trysail
Catch Me Who Can
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2005
- Posts
- 25,593
After all the worries of doubling oil costs (based on factors that are still around), we now have OPEC worried about $100 oil again. Do we actually know anything about what drives the insane futures traders? That they can lower the price because Gustav wasn't as bad as feared when the Russia and Iran mess still goes on is baffling (never mind the talks of shortages, lack of refining, booming China, etc.)--now don't get me wrong, I like low prices like everyone else, but I hate that it makes no sense to me. It indicates I still know nothing, after all this reading. Are the newspaper people just full of shit? Trysail, Hand, have you heard anything that actually justifies this? Is someone playing with politics, or are we Americans actually lowering our demand by that much?
I'm annoyingly lost.
In many respects, "the newspaper people" ARE "full of shit." Never, ever forget that their primary job is to sell newspapers**. Beyond that, very few of them have any understanding of economics or basic knowledge of the energy industries. Face it, the only qualification necessary to become a journalist is an ability to regurgitate other people's statements and to type basic English.
Daily journalism, by its nature, is concerned with the ephemeral. As such it tends to focus on spot prices (as, of course, do traders). Do not confuse the abstract concept of trading/speculating with investment— many people (and newspapers) make that mistake.
One of the reasons that Warren Buffett became the best investor the world has ever known is his ability to recognize and discriminate between marginal prices (a/k/a "spot" prices) and intrinsic value. They are two very, very different things and Buffett's fortune was made by his extraordinary talent at evaluating and capitalizing on those differences.
The marginal price of anything is merely the price where the most recent buyer and seller agree to buy and sell. It does not necessarily reflect the cost of production or the replacement cost. It is merely one transaction.
Intrinsic value, on the other hand, is a far more substantive and enduring concept. It is an informed estimate of the present value of the long-run worth of an enterprise or asset.
The human participants in markets are subject to periodic bouts of fear and greed; under the influence of these emotions, people behave irrationally. As Buffett once put it, " 'Mr. Market' has manic tendencies." In response to fear and greed, many market participants will behave stupidly: they will buy high and sell low.
It is amazing how many otherwise bright people permit their emotions to dictate their behavior.
With respect to petroleum prices, marginal demand has been curtailed by (1) conservation arising from comparatively high prices, (2) substitution and (3) slower economic activity. At the same time, production has been stimulated by those same comparatively high prices.
ETA:
"Buy when stock prices are low and hold on to your securities...
People seem unable to grasp these simple principles.
They do not buy when prices are low.
They are fearful of bargains."
-J. Paul Getty
______________________________
**Newspapers and the media are in the business of selling newspapers and attracting eyeballs. To that end: "If it bleeds, it leads." The media is, most assuredly, not interested in "Dog bites man" stories; the precise opposite is the case— they are drawn like flies to the scene of accidents, spilt blood and "Man bites dog" stories.
Last edited: