppy seconds theme
WTH why not

Is this something you're considering writing? Or is this more like what we see in the Story Ideas (seeking a writer) forum?

Anyway, it doesn't have to go in the LW category. It might still attract negative attention from those people but you don't have to lead with the chin by putting it there.
 
I kinda had a similar thought about this kinda thing earlier.

It was a swinger party at a hotel or other such place with lots of private rooms. During the partying before when everyone is socializing, all the ladies get assigned a color. That's the room they stay in.

Then all the men get a color, that's the room they start in. Everyone gets Viagra so they stay nice and hard. After the initial coupling, the ladies stay in their rooms and the men go around and fuck whoever they fancy till the party is over or everyone is tired.

Kinda sloppy seconds-ish
 
For those saying the OP has two conflicting ideas going, I don't feel that way

What I think is the OP didn't word his post quite right.

To me, this is the simple cliche of the wife not into sex anymore within her marriage as its routine, boring, the husband isn't into her, she's curious etc and she decides to go out exploring to see what's out there.

This will lead to the clutching of tiny penises and gnashing of bad teeth as the LW incels and moralists freak out over a fictional story.

It must not be easy to be self-important while also being impotent,
 
Seems like it would make sense for the bigger man to go second.

I'm not speaking from experience.
It's not just about size when you use a fist full of lube. There is such a difference when there's too much lube.


By the way, I have done this story line before in Loving wives, with the "sloppy seconds".
"A Dare at the Nude Resort"
"Husband watches his horny wife and her boy-toy in a restroom."

The husband watched them have fun, then he followed in her. Rated 4.13/266 with 37k views after almost two years since publication.
 
Last edited:
It's not just about size when you use a fist full of lube. There is such a difference when there's too much lube.


By the way, I have done this story line before in Loving wives, with the "sloppy seconds".
"A Dare at the Nude Resort"
"Husband watches his horny wife and her boy-toy in a restroom."

The husband watched them have fun, then he followed in her. Rated 4.13/266 with 37k views after almost two years since publication.
I live on a small, remote island, and while it's not 'nude', a lot of women tend to go topless at their rental house or when they think they are in a secluded spot. There is a walking trail right off the beach, so it's really impossible to find a spot on the beach that offers 100% privacy.

About a year after I purchased the house, a couple came to stay. The husband, after an hour, lost interest in the beach and wanted to head back to the house to watch SportsCenter. The island is remote, but we do have reliable power from shore and DirecTV.

About ten minutes later, she asked if she could go topless as she's always wanted to.

Who am I to block someone from reaching a lifelong goal! I was more than willing to help her with her bucket list :)

sadly, this was before her boob job, but still, I thought her breasts were amazing. She was talking bout how much she wanted a boob job and her 'fried eggs' looked horrible. Did my best to boost her up as she was model material. Anyway, think my erection showed her that I was being honest.

That was one of the best days in my life, but what happened that night was AH-mazing!
 
I'm writing this now, one of my "projects"
OK, I have no idea what it feels like for a guy, but I’ve had things said like, “more slippery,” “slicker,” etc., as you’d kinda expect. This isn’t something to get caught up on. Use some logic and imagination. What does your cum feel like between finger and thumb? Then extrapolate.

As for sensations, feelings, and thoughts, everyone is different and fucks can feel very different physically and emotionally, depending on who is involved the scenario, and what has led up to this. Again, try to imagine. There is enough variety of experience that you’ll probably be fine.
 
OK, I have no idea what it feels like for a guy, but I’ve had things said like, “more slippery,” “slicker,” etc., as you’d kinda expect. This isn’t something to get caught up on. Use some logic and imagination. What does your cum feel like between finger and thumb? Then extrapolate.

As for sensations, feelings, and thoughts, everyone is different and fucks can feel very different physically and emotionally, depending on who is involved the scenario, and what has led up to this. Again, try to imagine. There is enough variety of experience that you’ll probably be fine.
Totally understand that 'each experience is different' and even though I'm a guy :) I don't have sex with every woman that I see. Have to have a connection, plus have to know 'her' before I'm doing the horizontal tango. I had a couple of one-night stands in high school, but my college years were devoted to education and being a single woman. I'm still not a fan of one-night stands :( while I can see the appeal and why it can be hot. guessing I'm weird, but when I know my partner, it's so much more enjoyable doing things that I know drive her wild.

ugh, my last one-night stand/hookup was on my senator's desk. Sadly, she was 'one' that got away (long story that I need to write about)
 
Last edited:
It's not just about size when you use a fist full of lube. There is such a difference when there's too much lube.


By the way, I have done this story line before in Loving wives, with the "sloppy seconds".
"A Dare at the Nude Resort"
"Husband watches his horny wife and her boy-toy in a restroom."

The husband watched them have fun, then he followed in her. Rated 4.13/266 with 37k views after almost two years since publication.

Holy crap, a memory just came back to me. I had my buddy with me and his sisters best friend. His sister got tied up with something, so I drove the three of us. This girl was cute but her body was a smoking 11.

At that time, I was dating a ballerina on the way to her house, the things she would whisper to me...well I was having a hard time (pun) driving straight. I can't recall her name, but she was best friends with my best friend's sister. She invited me to her house to check out all the video games her father had. We were at her parents' house as she wanted to show me all the video games her father had.

This wasn’t a game system like the Xbox; there were the actual old school arcade machines. Guess he was some collector and had ten that were playable and another 20 that he was in the process of restoring. My buddy was in hog heaven and drove right into the games. Guess that’s why she grabbed my hand and took me up to her old bedroom. It was one of the best days of my life! We totally clicked and she had something like three orgasms. Always had this thing with foreplay & seduction with my goal of having my date orgasm first as she did.

Anyway, after we were finished, she asked me if I wanted something to drink and went off to fetch some Cokes. She grabs a T-shirt, slips it on, and heads to get those drinks. five minutes later … I realized that she wasn’t coming back. So off I go searching for her.

There she was in the middle of the room riding my friend's face. I was frozen and didn’t know what to do. One part of me wanted to yell at her but he had to know what he was getting. Guess he had a hunkering for some fresh pie ;) Sorry, I couldn’t resist.

Anyway, we never spoke of that day. I’m not 100% sure if he knew what he did or not, and decided it's best to let that experience go. I didn’t want to embarrass or gross out my friend.

What would you do? Would you have told him? Would you join? I just collected my clothes and snuck out the door.
 
Back
Top