The Help

A tribute to who again?



My girlfriend's mom lived in Jackson Mississippi in the '60s. She saw The Help and said it was improbable because there is no way the white community would have let those women get away with the things they did. "People were beaten or killed for far less," she said. She seemed to feel confused that the story did not show the extreme danger those women were in. She felt the inaccurate portrayal was disrespectful of the civil rights movement. Clearly her mother's history and experience influenced her opinion of the story.




I didn't read the book, but I heard that it was laced with a lot more menace and fear. It was confusing when the trailer for the movie looked so fun and harmless.


The book made it very clear the women in the story were taking their lives in their hands in telling their stories, even though no names, not even that of the author of the book were being used. It was not presented as the white girl jogging merrily up to the maids and asking if she could interview them for her book. All that was done under cover of darkness and with great care that they not be found out. The Help was the telling of the story of making the fictional author's book possible. It may have not been written as hardcore as it could have been, but the point is well taken that these white women employers held a huge amount of power over the lives of their 'help', moreover, they were not afraid to use that power when crossed.
 
I loved the book, and in my opinion the movie only fell slightly short.

I couldn't help wonder though, that these white southern women took such pains to avoid sharing a bathroom, etc. but had no problem with them diapering, cuddling and mothering their children.

I understand that it's probably not the norm but I really don't understand how the children themselves, after such a nurturing relationship, can grow up to be so cold hearted...
 
Totally and if Michelle Obama really is "like all of the other black women in government housing", maybe you could hire her to help with the daily chores on your boat.

*muesli spew*

Oh shit. I bet she didn't see that one coming!

:D
 
I, for one, am very warm hearted towards the women who raised me. The 'help' was the norm in the '60's when I was raised and not so much in the '80's as I became a young man. The book was well written and I actually liked the movie. Again, I love and appreciate Gladys who literally raised me until the age of ten. Taught me well.:cool:

Gladys must have been a saint :)

The south I grew up in was South Florida in the '60s. A very different kind of south, yet we still had "help". Mostly the women were referees in sibling warfare...
 
We never had any help. I don't even have a maid service now. Don't want no strangers pawing through my stuff. Creeps me out.

Still, good book and decent movie. The pie thing will always bother me though. I really don't understand why they had to much such a huge deal of it in the movie.
 
My grandmother was an old school Virginia matriarch, and her "help" was with her for over half a century and was still tottering around cooking and cleaning when they were both in their late 80s. She had one of those cloying nicknames that's as Southern as hog and hominy. SHe raised about 8 kids in a tiny little, run down 2-room house-which my grandparents owned-- 50 yards from my grandmother's house.

We'd go there for supper when I was a little kid, and she'd ring a bell at the table and her servant would come out to serve the green beans or roast beef. I found it strange and uncomfortable, and as an adult I'm vaguely repulsed by the feudal servility of it all. My dad and uncles grew up with her and probably have a different take on it.
 
I have to admit I'm surprised how many people here had "help" when they were kids/younger. I didn't think it was that common unless you came from a rich family. That wouldn't have been us, whether we lived in the north OR the south.
 
*muesli spew*

Oh shit. I bet she didn't see that one coming!

:D

The myopia is ridiculous.


The book made it very clear the women in the story were taking their lives in their hands in telling their stories, even though no names, not even that of the author of the book were being used. It was not presented as the white girl jogging merrily up to the maids and asking if she could interview them for her book. All that was done under cover of darkness and with great care that they not be found out. The Help was the telling of the story of making the fictional author's book possible. It may have not been written as hardcore as it could have been, but the point is well taken that these white women employers held a huge amount of power over the lives of their 'help', moreover, they were not afraid to use that power when crossed.

Right as I said, the book appears to have done a better job of conveying that than the movie did.


This thread has split consciousness. I'm not going to lie, the spectacle of people stroking themselves to memories of mammy is nauseating to me - but in the context of celebrating a movie that decries the oppression it's also baffling. It's as if they're saying it was a terrible thing, while at the same time consoling themselves with the idea that it really wasn't so bad. It would be interesting to try to understand, if I had more patience.
 
A tribute to who again?



My girlfriend's mom lived in Jackson Mississippi in the '60s. She saw The Help and said it was improbable because there is no way the white community would have let those women get away with the things they did. "People were beaten or killed for far less," she said. She seemed to feel confused that the story did not show the extreme danger those women were in. She felt the inaccurate portrayal was disrespectful of the civil rights movement. Clearly her mother's history and experience influenced her opinion of the story.




