When/how does a bug become a feature?

AG31

Literotica Guru
Joined
Feb 19, 2021
Posts
5,478
I became curious about what Michael Connelly (Harry Bosch fame) was doing with his style. It was engaging and compelling. But he was ignoring all kinds of advice we hear for writers. He showed an extreme avoidance of show, don't tell. There is virtually no point at which he describes how a person is feeling. In the rare instances where he goes there, it sounds like a newspaper report. He visits a comatose colleague in the hospital because "he wanted to go and show his support even if she didn't know he was there." He's going to invite his SO to join him on an investigative hike, "Plus he would enjoy her company." Those are actually the only references to emotion I can remember in the first 75 pages.

Vary your sentence structure. Almost all of his sentences are plain declarative, occasionally introduced by an "As..." phrase.

He mostly avoids dialogue tags altogether, usually 2 to 4 per page. That's not exactly ignoring good advice, but I've yet to see him use anything but "asked" and "said." Variety, variety, variety. Isn't that what we're supposed to strive for?

The result of this dry, low key approach is to make me think of those true crime shows, where the narrator speaks almost in a monotone. I call on the ancient among us to remember Dragnet. "Just the facts, ma'am."

So how does all this result in a distinctive, attractive style, instead of an amateurish, klunky story it would be hard to get published.

One thing, of course, is the story itself, the action. It's a good story, and every sentence moves it ahead. But why doesn't this succeed only in spite of the writing style? It has something to do with intentionality, I think, but I can't go further than that.

Can you articulate what moves a book like this into the realm of a really good read?

Can you think of other kinds of ignoring the best advice and coming up with a gem?
 
I don't agree with your assessment of Connelly at all. I think Connelly is a skillful author of crime stories who writes in a style that is more or less consistent with the style associated with crime fiction for the last 90 years.

"Variety, variety" does not apply to dialogue tags. The standard rule in actual published fiction is primarily to use "asked" and "said," and there's good reason for that. Connelly, like other authors, avoid dialogue tags when they are unnecessary to establish who is speaking, but otherwise uses "asked" and "said." Crime authors like Elmore Leonard do the same thing.

It's not quite true that his style does not reveal Bosch's feelings. Most of the novels I've read are told in the third person, limited to Bosch's perspective. Bosch's thought processes and feelings are revealed, but the narrator doesn't explore his internal thought processes in depth. But this is consistent with the long-standing tradition of the stoic detective. The classic stoic detective has an inner life, but doesn't reveal it willingly, either to others around him or to the reader.

I think his novels are very good reads, because they shift attention away from the words themselves to the story. The style is understated and spare, but still fairly traditional in the vein of other crime/detective stories. The story is what matters.
 
A bug is a feature if the writer intended it. That doesn't necessarily mean that it works, or make for a good story, of course.

First and foremost, a story has to be compelling, and the writer needs a good understanding of how their words affect the reader's experience. Following all the writing advice in the world doesn't guarantee a good story, or even an enjoyable read.

I'd say that it's important to know what kind of story you're writing, what the reader is looking for in that kind of story, and choose a style that fits. Then you can eliminate any advice that isn't necessary for achieving that style, and focus on highlighting the elements that are.
 
I don't agree with your assessment of Connelly at all. I think Connelly is a skillful author of crime stories who writes in a style that is more or less consistent with the style associated with crime fiction for the last 90 years.
I'm not sure I would disagree with this. How do you see it as a disagreement?
"Variety, variety" does not apply to dialogue tags. The standard rule in actual published fiction is primarily to use "asked" and "said," and there's good reason for that. Connelly, like other authors, avoid dialogue tags when they are unnecessary to establish who is speaking, but otherwise uses "asked" and "said." Crime authors like Elmore Leonard do the same thing.
Interesting about variety and tags. I don't believe I've heard that advice, although I do acknowledge that other authors use the same sort of style as Connelly.
It's not quite true that his style does not reveal Bosch's feelings.
I didn't actually say that. I quoted two places where they are revealed. I was just pointing out that they were "told" not "shown." Actually, those places pack more punch for their rarity. Another way feelings are revealed is simply in the dialogue.
Most of the novels I've read are told in the third person, limited to Bosch's perspective. Bosch's thought processes and feelings are revealed, but the narrator doesn't explore his internal thought processes in depth. But this is consistent with the long-standing tradition of the stoic detective. The classic stoic detective has an inner life, but doesn't reveal it willingly, either to others around him or to the reader.
Not sure it's relevant, but the novel I was reading was a Catalina Island story, not Bosch based. And, to repeat, I wasn't saying at any point that no other authors use the same technique. Just that it seems to ignore conventional wisdom. In a good way.
I think his novels are very good reads, because they shift attention away from the words themselves to the story. The style is understated and spare, but still fairly traditional in the vein of other crime/detective stories. The story is what matters.
I totally agree.
 
It has something to do with intentionality, I think, but I can't go further than that.

