Would you help a stranger?

Debbie

Persnickety slattern
Joined
Feb 4, 2001
Posts
24,213
http://www.stuff.co.nz/world/australia/9619308/Womans-screams-ignored-by-dozens


"When Aida screamed for help on a busy Sydney street this week, people just watched.

At 4.30pm on Monday, on busy Railway Street in Liverpool, Aida fought off a man who tried to drag her into a car.

Not one of the people came to Aida's assistance, despite her screams.

Someone is in trouble. You help them. If you don't, you are morally flawed and/or a coward. But psychologists offer an alternative view. They call it the "bystander effect"."

Do you think the days of being a good Samaritan are gone?

Would you help a stranger?

Help, do nothing, run away or film it?

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/driver-crashes-rite-aid-entrance-article-1.1570672
 
Bystander effect and normalcy bias terrify me. I think it helps to be aware of them, though. Name your monsters.

I've never been in a real crisis situation that's comparable to the stuff you read about, but when shit's gone down or if I see someone who needs help, I always try to step in. I am also comfortable taking charge and being in leadership positions, so I like to think that I'd never stand by and do nothing in a situation like that, but it's impossible to know. Also, my self-preservation instinct is not as good as it should be.
 
I absolutely would. I can't imagine not at least yelling for more help, or trying to scare the assailant off by just making a ruckus and bringing more attention to what was going on.

But I can totally see the scene with everyone just watching and doing nothing, because I experienced an incident at the shopping centre just after Christmas.

A woman was sitting on a bench, just inside the mall doors. I was walking down toward the doors, on my way to my car. The woman attempted to stand up. She had a cane, and I am not sure if her cane slipped, or she lost her balance or what, but she fell down, hard, between the two benches. I was probably 20 odd metres from her, and kept walking toward her, expecting someone to help her. Nope. A bunch of people were standing around, a few asked her if she was alright, but not one blessed person knelt to try and actually help her.

By the time I got there, she was sort of floundering on the floor trying to right herself. I squatted next to her, and told her to just wait a moment and make sure she was not injured. I've slipped on ice and fallen before, so I know how embarrassing it is to fall in public...you just want to pop up and pretend it never happened.

She said she thought she was okay, and I took her hand and forearm and helped to steady her as I pulled her up, and supported her while she shuffled back on the bench. I picked up her parcels, and asked if she would be okay. She asked if I would help her to her car, as the fall had rather shaken her up. So, I carried her parcels in one hand, while letting her lean on my other arm.

She was not an old woman, maybe in her mid 30's, but had been diagnosed with MS about three years ago. I guess it came and went, and she'd had a recent flare up. I got her to her car, opened her door, put her stuff away, and helped her get in. She was sooooo grateful, and thanked me profusely.

I still can't believe none of those who were right there when it happened helped her. :(
 
Long ago at the beach, in the sand dunes, there I was with friends, partying. We hear a woman in the tall weeds yelling HELP HELP!!! And see some rustling of people. It was dusk on the verge of night time, so it was hard to see. So two male friends ran up to find out what was going on and this couple stand up, half clothed, very drunk, and she starts yelling at them to Fuck Off, what the fuck are they doing and starts to pick a fight with my friends. My friends just backed off confused...whatever.

The whole situation was weird.
 
Weird situations

The walls in my apartment complex are thin at some points, so I can occasionally hear the tv/loud conversations of the older woman who lives next door. One night when I was getting ready to go out, I heard some loud, painful moans (not the good kind, I could tell), and the sound of someone shifting back and forth. Right before I leave I hear, quite distinctly "Oh God, please, someone help me!" This is repeated in several variations over the next few minutes. I try shouting through the wall, asking what she needs help with, but get no response other than some softer moans. I try knocking on her door, I contemplate trying to pick the lock, break it down, call 911, I tell her if she really needs help to give me a sign that I should do any of these things. No comment, no response, some softer moans or whimpers.

I end up deciding to continue with my evening, though I did not feel entirely right about it all. Without knowing how things turned out after this, it felt like I should do something more, but I could not think of what. My evening was nigh ruined by worrying about whether I had done the right thing, and what was happening in my neighbour's place.

I knocked on her door the next day, and she answered, saying she was sorry she had not responded to me or opened her door last night, but she was having a bad time on the toilet! Now I understand having a really bad time there, for any number of reasons. but why would someone in such a situation ever yell out "Someone help me!" And why, having yelled that out, would that someone not respond to someone trying to answer them? I could have had firemen break down her door (I would have tried myself first, but probably failed), if I had acted on what I thought could have been happening inside her place, and assuming that a lack of response meant the worst.

That being said, I hope to always try to respond in some way to every cry for help that I hear. And certainly on those occasions when I can see someone actually is in danger.
 
help

it's alien to be any other way. maybe i should think first before i act but the act part just kicks in. so far, it's not harmed me.
 
http://www.stuff.co.nz/world/australia/9619308/Womans-screams-ignored-by-dozens


"When Aida screamed for help on a busy Sydney street this week, people just watched.

At 4.30pm on Monday, on busy Railway Street in Liverpool, Aida fought off a man who tried to drag her into a car.

Not one of the people came to Aida's assistance, despite her screams.

Someone is in trouble.

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/driver-crashes-rite-aid-entrance-article-1.1570672


I got this far into your post, thinking it was another "help me find a story" thread.
 
Long ago at the beach, in the sand dunes, there I was with friends, partying. We hear a woman in the tall weeds yelling HELP HELP!!! And see some rustling of people. It was dusk on the verge of night time, so it was hard to see. So two male friends ran up to find out what was going on and this couple stand up, half clothed, very drunk, and she starts yelling at them to Fuck Off, what the fuck are they doing and starts to pick a fight with my friends. My friends just backed off confused...whatever.

