W
where
Guest
I haven't seen or read the book but whilst I do get why people who had this 'help' as children would have fond memories of the women that provided that help, The whole idea icks me out. Mr TRB's gran was from South Africa and they had lots of 'help'. Their attitude to the black people who worked for them was patronising and infantilising. As much as I cared for the old girl, every time she'd say "we loved our blacks and they loved us" I wanted to cave her head in.The myopia is ridiculous.
Right as I said, the book appears to have done a better job of conveying that than the movie did.
This thread has split consciousness. I'm not going to lie, the spectacle of people stroking themselves to memories of mammy is nauseating to me - but in the context of celebrating a movie that decries the oppression it's also baffling. It's as if they're saying it was a terrible thing, while at the same time consoling themselves with the idea that it really wasn't so bad. It would be interesting to try to understand, if I had more patience.
It's kind of like a false consciousness. Just like it can work to keep the oppressed in the dark about their oppression, so it also keeps the oppressor in the dark.
this. really this. It sounds like one of those Masters/PhD projects that went from being some useful social history into sentimental money-spinner.Good White Mediator making black story "OK" to tell = fuck you, I'm not seeing your movie or reading your book.