The List

John:

"Then we'll get other kinds of fun"

"You go talk with Christine, I'll get Brice. Her class ends at 11. "

"Alright, be sure to let me know how it goes. I will do the same."

With that, he pretended to read a book as Mary walked away. While paying close a

Brice:

Brice was more than surprised at the sight of Mary, yet as upset as he was in regards to the situation with Christine, he was also very horny, he should have been fucking her hours ago, and even if Mary wasn't as hot as Christine, she had alot to be proud of.

So when Mary was smiling and caressing his bicep, his cock twitched, and his mind begun to make excuses.

"I'm glad you said that, you had me really turned on, but I couldn't let my sister alone when she was so upset."

He tried to prevent it, but his eyes were already taking in her body.

"Would you like to come in?"
 
Mary

Mary feigned a sympathetic look. "Yeah, I know. I feel absolutely terrible to. It was just...you had me so turned on and wet, it was hard to actually concentrate on my friend." She continued caressing his bicep, seeing the sort of effect it had on him.

She fought back a grin as his eyes roamed over her body. Apparently, he wasn't so stuck on his sister (literally) to ignore the charms of another beautiful woman.

"I'd love to. I mean, I have some time before my first class. It starts at 12. That gives us... how many hours to.... 'talk' things over?" She grinned and winked at him.

It was obvious by the way the two were looking at each other there'd be a lot less talking and much more doing.

Christine

Christine tried to focus hard on her history test but those texts kept bugging her. Who would black mail her? Why would they want to? Once she finally focused on her test, she began answering the questions with assured confidence that she knew the material.

However, it took her until the end of class time, 11 am to finish.

When she finished, she put her test on the professors desk, grabbed her books, and started out of the door.
 
Brice

The idea of Mary turned on and wet was too much to pass on, and it crowded Brice's mind as they went into his room. He offered her a seat, they needed to seat to talk after all... yet that he offered his bed rather than a chair talked about what was to come.

"You had me hard as a rock too, it's a shame we never got to find out just how wet and hard we were"

While she played with his arm, his other hand was softly caressing her neck, slowly making it's way down to her breasts.

John

John was outside the history class at 11, he was very glad none of the other Christine fans were there.

As soon as he saw her he reached for her "Christine! Hi" His hand was on her shoulder, and images of how her breasts felt in his hands rushed through his head.

"Hope your exam went well. I wanted to talk to you, we never got to finish our date... I'm sorry I left... I just wasn't sure what to do, hope I didn't embarrass you... would you let me make it up to you?"
 
Mary

"Yeah, it is a shame.." She said, leaning back against his bed. She smiled lustfully, "Perhaps, we can...start all over again." Her hand that had been caressing his arm, moved up his shoulder, then down his chest ever so slowly.

"Unless, you have...something else to do. I hope not because, I'd rather you do me." She grinned, certainly unshy about her advances.
~~

Christine

She blinked for a few seconds slightly fazed by the fact that John had met her at her class. Normally, her brother was here waiting. She suddenly remembered that she told him to stay away for awhile.

"Oh, its okay. It was slightly embarrassing though. Ya know, getting ready to have sex and your brother is in the room doing the same thing with your roommate. I'm okay though." She said, brushing it off. This was something she could do, she couldn't easily control her brother but someone like John was a piece of cake.

Christine gave him her trademark smile, "And how were you thinking of making it up to me?"
 
Brice

He didn't answer, he just moved over her and kissed her, his hand stopped moving slowly and met the other one as he started to rub her breasts through her clothes. His tongue made it's way to play with hers, and her pressed his bulge against her, letting her feel how hard she had made him.

"I think I can fit you in my busy schedule, think I can fit in you?" he asked as he pressed even harder.

John

"Maybe we could resume our date" He said reaching for her hand "Where were you heading right now? The least I can do is walk you back to your dorm... or is there somewhere else you would rather go?"

John was trying to act cool, but Christine's attractiveness plus the fact that he hadn't gotten any relief during their date, and hearing her have sex with nobody else but her brother... he wanted nothing else than to be inside her right now.
 