The whole situation was weird.

Angry drunks are stupid and they probably put people off trying to help them
because of the verbal and possible physical abuse.

I really don't understand how some people see someone who needs
help and do nothing but whip out their phones and film whatever is happening.
 
Growing up rural, I've always been good in an emergency, and don't hesitate to get involved.

Except once. I was too confused to get involved. It made no sense. It still doesn't.

I was in Britain and 3 girls ambushed 2 others in a busy public place.
( Apparently fans of one soccer team were trespassing on the turf of another.)

Nobody else was getting involved, were they afraid it would escalate to a riot or something?

Was a tv show being taped?

I wondered if I would get accused of sexual assault if I grabbed one of these girls and pulled her off.
 
If I'm armed, call me Batman. If I'm not, I'll be a little more careful about getting in the middle of something beyond shouting a warning. I'm not a good knife fighter and I hate hospitals... and cemeteries.


Help, do nothing, run away or film it?

Filming it might sound bad, but can actually be of great service to the victim later on. Or at least you should observe everything carefully and report to the police what you saw.

Too many violators go free because of lack of evidence...
 
Not sure this qualifies...

...but 25 years ago, on our way to the airport to fly to Jamaica to get married, we passed a vehicle rolled over on its roof in a ditch of a rest area on the Interstate. We stopped to see if anyone needed help, turned out to be a drunk driver, who was unhurt and took off into the woods to avoid being arrested for OUI. We contacted the Police by waking a truck driver and using his CB radio...long before the cell phone days. We waited for Police to arrive, explained situation and continued on our way.
 
People suffer from group think.

Each member individually thinking that someone else in a group will do something so they do not have to.
Leads to nobody doing anything.
 
if you train people from the cradle to mind their own business and think only of themselves it tends to have an effect and that effect is not necessarily positive.
 
Filming it might sound bad, but can actually be of great service to the victim later on. Or at least you should observe everything carefully and report to the police what you saw.

Too many violators go free because of lack of evidence...

Thank you! I meant to say that and forgot.
Filming them before they flee the scene is getting involved and taking action.
 
I have more than once. Sometimes they wanted it, sometimes they didn't. I just know if I needed help I wouldn't want someone to walk the other way, so I try to help if I can. Every time I'm aware it can be dangerous, but my morals outweigh my sense. Sometimes the only difference between bravery and foolishness is the outcome. I've been lucky so far.
 
I have more than once. Sometimes they wanted it, sometimes they didn't. I just know if I needed help I wouldn't want someone to walk the other way, so I try to help if I can. Every time I'm aware it can be dangerous, but my morals outweigh my sense. Sometimes the only difference between bravery and foolishness is the outcome. I've been lucky so far.

I'm kinda disappointed here. I had fully expected you to create a "Would you help a strangler" thread by now. ;)


That being said, you are right about the issue with not everybody wanting your help.

Sometimes it turns out to be a violent quarrel between a couple of two drama-queens or drunkards, and in those cases whoever tries to break them up can end up facing the wrath of both idiots.

Last year I was flagged down by a woman screaming for me to call the police because she had been violated and raped. In fact, I almost ran the crazy chick over because she just stepped out in front of me and Harleys are generally not known for their good brakes. I quickly asked her who and how. She pointed to a guy walking along on the opposite side of the street and identified him as "Dumb-ass." And then, to make completely certain that I knew who she meant, she ran over and proceeded to kick and punch the guy. He tried to defend himself at first, and then he took off running for dear life with "the victim" chasing him while screaming promises of unpleasantries he would experience if she caught him.

When you hit the town there are many such people out there, and it's not always easy to assess whether a situation requires an intervention and is worth the risk.
 
It's hard to distinguish an actual victim with a complete psycho in these age in times. besides it's really hard for ppl in big cities to give a shit about another stranger. be sure if you're trying to be a samaritan don't forget your leather jump suit and eye mask.
 
I've never not helped.

I don't know. Some people are better at handling those types of situations than others.

I've been hearing a lot of stories about sick men in groups lately and it's difficult for me to understand how a lot of this type of behaviour isn't reported to the police.
 
Filming it might sound bad, but can actually be of great service to the victim later on. Or at least you should observe everything carefully and report to the police what you saw.

Too many violators go free because of lack of evidence...

I agree with you and p1. Filming it for evidence is acceptable. If you are filming
it to upload onto youtube for shits and giggles or net notoriety you are a dick.


if you train people from the cradle to mind their own business and think only of themselves it tends to have an effect and that effect is not necessarily positive.

I agree and that is sad. There was a news story a few years back where a toddler in China was hit by a vehicle and no one stopped to help. People walked right past the child and did not stop to help her. The poor child was hurt, bleeding and no one gave her comfort or got her medical. She died. :(

What sort of world would it be if no one helped anyone?

Thank you to those who would help a stranger. :)

Someone did that for my youngest when he was 14 and mugged. He was more shaken than hurt but if a stranger had not stopped and shouted at the youths pushing and shoving him for his watch and a dvd it might have been different.

(I also understand people wanting to be careful when helping a stranger. It can be a bit risky in case the situation is dangerous. Calling emergency services is helpful.)
 
And... no drum roll please.

She may have made the story up.

http://www.stuff.co.nz/world/9638082/Woman-made-up-abduction-tale-police-say

"A Sydney woman who claimed she had narrowly escaped being abducted by a carload of men while the public watched has been charged after she allegedly made up the story."

Once again someone calls wolf and when people really need help onlookers may hesitate thinking it might be a hoax.
 
Back
Top