Spring heat = global warming?

BoyNextDoor

I hate liars
Joined
Apr 19, 2010
Posts
14,159
Spring heat = global warming? "Stu" the chief meteorologist at Weather.com says so


For more than a week, we've been tracking record high temperatures across the central and eastern states. It's been so warm that some cities set record highs during the morning hours on Monday! This happened in International Falls, Minn., Green Bay, Wis. and Burlington, Vt., to name a few locations.

The record heat will continue the next couple of days. Let's start by examining the potential daily record highs Wednesday and Thursday, then we'll "go deep" into perspective on how anomalous this warm spell is.
 
I don't think you can say "global warming" until this sort of thing becomes routine.

But if you picked several American cities at random and counted the number of new record highs and new record lows in those cities in the last ten years, I have a pretty good idea which one would be greater.
 
Spring heat = global warming? "Stu" the chief meteorologist at Weather.com says so


For more than a week, we've been tracking record high temperatures across the central and eastern states. It's been so warm that some cities set record highs during the morning hours on Monday! This happened in International Falls, Minn., Green Bay, Wis. and Burlington, Vt., to name a few locations.

The record heat will continue the next couple of days. Let's start by examining the potential daily record highs Wednesday and Thursday, then we'll "go deep" into perspective on how anomalous this warm spell is.

Global warming isnt real!! Humans have no impact on the planet when they spew toxic shit into the environment!!! *sticks fingers in ears * LALALALALLALALALALLALALALLALA CAN'T HEAR YOU!!! LALALLALALAAlALLALALALA

Just wanted to do it before the Rush/Beck worshipers showed up.
 

Ask residents of Eastern Europe, Siberia or Alaska what they have to say about Stu's crackpot idea.


Ever hear of La Niña?


 
Last edited:

Ask residents of Eastern Europe, Siberia or Alaska what they have to say about your crackpot idea.


Ever hear of La Niña?



Stu is the crackpot I am just the messenger. Of course he is the el hefe over @ Weather.com. Does that give him any cred?
 

Ask residents of Eastern Europe, Siberia or Alaska what they have to say about Stu's crackpot idea.


Ever hear of La Niña?



Global warming is making the weather unusually cold in that part of the world.

:D
 
its done it before. i remember it. we'll probably end up getting slammed with a frosty snap that will make all the purdy flowers wilt and die soon.
 
Global warming isnt real!! Humans have no impact on the planet when they spew toxic shit into the environment!!! *sticks fingers in ears * LALALALALLALALALALLALALALLALA CAN'T HEAR YOU!!! LALALLALALAAlALLALALALA

^^^^^ Best Trysail imitation of all time. OF ALL TIME!
 
Last edited:

Global Warming As Cargo Cult Science



Science is all about establishing and understanding cause and effect. Unfortunately, there are few examples in science where causation can be easily established, since the physical world involves myriad variables interacting in different ways.

I would argue that this is why there is a “scientific method” at all. Because it is so easy to fool ourselves regarding what causes what to happen in the physical world.

Laboratory experiments are powerful because, if you can control the factors you think are operating, you can isolate a specific effect and more reliably trace it to its cause.

But many problems are not amenable to laboratory investigation. Global warming is one of them. There is only a single subject, or ‘patient’ if you will (the Earth), it apparently has a low-grade fever, and we are trying to determine the cause of the fever.

It’s not that there isn’t any laboratory evidence supporting global warming theory. There have been many laboratory (spectroscopic) investigations where it has been convincingly established that carbon dioxide absorbs infrared radiation (the fundamental starting point for global warming theory). We even see evidence from satellites that greenhouse gases reduce the Earth’s ability to cool to space.

But to extend those observations to the conclusion that adding more CO2 to the atmosphere will cause substantial global warming is another matter entirely.

If we had hundreds of Earth-like planets nearby that we could visit with satellites and probes, we might randomly split them into two equal groups, inject one group with more carbon dioxide, then monitor them to see whether that group of planets’ climate systems warmed relative to the others. This would allow us to more reliably determine how much warming (if any) was likely due to adding CO2 versus natural, internal quasi-chaotic climate variations, which are always occurring. This is one of the more rigorous methods of research in epidemiology, but one which is not often performed due to expense and ethical issues.

Needless to say, we don’t have hundreds of Earth-like planets to do experiments on. Instead, we have only one subject to study, the Earth. Establishing causation in such a situation is dicey, at best.

Contrary to what you have probably been told, there are no ‘fingerprints’ of human-induced warming which distinguish it from other, natural radiatively induced sources of warming. The warming is indeed (as the IPCC so artfully claims) “consistent” with increasing CO2, but it would also be consistent with other potential causes. Maybe not from direct effects of solar irradiance changes, or from changes in ozone, but I could list many more possibilities which we don’t have good enough data for enough years to thoroughly investigate.

