The "debate" here

KyleW

King Taint Kicker
Joined
Feb 3, 2003
Posts
16,327
Have you ever had someone actually change your mind? Have you changed anyone else's mind? Link examples.

And no, not examples of you listening to a song that was linked and deciding you like that music now and you were wrong about music in general.

I mean actual intellectual debates.


And let's assume no one has changed anyone's mind. Does it matter?
 
I used to think vettebirther had some of his facilities left but his actions over the past few years proved otherwise.

Vette wins!
 
Not to toot my own horn, but PC once said I changed his mind on the death penalty during a debate here. Though I can't seem to find it because the search is screwed or I don't know how to use it. Or because it never happened. I'm pretty sure it did though.

It was real to me, damnit.

Anyhow.
 
Internet debates suck because of the whole "link?? proof??" thing...but not for the reason you think. Because it's the internet, people assume that if you can't show "factual" substantiation--"proof"--for a point, what with all those sites out there, it must not be a valid one. So primacy is on the verifiable, the "proof"--no matter how shaky the source.

In matters of opinion, though, verifiability is not the prime currency; force and clarity of thought are. Those elements exist regardless of the size or scope of the internet.

Real debates--ones that shape or change the way the other person looks at an issue--need a common baseline. Are you discussing the reasons for an opinion you hold, or are you parsing the details of published facts?

The debates here almost always talk right past each other because someone with an "opinion" position engages someone with a "proof" position (flimsy as it may be). Like this:

"I hate guns, I wish they didn't exist." [Opinion]
"Oh yeah? Maybe you've forgotten we live in a country with a second amendment, where the Supreme Court has affirmed that guns have a right to exist. Here's the text, read it and weep." ["proof."]
"Are you saying you don't think we have a gun problem in this country?" [asking for opinion]
"I'm saying the courts have decided again and again that guns are a basic American right, and unless you're prepared to say why they're wrong, you don't have a leg to stand on." [asking for proof]
And so on.

And never the twain shall meet.

Also: Jizz.
 
Internet debates suck because of the whole "link?? proof??" thing...but not for the reason you think. Because it's the internet, people assume that if you can't show "factual" substantiation--"proof"--for a point, what with all those sites out there, it must not be a valid one. So primacy is on the verifiable, the "proof"--no matter how shaky the source.

In matters of opinion, though, verifiability is not the prime currency; force and clarity of thought are. Those elements exist regardless of the size or scope of the internet.

Real debates--ones that shape or change the way the other person looks at an issue--need a common baseline. Are you discussing the reasons for an opinion you hold, or are you parsing the details of published facts?

The debates here almost always talk right past each other because someone with an "opinion" position engages someone with a "proof" position (flimsy as it may be). Like this:

"I hate guns, I wish they didn't exist." [Opinion]
"Oh yeah? Maybe you've forgotten we live in a country with a second amendment, where the Supreme Court has affirmed that guns have a right to exist. Here's the text, read it and weep." ["proof."]
"Are you saying you don't think we have a gun problem in this country?" [asking for opinion]
"I'm saying the courts have decided again and again that guns are a basic American right, and unless you're prepared to say why they're wrong, you don't have a leg to stand on." [asking for proof]
And so on.

And never the twain shall meet.

Also: Jizz.

Bullshit.
 
"Debating" on the internet or at work or any other casual situation is mostly blowing off steam and screwing around. No one directly involved in the argument is going to change their view. There's little difference between arguing about the death penalty and arguing over whose team is going to win the Superbowl. People do it for amusement and to kill time.

But I think debates on issues are important for the lurkers. When I was younger, I had my opinions changed by that very persuasive and logical sentence buried in a thread full of name-calling and bullcrap. So even though you may feel it's a waste of time when you do go through the effort to source your claims and logically build a case only to have the other guy respond with ad hominem or a funny gif, there are people reading who may be swayed to your cause - people you've never met, who will go on to influence others.

It could happen!
 
"Debating" on the internet or at work or any other casual situation is mostly blowing off steam and screwing around. No one directly involved in the argument is going to change their view. There's little difference between arguing about the death penalty and arguing over whose team is going to win the Superbowl. People do it for amusement and to kill time.

But I think debates on issues are important for the lurkers. When I was younger, I had my opinions changed by that very persuasive and logical sentence buried in a thread full of name-calling and bullcrap. So even though you may feel it's a waste of time when you do go through the effort to source your claims and logically build a case only to have the other guy respond with ad hominem or a funny gif, there are people reading who may be swayed to your cause - people you've never met, who will go on to influence others.

It could happen!
Link? Cite??
 
This thread needs a Poets of the Fall song or something

http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?v=ZStQhKaSfm0&desktop_uri=/watch?v=ZStQhKaSfm0

Well excuse me

Who was it who wanted every sec of the fifteen minute flame of fame
A name to last for all eternity
Who was it who wanted ingratiation beyond definitions
When love alone is enough to set you free

No escaping though you're running, you cannot find home
Drowning in your desperation
Conviction seems to follow accusations alone
No place here for an easy redemption
If I lack your tears of joy, please forgive my heartless ploy
Said the fool to his majesty dethroned
Now excuse me

Who was it who wanted every sec of the fifteen minute flame
 
"Debating" on the internet or at work or any other casual situation is mostly blowing off steam and screwing around. No one directly involved in the argument is going to change their view. There's little difference between arguing about the death penalty and arguing over whose team is going to win the Superbowl. People do it for amusement and to kill time.

But I think debates on issues are important for the lurkers. When I was younger, I had my opinions changed by that very persuasive and logical sentence buried in a thread full of name-calling and bullcrap. So even though you may feel it's a waste of time when you do go through the effort to source your claims and logically build a case only to have the other guy respond with ad hominem or a funny gif, there are people reading who may be swayed to your cause - people you've never met, who will go on to influence others.

It could happen!
Spero 49er's Superbowl adipisci.
 
Back
Top