I didn't read the book, but I heard that it was laced with a lot more menace and fear. It was confusing when the trailer for the movie looked so fun and harmless.


That was the one part of the movie that I felt came up a bit short--that it really failed to express how dangerous those times were, and those dangers went beyond merely the risk of losing your job. The movie was solid entertainment, though I think the notion of it as a likely Best Picture nominee is pretty ridiculous.



I have to admit I'm surprised how many people here had "help" when they were kids/younger. I didn't think it was that common unless you came from a rich family. That wouldn't have been us, whether we lived in the north OR the south.

We had a maid when my father was stationed overseas in the late '60s--and given that Dad was an Air Force captain with 4 kids, you can imagine how little money she must have made (her wage, I hasten to add, was not our choice but was dictated by the country where we were living). So I can relate to people here remembering their own "help" with affection from the perspective of having once been children in those homes, since I briefly lived in such an environment myself. But one would hope they appreciate that the system that made servitude about the best career those women could aspire to was all kinds of terrible.
 


Even today, when we gather, we reminisce about the chauffeur and cackle about the way he'd stick a cigar in his pipe and smoke it. There are stories about my grandfather's butler and the ladies in the doctor's office of whom it was said, "They knew more people at the Cotillion than anybody else."





 
I'm not going to lie, the spectacle of people stroking themselves to memories of mammy is nauseating to me - but in the context of celebrating a movie that decries the oppression it's also baffling. It's as if they're saying it was a terrible thing, while at the same time consoling themselves with the idea that it really wasn't so bad. It would be interesting to try to understand, if I had more patience.

oh come on! a woman loves you, reads you bedtime story, picks you up when you fall, holds you when you cry, kisses you geed night and is as much a mother to you as your real mother (if not more)... it would be creepier to have no fond memories.

it's not a fond memory of an oppressive and racist culture, it's not a political stance, it's a fond memory of the love of a warm and loving carer. and what woman who raised a child wouldn't want to be remembered like that?
 
oh come on! a woman loves you, reads you bedtime story, picks you up when you fall, holds you when you cry, kisses you geed night and is as much a mother to you as your real mother (if not more)... it would be creepier to have no fond memories.

it's not a fond memory of an oppressive and racist culture, it's not a political stance, it's a fond memory of the love of a warm and loving carer. and what woman who raised a child wouldn't want to be remembered like that?

She might like to be remembered that way by her own children.
 
She might like to be remembered that way by her own children.

that's true. but how does that negate the love they feel/felt for her or the comfort she gave them? those things were real and solid throughout their childhood. they don't vanish the day someone tells them about segregation.

a child is a child, whatever colour they are. if you bond with them and raise them with love then they'll have warm memories of you, whatever colour they are.

nobody has said they thought it was the right way to live. they've just said that they remember being loved as children by wonderful women.
 
Good White Mediator making black story "OK" to tell = fuck you, I'm not seeing your movie or reading your book.
 
Raised by nanny, that's what we called her till age of six when we moved from Biloxi to Philadelphia, PA.
 
that's true. but how does that negate the love they feel/felt for her or the comfort she gave them? those things were real and solid throughout their childhood. they don't vanish the day someone tells them about segregation.

a child is a child, whatever colour they are. if you bond with them and raise them with love then they'll have warm memories of you, whatever colour they are.

nobody has said they thought it was the right way to live. they've just said that they remember being loved as children by wonderful women.

During the same time in a different place my great grandmother, her sister and my grandmother at various points in their lives have been the help, in England, Canada and the United States (northern), this is in the 40's through the 70's.

When "Our Minnie", is also your mother's mother it's clear that the system they were tangled in was a thief. Maybe the grown ups in here recognize what was stolen. Who knows (who cares).
 
i took the evil teen to see it and she came out of there seething with rage and ranting. i think perhaps we expect to always see the sledgehammer approach constantly taken to depicting racism, when in reality it was a constant drip with sledgehammer moments. but to a young mind, someone who assumes (from her rather sheltered life) that equality just is, it was absolutely shocking.

quaking with rage.

livid.

it made me proud.
 
When "Our Minnie", is also your mother's mother it's clear that the system they were tangled in was a thief. Maybe the grown ups in here recognize what was stolen. Who knows (who cares).
you can recognise that but still feel warm & fuzzy when you remember being loved as a child.
 
Back
Top