Cargo Cult Science
I am on a mailing list of a career MD/JD who claims much of what passes as policy-relevant science these days (global warming, air pollution epidemiological studies) is what physicist Richard Feynman in 1974 called “cargo cult science“.

The story goes that after primitive South Pacific tribes were exposed to the modernized world with transport planes bringing supplies, they later tried to build mock-airstrips and planes which they believe would ’cause’ the real cargo planes to reappear.

Of course, the villagers were confused about causation. In this case, the need of advanced societies to deliver cargo is what causes airports to be built, not the other way around.

Humans are endlessly ingenious at devising explanations for physical phenomena, while typically there is only one explanation. You can believe that global warming is mostly caused by increasing CO2, changing sunspots, natural climate cycles (my personal favorite), the moon, the planets, HAARP experiments in Alaska, or whatever you can dream up. But to actually prove any of those is impossible, and to even convincingly establish a connection is more a matter of how easy it is to convince people, rather than how good the evidence is.

The Earth has warmed…but there is also abundant proxy evidence that it warmed (and cooled) in the past. So, did increasing CO2 in the last half century really cause the most recent period of warming? We might never know.

The courts are increasingly deferring such matters of causation to the “expertise” of government agencies, such as the EPA. The Circuit Court of DC recently heard challenges to EPA’s 2010 endangerment finding (or ruling) that increasing CO2 is a threat to human health and welfare, and thus must be regulated under the Clean Air Act.

Yet the judges sitting on that court did not want to hear any challenges to the science(!) If the endangerment finding was based upon the science, how the hell can a court hear challenges to the Finding if it does not want to hear about the science? I’m not an attorney, but it seems like lawyers are so busy arguing procedural and obscure legal issues, they are not willing to go after the fundamental premise: that more CO2 in the atmosphere is bad for you.

Yeah, science is hard. It can make your head hurt. But if you are going to base policy on what some scientists claim, you’d better be prepared to address challenges to that science.
 
Spring heat = global warming? "Stu" the chief meteorologist at Weather.com says so


For more than a week, we've been tracking record high temperatures across the central and eastern states. It's been so warm that some cities set record highs during the morning hours on Monday! This happened in International Falls, Minn., Green Bay, Wis. and Burlington, Vt., to name a few locations.

The record heat will continue the next couple of days. Let's start by examining the potential daily record highs Wednesday and Thursday, then we'll "go deep" into perspective on how anomalous this warm spell is.

la nina
 
Are you sure it isn't global warming causing la nina?

The glaciers are melting, lowering the temp of the oceans ...
 
Maybe it is, and maybe it isn't, and the deniers will have a lot to say, but only one thing matters: the mood of the populous at large. Enough of these crazy heatwaves and the average Joe is going to start believing in global warming.
 
Hmmm the MMGW faithful spent the entire winter telling us that record snowfall was in no way an indication of lack of MMGW. Now, of course, a few hot days = the end of the world. :rolleyes: You really have to laugh at these morons!
 
It's the 3rd week of Autumn here, and we are getting a cold snap.
Snow predicted and temps about 10 degrees below normal.
Global warming sure is cold!
 
The first three months of the year during a La Niña typically feature below normal precipitation in the Southwest, the central and southern sections of the Rockies and Great Plains, and Florida. Meanwhile, the odds of surplus precipitation increase across the Pacific Northwest, in the northern Intermountain West, and over scattered sections of the north-central states, Ohio Valley, and upper Southeast. La Niña features unusually cold weather in the Northwest and (to a lesser extent) northern California, the northern Intermountain West, and the north-central states. Farther south, higher than normal temperatures are slightly favored in a broad area covering the southern Rockies and Great Plains, the Ohio Valley, the Southeast, and the mid-Atlantic states.
 
Two warm days does not a global event make.

Unless you are Fox or CNN.
 
Are you sure it isn't global warming causing la nina?

The glaciers are melting, lowering the temp of the oceans ...

Doesn't lower the temp of oceans it lowers the salinity which will fuck up the currents that circulate around the planet giving ocean life (our food) nutrients and also regulate climate. The halting of even one of these major currents would be catastrophic on so many levels it would be a rough ride to survive the inevitable famines.

^^^^^ Best Trysail imitation of all time. OF ALL TIME!

Point and case below...


Ask residents of Eastern Europe, Siberia or Alaska what they have to say about Stu's crackpot idea.


Ever hear of La Niña?


 
It be snowing here in Oregon, I thoiught Spring was here?

amicus:rose:
 
Solar flares, great year for them. Expect a hot summer and coastal flooding. :cool:
 
Back
Top