I'd say that it's important to know what kind of story you're writing, what the reader is looking for in that kind of story, and choose a style that fits.
On further reflection, I think the degree to which one can name the style governs whether the style is working or not (eliminating, of course, "klunky" and "amateurish"), whether it can be called a style. Connelly's most definitely can. After starting this thread I realized I'd posted a related one back in August, asking us all if we could name our own style and whether or not it was intentional. I bet Connelly could have said to himself, as he embarked on his career, "I'm going to write in the style of Dragnet." (Not sure if he's that old.)
 
I stopped reading for a long time after I started writing. I couldn't turn off the writer in me enough to enjoy the story. This was for mainstream and Lit.

About a year ago, I started reading again, both in Lit and mainstream. The most important thing I've noticed with my new (very old) eyes is that everything that's discussed in the threads here as being proper writing technique is pretty much wrong.

The single most important aspect of a story is its plot. An author can write like shit, but if the reader keeps wanting to know what the hell is going to happen next, they'll keep going and be satisfied.

I found it very interesting reading one of the threads here about dialogue tags. At the time, I was reading last year's Booker Prize winner (I think). One paragraph in the novel had dialogue from three different people, no 'dialogue tags, but with lots of narrative language between the quotes. It was absolutely clear who was speaking and how that affected the plot. That paragraph violated pretty much everything everyone said about dialogue, yet was great.

Andy Weir's The Hail Mary Project is an ungodly mess of obvious authorial duct tape and baling wire. But I've read it twice because, despite that clunky style, he keeps me wanting to find out what happens next.
 
"Show, don't tell," "vary your sentence structure," and "use dialogue tags to tell readers who's saying something" are good advice in a very general sense, but they're particularly good advice to novice or amateur writers like most Literotica writers.

Novice or amateur writers might not have ever got that advice before (some people start writing without even taking classes on it!), might not think of it on their own, and might not have any idea how to do it until someone else points out examples of it. Therefore they're good bits of advice to offer early and often, even if they aren't absolute laws. Sorry if this sounds condescending, but just browse New sometime, or Random in a given category, and ignore anything that isn't identified as a later chapter of a series. There is a lot of very amateurish stuff out there, and that's fine; everyone starts somewhere and many writers don't want or need to take it beyond a hobby.

Michael Connelly is not a new or amateurish writer, though. He has picked his style and had time to cultivate it. He knows other ways to make it clear who's speaking besides dialogue tags, as people have already pointed out. "Show, don't tell" is good advice for fiction writers like "poetry should rhyme" is good advice for poets, and Michael Connelly is more than capable of the prose equivalent of free verse if he chooses.
 
On further reflection, I think the degree to which one can name the style governs whether the style is working or not
And on yet further reflection, I think this works because you have a standard to test your writing choices against. For reasons which the brain can't articulate, but can recognize, some rule breaking works to achieve your goal, and some doesn't.
 
Interesting about variety and tags. I don't believe I've heard that advice, although I do acknowledge that other authors use the same sort of style as Connelly.
This is common, standard advice by published authors and professional fiction editors. Elmore Leonard wrote a book about the "10 Rules" of writing, and one of them is to avoid substitutes for the words "said" and "asked." Stephen King said something similar in his writing book. Benjamin Dreyer, chief copy editor at Random House, said something similar in his book about editing and writing, "Dreyer's English."

More often than not, replacing "said" with a more high-flown word is a form of telling, not showing. "Showing" entails revealing the dialogue through the spoken words of the character, rather than through the tag. Often, fancy tags come across as amateurish because they are redundant and unnecessary. Example:


"I think the wife did it," Jason revealed.

"I agree," Detective Smithers concurred.

Yuck. "Said" is the obviously superior choice in these two cases.


Just that it seems to ignore conventional wisdom. In a good way.

This is where I push back somewhat, because I think of Connelly as a very good example of a "conventional writer" among detective/crime novelists. The way he writes is, IMO, conventional and non-buggish. He's restrained about showing the main character's inner feelings, but that's common in this genre because that's the way the hard-boiled detective usually is. He can't do it through dialogue, because a standard feature of these characters is that they don't openly share their inner feelings with the people they deal with in the story. They hold their cards close to the vest. So the way to do it is to reveal inner thoughts and feelings in a spare, almost flat style. That's common. You can see it in Phillip Marlowe and Sam Spade from over the stories of over 80 years ago.
 
There is virtually no point at which he describes how a person is feeling.
Isn't that exactly what "show don't tell" is?

I read that author, and for your thesis to be true, we readers would have to not know at all what any characters are feeling. I think he does employ "show don't tell," because not knowing how characters are feeling is not at all how I experience these stories - even though he didn't tell me. He showed me.
 
Last edited:
Isn't that exactly what "show don't tell" is?

I read that author, and for your thesis to be true, we readers would have to not know at all what any characters are feeling. I think he does employ "show don't tell," because not knowing how characters are feeling is not at all how I experience these stories - even though he didn't tell me. He showed me.
I don't understand. Examples? What about the examples I gave? Even though he doesn't describe their feelings, we pretty much know their feelings because of their actions and conversation.
 
