Stupid feedback...

[lovecraft68]

Yeah. On consideration, I'd omit Gay from my categories. Gay men are usually exceptionally tolerant and understanding. What I was trying to get at are people who are deep in the closet and highly conflicted about some secret desire or fantasy. They come here and read stories on the subject and then purge themselves of guilt by directing their anger at the author.

And you're right again. I'd say by far the majority of them are men, who feel their masculinity threatened by these desires and who are more likely to react with anger.

I don't work much in the high-risk categories. Most of the nasty FB I get is from men demanding my heroines be punished for being 'sluts,' or taking me to task for not being more cruel and sadistic in my BDSM stuff.

This is where I believe the really nasty incest feedback comes from. These guys get off to stories about sex with mom or sis which is something they have fantasized about, then get pissed they liked it and take it out on the author.

In GM, which I don't read, but my wife does, I see the occasional snotty remark(I love the feedback portal and read comments to stories I will never read) The wife has commented that although she don;t give a rats ass, the "every straight guy in the world secretly wants to suck cock" theory brings some of that nastiness on.

 

[Safe_Bet]

In GM, which I don't read, but my wife does, I see the occasional snotty remark(I love the feedback portal and read comments to stories I will never read)...

"The man doth protest too much, methinks."

 

[lovecraft68]

"The man doth protest too much, methinks."

Sorry to break it to you, but I am not a member of the closet rainbow brigade. I have no desire to play with parts I already have.

 

[carlieplum]

I don't get the point of posting negative feedback if something doesn't put lead in your pencil. If it doesn't, click to the next story. I rarely post feedback, but when I do it's about things like the main character's name changing three times in the story.

 

[Cruel2BKind]

I don't get the point of posting negative feedback if something doesn't put lead in your pencil. If it doesn't, click to the next story. I rarely post feedback, but when I do it's about things like the main character's name changing three times in the story.

I don't read stories as often as I used to, but when I do, if I don't like a story I quit early. I never have a chance to leave negative feedback because I wont read what I don't like.

The only times I have ever leave negative feedback is when the end makes me angry. I once read a story with absolutely fantastic buildup. I was getting more and more excited, and then it just ended. No sex scene, a clear end, so no possibility of another chapter. Just two pages of fantastic erotic buildup and an extremely brief ending.

I wasn't the only one who was angry. That author had an average score of 4.4-4.6 on most of his stories, but the one I read had a rating of 2.9 when I read it. It was like he wanted to fuck with us. But that was the one time I ever scored 1 on a story. The only scores I give are 4 and 5, because the only stories I finish are the ones I really like.

 

[Safe_Bet]

I don't read stories as often as I used to, but when I do, if I don't like a story I quit early. I never have a chance to leave negative feedback because I wont read what I don't like.

The only times I have ever leave negative feedback is when the end makes me angry. I once read a story with absolutely fantastic buildup. I was getting more and more excited, and then it just ended. No sex scene, a clear end, so no possibility of another chapter. Just two pages of fantastic erotic buildup and an extremely brief ending.

I wasn't the only one who was angry. That author had an average score of 4.4-4.6 on most of his stories, but the one I read had a rating of 2.9 when I read it. It was like he wanted to fuck with us. But that was the one time I ever scored 1 on a story. The only scores I give are 4 and 5, because the only stories I finish are the ones I really like.

I never leave negative comments on the stories I finish. The ones I do are the ones I quit early because of stupid spelling/grammar errors that slipped through (saw one the other day = "Sorry, she's not hear right now") or if the plot just absolutely sucks (i.e. "The six lesbians immediately became enthralled by the sight of Habib's throbbing 18" cock and surrendered to his manly desires"**)

(** and yes, that was meant to insult many of the Indian writers whose stuff uniformly sucks).

 

[soflabbwlvr]

I don't get the point of posting negative feedback if something doesn't put lead in your pencil. If it doesn't, click to the next story. I rarely post feedback, but when I do it's about things like the main character's name changing three times in the story.

I won't leave negative feedback if I read a story in a category that I don't enjoy. That's my own fault, not the author's (sometimes I forget to look at the category, sometimes the description is interesting). But I will point out if a story promises more than it delivers; if after a point it becomes entirely implausible; if something that squicks me is introduced toward the end with no warning beforehand; or if it just ends too abruptly. In those cases, I will point out what was lacking. But if I just don't enjoy a story, I will back out before I get more than half a page into it and forever banish it from my memory.

And I will almost always leave positive comments on stories I enjoy.

 

[Boxlicker101]

This is complimentary feedback, and not funny or stupid, but disturbing:

wish I had a daughter I COULD FUCK
03/27/12 By: Anonymous
I belieave the father should be the first one to fuck his girl. As long as he dont force himself on her and she dont mind, then it should be noone else business but theirs. Its no fun like old and young sex. Alot of fathers fuck thier daughters when they r young n the daughters like it thats why they dont say anything while its going on. I dont know how many women told me they been had by thier father.

Especially when it was written by somebody as highly educated as this man obviously is.

 

[voluptuary_manque]

Hence the phrase, "Who's your Daddy?" perhaps? I am thoroughly squikked.

 

[Cruel2BKind]

Recently, I have gained a new fan who has been methodically reading my stories and giving me honest critical advice. I have to admit, it is very refreshing to get real advice.

 

[voluptuary_manque]

It happens. Not often, but it happens. I love it.

 

[DG Hear]

I get all kinds of weird feedback. Here's one I just received. The story was posted in Nov. 2005


by Anonymous03/28/12
This is YOUR story, Douchebag

This is your story and yours to write as it is in your mind. If you do this regularly it is just playing around with your readers, of which I am no longer in that category.

