It's no different. Muslims are not trying to create any "Shariatown."How messed up are you to pull up a 100+ year old Catholic experimental town as if the Pope was burning Protestants and Muslims in an auto da fe? Muslims try to create Shariahtown and you harken back to a failed 19th century village of Germans and Irish?
Controversy:
The announcement of the project sparked controversy and multiple political responses. On February 24, 2025, Texas Governor Greg Abbott publicly expressed opposition to the development, sharing concerns on social media platform X (formerly Twitter).[4] Abbott specifically stated: "To be clear, Sharia law is not allowed in Texas. Nor are Sharia cities. Nor are 'no go zones' which this project seems to imply." The governor's comments were in response to characterizations of the project as a "402-Acre Sharia City" by conservative commentator Amy Mek, though no public statements from the project organizers had overtly referenced implementing Sharia law or creating governance structures separate from existing U.S. laws.[2]
In response to the controversy, Community Capital Partners issued a statement affirming their commitment to comply with the Fair Housing Act, which prohibits discrimination in housing based on protected characteristics, including religion. The developers stated they would not impose "blanket bans on any group of people" but would conduct "thorough individualized assessments of prospective buyers" to ensure alignment with community goals of "safety and security."[2]
Project representative Yasir Qadhi emphasized that EPIC City was not intended to be isolated from the wider community, stating: "We are not forming a cult. We're not forming big barriers between the rest of society. We're going to be giving back to this state and this country, and we're going to be showing what it means to be a Muslim neighborhood."[2] The developers modified language on their website after questions from media, removing text that had indicated sales would be limited to "persons we believe will contribute to the overall makeup of our community."[4]
Local residents expressed concerns primarily related to infrastructure and environmental impacts rather than religious or cultural aspects of the development. Key concerns included increased traffic on narrow rural roads, environmental impacts on local ecosystems and wildlife, prominent construction-related noises and disruption, and additional strain on local resources and services.[4]
In April 2025, Gov. Abbott launched multiple state investigations of EPIC,[6] temporarily halting any construction from going forward. Many in the Islamic community believe these investigations are unfair, politically motivated and based on negative stereotypes of Muslims.[7]