The"Knockout Game"

Are you out of your fucking mind?

Society also cannot function if we invoke criminal and civil penalties based solely on the degree to which we are outraged by a particular offense. The crime under which the stupidly cruel "knockout game" falls is that of a simple assault or perhaps in the case of the elderly victims, aggravated assault. The range of available penalties under either of these two charges is normally sufficient to cover the act of malice inherent in the crime.

It is not attempted murder for the simple reason that the overwhelming number of offenders are not attempting to kill anyone. If they were, they would presumably use a more effectively lethal weapon than their mere fist.

Additionally, detention under criminal insanity laws NEVER comes AFTER serving a criminal sentence because detention of the criminally insane is for rehabilitative rather than punitive purposes. In many cases, the accused may stand trial AFTER he has received mental health treatment and has been proven capable of understanding the gravity of the charges levied against him.

Your failure to recognize this standard methodology within the criminal justice system indicates that you might well benefit from a chat with a mental health professional concerning your anger issues.
Have you seen the videos? Would you feel the same if that were your sister who was hit from behind? You think I need help with my anger issue over this? Of course society can function if we invoke harsher punishment based on our proper outrage; much more so than if a scourge like this were to continue.
 
Have you seen the videos? Would you feel the same if that were your sister who was hit from behind? You think I need help with my anger issue over this? Of course society can function if we invoke harsher punishment based on our proper outrage; much more so than if a scourge like this were to continue.

yes we've all seen the videos and no he likely wouldn't feel the same if it was his sister. That's however exactly the point. Laws can't be based on our personal feelings.
 
Have you seen the videos? Would you feel the same if that were your sister who was hit from behind? You think I need help with my anger issue over this? Of course society can function if we invoke harsher punishment based on our proper outrage; much more so than if a scourge like this were to continue.

This is my point. Your rantings about attempted murder and denial of bail to someone charged with a non-lethal assault were not "proper." Proper outrage is not reliably derived based on how someone feels about a crime after they or their family have been a victim of it.

Civilized societies have largely decided that the proper response to criminal activity is to analyze the societal impact of individual crimes and essentially rank them from minor to the most severe and affix penalties accordingly and in advance of whatever emotional heat might overcome us in the moments immediately following their commission.

That's what civilized societies do.
 
That's the answer, a .45 and 230 grains of lead puts the proper price on the kind of viciousness these attacks represent. I see one mother fucker was drilled twice in Philly while trying this shit on an armed citizen. He lived and says, he won't be playing this game anymore.:rolleyes:

To be clear, nothing else I've written in this thread should be viewed as contradictory to my opinion that I have no problem with the above response whatsoever.

If someone comes up to you and slugs you in the face, you have no idea what their next act of violence might be, particularly if they appear to be part of a predatory group.

On the other hand, the fact that the act of self-defense is also rightly subjected to judicial scrutiny and that the second shot may be deemed excessive if the first shot is judged to have been or SHOULD have been sufficient to repel the attack is not contradictory to the philosophical basis of the defense itself.
 
This is my point. Your rantings about attempted murder and denial of bail to someone charged with a non-lethal assault were not "proper." Proper outrage is not reliably derived based on how someone feels about a crime after they or their family have been a victim of it.

Civilized societies have largely decided that the proper response to criminal activity is to analyze the societal impact of individual crimes and essentially rank them from minor to the most severe and affix penalties accordingly and in advance of whatever emotional heat might overcome us in the moments immediately following their commission.

That's what civilized societies do.

My mom usta point her pistol at guys who made lewd remarks to her. The gun had a wonderful effect on these guys.
 
This is my point. Your rantings about attempted murder and denial of bail to someone charged with a non-lethal assault were not "proper." Proper outrage is not reliably derived based on how someone feels about a crime after they or their family have been a victim of it.

Civilized societies have largely decided that the proper response to criminal activity is to analyze the societal impact of individual crimes and essentially rank them from minor to the most severe and affix penalties accordingly and in advance of whatever emotional heat might overcome us in the moments immediately following their commission.

That's what civilized societies do.

Like DUKE LaCrosse and G Zimmerman?
 
To be clear, nothing else I've written in this thread should be viewed as contradictory to my opinion that I have no problem with the above response whatsoever.

If someone comes up to you and slugs you in the face, you have no idea what their next act of violence might be, particularly if they appear to be part of a predatory group.

On the other hand, the fact that the act of self-defense is also rightly subjected to judicial scrutiny and that the second shot may be deemed excessive if the first shot is judged to have been or SHOULD have been sufficient to repel the attack is not contradictory to the philosophical basis of the defense itself.

Stand Your Ground/Castle Doctrine laws, do away with the "you could have let him run away" bullshit.
 
and N PEE R and NY SLIME say NO BIG DEAL

I know, lets talk ZIMMERMAN:cool:
 
These "Knockout Artists" should be found out, and have a dump truck run over they're legs, than set them free to play Basketball.
 
These "Knockout Artists" should be found out, and have a dump truck run over they're legs, than set them free to play Hockey.
 
NYC Democrat Says Jews Are To Blame For Racist Knockout Game Attacks…




According to NYC councilwoman-elect Laurie Cumbo (who is black), the unprovoked attacks represent a “genuine concern” about Jewish influence.

Via Daily Caller:


A local New York City politician and ally of mayor-elect Bill de Blasio says the recent spate of “knockout” attacks in Brooklyn may stem from “a genuine concern” about Jewish influence.

Laurie Cumbo, the councilwoman-elect for the Brooklyn neighborhood of Crown Heights, made the comments in an open letter posted to her Facebook page. In the letter, Cumbo reports that many of her African-American constituents are alarmed by the growth of the local Jewish community.

The resulting tension, she says, could have lead to a number of attacks on Jewish residents that bear the hallmarks of a “game” in which teens attempt to knock someone unconscious with one punch.

“Many African American/Caribbean residents expressed a genuine concern that as the Jewish community continues to grow, they would be pushed out by their Jewish landlords or by Jewish families looking to purchase homes,” Cumbo wrote. ”I respect and appreciate the Jewish community’s family values and unity that has led to strong political, economic and cultural gains… While I personally regard this level of tenacity, I also recognize that for others, the accomplishments of the Jewish community triggers feelings of resentment, and a sense that Jewish success is not also their success.”

Like mayor-elect de Blasio, Cumbo hails from the resurgent left wing of the city’s Democratic Party. De Blasio, who once volunteered to assist the radical socialist Sandinista movement in Nicaragua, will be New York City’s first Democratic mayor in 20 years when he’s inaugurated next month.
 
Back
Top