I don't understand. Examples? What about the examples I gave?
What about the examples you gave? Those are examples of telling not showing. That doesn't mean he doesn't show-not-tell. It just means he didn't do it there.

Even though he doesn't describe their feelings, we pretty much know their feelings because of their actions and conversation.
And that's showing not telling, isn't it.

He showed an extreme avoidance of show, don't tell.
This is what I was responding to. I don't find it to be extreme, or avoidance, or true. And that's what I was trying to say.
 
I pulled a Connelly book, The Black Echo, off my shelf.

Here's an example:
Bosch wondered what Lewis and Clarke were doing. Did they expect that he would break some law or cop rule with an FBI agent in tow: He began to wonder if the two IAD detectives weren't just hotdogging on their own time. Maybe he wanted to see them.

This is not an example of "telling, not showing." The author is narrating Bosch's thoughts exactly as they happen, which is as close to showing as you can get to reveal interior thoughts. "Showing" interior thoughts does not necessarily mean manifesting them in an exterior way. That wouldn't be possible with respect to all thoughts, because most interior thoughts are not revealed, and trying to express them that way by having Bosch communicate his thoughts to other people would seem forced and false, and untrue to his character. The manner in which the story narrates what Bosch does, says, and thinks reveals his character. That, too, is showing.

Connelly's novels are dominated by straightforward narration of events, which is showing, not telling, and dialogue between characters, which is also showing, not telling.

It seems pretty conventional to me, and not at all rule-defying.
 
You can't show anything without telling something else, and generally you can't tell stuff without showing other stuff - unless you make a deliberate effort.

Choosing which stuff to show and which stuff to tell is a feature of authorship. You can't do all-show, unless you want to be like this guy. And even he's telling something.

1795115461456.png
 
Last edited:
What about the examples you gave? Those are examples of telling not showing. That doesn't mean he doesn't show-not-tell. It just means he didn't do it there.
In the first 75 pages I didn't remember seeing any instance of describing feelings. If describing feelings isn't showing, what is?
And that's showing not telling, isn't it.
It's setting up an implication of feelings. It's not describing feelings.
 
If describing feelings isn't showing, what is?
Describing feelings is telling.

Showing is giving the reader some lines they can read between. Telling is whatever the lines actually say.

It's setting up an implication of feelings.
This. This is what "showing" is. The implication, not the statement. The reader can see it, even though they aren't reading it.
 
These conversations can seem vexing, because it's not always completely clear what's telling and what's showing, and people can disagree. I have a tendency to enjoy disagreement, which makes things worse (for some, not for me).

Here are some examples I see between telling and showing:

Telling: Joe was sad.
Showing: Joe cried.

But if you're dealing with a stoic character who doesn't show much emotion, or if in a particular scene you only want to convey what's going on inside and not show it on the outside, then you're stuck with doing something that can look like both: narrating what's going on inside the person's head, but without any outward, physical manifestation of it. There's nothing wrong with that. You do what you have to in the circumstances. The needs of the story, more than anything, dictate the choice of words.
 
I don't understand. Examples? What about the examples I gave? Even though he doesn't describe their feelings, we pretty much know their feelings because of their actions and conversation.
I'll join in with a hypothetical example, if I may?

Telling: Bosch was stressed. He had a headache and his neck hurt. He hadn't felt so helpless in a long time. 'What do I do now?' He said out loud, to no one.

Showing: Bosch reached up and massaged his temples for a bit, his eyes clenched tight. He let his hand drift to the back of his neck, sighing with mild relief as the muscles relaxed slightly under the self-massage. He stared at the ground and shook his head. 'What do I do now?' He said out loud, to no one.
 
Describing feelings is telling.
I think it's showing. It's not saying, "He was angry," it's saying, "Bile rose in his throat and his vision blurred."
Showing is giving the reader some lines they can read between. Telling is whatever the lines actually say.


This. This is what "showing" is. The implication, not the statement. The reader can see it, even though they aren't reading it.
I don't think revealing states of mind through conversation is either telling or showing.
 
I'll join in with a hypothetical example, if I may?

Telling: Bosch was stressed. He had a headache and his neck hurt. He hadn't felt so helpless in a long time. 'What do I do now?' He said out loud, to no one.

Showing: Bosch reached up and massaged his temples for a bit, his eyes clenched tight. He let his hand drift to the back of his neck, sighing with mild relief as the muscles relaxed slightly under the self-massage. He stared at the ground and shook his head. 'What do I do now?' He said out loud, to no one.
And revealing: "No, I'll be OK. Just give me a minute."
 
Well, you have the case of incorrect grammar and misuse of words, which would normally be a bug, but you stick it in dialogue and it becomes a feature of voice, or in the narrative too, honestly, and it can be used as a way to denote voice, degree of formality, and vibe.
 
Back
Top