Bramblethorn
Sleep-deprived
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2012
- Posts
- 16,922
I believe that falls-or should-under hate speech which is a violation....issue is the inconsistent designation of hate speech. My personal opinion is that it should still be allowed although it is hurtful to people, and my reasoning is let everyone see that person for who they are, and it reminds us that this crap is out there and those reminders are needed seeing media and politicians have beaten the word racist so badly into the ground they've turned people deaf to it, so real life examples are all that's left to keep people mindful of the reality of it behind the over the top woke BS
But as far as leftist twitter goes let's do this. On Twitter Jordan Peterson had his account banned for hate speech because he said there were only two biological genders.
No, that is not what happened.
Twitter doesn't forbid people from expressing the belief that "there are only two biological genders", and AFAIK it never has. Searching the site will pull up many, many examples of folk saying that without consequences.
Here is a screenshot of the relevant tweet, which JP made in response to a NY Post story about Umbrella Academy actor Elliot Page's gender transition:
As you can see, there's nothing whatsoever in that tweet about how many genders there are. Rather, he's talking about a specific transgender person, making a point of using Page's pre-transition name ("deadnaming") and referring to him as "her". That is against Twitter policy, which Peterson would very likely have known when he posted it, seeing as how "Help Help I'm Being Oppressed For Being Politically Incorrect About Transgenders" is basically his personal brand. As Simon commented re. Literotica, it's not unreasonable for a forum operator to decide that they don't want forum users directly targeting other users with personal insults, which is what Peterson was doing here.
(IMHO talking about a stranger's breasts like that is kinda gross, as is calling somebody a "criminal" for performing legal surgery on a consenting adult, but Twitter doesn't ban people just for being creepy and gross.)
Further - and feel free to consider this nitpicking if you like - Peterson wasn't actually "banned" from Twitter.
Twitter has a couple of different levels of action they can take against accounts which they deem to have broken the rules. Banning, aka "permanent suspension", is the big one: your account is permanently locked, nothing you can do to get it back, unless Twitter management have a change of heart. Under the old management, this was fairly uncommon outside of blatant spamming, single-purpose harassment accounts, and people who persistently violated the policy. (These days though, you can get banned for just about anything that hurts Elon's feelings - the guy who claimed to be the champion of free speech had one user banned for posting publicly available flight tracking information about Elon's jet.)
The milder level of action, what Peterson got, what most people get for a one-time breach, is a temporary suspension. You get notified that one of your posts violates their policies, and your account is suspended (can't post, tweets hidden from other users) until you agree to delete the offending tweet. Then the suspension gets lifted and you get your account back. About two months after his suspension, Peterson did exactly that, because he wanted to do some kind of "housekeeping" on his account.
I'll grant that "you can come back but you have to delete that tweet" isn't full free speech, but it's misleading to characterise it as a ban.
I see this because I sit center in my beliefs, some right, some left, and based on where my personal feelings lie, not having to adhere to one mindless group like most everyone here does. Because I look at both sides equally I know they're both trash, they both spread hate and fear and want division which the herd has happily given them
The problem is that you're so addicted to "both sides suck" you'll accept and repeat any story that validates that position without checking whether it's actually true.