Why do Bible thumpers

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re-Re

MechaBlade said:


It feels like an insult because they're basically saying "I don't believe in your bs religion, so I'm going to wish you well in my own religion, because mine is the right one, and if I don't pray for you, you might not convert and will go to Hell."

Ok, perhaps I misread what you were saying. I assumed you meant that people praying for you for any reason was offensive... such as being put on a prayer list when you're ill. Did you mean praying that you would convert?

What religion is the lighting candles religion? Do you believe in prayer?



I'm a witch. I light candles as a tool for sending out energy. Yes, I believe in prayer as another tool for sending positive or healing energy out. I figure if someone wants to take time out of their busy lives to send energy my way, it would be completely selfish and absurd to be offended because they're doing it in a manner that is not my own.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re-Re

pagancowgirl said:
Did you mean praying that you would convert?
I think that's the idea.

I'm a witch. I light candles as a tool for sending out energy. Yes, I believe in prayer as another tool for sending positive or healing energy out. I figure if someone wants to take time out of their busy lives to send energy my way, it would be completely selfish and absurd to be offended because they're doing it in a manner that is not my own.

So you believe that prayer actually accomplishes something. Of course you're not offended.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re-Re

MechaBlade said:
So you believe that prayer actually accomplishes something. Of course you're not offended.

If you don't believe that prayer accomplishes anything, why are you offended? They're wasting their time, energy, and breath... and you're not out anything.

I'm not trying to be difficult, I'm honestly curious. Even if I didn't believe prayer accomplished anything (and I don't believe that 'god' is actually going to 'answer your prayers' like santa bringing you the toys you put on your christmas list), I'd have a hard time being offended because someone wanted to do something for me that they honestly believed might help.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re-Re

pagancowgirl said:


If you don't believe that prayer accomplishes anything, why are you offended? They're wasting their time, energy, and breath... and you're not out anything.

That's just it. They're wasting their time praying when they could be getting me a sandwich or getting back to work or something productive. Plus, they know that I don't believe it will help. They are telling me this because they doubt my faith in my own beliefs.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re-Re

MechaBlade said:


That's just it. They're wasting their time praying when they could be getting me a sandwich or getting back to work or something productive. Plus, they know that I don't believe it will help. They are telling me this because they doubt my faith in my own beliefs.

Obviously, this is an agree to disagree issue...

But have you thought about it from the standpoint that they do, in fact, respect your beliefs, but that they want to 'help' in the way that they think may do some good?

I tend to put more importance on intent than on actions. If the offer to say a quick prayer was made with the intent to help, offer support, lend a hand... I'd be grateful.

Then again, I know very few people who doubt my faith in my beliefs.
 
MechaBlade said:
I'm just saying that religion went hand in hand with government the farther back you go in history. Kings were thought to be appointed by god, so any political strife was a matter of who's god is the right god, even between two Christian nations.
That was the government using the religion, not the religion using the government - there is a difference. While the waters were certainly muddied up in those wars, you can't say that every war where the support of Christianity was sought, or where Christianity was used to further a means, was a Christian war. Probably not even most of them.

Plus I doubt hardly anyone has been killed in the name of Atheism. There have been atheist fascist dictators, but they didn't kill others because they were atheists, but because they were fascist dictators.
I used the terminology "aetheistic socialism". I was not referring to atheism alone. However, I would refer you to the Lenin and Stalin periods of the history of the USSR. An argument can be made there that there was a concerted effort to stamp out all religion save the state religion which was atheistic socialism, and that tens of millions were murdered in its name. The same goes for Com-China.

My point being that total power, whether in the name of religion or in the name of government, corrupts, and that as far as history indicates, that government without a conventional religion, although often a religion of sorts in itself, has proven much more harmful (by orders of magnitude), than religion itself.

The comparison holds; so-called "Christian wars" pale in comparison to to an atheistic totalitarian government. My point being not that atheism is therefore evil, but that if you want to use comparative terminology to drag down Christianity, be sure of your facts, and look to what has been done in the last century where Christians were the victims and not the perpetrators.

Every war has a point. World War II prevented a anti-Semitic fascist dictator from taking over the world. The Gulf War let gas prices stay low. The Crusades... uh well, the crusades... nope, no point there.
Actually both WWI and WWII did not need to happen, or at least they did not have to happen the way they did; had the worlds nations acted just a little differently, millions of civilian and military lives would have been saved. Hitler could have been stopped early on.

The Gulf War was pointless also in the that it did not have to happen - there is some validity to the argument that we let it happen by not sending clear signals to Iraq before they invaded Kuwait.

If you go back to the beginning of most wars, you will see a point in time where just the right action would have either prevented the war, or where it would have been stopped and over with in a much shorter time.

When you come right down to it, when you look at the original reason a war was started (not the reason the good side fought back), most wars are just plain pointless. Hence my statement.
 
Last edited:
pagancowgirl said:
I tend to put more importance on intent than on actions. If the offer to say a quick prayer was made with the intent to help, offer support, lend a hand... I'd be grateful.

