The Departed

center_stage said:
Clearly the best movie of 2006, and should win best picture at the Oscars.

best line of last years Oscars

Jon Stewart - Three Six Mafia -- One. Martin Scorsese -- Zero.
 
I think I agree that it was the best film of 2006, but this doesn't mean it's a great film.
Goodfellas, also by Scorcese, was a better film but didn't even get nominated.
Scorcese has for a very long time been dipped in shit when it comes to the academy.
 
Somehow, I'm not loving this movie like everyone else is. When I saw it at the theatre I thought it was good, not great. I've seen several better movies from 2006 and this is certainly not Scorsese's best film.

I watched it again last night to see if my feelings changed any and I enjoyed it even less the second time. I can't really put my finger on what doesn't work for me but there are a lot of little glitches that bother me. The fight choreography is off in certain scenes; punches being thrown and clearly not hitting anyone. And when Nicholson smashes the boot on Dicaprio's broken arm, you can look and tell he's not really hitting him. From Scorsese, who's violence is usually quite intense and resonant, this comes off as sloppy and amateurish. Also, sound cues seem wrong; you see blood and brains flying from people's heads because the actual shot is heard.

Maybe I'm just nitpicking these technical details since I work as a tech myself, but they were enough to take me out of the moment. Also, the female lead wasn't good and had too much screen time. And the movie was too long. Perhaps if I hadn't seen the orginal a few years ago I wouldn't be so critical, but aside from some really great acting, this movie is rather standard.

I hate to say it but Scorsese really doesn't deserve an Academy Award for this effort even though he'll likely win it this time after getting shafted so often.
 
No Spoilers Whatsoever

Watched 'The Departed' last night and thoroughly enjoyed it. Didn't think it was too long at all.

Kept observing the backgrounds at the stores/pubs and such as Scorsese is so damn finicky with details (see 'The Age of Innocence'). Cracked up at some of Nicholson's lines. My god was he fabulous. Wahlberg's hair style got on my nerves and was it just me or did some of his lippy dialogue resemble the insults often shared here in Literotica within drama threads?

Leo's voice often gave me brain cramps. I know I know, I always bitch about his voice even though I think he's one of the best actors alive if not THEE best. Just wish it was more manly and not seemingly on the cusp of a boy spotting his pubes for the first time. Regardless, he was awesome in this awesome movie.

Surprise Surprise... I even liked Matt Damon in this! Have always figured him to have a vagina face but he blew me away last night. Saddens me to think that I've totally changed my tune about him because of this movie.

Also liked the chick in the film, maybe because I've never seen her work in any other picture or that she was simply appropriately casted. Medjay, you thought she wasn't good and got too much screen time? Hmmm. I thought her role was best in that it made you think she was going to be the cause for a bizarre love triangle that would shatter everything that the other two were up to. Her character, to me, provided more to the suspense level.

I give the film two hearty thumbs up!
 
Last edited:
i really want to see this film .So iam not reading this thread anymore.Just in case the plot is given away :confused:
 
Good movie, but definitely not better than Goodfellas. But they might give Scorsese the Oscar for it anyway - more as an honor for the body of his work, as they've done for some past winners.
 
Morcheeba said:
Medjay, you thought she wasn't good and got too much screen time? Hmmm. I thought her role was best in that it made you think she was going to be the cause for a bizarre love triangle that would shatter everything that the other two were up to. Her character, to me, provided more to the suspense level.

She just didn't really register with me. In the midst of so many other stellar actors, she just came off as rather muted. And I thought the whole romantic angle was not needed in the first place.

Also I didn't think she was pretty.
 
incognito said:
Good movie, but definitely not better than Goodfellas. But they might give Scorsese the Oscar for it anyway - more as an honor for the body of his work, as they've done for some past winners.

He's LONG overdue. Makes me fucking batty just thinking how the Academy shuns him.
 
medjay said:
She just didn't really register with me. In the midst of so many other stellar actors, she just came off as rather muted. And I thought the whole romantic angle was not needed in the first place.

Also I didn't think she was pretty.

I didn't think she was pretty at first, but her body turned out to be much better than I'd expected.
 
Back
Top