It pisses me off to have you give no signal at first, so we can pass on reading this. You just start weaving your tale and then leave it undone. I think it is like masturbation, you are just mentally masturbating, because it doesn't matter to you one way or another how it ends. Your readers were looking for a complete product.

Well, FUCK you! Creep!

I am going through all your stories and voting 1. See if you like that.

I did write a sequel to the story about a month later and here's the reply that I received for it.

by Anonymous03/28/12
Fuck You

What a doofus.

 

[voluptuary_manque]

Now there's a chap with serious issues. Pity we can't send out a consulting philosopher to help him with his logic.

 

[Saxon Stonedyke]

I've not gotten a lot of feedback yet being new and all but the first two I got nearly sent me running for the hills. The first was suggesting I incorporate bestiality into a story and the second was asking me how many children I had, their ages and what age they were when I started having sex with them.

The third one I got it took me 3 days to get up the courage to open but it was very nice and helpful. I just hold my breath when I open one now and hope I won't end up needing the pepto-bismol after I've read it.

 

[Cruel2BKind]

I've not gotten a lot of feedback yet being new and all but the first two I got nearly sent me running for the hills. The first was suggesting I incorporate bestiality into a story and the second was asking me how many children I had, their ages and what age they were when I started having sex with them.

The third one I got it took me 3 days to get up the courage to open but it was very nice and helpful. I just hold my breath when I open one now and hope I won't end up needing the pepto-bismol after I've read it.

I guess it does depend on where you write.

I will never ever never ever ever never write an incest, LW, or nonconsent story.

The noncon story I have now, doesn't count. Because it was supposed to be first time.

 

[Saxon Stonedyke]

ah, well you will never see me anywhere writing or reading other than Lesbian sex

 

[Zeb_Carter]

So...you expect readers of porn on a free site to be able to express themselves in an intelligent and cogent manner to your prose? What're goofy?

 

[wet_special]

Yeah, this is a bitching-thread, but hey, misery loves company.

I have a total of 2 (count 'em) 2 heterosexual stories out of 50. I can understand them being the most popular, because lets just face it, the breeders on this site outnumber the gays.

Is "breeders" some kind of slur gays casually throw around? Because let's face it, it doesn't sound like a very nice thing to say.

 

[Boxlicker101]

I guess it does depend on where you write.

I will never ever never ever ever never write an incest, LW, or nonconsent story.

The noncon story I have now, doesn't count. Because it was supposed to be first time.

I write in all categories except audible and illustrated, and will continue to do so. Some of the most amusing feedback I have ever gotten is in LW and Incest. I am a little squeamish about writing of rape, though, so I tend to stick to the Reluctant part of that category, and usually have the "victim" enjoying the sex as much as the other persons.

I write for myself, so I write what I want.

 

[Cruel2BKind]

Is "breeders" some kind of slur gays casually throw around? Because let's face it, it doesn't sound like a very nice thing to say.

I was trying to be funny.

It is a casual term that many of my LGBT friends use when referring to Straights. But as with nearly every slur on the planet, it can be used in a friendly way or a hurtful way.

As some of my friends call each other bitches, and as some of my LGBT friends call each other queer, and as some black people call each other 'nigga',

I call straight people (myself included) breeders.

 

[Saxon Stonedyke]

Is "breeders" some kind of slur gays casually throw around? Because let's face it, it doesn't sound like a very nice thing to say.

It is not a term I would use and I haven't heard many use it in the real world, but then I am pretty laid back and not all angry and confrontational like some. To me being Gay doesn't mean I hate or belittle anyone it simply means I love women exclusively. Most of my close friends are male and/or straight.

 

[sr71plt]

It is not a term I would use and I haven't heard many use it in the real world, but then I am pretty laid back and not all angry and confrontational like some. To me being Gay doesn't mean I hate or belittle anyone it simply means I love women exclusively. Most of my close friends are male and/or straight.

Agree with this.

 

[Transverse]

I concur with the person above who said they never receive mean feedback in Gay Male. I only got one weird feedback item on one of my stories. They were admonishing me for including marijuana because kids might be reading it who "haven't quite found their maturity."

I got one nutty comment on a Reviews and Essays entry about the Loving Wives thing with black men and white husbands. I was discussing some possible motivations for writing it - most of the writers are men over there, and white, too, I believe, and I thought it could be an interesting exploration of a niche category. This guy writes me back and tells me I must be a slutty bitch who "fucks chocolate shit dicks" and "won't let [her] husband get a look in." I was informed that I deserved to be raped repeatedly by the white men I hate so much to teach my bad self a lesson.

I deleted it, and checked my locks twice that night.

 

[Cruel2BKind]

I concur with the person above who said they never receive mean feedback in Gay Male. I only got one weird feedback item on one of my stories. They were admonishing me for including marijuana because kids might be reading it who "haven't quite found their maturity."

I got one nutty comment on a Reviews and Essays entry about the Loving Wives thing with black men and white husbands. I was discussing some possible motivations for writing it - most of the writers are men over there, and white, too, I believe, and I thought it could be an interesting exploration of a niche category. This guy writes me back and tells me I must be a slutty bitch who "fucks chocolate shit dicks" and "won't let [her] husband get a look in." I was informed that I deserved to be raped repeatedly by the white men I hate so much to teach my bad self a lesson.

I deleted it, and checked my locks twice that night.

LW...

Has there ever been a category worse-named? They should split it into LW and Cuckold, or something.

 

[Stella_Omega]

LW...

Has there ever been a category worse-named? They should split it into LW and Cuckold, or something.

yep... But people have been saying that since befor my time, and it simply isn't going to happen. It's on of those builtin flaws.