PCG, With absolutely no intent to offend, You're a far more "Christian" person than 99.9999% of the people who claim that label.
 
Weird Harold said:


PCG, With absolutely no intent to offend, You're a far more "Christian" person than 99.9999% of the people who claim that label.

No offense at all taken, WH.
 
Shy Tall Guy said:
That was the government using the religion, not the religion using the government - there is a difference. While the waters were certainly muddied up in those wars, you can't say that every war where the support of Christianity was sought, or where Christianity was used to further a means, was a Christian war. Probably not even most of them.

I used the terminology "aetheistic socialism". I was not referring to atheism alone. However, I would refer you to the Lenin and Stalin periods of the history of the USSR. An argument can be made there that there was a concerted effort to stamp out all religion save the state religion which was atheistic socialism, and that tens of millions were murdered in its name. The same goes for Com-China.

My point being that total power, whether in the name of religion or in the name of government, corrupts, and that as far as history indicates, that government without a conventional religion, although often a religion of sorts in itself, has proven much more harmful (by orders of magnitude), than religion itself.

The comparison holds; so-called "Christian wars" pale in comparison to to an atheistic totalitarian government. My point being not that atheism is therefore evil, but that if you want to use comparative terminology to drag down Christianity, be sure of your facts, and look to what has been done in the last century where Christians were the victims and not the perpetrators.

Actually both WWI and WWII did not need to happen, or at least they did not have to happen the way they did; had the worlds nations acted just a little differently, millions of civilian and military lives would have been saved. Hitler could have been stopped early on.

The Gulf War was pointless also in the that it did not have to happen - there is some validity to the argument that we let it happen by not sending clear signals to Iraq before they invaded Kuwait.

If you go back to the beginning of most wars, you will see a point in time where just the right action would have either prevented the war, or where it would have been stopped and over with in a much shorter time.

When you come right down to it, when you look at the original reason a war was started (not the reason the good side fought back), most wars are just plain pointless. Hence my statement.

I know that the government used the religion, but the fact is a lot of the warriors were inspired by their religion to fight. Quoteth the pope "God Wills It!" (about the Crusades) Who knows what would have happened if kings just had said "We fight the french just because we want their land?" Would armies have fought as hard? I see religion being the main factor in many wars.

When killing in the name of "atheistic socialism" I believe the socialist part was more important. The political side had greater importance than the religion. I don't think the fact that Hitler and Stalin were atheists, as you say, had anything to do with their genocidal policies. The fact that they were atheists is a coincidence. I can't think of a war where Christians were targeted except for some in the Serbian area where they were persecuted by Muslims.

I'm not saying all the horrible wars were Christian ones. But many of the horrible atrocities ever committed were committed in the name of religion. Which is pretty hypocritical because religion, especially Christianity, is assumed to promote tolerance and make life better in general. Atheism has no philosophy.

WWII was necessary. Of course it could have been prevented, but in 1942, the time machine hadn't been invented yet, and so war was necessary.
 
MechaBlade said:
I know that the government used the religion, but the fact is a lot of the warriors were inspired by their religion to fight. Quoteth the pope "God Wills It!" (about the Crusades) Who knows what would have happened if kings just had said "We fight the french just because we want their land?" Would armies have fought as hard? I see religion being the main factor in many wars.
And patriotism was the factor in a lot of other wars, and indeed in those same religious wars. I am just saying that there are many factors in a war, and leaders use whatever is handy to inspire support. Patriotism and religion are two very powerful motives, and hence they are often used to motivate. That doesn't necessarily make religion or patriotism the cause of the war. The main cause of war is power and its corrupting influence.

I don't think the fact that Hitler and Stalin were atheists, as you say, had anything to do with their genocidal policies. The fact that they were atheists is a coincidence.
Well, Hitler wasn't an atheist - he was very heavily into the occult, as was his close-in group - but that is not the issue. With Stalin, atheism, or rather more correctly the intense dislike and persecution of any religion other than the socialist state, was the main factor in the genocide that took place in the USSR. Again though, the main factor was not so much the religion of socialism, which was used by Stalin, but rather the corrupting influence of power. Stalin was a paranoid who craved power and would do anything to increase his power and remove any percieved threat to him and his power.


I can't think of a war where Christians were targeted except for some in the Serbian area where they were persecuted by Muslims.
There was the persecution of Christians by the Armenians, and there was the Romans too. I am not limiting myself to wars; Stalin killed 40 million outside of any war.

WWII was necessary. Of course it could have been prevented, but in 1942, the time machine hadn't been invented yet, and so war was necessary.
WWI and WWII could both have been prevented, or at least drastically shortened and not have become world wars, had the nations involved had some foresight and backbone and become involved early on, rather than having tried appeasement.
 
LOL!

JazzManJim said:
Why is it that when people encounter a person with a strong religious faith, they feel the unerring need to "make them think a little more"?

By the way, I'm known as the religious person who makes most athiests wet their pants because they don't think enough.

Jazzman, you are still my hero....
 
Back
Top