"When your child goes to war"

G

Guest

Guest
This kind of view is not so well reported in the media. - Perdita

War Torn - Parenting advice for those left at home - Richard Hanlin, SF Chron, June 13, 2004

Somewhere there must be a parenting book with a section titled: "When Your Child Goes to War." In case one doesn't exist, I'll make a contribution. My credentials: Our son, Max, is an infantry officer with the Stryker Brigade in Mosul, Iraq, FOB (Forward Operating Base) Regular.

It might seem useful in the age of the Internet and cell phones to enjoy daily updates both personal and institutional. Yes and no. When the coalition announces that a soldier has been killed, the name is withheld for a couple of days. Which means that because you know where he is, his unit, the names of his officers and men, you end up hourly searching the Web for a name to go with the bad news.

Your mind jumps from imagined event to imagined event. A homecoming party at Malvina's in North Beach transforms itself into a funeral at Grace Cathedral, where Max went to grade school. When my son telephoned to tell me he'd crossed the Tigris River, I ended the call by reminding him (why, I'll never know) to floss his teeth. Which left me wondering if these would be my last words to him.

Fear might take another form. I dreamt Max came home with a missing arm. I was not distressed in the least. I told him (in the dream), "OK, you've done that, time to get on with your real life." Would I make that trade? You bet I would.

The most unsettling of my thoughts came after reading an article about how bodies are preserved before and after being sent home. Embalming only takes place after a body reaches the East Coast. For the flight, the article said, bodies are packed in ice. I could only think: Gee, my kid never liked to be cold.

My thoughts also take on a more banal cast. When I see a young couple smiling at one another, I can only hope when our son comes home he will also do this. When I see young men in their mid-20s drinking and laughing in a restaurant bar I want to say, "How dare you laugh when my son is doing what you should be doing?" Perhaps the most wistful of moments occurred while sitting with a group of parents at a high school track meet. They were anguishing over their children's upcoming SAT tests. I wanted to laugh and tell them I'd trade worries with them, but of course I didn't. At that moment I got a hint of what grandparents must feel.

Fear often gets replaced by pride when I'm reminded that I have (along with his mother and my wife) produced an alpha male -- Ranger, paratrooper, battle-hardened soldier. I contrast this with the memory of watching a country collapse (South Vietnam) because young men only wanted to ride around on motor scooters, not move to contact (with the enemy), as my son expresses it.

Conversations with people who watched him grow up run the spectrum. "I hope he's all right or will be all right," being the best. "What does he think of the war?" being the worst. How can I explain, nicely, that soldiers in combat don't ask large questions, at least not my soldier. It's flattering when he solicits my advice, but having never been in charge of, as he is, 45 men and four 20-ton armored personnel carriers (Stryker Vehicles), I can only answer his questions -- an example being my thoughts about enlisted hazing rituals -- by telling him to do what he thinks is best. I just listen.

What gets the most worrisome is vagueness. In his first of three months, it was FOB this and FOB that. Lately, as his unit has gone south to Najaf, it's been, "I'm at an FOB." Which one? Where? I ask. "Watch the news," he tells me. So I do, and when the Army decides to assault Najaf and if U.S soldiers are killed, I can only hope it's somebody else's kid. It gives me no pleasure to say that, but it's the brutal truth.

Richard Hanlin is a North Beach landlord and the father of a paratrooper.
 
perdita said:
When the coalition announces that a soldier has been killed, the name is withheld for a couple of days. Which means that because you know where he is, his unit, the names of his officers and men, you end up hourly searching the Web for a name to go with the bad news.
A note for the family of soldiers in the field: If you find the name of the fallen soldier on the internet, it won't be your son/daughter.

They are usually pretty good at making sure that the family hears the news directly rather than allowing them to find out on the internet/TV/newspaper.

If it were actually your own son, the name wouldn't be on the internet until you (or your daughter in law) had received a knock on the door.

Actually, that can make it harder. When a wife/mother/father/husband opens the front door to see two dress uniforms with their covers in hand, they know immediately what has happened.
 
We often forget how difficult it is for the loved ones left behind when a soldier goes off to fight. What's the old saying? "The not knowing is the hardest part"
 
Wildcard Ky said:
We often forget how difficult it is for the loved ones left behind when a soldier goes off to fight. What's the old saying? "The not knowing is the hardest part"

Do you forget? It's always the first thing I think of: the families left waiting
 
minsue said:
Do you forget? It's always the first thing I think of: the families left waiting

I think I do forget, though not intentionally. I usually look at it from the perspective of the one that leaves. When I was in the military, I was the one that was leaving.

I think people tend to look at things from the perspective of their own life's experiences. My experiences were of being the one leaving, not the one left behind.
 
I don't have a son there, but I do have two nephews over there, fighting. And one young cousin that won't be coming home.

The waiting is awful. I see the news and then have to wonder, and wait, and hope someone will remember to call me either in their joy that they escaped harm this time, or their grief that they didn't.
 
perdita said:
When I see young men in their mid-20s drinking and laughing in a restaurant bar I want to say, "How dare you laugh when my son is doing what you should be doing?"


I'd say that THEY are doing what HE should be doing.
 
Re: "When your child goes to war"

quote:
Originally posted by perdita
When I see young men in their mid-20s drinking and laughing in a restaurant bar I want to say, "How dare you laugh when my son is doing what you should be doing?"




I'd say that THEY are doing what HE should be doing.

Yeah, my brother is over there, but I'm not sure I agree that all young men should be in the service. There are many ways to serve your country - work hard, pay your taxes, do community service. It's a volunteer Army, so only the men and women who want to be soldiers should do it.
 
Not that it matters...said the turtle on Neverending Story...but, I am about 700 pages into writing a novel...currently the Chief, the leader, is returning with his remaining men from a battle.

He worries and wonders how to tell his villagers about the 'braves' that fell in battle. He thinks of how to tell the newly wedded young maiden in his lodge, that her mate was injured, protecting him, the Chief.

He wonders how to tell his mother and the Elders of his village, why so many lives were lost.

It was a problem, even then, not just for leaders, but for mothers and fathers and kin, long before the 'stylized ritual' of modern times.

There are no answers...we do the best we can...and then continue on...hoping for the best...day by day.

amicus
 
I'm a combat veteran of the United States Army, but I don't think I would ever allow a child of mine to enter the military--certainly not under this administration.
 
Clare Quilty said:
I'm a combat veteran of the United States Army, but I don't think I would ever allow a child of mine to enter the military--certainly not under this administration.

I get so furious when I see how this administration mistreats veterans and our active duty troops, I can barely see straight.

You said it better than I can, Clare.

And thank you for your service to my country. Vets don't hear that enough, in my opinion.

:rose:
 
KarenAM said:
I get so furious when I see how this administration mistreats veterans and our active duty troops, I can barely see straight.

You said it better than I can, Clare.

And thank you for your service to my country. Vets don't hear that enough, in my opinion.

:rose:

What chafes my bottom is that no members of the Senate, and I believe even the House, have a child in harm's way in Iraq-- not to mention the Bush cabinet. Working class kids are apparently quite disposable in the eyes of the powers that be, but not so their priviledge progeny.

Thanks, but were it not for the fact that I worked in a medical capacity and so assisted in saving lives, I would be inclined to believe that my wartime military service served only to reunite the despotical Amir of Kuwait with his golden toilet-- and of course the several aims of Skull & Bones and The Carlyle Group.
 
Back
Top