Mary whimpered into the kiss and returned it, allowing him to explore her mouth while she too explored his with her tongue. Her tongue glided over the roof of his mouth. She could feel his bulge pressing against her thigh which only made her moans grow as he pulled away.

She grinned at his question and little innuendo, "Oh I'm sure you be able to fit me in...somewhere." She winked at him, pulling him towards his couch. Her nipples poked through the thin materials of her top.

It was no secret that she'd had a crush on Brice since forever and if John and her plan worked, she'd end up being his girlfriend.

~~~

Christine glanced down at the hand he'd grabbed and resumed her calm, yet seductive smile. "I was actually going to head to the library and study. I think I might have failed my test. I was too busy thinking about you..." She lied, easily while running a single finger down his chest.

"However, I think studying can wait. We can definitely resume our date if you'd like or...we can go back to my dorm and maybe you can help me study." She leaned forward and nipped playfully at his earlobe signifying that they probably wouldn't be studying.
 
As he felt her nipples he begun to roll them between his fingers, pinching them lightly, testing how rough she liked it He kept pressing his bulge hard against her, hoping she would release him from his pants.

He broke the kiss and started to kiss and lick around her neck, even biting softly, once again testing if she liked it rough.

He heoped she liked it the same way he did... the way Christine did, if she could take her place it would make it easier to stay away from his sister

~~~

The nip on his earlobe almost made a moan escape his lips.

"I think I can help you study... I know a few tricks you haven't tried yet, I'm sure they can make you relaxed."

He knew she was lying about thinking about him, but it was a nice lie, one that made him feel good and slightly turned on. Most of all he wanted to believe it, so he didn't questioned it.

As they made their way to her room, he was already picturing what was going to happen in his head.
 
Mary

Mary gasped sharply as his fingers found her nipples and began tugging a bit roughly. She had never been the type of girl who was into pain. However, if Brice liked it then she would certainly fake liking it.

Her head fell back with another groan of pleasure as he began trailing kisses down her neck, licking it, and then nipping at it gently. It wasn't too hard, so it didn't make her cry.

Part of the reason she didn't get many dates was because she wasn't as kinky as Christine was.

~~

Christine

"Oh you do?" Fantasies rolled through her head as he mentioned tricks he could show her. She smirked as she began pulling him towards her dorm room. Once there, she stood on her tip toes and whispered hotly in his ear, "Well, I've always loved learning new things."

She unlocked the door before making any move on John, she called "Anyone here?" there was a moment of silence.

It was just the two of them. She shut the door and locked it.

"All alone...so what are these tricks you wanted to show me." She asked as she set her books down on the kitchen table. John would be the perfect distraction and she wanted to get distracted.
 
Brice

While Mary wasn't complaining, he realized she wasn't enjoying the bit of pain he caused, so he stopped the biting and just focused on licking and kissing, his fingers begun to just roll her nipples on his fingers.

And he kept rubbing his bulge against her, the hardon was starting to become painful, he needed to let it free, but he didn't want to stop massaging her tits.

"Get my cock out, it's time to see if it fits"

~~

John

Soon they were alone in her room, and she was asking about his tricks, he was just talking so he felt nervous for a second, a part of him was afraid of not measuring up to what Brice caused to her.

He reached and grabbed the back of her neck, pulling her in for a deep kiss. Maybe he wouldn't but he was good, and Brice wouldn't go near her as long as him and Mary had the file and could go public with it.

His other hand went to her breasts and begun to rub them, exploring them as moans escaped into their kiss. It was amazing how much she turned him on.

He begun to move her towards the couch. He wanted more.
 
Mary

When he finally stopped being so rough. Mary finally began to really enjoy herself. She moaned as he continued playing with her nipples, rolling them around. Her head fell back in pure delight as licked and sucked on her neck.

Her breathing became slightly more rapid. And then came his demand.

She grinned up at him and undid his zipper and pulled his cock out of his boxers, pushing them down past his legs a bit. She stroked it gently for a minute and smiled lustfully at Brice.

"I think it will, but maybe you should test it out?"

~~

Christine

The deep immediate kiss caught Christine by surprise for sure. She didn't pull away though. Instead, she only kissed him back. Grabbing the lapels of his shirt, pulling him on top of her they both fell on the couch him on top of her.

