Sean Renaud
The West Coast Pop
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2004
- Posts
- 59,599
1. As long as you win the fight I'm down. Kick his ass!
2. For you're next three posts my opinion in the end comes down to this. You're putting WAY too much thought into areas that don't particularly need them. I for one don't want to have to dig through (no I didn't click the link. I'm just assuming a large number) how ever many words everytime I cast a spell. Granted my charachter is kinda different but still.
The just writing, chanting the spell, is good. At least for everyday spells. I like the idea of having a specific chant for an enormous spell. Or maybe for new comers/weaker wizards. Example: There is no chanting really for a fire ball, there's just fireball goddamnit! But summoning a demon requires a whole ritual where you put your right hand in and take your right hand out, put your right hand in. . .(I can see you getting annoyed and it makes me smile.) Point made?
I don't think making up words is a good idea UNLESS we are going to have it where magic is intensely personal and while you may associate fireball with fireball I might associate it with Ignite, and someone else with Hell. It's just the word, or talisman that is most associated with that spell to that person. Sounds overly complex to me.
I don't particularly like the idea of all magic being thought based. Reason being that if wizards (and you've already given us a breif demonstration in your first post of just how powerful you are) how the hell does someone disarm you? It becomes problematic at the least.
i do like your idea of the runes being etched in the mind. That way maybe we can drug you and wipe you.
3. Different typs of magic are neat but i didn't see anything here that I think was worth the energy you put in.
Are there different rules for each? Like perhaps alchemical rules still follow the basic physics of matter cannot be destroyed or created only changed? So if you want to make an elephant you need two thousand pounds of SOMETHING?
Do enchantments need to be powered by something, a crystal, a life, sunlight?
Aside from Necromancy=Bad I don't see WHY you defined them.
2. For you're next three posts my opinion in the end comes down to this. You're putting WAY too much thought into areas that don't particularly need them. I for one don't want to have to dig through (no I didn't click the link. I'm just assuming a large number) how ever many words everytime I cast a spell. Granted my charachter is kinda different but still.
The just writing, chanting the spell, is good. At least for everyday spells. I like the idea of having a specific chant for an enormous spell. Or maybe for new comers/weaker wizards. Example: There is no chanting really for a fire ball, there's just fireball goddamnit! But summoning a demon requires a whole ritual where you put your right hand in and take your right hand out, put your right hand in. . .(I can see you getting annoyed and it makes me smile.) Point made?
I don't think making up words is a good idea UNLESS we are going to have it where magic is intensely personal and while you may associate fireball with fireball I might associate it with Ignite, and someone else with Hell. It's just the word, or talisman that is most associated with that spell to that person. Sounds overly complex to me.
I don't particularly like the idea of all magic being thought based. Reason being that if wizards (and you've already given us a breif demonstration in your first post of just how powerful you are) how the hell does someone disarm you? It becomes problematic at the least.
i do like your idea of the runes being etched in the mind. That way maybe we can drug you and wipe you.
3. Different typs of magic are neat but i didn't see anything here that I think was worth the energy you put in.
Are there different rules for each? Like perhaps alchemical rules still follow the basic physics of matter cannot be destroyed or created only changed? So if you want to make an elephant you need two thousand pounds of SOMETHING?
Do enchantments need to be powered by something, a crystal, a life, sunlight?
Aside from Necromancy=Bad I don't see WHY you defined them.
.