Her back arched into to him pushing her breasts towards him more as he rubbed and played with them.

She pulled away from the kiss, long enough to say "I love a man whos able to hand the control over to me. " Christine gave him a wink before pulling him back into the kiss.
 
Brice

He moaned as she caressed his cock, it felt very good for him to have it out of his pants, and of course her hands made it much better.

His hands started to undress her, and the second her breasts were freed, he leaned forward to lick and suck them, in his thoughts trying to convince himself that it was better than Christine so he focused on her bigger breasts.

As he finished undressing her... or more like as he finished exposing her pussy, he moved his hips with urgency, pressing the head of his cock at the entrance of her pussy. He didn't rush in, he started to tease her and himself by only rubbing it across the entrance.

~~

John

As he felt her breasts against him, he moaned into their kiss, then as she said she loved to be handed control, he felt no choice but to let her handle him. He wasn't particularly submissive, but he wasn't Brice who would probably had her regretting asking for control, what he really wanted was to be able to pleasure Christine as much as he could.
 
Mary

Mary leaned her head back as Brice teased her cunt with his cock, rubbing the head against her lips. Warily, she glanced towards the door, hoping no one would burst through and ruin the moment. He was hers now! As long as they had the files, he'd probably never want to be seen with his sister again.

"Please..." Mary whimpered. Her back arched as he licked and suckled on her breasts.

She didn't think she could handle his teasing her. Mary was just as slutty as Christine, if not more but unlike Christine, she made it perfectly obvious how much she enjoyed to be fucked while Christine gave subtle hints.

~~~

Christine

Despite the fact that she was used to having guys do anything she wanted, whether they wanted to or not. The past few days, she'd had to argue her way into control with her big brother.

Even that didn't work. She had to use her manipulative ways to get him to do what she wanted and had to make sure he thought it was his idea. Had she made this sort of demand with Brice the way she had with John, he would probably would've made the sex all the more rougher.

It made her heart lurch, made her realize that already she missed her brother. She forced a smile and managed to turn them around on the couch so that she was on top and began grinding against his crotch.
 
Brice

When she said please Brice stopped resisting, and shoved his hard cock deep into her pussy, he wanted it, even if his mind kept comparing her with Christine and finding more and more faults he still wanted her, even if to just fill in for his sister.

He didn't hold back, since he stopped teasing he just fucked her hard and far, trying to reach deeper and deeper, losing himself in the moment and trying to push away the thoughts of his sister.

~~~

John

John moaned loudly as she rubbed against him, he wanted to take out his cock and just pound her hard, but trying to please her he allowed her to be in control, so he contented himself with caressing her body and kissing her anywhere that he could reach.

His hands grabbed her breasts, and he softly rolled her nipples between his fingers, being very careful as he didn't want to hurt her, all the while looking at her face for her reaction.
 
Mary

Mary was sure she would be in pain by the time this was over and finished with. As he slid into her, it started out at a nice rhythm but only seemed to get rougher and rougher as he pushed deeper and deeper inside of her. This was what she wanted though, right?

Brice was the most popular guy on campus. Every girl that had been with him ranted and raved about how great he was in bed. Hell, even his sister had a piece of him. Brice owed her this and she would take as much as she could get for however long she could have him.

However, Mary whimpered in pain as he thrust deeper and deeper into her. She wasn't trying to show her displeasure but it was kind of hard. Biting her lip, she clutched onto his shoulder tightly. "I can handle it..." she said more to herself than to him.

~~~

Christine

This was not going quite as she planned. God, she used to be okay with this sorta sex. Her taking control but after having her brother it was like everything had been dull until now. Which in truth, it had been dull. Closing her eyes moaned though because she was still female and the feel of his throbbing member through those jeans of her rubbing against her drove her nuts.

As she slowly opened her eyes, she was picturing Brice beneath her holding onto control, letting her take the lead as he played with her tits. "Oh fuck..feels so good. I want you now..." she moaned. Her eyes were glazed over with lust as she pulled away from John and pulled her skirt down and unzipped his jeans.

She stroked him for a few moments and then straddled him guiding his cock inside of her wet pussy.
 
Last edited:
Brice

Brice was slightly worried that he was being too rough on Mary, and she must have felt that since she said she could take it, so he moved her, so that his cock would sink deeper into her as he kept fucking her hard and fast. He secretly wondered if he was reaching her deeper than anyone ever had.

"Oh Mary, it feels so good" it did... still there was something missing, it felt even better with Christine, and it didn't feel good to be missing her as he was with Mary, so he pretended she was Christine, just briefly he imagined her voice and her body, and because of that he was pumping even harder and faster.

~~~

John

John moaned loudly as she stroked him, and even louder when she guided him to her pussy, tried as he did, he couldn't resist pushing up as he felt her, entering her completely, she was incredibly wet, as if something had just really turned her on. John smiled thinking it was him, or her control over him.

He softly squeezed her breasts as he kept pushing his hips up to fuck her as she rode over him.
 
He was indeed inside her, deeper than any other guy had ever been. It was not a shock that he was such a high commodity when it came to sex. Mary now knew what all the girls talked about. She felt like she was literally being split in half by his cock.

"Yesssssss...." she moaned, forcing her body to get used to his cock so deep inside of her. Apparently, he was enjoying this alot because his thrusting became more rapid and harder. She shook from the pain and felt like she would gush all over him.

"Oh god, Brice...yeah, yeah, yeaah fuck that hot pussy." she whimpered and with each hard thrust, her breasts bounced and jiggled against his chest.

~~~

Christine kept her eyes closed for the time being as John pushed up into her. When he softly squeezed her breasts, she growled. No, no, nooooo!!! This fantasy wasn't working. How could it work if he was being so...submissive, damn it!!

He was a man, he was supposed to show that he didn't need her to guide him.

"Harder..." she whimpered as she continued bouncing up and down on his cock. "Harder, please play with em harder..."
 
"mmm yes..." he bit his tongue rather than saying a name, the last thing he wanted was to say his sister's name.

"It's my pussy, say it" he said as he kept pounding her as hard as he could "say it's mine" The feeling of her breasts bouncing against him plust the image of his sister turning him on beyond measure.

"I want you to cum all over my hard cock, and then I'm going to make you cum again." He told her before kissing her deeply as he moaned into their kiss

~~~

As she said harder John thought she meant his fucking, so he tried his best to push up hard as she went down, unwillingly he gripped her breasts harder, and as she clarified, he started to really squeeze and play with her nipples. He enjoyed it much more like this, but he still was seeking Christine's aproval at every turn.
 
She whimpered as his assaulting on her pussy never stopped. She bit her lip as the thrusting began to get harder and harder. Then he suddenly demanded that she tell him that her pussy was his. "Oh god, oh god, oh god..." she whimpered, pulled into pleasure so beyond measure that she could hardly speak.

He ordered it again, thrusting even harder inside of her.

"It's yours, its all yours, Brice." She whimpered

Then he claimed that he would make her cum over his cock and then make her cum again. She bit her lip whimpering even louder, her breathing getting harder and harder.

"So close..." she whimpered

~~~

For a moment, Christine was certain that he wasn't getting what she was saying. It was frustrating because Brice would've known. He would have tortured her tits until she was crying with pleasure.

Oh but not John and it pissed her off.

Finally, he seemed to get the hint as she began slam down on his cock over and over again.
 
"Let go, cum for me, I want to hear you scream" Brice seemed to order, his chest pressing hard against her breasts as he kept fucking her hard. Just as hard as he had fucked Christine, but it was different, his sister he fucked this hard because of how incredibly horny she drove him, with Mary it was almost as if it was anger at her for not being like Christine.

He kept moaning loudly, feeling her pussy squeezing him hard, and he kissed her deepy while he kept pounding hard.

~~~

Noticing the difference John started to be rougher, pinching her nipples, and twisting her breasts, slowly getting rougher and harder trying to see how rough Christine wanted it.

His hips kept pushing up, loving the tightness of her pussy, so he tried hard to fuck her as hard as he could from his position.
 
Back
Top